We chose this pizza place, because of the high reviews and we were literally around the corner…read more It's a small place, so our party of 6 split up at 3 tables. We ordered two large pizzas. One with peppers and onions and one with meatballs. We all found the pizza to be just ok. It was lacking flavor in the crust and the sauce. Perhaps, it was an off day given the stellar reviews. Unfortunately, we found the pizza to be mediocre.

Best cheese pizza in this area. I always get cravings for…read moretheir pizzas even if what I get is just cheese pizza. It's ny style...thin crust and soo cheesy. I always forget to take a picture because by the time I remember, I'm more than half way done with the pizza! Other pizzas and buffalo wings here are good too, but the cheese pizza is just amazing.

Went to Campania Pizza for the first time today! Glad we did, great service and pizza. 8.2 scale,…read moreno flop and crispy! Plus they put real slices of sausage as a topping!

Service was pleasant over the phone. We ordered the Grandma pie which they said was thin crust but…read moreI guess they meant thinner than Sicilian pizza as it was at least 3/8"thick. Also seemed they built the pizza with cheese underneath the sauce which I thought was odd. I would try it again but perhaps a different pizza.

We've lived in NJ for roughly 10 years now and I am not sure why we hadn't heard of this place. We…read morehave a couple of local "go to's" when it comes to Italian style food, but I don't know for certain how this place evaded us. The restaurant is tucked behind a Walgreen's and proximate to an urgent care on a side street off Rt 31, so that might explain it. We arrived for dinner on a random Thursday. The dining room is large, clean, bright, and had a lot of empty tables, but few patrons. They have a take-out business and it was sort of rainy outside, so that explained it in my head. The server came right away and took our beverage orders (it's a BYOB and I still can't get used to that concept). We ordered our meals after our drinks arrived. I like to keep it simple on a first visit. If you've seen my other reviews, it sorta makes sense. I got the linguine, with mushroom sauce and meatballs. It gives me a chance to see if the pasta is boxed or not, how fresh the ingredients are, the taste of the sauce, and if they can make a decent meatball. The linguine was made in the kitchen from scratch and the mushroom marinara was delicious. The meatballs are amongst the best I've had in the area, including two NYC Little Italys (Manhattan and Bronx). The salad was fresh and crisp and the bread came out warm and delicious. It's a bit of a drive from Clinton, but I am going to try their pizza at my next takeout opportunity.

We've been in the area for a year Ava have only gotten pizza from Capuano. To "celebrate" our…read moreanniversary in the area, we decided to try the dining room. The inside is quaint, with brick and stucco walls. My wife ordered the penne with broccoli. I ordered the linguini alla vongole (linguini with clams) in white wine sauce. Both entrees came with soup or salad. We both chose salad. They also brought some warm bread to the table with oil for dipping, though the bread did seem a little dry. I prefer my bread to be a bit more stretchy/chewy. We both enjoyed our meals. They were a good portion size, with nothing left to bring home. For dessert, I chose the affogato (special), my wife went with the fudge cake, and both of us had cappuccino. It is a BYOB but there is a liquor store next door if you want a bottle (or two) of wine.

Very solid slice of pizza. Good, well-baked crust with good cheese and pretty good sauce. Very…read moreserviceable slice for out in the suburbs. Good price for a slice of pizza. Came pretty close to five stars but I have been to many, many pizza places and I'm a very harsh judge.

We love this place. Salads, dinners,antipasto, all delicious. And the pizza is delicious!read more

Stopped by this pizzeria recently and had a solid experience overall. The food wasn't the best I've…read moreever had, but it definitely wasn't bad by any means. I ordered the eggplant parm sandwich and it was made well. Service was fast about 10 minutes,. I'd heard great things about their Jersey slices, but unfortunately they were sold out by the time I arrived. Still, it seems like a popular spot for a reason, and I'd be open to coming back to try the pizza next time.

We drive 30 minutes to get a pizza from Panatier's. Best I have ever had…read more Italian dishes and salads are great too. Friendly staff.

In a world that relentlessly pursues extremes, the Average Pizza stands humble yet proud, asserting…read morethat consistency and familiarity also have merit. Isn't it comforting to know there's something that won't surprise or disappoint but consistently deliver a usual, familiar taste? Lenny's aims to shift the perspective, to encourage appreciation for 'ordinariness,' and to sing praises of our trustworthy, average pizzas that do not aspire to be spectacular but remain steadfastly satisfying. Less than average: Gen Z's answering the phone.

Gluten free pizza is the frozen type with no taste. Toppings were good but the crust tastes like…read morecardboard. If you're not gluten free the menu seems great . Probably won't order again, if I do I won't get the pizza.

Flemington finally has a New York style pizzeria after all these years I finally have my new spot…read morewhat a cute dining area also and I totally am in love with the Music and decor A + Frank would be proud

Good choice if you are in the Flemington area. If you are totally fixated on avoiding flop be…read morewarned, this is not the place for you. It sags pretty deeply. Having said that they manage to get a nice snap on the bottom, which is well baked, and the crust around here edge has a satisfying crunch. The sauce and cheese is plenty good for a standard pizza. Again, not a place you'd drive 30 minutes to get to but a better than average neighborhood pizza joint. Oh, and they have an early week special with a large cheese (cash only) for $12.99. Great deal for some pretty good pizza.

One of our favorites...we go often...love the friendly staff and owners!! Prices reasonable...food…read morealways great! Easy to get reservations for a group

Found half a horse fly in my salad. Which means I must have ate the other half…read more... How does one miss that when preparing it?