My husband and I were visiting from Michigan and were very pleased to run across this gem. Great food, quaint atmosphere and ambience. The Owner (who is from Ireland) greeted us when we came in and gave us a quick tour. Extremely friendly and welcoming. Wish we lived closer because we would definitely come back. read more

Delicious! Such a cute area, little lights, and outdoor green space! Very aesthetic! Great food! We ordered the vegetarian teramisu, which was great! Lamb stew was good! Outstanding burgers! Very good soups! Clean bathrooms! read more

Excellent! Food and service was amazing. Definitely one of the best, if not the best restaurant in new paltz!

Great food excellent service lovely atmosphere. The drinks were creative and delicious. The crab was real and a lot of crabmeat. Great spot

Excellent service at this quaint old tavern which the staff says is in a home that is at least 200 years old (sorry, wasn't exactly paying attention on the date). Guinness is served in the proper way and the menu breaks the barrier between pub food and continental cuisine. Had the duck breast special with puréed sweet potato and asparagus. Awesome! read more

Very delicious food. The flavors are so distinct and bold. Truly stands out. The ambiance is so warm and inviting. The host was great, I love his Irish accent. read more

Great location, delicious food, especially the short ribs and chicken & mushroom dishes and a fun atmosphere, especially if you like Irish music. What's not to love?? read more

What a great restaurant! We had Shepard's Pie and it was wonderful. We may go back tonight!

Amazing place! Very attentive service along with a great food! We were met by the owner who was nice enough to personally take us to our table. The restaurant is located in a 258 years old house, the decor inside is lovely and makes the place look very cozy. The food and drinks were also very good. We ordered bangers and mash, fish and chips and a house salad. My husband had tap Guinness and I enjoyed The Pimm's cup drink, which became my favorite summer drink after this visit. Highly recommend! read more

A 5-star review is well deserved for Garvan's. Everything from the food, to the waitstaff is incredible. The atmosphere is unlike anything else in the area - tucked away on the quiet side of town, not too far from Main St. Garvan is one of the most kind and generous people you will ever meet, and his staff reflects such. You will definitely be taken care of here. read more

We found this restaurant on a Saturday night through the yelp app. We had been hiking in the area and are from CT so we didn't know what to expect. They were completely booked but gave us a seat at the bar and assured us we could order from the regular menu. The space was bueatiful, cozy and welcoming. The owners were present and everyone was just amazing. The food was superb and I honestly cannot say enough wonderful things about our experience there, read more

Great experience at Garvan's that began immediately with the host serenading our daughter with an old Irish folk song when he learned her name is Mollie. The hospitality of this establishment is impeccable! The meal was also excellent, with an attentive waiter and solid service. We enjoyed two salads to start- the large house salad with Gorgonzola and walnuts that was well dressed and indeed as delicious as other reviewers have indicated & the beet salad, a small but attractive assembly of beets and greens. The lamb stew was rich and hearty, precisely what one would expect from an Irish based restaurant. The salmon was cooked properly and served with a delicious yet simple risotto and fresh green beans. The only fault in the meal was the eggplant rollitini, a choice for the vegetarian at our table, that perhaps should not be on this menu. The desserts were delicious- an Irish tart with cream that was a special that evening and a raspberry lemon pound cake. We'll be back! read more

We had our intimate wedding reception (21 people) in their upstairs space. Everyone was so warm and welcoming and made our day extra special!!! Delicious food!!!! read more

The food and atmosphere here were amazing. One of the best meals we've had in a long time. We were greeted right away by the owner who was very personable and nice. He took time to speak with us again on our way out and ask us how our meal was. Our server was very helpful and patient as we were feeling indecisive and took a while to order. She offered a lot of suggestions and made sure we knew she was available without being overbearing. My wife is pregnant and the staff was very willing to accommodate her dietary needs. We started out with the bacon wrapped scallops appetizer which was the special of the night. It was simple but delicious and the scallops were cooked perfectly. For dinner, we shared two entrees - Garvan's Gorgonzola burger with truffle fries and the Seafood Trio. The burger had to be well done due to my wife being pregnant and yet it still had a ton of flavor. I am a big fan of truffle fries and these were by far the best I've ever had. The seafood on the trio (salmon over Asiago risotto, more scallops with spinach and a butter sauce, and a crab cake with a red pepper sauce) were each unique and delicious. My wife isn't a big fan of salmon but said this was the best she'd ever had and would eat salmon more if it tasted like that! Overall, just a great experience, portions were a good size, and it was worth every penny. Definitely a place we will come back to next time we are down this way. read more

The food was great! That's not why I am giving it three stars. It was the service. We had reservations and were brought to our table quickly but we waited an extremely long time for service for food and drinks. The tables around us got service from a different waiter/waitress and were treated properly. I don't think waiting an hour after our appetizers to get our dinner is reasonable. We even had to wait a long time after our food to get the bill. I had to leave the restaurant and walk around because I couldn't sit anymore waiting. Even when the dinner came it dat for a while when we were done waiting for it to be cleared. We were at the restaurant for 2 and half hours and only got one appetizer and two entrees. Therefore if you have time to spare then go to this restaurant it is really nice and the food was great! read more

We enjoyed an excellent meal at Garvan's recently. We started with a delicious beet salad and then had duck and lamb stew as main courses with an excellent apple pie for dessert. The tap beer selection was excellent but the choices for wine by the glass were only ok and not very extensive. Our service was fine once we were attended to as we had to wait too long to order. Dining room was lovely and rustic and not noisy. read more

Awesome food and staff had a very good meal on thanksgiving thanks to the owner and staff

Went here for a date night and had a great time! Their food was super tasty, especially their upside down apple pie :O yum. A little pricey, but worth it if you want to treat yourself. The owner greeted us at the door like we were his old friends. Actually, it seemed like most of the patrons were his old friends. My fiance and I joked that it felt like we were crashing someone's party where we didn't know anyone. Definitely a really homey, warm environment, but also a little loud (like, I couldn't hear you a half a foot away from me loud) so I'm not sure I'd choose this as the most romantic date spot. Regardless, I would definitely return! read more

Out of the way of the normal college life hustle and bustle that has come to define the town of New Paltz, Garvan's in just to the north, down a short winding road. The gastropub is situated in a small cottage on a golf course. It's a place more likely to find the professors than the students. The staff and the service here were great, as was the food. I opted for the seared scallops as an appetizer, which was cooked perfectly. Delicious flavors and the perfect texture. The lobster ravioli I had ordered as my entree was equally enjoyable, not skimping on the lobster stuffed inside, nor on top of the dish itself. The menu has a lot of great choices and I hope to try something new when I return. read more

Such a lovely and quaint place, a restored farmhouse. Lunch was wonderful, and servers were attentive. Wholeheartedly recommend!

I just love Garvans. The atmosphere is charming, their food is terrific and the service couldn't be better. We sat on the patio and thoroughly enjoyed our evening. Thanks Maria and the rest of the staff . read more

Absolutely phenomenal. The service was impeccable, the food spectacular, the drinks perfection. We knew it was going to be special when we were greeted and seated by Garvan himself, but our every expectation was blown out of the water. We will be back again, as soon as we're able! read more

We went for a staff lunch and had a great time. The restaurant is lovely. We were in a dining room upstairs. Mike our server was so accommodating and kept up with the requests of our large group with no problem. Had the chicken and Brie sandwich with fries. Fresh and delicious! Salad and potato leek soup was also a hit. Very nice addition to the Hudson Valley! read more

Great new restaurant. I was there on opening day the food and service was fantastic. Prices are a little on the high side but the quality is very good. I would say one of the best places to eat in New Paltz .I've been there one other time since then and it was consistent with the first time. We are heading there tonight for a St. Patrick's day dinner with eight other people and I'm sure will be happy. read more

After a great day of hiking at Lake Minnewoska we stumbled upon Garvan's. Met by Garvan himself as we walked in to a welcoming smile and Irish Brogue. We knew instantly this was going to one of our new haunts! Warm, welcoming, a true gem and a little slice of Ireland in the Hudson Valley. From the pint of Guinness poured with perfection from the tap flown in direct from Ireland from Guinness themselves to the sound of Irish melodies playing in the background to the Guinness Lamb stew, superb! Special thanks to Jake for taking such good care of us at the bar. Until next time (soon). Sláinte read more

See all

What a restaurant should be. Warm hospitality, great service, delicious food. Authentic Irish Guinness (the owner brought the tower himself from Ireland). Real wood fireplace. Do yourself a favor and bring some friends. read more

Was greeted by the owner at the door- with his authentic Irish accent!! Wonderful food, great cocktails, and a truly relaxing atmosphere. Must haves- Strawberry Delight, Guinness Chocolate Cake, Short Rib Sliders, Clam Chowder, and Seared Scallops! The only thing they could work on is service. I think they need a little concentrated training. But our waitress was extremely sweet and knowledgeable- but just in my opinion, to meet the caliber of the food, service needs some fine tuning. Thank you for a wonderful experience- best meal we had while visiting the area! read more

Great place owner very friendly, great service really good corn-beef. Scallops were amazing and they pour a good pint!

I have dined at Garvan's four times and it is by far my favorite restaurant in the New Paltz area. The scallops with Parmesan risotto are always perfectly done. The braised beef short rib is better than Grandma's (and Grandma was a damn good chef). The Caesar salad is lightly dressed as it should be. Oh, the atmosphere is so warm and welcoming with roaring fireplaces and different rooms for dining and relaxing in the bar that I am inclined to spend the day. The staff is wonderful on every visit. If you find yourself in New Paltz, you have to check it out. It's not on Main Street but maybe a mile drive away. read more

Great vibe inside. Owner who was on site was the nicest, most accommodating host I've ever met. Great place for a drink or casual dinner.

Couldn't be more impressed. Haven't been here since the new owners took over, and I am just thrilled with the new menu and the chef. All the food was amazing, including the roasted chicken and the short rib. Cocktails were equally as impressive. Would recommend this to anybody looking for a fine dining experience, and a casual and beautiful atmosphere. read more

Awesome atmosphere. Warm and cozy fireplace with great food and drinks. Recommend!! Had the soup and fish and chips. Entertainment at weekends. Will definitely return!! read more

Supremely charming setting. The leek soup and the scallops were beyond! There's a reason so many people have posted pics of the scallops. Maybe best scallops I ever had. Great place for a serene afternoon getaway. Service is warm and friendly. It doesn't get more quaint than this. They were out of the chocolate cake today. Must go back for it. read more

Outstanding! My wife and I showed up on a busy Friday evening without reservations and were personally greeted by the owner. He shook our hands and sat us at a nice table. The waiter was polite and knowledgeable about the menu and specials. The food was served at a comfortable pace and was completely on point. We took our time and enjoyed our meal. We were never rushed and enjoyed the comforting environment that the historic restaurant offered. The chef, Josh Paige, took time to speak with us on the way out. It is a very welcoming place to relax and enjoy a well prepared meal. I highly recommend this establishment! read more

Two bad meals in a row. This time ordered a salad with no salad dressing it was good, then I ordered salmon with nothing on it medium with asparagus and green beans. Asparagus not cooked, green beans not cooked and the salmon came out 40 minutes later completely black on the bottom and flaking. It was burnt so bad. I told the waiter it was burnt his response was, it's just the skin and he walked away. Paid for the meal walked out. Owner confronted me and told me I was crazy that his restaurant has all good reviews, so I have to leave this review. good luck. read more

Really great drinks! The risotto and mushrooms are amazing. The salmon and burger are pretty good. The scallops are a bit small and the vegetable napolean is really not great, but it was a good experience and we were overall thrilled with our meals. Nice prompt and attentive service! read more

Food, as always is excellent. Wait staff is attentive and courteous. Ambience is homey and relaxed. Always a pleasant experience.

Went to New Paltz for a long weekend. On our last evening in town we decided to go to Garvan's for dinner. The food was rich, but delicious. Everything we ate we would recommend - stuffed mushrooms, shrimp scampi appetizer, lobster ravioli, and OH MY GOD the beef short rib. It falls off the bone and melts in your mouth. Our server was Rob and he was the best server we have ever had. He put up with our million questions like a champ and was just so kind and welcoming. If we come back we will be requesting him for sure. All in all a great evening with great food. read more

I came here with my wife and two friends after touring Coppersea Distillery just down the road, and this could not have been a better meal to follow that singular tour. Every part of this experience made us feel welcome, well served, well fed, and definitely cared about. Phenomenal atmosphere, top notch bar (they do know how to pout a perfect pint), simple yet amazingly flavorful food (I've never had a better creme brulee), and a host (Garvan himself) and waitstaff that are attentive, friendly, and generally welcoming. We found this on a lark, and it was one of the best restaurant dining experiences I've ever had. I'll definitely make the trip up from the city again to come here. Thank you again Garvan! read more

Great food and atmosphere!! Definitely worth driving off the main strip. Restaurant is from the 1700's and very cozy. Delicious lunch and will be back soon! read more