Gelatoville was good, but nothing to rave about. Average gelato spot with very mid to low service. The inside was beautiful and they were newly finishing a remodel when we came in. Unfortunately, there was nothing praise worthy of this spot. The flavors were typical flavors. Would I navigate back just for this place? Absolutely not Yelpers. Here's to originality Yelpers, it sets us apart! Xx read more

Gelatoville - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

Okay gelato. Came when they had a grade pending, but they were cleaning thoroughly. They were cleaning up an hour early and only had some of the gelato out. We tried the lemon and tiramisu. The lemon sorbet wasn't great, a little too sweet and lacking some flavor. There are better lemon sorbet at other places or in the store. The tiramisu was good. Not worth the price. read more

The gelato was ok I got the cup with 2 flavors amaretto and cheesecake. I do prefer other gelato spots tbh the flavors weren't that bold. read more

Gelatoville - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

The pistachio gelato here is so good! I love the real nuts on top and inside to give it crunch. The gelato is so smooth and creamy. I love how they let you try samples! There is a good amount of seating inside, and the workers are nice. I noticed there were a good amount of flavors out. Definitely a great spot to grab a treat! read more

Gelatoville - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

There was a slight line when I went but that's because there was only one employee working and he moved through the line fast. The gelato flavors were so good but the hazelnut mixed with Nutella was fire! read more

Gelatoville - Hazelnut - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Really solid gelato experience with a variety of flavors and generous portions. The interior of the store is minimally decorated but does offer some seating. I was super impressed with the unique flavors the store offered. Every gelato flavor I tried was delicious. There were more classic flavors but also seasonal and creative choices. I saw some solid vegan options as well. I visited on National Ice Cream Day, so the store was packed. They were giving away gift bags and had a cute temporary photo booth. Despite the crowd, the service was super speedy, and all the employees I interacted with were friendly and helpful. I was shocked by how much gelato they piled into each cone/bowl. My bowl was absolutely overflowing with gelato. I need to visit again to try more flavors! read more

See all

Really good gelato all around with friendly service that's open reasonably late for the area. I'd highly recommend the pistachio, banana, and ferrero rocher flavors! They're an oddly perfect mix in the medium cup (3 flavors), and they're pretty generous with their scoops here. If you're from out of town, you might think it's expensive at $9 (in 2025), but the quality and flavors are there, and the prices are just the going rate for NYC. If you like a lot of flavor options without too long of a line when you're in the area, you'll have no regrets at this Gelatoville! read more

Gelatoville - Inside - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

I highly recommend you try this place at least once in your lifetime. Yeah it's that good. Not too sweet but perfect. I got dark chocolate yummmmm and hazelnut mehh but cappuccino oh so good. And they let u try different flavors read more

Gelatoville - Hazelnut pistaccio cappuccino and dark chocolate - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

Rating: 9/10 Date Last Visited: 8/27/2025 We ordered the large gelato that comes with 4 scoops. We tried t he Ferrero Rocher, Cheesecake, Gelatoville, and Tiramisu. My favorite was Ferrero Rocher - it tasted exactly like the chocolate. The tiramisu and cheesecake were also really good, they were the perfect gelato versions of the original desserts. The gelatoville was good too, but I don't really know how to describe the taste. The gelato is creamy and represents their flavors perfectly. Overall, I would recommend if you're looking for good ice cream. read more

Gelatoville - Tiramisu, Ferrero Rocher, Cheesecake, Gelatoville - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

They are open late, so you can visit after dinner or drinks in the East Village. I enjoyed my gelato, which was delicious! They had a lot of different flavors, including several vegan options. There are some seats if you want to eat your gelato to stay. read more

Gelatoville - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

I'm genuinely shocked by how good this place was. I don't know what it was, but everything here hit and may have been some of the best I've ever had. We came after dinner in the area and it wasn't busy, and they have plenty of open space and seating as well. They let us sample flavors before choosing too which was nice. I got the pistachio and vegan dark chocolate and - OMG this was so good. The texture of this gelato is so thick smooth and creamy, and the flavors are so pronounced. I loved every bite of it so much. You can't even tell the chocolate one is vegan, as it's so rich and perfect for chocolate lovers like myself. The pistachio flavor was also so nutty and perfectly pistachio. Out of all the gelato spots I visited this time around, this one had to have been my favorite! read more

Gelatoville - Pistachio and chocolate - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

I got a small cup (2 flavors!) with hazelnut and black cream. Hazelnut was definitely the star here- it was so creamy and delicious and I'd definitely get it again. The black cream was okay, but definitely better in my sample than it was in a scoop. It wasn't as smooth and had some larger chunks of ice in it that just made the whole eating experience less enjoyable. I appreciated that there was a lot of seating though! There are so many dinner places in the area that this is a great place to get dessert afterward if you want to keep the conversations going. read more

Gelatoville - Black Cream and Hazelnut - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

Some of the best ice cream I've ever had actually and HUGE portions. The pretzel was INSANE. read more

Gelatoville - Pretzel - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

Got the tiramisu, black cherry and cookie Caramel... pretty decent gelato not bad ... gonna come back try the cappuccino flavor read more

See all

Good service and lovely gelato. On a weekday this place was busy. But it also was during a heatwave as well. The place was wall to wall with students and people coming from work. I had a good mix of mango passion fruit exotic and raspberry. All were great tasting and not too sweet. They let you try as much flavors as you want too. read more

Gelatoville - Mix - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A small cup holds two flavors. I chose one scoop of Bueno Cream and the other of Amarena. The first flavor was hazelnut, chocolate and wafers. A balanced texture of creaminess and crunch. I fell in love and could have had another scoop. Located in the East Village and opened two years ago , this gelateria fills the need for chilled ice cream in this neighborhood. Mujo is the Turkish owner, who has spent time in Italy and as he told me this gelato is from Florence. Sam was the friendly ice cream server who let me sample assorted flavors before I made my selection. I sat down to eat as there was plenty of seating. The wall of cones is pretty. I plan to return to sample and enjoy more flavors. Prices here are similar to other ice cream parlors. read more

See all

No notes, just great classic gelato. I loved the pretzel flavor, but the others (cookies and cream, hazelnut, etc.) that we got were all good. I like that they gave you big scoops. Not a lot of seating but there was a table open when we got there at 10 PM on a Friday read more

5 stars for the customer service and the memorable shop name. The servers look like little supermodels and are friendly. But the prices are high. A small cup of gelato costs 8 dollars. read more

Very delicious gelato. I believe they have a rotating menu so I highly recommend the pretzel and strawberry cheesecake flavors before they're gone. They give samples here but the employee seemed kind of irritated after a while so maybe they should implement a limit if they're worried about sales. There's plenty of indoor and outdoor seating to enjoy your dessert. read more

Food: The ice cream is extremely soft and creamy. The fruity ice cream is so on point! Service: they were extremely kind about samples and served me and my friends individually. Ambiance: perfect! read more

Gelatoville - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

The best gelato! It's so good and they have the Most amazing flavors ever. If you like icecream , this is a must- go! High quality, 5 stars read more

Gelatoville - Heal - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

The staffs are friendly. The small cup is $7, medium is $8, large is $9. You get to sample their flavors. I got a small gelatoville lemony, chocolatey flavor. There's seating outside and closes at 12pm. Would recommend coming here! Food: 4/5 Service: 4/5 Ambience: 4/5 read more

Gelatoville - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A little pricey, but they have such creative and delicious flavors! Came on a Thursday summer evening and it was decently busy. Even though it's pricey, I appreciate that they let you sample different flavors, and the servers are really nice. The ambience is good, if a little bit dilapidated, with a sparse scattering of some small tables and seating. I really enjoyed my strawberry cheesecake (really great tart and cream cheesy flavor), but there are so many other flavors that I'm itching to try! read more

See all

Places like this make it hard to order. BECAUSE EVERYTHING IS SO DARN GOOD. I love that a small cup allows you 2 flavors, so I went with cappuccino on the bottom and a flavor I forget but basically it had Biscoff cookie crumbles in it and I really never wanted it to end. So good. I love that your cup comes with a little waffle piece to give you some crunch. Great staff, decent prices (a single was $7) and amazing flavors! read more

Gelatoville - A single serving, which was plenty! - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

My friend and I had a sweet tooth after grabbing dinner nearby and ended up coming to Gelatoville for some gelato! They had a decent variety of flavors, including some vegan options. I chose cookie caramel (cookie butter ice cream with chunks of biscoff inside) and pistachio. Both were so yummy and delightfully creamy. The interior has a few tables, all of which were occupied by the time we left. Would return! read more

Gelatoville - Caramel cookie and pistachio - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

"Wow! Real Gelato!" I love the gelato here because it reminds me of Italy. Simple shop with a finite number of flavors but all of them very tasty and natural What's to cheer - Good pistachio, fondant and more! - pretty large sized scoops - 2 flavor choices in the small What's to jeer - Slightly more than you might want to spend in this neighborhood, but it's inline with good gelato prices in the city read more

Gelato is delicious. Service is friendly and fast. It's a great and convenient location, and there is a good amount of seating available inside and outside. I'd sit outside the shop and have gelato during summer, it's good ambiance. I also like that they're open late to hit that late night sweets craving! I like their pistachio and hazelnut flavors the most but have tried many, including dark chocolate (vegan), caramel cookie, Kinder bueno etc. They have a huge variety of flavors and some of them include nice chunky cookie or chocolate pieces. Portions are very generous for the price. read more

Delicious! I got the Gelatoville which is their special. It's an orange and chocolate blend, and it was so good!! The citrus tasted super fresh and was perfectly balanced out by the sweetness. The White Chocolate Pistachio was pretty good, and I also sampled the Banana which was perfect. The fluffy and creamy texture of this gelato is what took it to the next level. Everyone was super nice too. They were very helpful in explaining all the flavors, making recommendations as to what would pair well together, and letting us sample everything. They had a good amount of seating in and outside of the shop too! Great place to chill after dinner or for a quick treat. read more

Gelatoville - Gelatoville & White Chocolate Pistachio | IG @territheplatypus.eatz - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

Some of the best gelato I've had in the city. I got a single ($7) which comes with 2 scoops I had: - Biscoff cookie butter - Cookies and cream The Biscoff is their best flavor, possibly my favorite gelato in the city. The cookies and cream is also very good. read more

Gelatoville - Biscoff and cookie and cream gelato - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

Went here last night with a couple others after one of my many dinners. The staff here is friendly giving samples and answering questions. Their small is expensive but it comes with two scoops of whatever flavor so it's more like a medium in other spots. I think they should maybe add a mini with 1 flavor for a buck or two less. Anyway, there were a couple people sitting outside and after we ordered, a few others were ordering but it was late so the line was short. After trying two flavors, I could tell quickly that the texture of the gelato is very nice and it wasn't overly sweet. I went with the pistachio and the walnut fig. The former is very good. Strong pistachio though I would say not as good as Venchi but leagues better than the icy mess that is Amorino. Better is the walnut fig which is one of the better gelato flavors I've had in recent memory. Nice mix of nut and fruit with pieces of both and there was a floral flavor likely from the delicious figs. Would highly recommend it. They have a bunch of vegan flavors also for those who prefer and overall, it's a good selection. I think their signature is a mix of mint gelato with orange and for chocolates loves, they have gelatos mixed with Kinder Bueno bars as well as a Ferrero. Nice mix. Good staff. Would go back even with the high prices. read more

See all

Your standard gelato place with a wide variety of flavors including vegan ones! Pistachio flavor was very realistic and had the yummy nuttiness I was looking for. Mango was just alright in comparison. read more

Gelatoville - Pistachio & Mango - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

Gelato selection here is decent. Pretty delicious flavors to choose from. Staff is very friendly and allow you to try before you buy. The place is great for friends and family. There's enough seating. I'd totally come here again very inviting place. read more

See all

Just stopped by this newly opened gelato shop and decided to give it a go. They have a wide variety of flavors and 9 vegan options (the vegan pistachio tasted identical to the regular pistachio!!!) The gelato was incredibly creamy and smooth and the flavors were rich and decadent. The staff were super friendly and they were very generous with their samples. 10/10 recommend! read more

this gelato spot was rated 4.9/5 stars on google reviews - i had to see what the hype was about. they have a decent selection of flavors and quick service. a solid mix of non-dairy (sorbet) and dairy flavors, i will add. a small fits 2 scoops, and costs $7. they even throw in the free wafer cone! by the time we ordered and sat down, our gelato was melting down our cups because of the summer heat i ordered mixberry and passion fruit gelato! both very decent and very necessary for a hot summer night. i will say that ive had better gelato (for example, places where i could taste the individual mixed fruits ), but this is a solid spot to satisfy your gelato cravings! they also have a decent seating area with a free restroom for customers! read more

See all

As someone who is dairy-free, I LOVE the abundance of flavors Gillatoville offers! We tried hazelnut, pistachios, and strawberry and all were solid. Though it is vegan, it still was so creamy and delicious. read more

Gelatoville - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Lovely gelato! Owner notes in the reviews that everything is imported from Italy and there's a sister store in Florence. Loved the outdoor seating and kind staff. The white chocolate pistachio was sweet creamy and flavorful! I did sample the signature one with the orange and biscuit and would come back for it! Also gelato is typically healthier than ice cream (because ice cream may have higher fat content from egg yolk and cream). We need more gelato spots!! Would also love a crunch factor in the gelato if possible but could get tricky with allergens? read more

Gelatoville - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped in for a gelato after having dinner with the family across the street. Went with a small cone for $7. Choose two flavors - pistachio and tiramisu. As someone who has been to Italy and had gelato, I was not disappointed. Would I go back? Yes. Would I recommend to my family and friends? Yes. read more

The service is amazing. The server kept on offering samples, even when we felt a little too awkward to ask for more. So sweet. Besides the service, the gelato was delicious. We had the Ferrero Rocher and let me just say the Ferrero Rocher was the best gelato/ice cream I've ever had in my life. It taste exactly like Ferrero Rocher if not even better and the ambience is pretty decent as well as of plenty seating and cute photo ops. read more

decent gelato from a hearty variety of fruity flavors and nutty/cookie flavors as well. it however, doesn't compare to venchi. we got the mango/strawberry in a small cup and it was $7.63, which is a little on the pricier side for a tiny cup. it's nice that this place is open late, and the staff are nice. my only quip was that while we were trying to pay, one of the staffs, a girl was using her phone long enough to not notice us standing there waiting to pay to get out. minor thing but it left an impression. regardless, the gelato is fine, the staff are cool, and it's open late so it's pretty fine! read more

Gelato 10/10. So many flavors to choose from. The gelato is imported from Italy and is made in house, RIGHT DOWNSTAIRS!!! So extremely good. Def recommend. Servers are extremely friendly and attentive to their customers. The atmosphere of this cute gelato spot on 1st ave is happy and comfortable. Lots of seating and super clean. read more

Gelatoville - Beautiful entrance. - Gelato Near Me - New York, New York