Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Garden Island Rentals

    2.7 (15 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Garden Island Rentals Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Garden Island Rentals

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    19 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 15
    Thanks 0
    Love this 18
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    8 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Nic G.
    1
    58
    5

    10 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Sue D.
    5
    36
    0

    13 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Judy C.
    6
    55
    13

    12 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of L A.

    L A.

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Garden Island Rentals

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Vacation Rentals 497 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Parrish Collection Kauai

    The Parrish Collection Kauai

    2.5
    (105 reviews)
    0.4 mi

    I have booked 6 different homes with Parrish Kauai for a total of 10 visits. I have nothing but…read morepositive things to say about Parrish. They always get back to me promptly and have always taken care of any needs I might have. The houses have always had what we needed and been clean. Two years ago I booked a house inland with 5 bedrooms and a pool as we were taking our 2 sons and their families. A week before we were to go the house had damage done to it as a result of a storm. Parrish booked a different house on the ocean with a pool for us at no extra cost!! The kids got to watch the turtles from the house. My husband and I were coming back in 2 weeks and asked Parrish if they could keep some non-perishables in their office until we came back. They said sure and then even had them at the house when we arrived. This last trip the internet wasn't working and I messaged them on Sunday not expecting to hear back until Monday but they got right back to me and said someone would be out that day to check on it and that we didn't need to be there. In the meantime one of the umbrellas on the lanai broke off the stand due to rust. I was going to mention it to whomever came out for the internet but we were gone. When we got back I messaged Parrish and let them know about the umbrella. They sent someone back out on Sunday to take care of it. Again I wasn't expecting to get help on a Sunday. Parrish is great to work with and I would highly recommend them. I've already booked my house for next year.

    Parrish -- Do Not Trust Them With Your Special Trip…read more We booked Poipu Sands #521 through The Parrish Collection for our 25th wedding anniversary -- a milestone we'd planned carefully, choosing a building 5 unit specifically for its unobstructed view of Shipwrecks Beach. We are not naive renters: we owned a condo at Poipu Sands for over a decade and know the property well. Parrish still managed to ruin our trip. The problems announced themselves immediately. Every screen in the unit was torn, with gaps large enough to invite insects indoors. The portable AC exhaust ducts were sloppily routed through louvered windows, creating additional entry points. The rattan headboard in the downstairs bedroom was visibly embedded with dust and grime. The window shades were moldy. And the twin beds making up the "king" in the downstairs room were fully made up as individual twins beneath the king bedding -- meaning the next guests would sleep on sheets a stranger had already slept in, separated by a single layer of fabric. Charming. But the detail that stopped us cold: ten roach traps scattered across both floors of the unit. Not one or two tucked discreetly in corners -- ten, throughout the property. Parrish's website had described this unit as clean and well-maintained. Ten roach traps tell a different story. We had been traveling since 6:30 am and had specific reasons for choosing this exact unit, so we attempted to make it work. We shouldn't have. On night three, our son found a 3.5-4 inch cockroach in his bathroom. We immediately texted Parrish -- the contact method they told us to use for concerns -- and waited. And waited. An hour and a half passed with no response. We packed our bags, found rooms at the Marriott, informed Parrish by text that we were leaving, and requested a refund for the two nights we would not be staying. Parrish refused. Parrish had every opportunity to inspect and maintain the property they were charging premium rates to rent. They had every opportunity to disclose that the unit had an active pest problem requiring ten traps. They had every opportunity to respond to a guest text - as they had instructed us to do. They did none of these things. Then, when a cockroach the size of a small rodent drove a family out of the unit on the eve of a 25th anniversary, they declined to return two nights of rent. This is not a property management company that takes care of its properties or its guests. It is one that takes your money, sends you a glossy description, and hopes you don't look too closely at the headboard. We looked. Don't make our mistake. In response to JP: You're still fussing over the request for a refund - complaining about what we told you and when we told you. We should have complained right away about the condition of the property. But that's the catch-22 for the traveler - you want to make it work because you have limited time...until you can't. So, we're passed that. Now we're telling our story about our experience with Parrish, so others won't make our mistake

    Photos
    The Parrish Collection Kauai
    The Parrish Collection Kauai
    The Parrish Collection Kauai

    See all

    Orchid Vacation Rental House

    Orchid Vacation Rental House

    5.0
    (16 reviews)
    2.6 mi

    We just returned from an incredible week at Orchid house. The large 5 bedroom house was perfect for…read moreour 8 adults and 4 teens. The views take your breath away every single morning as we watched the sunrise over Shipwreck Beach. The kitchen has lots of cooking and baking items, plenty of dishes and cutlery, 2 large refrigerators to hold so much food and beverages. Restaurants and food shopping are close by in Koloa. There's a large dining room table inside next to the kitchen, plus another large table on the front porch by the large BBQ. The salt pool and deck are spacious and beautifully maintained. The garage has lots of pool toys, beach towels, even a wagon to carry things to the beach. The bedrooms are large and comfortable and all have an ensuite. The house is in a very quiet and safe neighborhood that overlooks Poipu Beach. Another great asset is Evan, the house manager. He's absolutely wonderful and quickly responds any time you have a question. I would stay here again and I very highly recommend Orchid house for amazing accommodations in the Poipu beach area.

    We had such an incredible stay at Orchid Home! It was perfect for our large extended family with…read morelittle kids in tow. The moment we arrived the hosts welcomed us warmly. They were very responsive and helpful throughout our stay. The house is absolutely beautiful yet so comfy. It is bright, airy, and the ocean views are spectacular. We woke up early everyday just to see the sunrise! Many special touches like binoculars (enjoyed by us birders!), toys and games, well appointed kitchen (a cook's dream!), huge well-maintained pool, and an abundance of beach towels, beach toys, beach chairs, and coolers. Everything we needed! The location is 5 min away from beautiful Poipu Beach where we swam with turtles and even a seal, and 5 min to Koloa town. Orchid Home exceeded our expectations in every way. We made many unforgettable family memories and hope to return again. Nui Mahalo to the hosts!

    Photos
    Wake up to stunning sunrise views from the bedroom suite
    Wake up to stunning sunrise views from the bedroom suite
    Fully equipped kitchen
    Fully equipped kitchen
    Orchid Vacation Rental House

    See all

    Kuhio Shores Condos

    Kuhio Shores Condos

    4.7
    (29 reviews)
    1.7 mi
    $$$

    We absolutely loved staying here! Located outside of Poipu in Kōloa, it was busy but wasn't super…read morecrowded around this area. The parking lot would get full at times, but we were always able to find a spot. They have quiet hours posted, but honestly, noise was never a problem here. I'm sure they were busy and full because of the parking lot, but we rarely heard or saw anyone! They also have elevator access and luggage carts which was helpful for when we received our Instacart order. Located right on the ocean, we had a remarkable view of Hoai Bay and Prince Kuhio Beach from our living room/dining room as well as our Lanai. We enjoyed relaxing on the lanai, listening to the waves and watching for sea turtles, which was saw many! Locals would come to the beach to fish and even that was fun to watch! There's also a ton of roosters and chickens, and the roosters crow all day, not just in the mornings lol! We also saw thousands of rose ringed parakeets flying into the area in the morning and flying out at night! Showers and foot baths were located in the parking lot to rinse off prior to returning from the beach. We had to take our trash out a couple of times during our stay, and that was located at the end of the parking lot near the BBQ area. The staff was friendly, although our interaction with them was minimal. One kind gentleman on staff offered to take my trash for me and told me to go enjoy my day, that taking out the trash was a horrible thing to have to do on vacation! I only wish the facility had a pool, but based on the fact the backyard of the grounds in literally the ocean, I get why they don't offer that amenity lol!

    We spent almost one week there and loved the view from our balcony. It was also nice that they had…read morean elevator. The other two condos didn't have them and it is difficult to carry the suitcases up the stairs. The condo looked bigger on the pictures because it has wall mirrors on both sides of the walls. The condo did not have shampoo or conditioner.

    Photos
    Unit 211
    Unit 211
    Kuhio Shores Condos
    Kuhio Shores Condos

    See all

    Castle Kiahuna Plantations & The Beach Bungalows

    Castle Kiahuna Plantations & The Beach Bungalows

    2.7
    (83 reviews)
    1.9 mi
    $$

    Buyer Beware!! Castle Kiahuna blatantly ignores the law to eliminate "Junk Fees" and does NOT…read moredisplay the total price of the rental costs. We were slammed with a $450 "cleaning fee" at check in. Don't be fooled by the discounted prices. New federal and state regulations, notably the FTC's "Junk Fees Rule" taking effect in 2025, require short-term rental (STR) platforms and hosts to display a total price upfront, inclusive of all mandatory fees like cleaning and service charges. This prevents hidden fees by requiring the full price (excluding taxes) to be shown in initial listings.

    We booked through Agoda and paid $838 for three nights, including "taxes and fees." After we…read morechecked out, we were shocked to find an additional $377 charged to our credit card for a so-called "cleaning fee" -- nearly 45% of the total cost. At no point during check-in, during our stay, or at check-out were we informed of this charge, nor did we receive a receipt or any written notice about it. In fact, the only thing made clear at check-in was that no cleaning services would be provided during our stay. When we called the hotel after our trip ended, and we saw the credit card charges, we were told the fee is buried under "Additional Property Policies" on Agoda -- which feels intentionally vague. This is a huge hidden fee and completely deceptive. We will not stay here again and urge others to be extremely cautious.

    Photos
    The property.
    The property.
    Our view looking out on the other side is a nice grass area but not an ocean view.
    Our view looking out on the other side is a nice grass area but not an ocean view.
    Slide end of the pool

    See all

    Slide end of the pool
    Poipu Plantation Vacation Rentals

    Poipu Plantation Vacation Rentals

    3.9
    (37 reviews)
    2.5 mi

    Terrible experience. Started with the toilet being turned off and the toilet tank empty when we got…read morethere. Reached out to the property manager and they said everything was working fine before we walked in the door??? Took them 18 hours (8:51 p.m. to 3:03 p.m) to fix it so we didn't have a working toilet through the night. I had to find a bucket on my own to use to fill with water and get it to flush. We also could walk about 8-10 minutes down to the beach and use those filthy toilets or ask the local restaurants. Next issue was a concern of our privacy in the bathroom. There was a large hole in the wall (partially covered with a picture) and I mean LARGE that led to a closet/storage area. If someone was in the closet, they could see directly into the shower. The hole was big enough to where someone could tip the picture out and literally grab you. Pictures attached. When I raised this with the property manager (who you never actually see on site), they simply said that nobody was in the closet so don't worry about it. Lastly was the bathroom was disgusting. More pictures attached. I asked for a partial refund and they said they would mail us a check (even asked for the mailing address). No check ever arrived and they stopped responding to my follow-ups.

    The host, "Pete", double booked our room, shut the door in our face when we arrived and refused to…read moregive a refund. We arrived the day after the start of our rental agreement. He claims we "No Showed", but we clearly showed up and stood face to face with him as he fumbled through an explanation as to why it was our fault that he rented our room to someone else. VRBO failed to honor their rental guarantee which states we 'have the right to enter the rental for the ENTIRE duration of our rental term'. Throughout the process of trying to get a refund, Pete repeatedly sent multiple inappropriate text messages to my wife telling her to "F$#% You"... "Sh@# Head". He only stopped after we filed a harassment report with Kauai Police. We are considering pressing charges. Pete is very two faced and what he says to in front of you is not how he feels or what he thinks about you when he is behind a computer screen. Don't let him SCAM or BULLY YOU. GO ELSEWHERE

    Photos
    Poipu Plantation Vacation Rentals
    Nice
    Nice
    Yuk

    See all

    Yuk
    Kauai Kahuna Vacation Rentals

    Kauai Kahuna Vacation Rentals

    2.8
    (19 reviews)
    0.0 mi

    Update about the review below: After further communication with the management company, they…read morereached out, acknowledged the issues we experienced, and worked with us to make things right. They ultimately provided a refund, which we truly appreciate. Although our stay had several challenges, we're grateful they took responsibility and made amends. We believe every company can have off moments, and we appreciate their effort to resolve things professionally and fairly. We've visited Kauai many times and have always had wonderful experiences, but this property was by far the worst we've ever stayed at. The shower floor had a large crack that sank when you stood on it, and it was "repaired" with duct tape -- completely unsafe and unacceptable. There were spider webs hanging from the ceilings, the dishes were dirty, and the towels were clearly not cleaned -- several still had makeup stains from previous guests. On top of that, every AC unit had a thick layer of dust, easily a couple of inches thick. The internet didn't work for our entire stay. Then, a few days before we checked out, the AC stopped working. I contacted the property management the same day it happened, and they said they would send someone out to look at it -- but no one ever came. I continued to call and ask to speak with a manager, but no one ever called me back. Even after our stay, we have not heard from the management team regarding any of these issues. The lack of communication, cleanliness, and basic maintenance was extremely disappointing.

    DO NOT BOOK A PROPERTY WITH THIS COMPANY!!! We booked a…read moreplace in Kauai managed by Kauai Kahuna Vacation Rentals. Our flight from San Diego was rerouted back after 2 hours due to tsunami warnings that happened while we were in the air. We were unable to get a different flight. Kauai Kahuna Vacation Rentals would not accommodate us due to the extraneous circumstance. In general, their customer service is lacking or non-existent. If you do decide to book with them, read all you the paperwork ahead of time as they tried to increase the cost from the advertised price. This was alarming to see and difficult to correct with them.

    Photos
    Green from the deck
    Green from the deck
    Kauai Kahuna Vacation Rentals
    Coast view from Sealodge

    See all

    Coast view from Sealodge

    Garden Island Rentals - vacation_rentals - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...