The best around! Gabby's pizza with as many Pizza places as we have around Flemington, they're my go to always. Nice atmosphere, good prices, and the best slice of pizza I personally know of! Great customer service, quicker delivery than others. Ultimately the pizza just can't be beat! read more

As the flavor is good this visit ruined my night I was looking for real Chicago style deep dish pizza and saw they offered it here. Decided to give it a go and they only have Chicago pan. Seems like nobody knows the difference. Chicago deep dish pizza is cheese on the bottom layered with sauce on top. Definitely should not be advertised this way as this restaurant does not offer it. They only have Chicago pan which is thick crust and made like a normal slice. Also very limited seating and dirty looking inside.The bathrooms are locked so we couldn't wash our hands either. Nobody said goodbye or have a nice night as we left and I wasn't rude to them at all. read more

Gabby's Pizza - This is what we got - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all

AMAZING STAFF AND FOOD!!! Absolutely recommend gabbys pizzeria! I go there Atleast once or twice a week.

While their food is not bad and service is ok, I like the fact they deliver. That said, I don't think I will return. They new policy of add 3.99% (please just call it what is,4%) PER dollar when you don't pay cash. At the high end the fee for credit card transactions is 3.5% plus $0.30 per transaction. The most common fee for business, sometimes less based on number of transactions a month, is 2.5% with $0.30 per transaction. I am tired of businesses profiting on me using my credit card. Oh yea they get to write off a percentage of that as a business expense too. See ya Gabbys I am going somewhere else. read more

Gabby's Pizza is tucked into a busy strip mall that is adjacent to one of Flemington's many circles. The parking situation can be a bit dicey at peak hours. There aren't very many spots. Inside is a bit cramped, but the staff is friendly and service is quick. I decided to go with a plain slice and a margherita slice. The slices were average. The sauce and cheese taste great, but the base of the slices was fairly soft and didn't have great structure. The cheese slid around a lot too when taking a bite. Overall, the pizza wasn't bad. read more

Gabby's Pizza - Pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

See all

Wonderful soup with bread!! It's now my weekly lunch. I order a large and along with the bread have a healthy affordable lunch each and every day. They carry two varieties. read more

I've tried all the pizza places in Flemington and this is our favorite. And by far the most reasonably priced. As great as the food is, the shining star of Gabbys is the lovely woman that man's the front. She is always there, double check's EVERYTHING and goes above and beyond to provide an exceptional customer experience. The Ingredients are fresh and perfectly prepared. The marinara is the BEST. The portions are generous. Our favs: the Chicago style pizza, vodka sauce, super fresh and flavorful sautéed vegetables, chicken Marsala. I'll be honest, takeout as a busy working mom is my favorite splurge, and with Gabbys we get fresh, flavorful home cooked meals that are worth the very fair price and then some. And did I mention the wonderful woman that answers the phone and does a million other things in the most friendly efficient way possible? She's like an earth angel doing gods work with incredible patience and graciousness. It's not easy serving the public, but these people get the job done right. Thank you Gabbys! We you. Especially me, who can rely on you to give me a night off of cooking to remember. read more

Hole in the wall kinda place. Certainly small. However, the food was very tasty and reasonably priced. I ordered the pasta calamari. The calamari was fresh, pasta was good and the sauce delicious. They give lots of bread and salad. Staff was very friendly. read more

What a scammer! you order for delivery - they give you an amount and charge your credit card like $5 more - and unless you notice - they get away with it . You then call and the owner argues around it with a bunch of bullshit reasons....ie oh theres a $1 delivery change (he originally told me there was none). Then after a bit of calling him out he just becomes an asshole and tells you he's no longer going to delivery to you. Thank God! Don't order from here unless you want to be F'd and thank them for being told to bend over! read more

My husbandKen&Iorder fried chicken fromgabby's for lunch&both of our fried chicken dinner was over cooked&the chicken taste more like rocks.&We were both very disapointed&the frie's were also burnt.&My husband&I will never order from them again since they gave us totally crappy food.I could get alot better fried chicken@Flemington Raritan dinder thedn@Gabby's&since this corona virus that diner is closed. read more

Gabby's Pizza - Over cook fried chicken from gabby's they totally suck - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

This is my first time ordering from Gabby's. I ordered delivery and my pizza arrived a bit messed up. (See picture). As for the food, I've had better pizza. The sauce was to the sour side, the crust was a bit chewy. The Caesar salad was descent. Overall I don't think I will be ordering from this place again. read more

Gabby's Pizza - Delivery pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Really good pizza - my husband and I think they have the best crust! Our favorite pizza is sausage & green pepper

My wife has loved Gabby's for years Mainly due to the fact that they are open until 11:00 PM on Friday and Saturday nights, she works nights and often sleeps until 6-7PM on these weekend nights. She always orders a Pizza with Tomatoes and Basil (which I've grown tired of). When you make a special order, you get a freshly made Pizza and she has been satisfied with it. Saturday evening 10/22/22,10:08 PM we ordered a plain pizza (I'm tired of the Tomatoes and Basil) for pickup (restaurant hours were until 11:00 PM). She was supposed to pick up the Pizza and bring it home for us to enjoy; but I felt I should accompany her for the sake of her safety (world has gotten ugly). We arrived by 10;25pm and the restaurant was full of between 5 -10 men (no women) who were not eating; but appeared to be just hanging out. None of them had masks on and we had to squeeze through the Croud to get to the counter. They were speaking to each other in a fairly animated fashion (Saliva Flying About). This situation would have been very uncomfortable for my wife had I asked her to go alone, and it was uncomfortable and unhealthy for us both of us. When we got home it became obvious that the Pizza had been rewarmed and not fresh because it was burnt on the bottom, and it was barely warm (we live less then 10 min. from Gabby's). The pizza was overly salted, dried out and burnt. Besides the poor quality the Pizzaria/Man Cave was completely unacceptable. We will not be using them again. CUSTOMERS BEWARE! read more

If I could leave less than one star I would. I called an order for delivery and was told 30-45 minutes. Over an a half later still no food. When I called to inquire, the staff were so rude that I then proceeded to cancel my order. I explained that if I had known it would be over an hour and thirty minutes wait I wouldn't have ordered. They first refused to cancel the order and then told me they won't take any future orders. The customer service is appalling and they should be embarrassed of the way they handled the situation. They permanently lost a customer and I will be encouraging other's to go elsewhere too. read more

Don't order from here, they'll negotiate how much are you willing to spend to see if it's worth for them to deliver your food. I'm at the border of Hillsborough and Flemington, so I'm not even that far. The best part is they've delivered to me before... unprofessional and tacky! read more

Gabby's pizza is our go to when we want a hot pizza delivered to our door. Their pizza is the closest in taste to what we grew up eating in western New York State. Our favorite is pepperoni with green peppers. In fact, I'm ordering it for dinner tonight! read more

Outstanding food all around. Chicken franchise pie is my fav. But the dough is so light and everything that I have tried is out of this world. To the people complaining about delivery time....the place is busy because it's that good! This isn't fast food, they take their time. read more

EDIT: The last few times I've been there the service was slow and the employees were incredibly rude. I'm staying away from this joint for a while. :::::::: This is a pizza for fans of good dough. It's a little thicker than others in the area and the sauce and cheese is not caked on to compensate, as one would expect. I myself am a big crust-lover, and it is currently the place I'll go to for a pie. Great for a night of vegging-out and relaxing. I mean, come on... It's pizza from New Jersey. Even New Jersey's BEST pizza looks like the retarded cousin of New York's worst pizza. read more

A complete shit show.. Come In ask a slice with sausage, Pay the girl.. Sitting waiting 10 minutes after seeing people come in and get there food and go, I go ask where's my slice and everyone looks around like Idiots.. Worse service ever had to wait another 5 mins for 1 slice of pizza.. read more

I tried Gabbys pizza yesterday for the first time. It was ok. It's not to thick and not to thin with an ok sauce. A lot of people rave about Gabbys , I thought it was just ok. read more

By far my favorite nj pizza. I have lived outside NJ for 4 years and have avoided purchasing pizza in my new state because of the poor quality. Visiting nj for an event we stopped by Gabbys and had the Perfect super thin crust volcano hot cheese and deliciously seasoned sauce. Family run business , definitely check it out. read more

I just had to do this... It's now over 3 years since my initial review for Gabby's. I still think they have the BEST pizza around. read more

I usually write long reviews but since i have only had one item here it will be sort. I have only ordered the deep fried calzone. If i never had one in Brooklyn i would have given them five stars. But since i have something to compare them to they only get four. If you have never had a deep fried calzone order one and give it a try. Try it plain, or with some ham. If you are feeling crazy fill it with your favorite topping and let the pocket of cheesy friend goodness take over! read more

Sunday we decided to go to Gabby's and order take out.....We ordered a lasagna dinner and a manicotti dinner. The lasagna had very little beef,,,my manicotti had layers of wide noodles and no ricotta...both entrees were flooded with a cover of mozzarella cheese. The entrees used to be very good when the owner ran the show......now he works out of his 2nd business in Budd Lake, ,,,we also ordered mussels,,,,,the liquid was spilled all over the inside of the box,,,the pizza has declined in quality also,,,thick,,doughy,,,they used to have great Margahrita pizza,,lots of garlic and basil..you have to try to find the garlic,,,,save your money lots of better places,,, read more

Fresh delicious pizza with little to no wait! Does it get better than that? And plenty of choices- even gluten free! The restaurant was clean and food was good! read more

The best pizza in flemmington definitely try the chicken vodka slice its the best. I also like steak sandwich their .

Terrible service Thru Grubhub. I ordered a decent amount of food and they told me it wa coming in an hr. Then received a text it was delayed for another half hr. Then received a text saying my order was cancelled. Waited two hrs total to find out my food wasn't coming. Very unprofessional. read more

The pizza was awesome! The crust on both the thin and thick crust were absolutely perfect. It took a little longer then I expected; but it was well worth the wait! We got a plain cheese thin crust and a half cheesesteak half pepperoni thick crust. Both pizzas were excellent. read more

Horrible customer service.. this place has the decency to charge 50 cents for Parmesan cheese on the side for pizza! Not going to return.

We loves Gabbys we order pizza and pasta meals never had anything bad. Chicken Marsala pizza is to die for and so is chicken bacon ranch. Very friendly staff. read more

I love Gabby's pizza but I wish they would get my order correct. I always get a stuffed pizza I ask for just pepperoni and cheese because my son and I don't like other meats this is the second time they made it with other meats. I couldn't even take it back because I live in PA. The other 2 pies I got were perfect. They have the best white pie I have ever had. read more

We ordered on a Monday because Viramis was closed. Over priced and sub par for pizza in this area. Sauce was too sweet and the crust was doughie. I was shocked by their prices. read more

Really good Jersey Pizza! We called them at 10 pm on a Sunday night. Not only are they the only ones smart enough to stay open late on a Sunday, they deliver to the Hampton Inn! We had a super delicious, hot, 'garbage' pie. Thanks Gabby's! We know who to call when we come back! read more

They are rude & have zero customer service sense. Pizza is Ok..nothing special. There are much better places in the area.

I have been ordering delivery from this restaurant several times a month for the past year. Tonight I placed an order and received phone calls that my address did not exist. I explained where I lived and mentioned that I receive deliveries from this establishment several times a month. I then had to argue with the delivery person that I indeed lived where I said and received several delivieries a month. They just lost all my business and now I will order from dominoes or papa johns. So sad. Too bad. read more

Service is REALLY BAD! Employees are not the greatest cooks. Place is not the cleanest. Pizzas are not very good. Food is limited.

Feel like family every time I order and pick up. Hector and his team provide quality food, good service, and affordable prices. Consistently! Of all the pizza places in and around Flemington, Gabby's is my first choice. Looking forward to some delicious Sicilian. : ) read more

Place has really gone downhill in the past few years. Filthy inside, questionable food safety .. If you are lucky enough to get your order right!!!! read more

Their deep-dish Buffalo Chicken Pizza is absolutely out of this world, but that's all I can recommend. I don't like their sandwiches or their plain pies. read more

Best pizza in the area, in our opinion! And the owners and staff are awesome too. I was a customer there for over 12 years. Ordered pizza once a week and used them for catering too. We recently moved out of state and definitely miss Gabby's pizza. We will stop in whenever we are back in town. read more