Loved this place! Delicious flavors. Peppermint chip was good, speculoos was insanely good. This isn't a smooth ice cream but it's more that dry style like Van Leeuwen, which is still really good! Generous portions. I think a double scoop is $10. Good cone. Friendly servers. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Peppermint chip and speculoos - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Staff here is super friendly. Ice creams okay. I'll be back to try the pup ice cream for my pups next time. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I saw no advanced notice of a 4% credit card fee. As I was being rung up, it quickly flashed on the screen for 1 or 2 seconds in tiny letters. I'm sure most people don't notice that. Then I realized I paid more than I was expecting. By then it was too late. The ice cream was good, but I'm deducting 4 stars for the slimy experience at the cash register. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Such a cute little ice cream shop with minimal seating, but still enough space for small groups to sit and enjoy. The staff was incredibly friendly and so sweet to both me and my cousin, which made the experience even better. I got the peppermint scoop and my cousin got cookies and cream, and both were amazing. The portions were generous for the price ($6 each), we could barely finish ours. The whole place had a warm mom and pop vibe with really good energy inside. It honestly reminded me of a small hometown ice cream shop, just in New York City. I'd definitely come back to try more flavors and would 100 percent recommend stopping by!!! read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Peppermint Chip & Cookies & Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Cute shop but not the greatest ice cream. Got the vanilla and it tasted more like ice milk than ice cream. Lots of water crystals and didn't have the greatest vanilla flavor. Cute spot, and friendly service but would rater go somewhere else for better ice cream. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Davey's Ice Cream is so good in this heat. I had Vanilla and it was delicious. I don't get the cone. You can add whatever toppings you want. They have Vegan Ice Cream made from Oat Milk and Almond Milk. There's something for everyone. The employees from Davey's were very nice. Everything was handled timely. They cater so it's a great treat for a child's birthday party or any party. I'm definitely recommending. It's a Summer of ICE CREAM! read more

See all

I am obsessed with Davey's now solely because they had homemade marshmallow creme when I went. My favorite ice cream order in the world is chocolate ice cream with marshmallow creme and crumbled Oreos or sprinkles, and they were able to provide. The girls working were sweet and fun. They also had homemade hot chocolate. Seems like a cool spot and I'm excited to try more fun combos. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Chocolate ice cream with homemade marshmallow fluff and oreo crumbs - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

We stumbled into Davey's on a rainy Saturday night after a friend deemed soft serve unacceptable, so we went searching for a spot that would offer classic scoops. Davey's came to the rescue! The best thing about this spot is the staff. Their energy was infectious, they were kind and generous and patient in explaining different flavors and overall made the desserts we shared even sweeter. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - seasonal croissant flavored *small* cone - "one scoop" :) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Popped in for the blackbird promotion. You can get a free ice cream scoop if you have the blackbird app. The lady serving me was very friendly and nice. I got the strong coffee and she let me know that it's the equivalent of an espresso? (If I heard her correctly) and asked me if I was okay with it. She gave me a heaping scoop! Unfortunately, I was not a fan of the coffee flavor. Usually, I really enjoy coffee flavor ice cream but this time I was kind of disappointed. Not a fan at all. I'll definitely pop by in another time to try out another flavor. I'm thinking maybe something more fruity or a peppermint chip. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Coffee Single Ice Cream Scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

RATING: 6.8/10 Davey's Ice Cream is an institution and a source of late-night ice cream for people staying up late drinking and having a good time everywhere. Finally got a chance to try it, and glad to have taken part. The service was great, the guys in there were so nice and let me try all the flavors even though I didn't want initially ask for it, but they really wanted to share their joy for the ice cream with me it seemed. COFFEE ICE CREAM Their coffee ice cream is notable, as it is actually really quite strong, and will get you awake and has a strong coffee flavor. I appreciated this, and they had a few other standard flavors. The other flavors were nothing too out of the ordinary and they have around 10 or less flavors. I think in the competitive ice cream scene of NYC it's hard to stand out, and so I would say that this place is good, but nothing that beckons you from too far away if you're not near it. But if I was in the area and the mood for ice cream struck? This would definitely be a great option. CATEGORY: GOOD (terrible / bad / ok / GOOD / great / excellent) read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

such a cute ice cream shop hidden in the east village! they don't have a lot of flavors to choose from, but the ones they do have seem to be fairly unique. I tried the speculoos chocolate chip and was surprised by how much was mixed into it! you could really taste the biscoff, but the rest of the ice cream seemed bland. I'm not entirely sure how much things cost as there's no price listed on their boards, and I got this scoop for free from an event, so I can't speak on that. however, their portions are really big for a singular scoop! workers are very lively and seem to want to talk to you. shop itself is tiny and not much seating inside, but my friend and I sat on the cute bench outside! I think I would def come back for the strong coffee flavor. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - speculoos chocolate chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Staff is lovely, warm, knowledgeable and overall very good at their jobs. I am banana split obsessed so it's always so exciting for me to try out a new place. This ice cream shop cares about the novelty of ice cream and I appreciate that wholeheartedly. read more

This is a classic ice cream shop with a modern twist with new quirky flavors. I've sampled 4 flavors, and they have all been top-notch. As far as unique flavors, the speckoolos and nutella flavors are amazing, super flavorful, and all creamy and rich. The cookies n cream was so good because of the large amount of oreos in the ice cream. The coffee flavor was really good, being that you could really taste a strong coffee flavor, but it was not overly sweet. The workers were so hospitable and helpful with so many suggestions and allowed you to sample as flavors if you were curious. They have new flavors seasonally, so you always have a reason to pop in and try something new. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Coffee ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Speculoo ice cream is my go to here. It has biscoff mixed into the chocolate chip ice cream. So good and the staffs here are awesome. Love this place. There's also seatings inside. No bathroom. read more

Super friendly workers and I wish it wasn't seasonal but the vegan vanilla berry crumble is my favorite so far here! read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Speculoos Chocolate Chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Super friendly staff, fun flavors, and cute interior. I was craving a classic brownie sundae and this place hit the spot. Their ice cream sandwich was also delicious and fresh made. Great place to stop for a sweet treat. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Brownie Sundae (Single Scoop) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I tried their hot chocolate for the first time and it was really good. The hot chocolate is so thick and creamy and perfect for winter! You can also add marshmallows if you like! read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Homemade Hot Chocolate - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Whenever I talk about ice cream with my friends, I tell them that two businesses have kind of ruined other ice cream for me. One is Vanilla Bean Creamery in Cranford, NJ. The other is Davey's Ice Cream. I was first introduced to Davey's a few years ago when they were still on 1st Avenue, and recently I visited their new location to see if the quality of the ice cream was still what I remembered. I was very relieved to see that this place is every bit as good as I remembered! First, kudos to the staff for always being cheerful, helpful and efficient. Want a free sample? They are pleased to help. Need some information about one of the flavors? They've got your answer. I've always appreciated the customer service at this shop. As for the ice cream, it is absolutely delicious. My two favorite flavors are their Roasted Pistachio and Strong Coffee (with their Strawberry in third place). Each flavor packs a flavor punch. There's no subtlety here. The roasted pistachio has a wonderful smokiness and nutiness that are wonderfully balanced. The Strong Coffee is as advertised, a concentrated coffee flavor balanced out by a smooth dairy creaminess. Even flavors that aren't really in my "favorites" list (like Salted Caramel) are very well done if you are into those flavor profiles. This new location is a bit smaller than the previous one, but there are still seats inside to enjoy your sweet treat but I did not see any rest room for customer use. I tell all my friends to visit Davey's if they're in the area, so I'm telling you, dear reader, to do the same. read more

More like 3.5 stars. Cute little ice cream place. Friendly staff They had less flavors then I was expecting though. I normally don't go for vegan ice cream, but their new vegan flavors was intriguing! Tried their strawberry shortcake flavor and it was a little bit bland. The carrot cake flavor was interesting - has carrot and "cream cheese" bits in it. With the added spices, it really tasted like carrot cake on a spoon! The shredded carrot bits adds texture to the ice cream (and make me feel good about eating it- helps me meet my daily vegetable intake goals lol) Overall it's a bit too sweet for my liking though. read more

See all

Davey's Ice Cream has some pretty solid homemade ice cream. I appreciate how they have a brownie sundae on the menu-surprisingly, I can't find too many places in the City that have them! Their Cookies and Cream ice cream is some of the best I've had-mostly because they do not skimp on the Oreos and there's always huge chunks throughout my scoop. Definitely my go-to flavor: I wish they had a bigger variety of flavors, but maybe the smaller selection helps me narrow my decisions. The brownie sundae is good-but sometimes how good depends on the day (as I've had a visit or two where I'm not super impressed). However, I do appreciate how they make the brownies themselves rather than going the pre-packaged route. The staff is also always friendly and they are always happy to provide samples. read more

i had the vanilla ice cream and it was pretty good. it did have a weird texture for some reason. maybe it was extra frozen? it almost tasted airy and not as creamy as i would like. but it wasn't bad. staff was really friendly and they have some seating. read more

So good! Came here on Friday night and ordered a speculoos chocolate chip icecream in a cone. It was delicious! There were plenty of speculoos chunks inside the icecream which made it oh so cookie buttery. The icecream base wasn't the thick, custardy type, but the texture was still pleasant. To be honest, the chocolate chips probably could have been dropped, but was still pretty good. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Very good ice cream in Penn Station. Friendly service. Yummy flavors. I had coffee and Oreo. Both were quite enjoyable.

pricey but good. i recommend the chocolate dipper sandwich cookie ($12.50 for example)

if chicken soup is for the soup then milkshakes are for the spirit animal. recently, put in a pickup order via a food app for a Peppermint Milkshake at Davey's Ice Cream. the milkshake is quality over quantity / gimmicks. the milk is rich and smooth and the ice cream was fresh-tasting, flavorful, and not overly sweet. the Peppermint Shake had that minty natural freshness and chips of dark chocolate of the ice cream all blended up with milk into a smooth sip-able through a straw dessert. Davey's did fumble my order in one way* milkshakes run about $10+ on food apps, cost a little less if you order in-store. *the only MINUS in my milkshake (and maybe it was bc I ordered via a food delivery app) was that they made the Peppermint Milkshake without a huge dollop of whipped cream--FAIL. kept waiting for the Davey's staffer to catch the error but sadly they didn't and i didn't want them to have to re-make it nor have a conversation about it bc at the end of the day it's just a milkshake. the strange part was the person before me got a milkshake topped with whipped cream. case of temporary amnesia maybe lol! i thought maybe they charge extra for whipped cream? but that would be superweird. also checked the app later to see if you have to pay extra for whipped cream but there's no listed extra charge for it and all the Davey's milkshake pics are with whipped cream. anyway if you look at my milkshake pics versus all other Davey milkshake pics--the only difference is whipped cream. oh the humanity lol end of day, it's a good milkshake the store is a small space but there is seating in the back as well as a bench out front. the store is warm, colorful, and well-maintained. **post-review edit--Davey's also didn't offer me a punchcard either on my pickup order even though they gave one to the person before me who also ordered a milkshake. Man, customer service is really dead LOL bastards read more

See all

Homemade delicious ice cream. I love everything about this place. Thoughtful design from top to bottom. Def try the ice cream sandwich if you haven't. If you don't like this ice cream, chances are you're the problem just kidding haha but no it's def you. This place rocks. read more

amazing ice cream with many different flavors! the staff is so friendly loved the girl who served me ice cream

Thanks for returning back to the east village. Flavors aren't oddballs like what most market about, but what Davey does with simple flavor is to perfection- chocolate that taste like chocolate, vanilla with no artificial flavor and of course, birthday cake...that just reminds you of your special day. Kept the same fun, whimsical store font. Nothing fancy. Nothing creamy, just god old, thoughtfully churned ice cream. read more

The 2 stars is for the staff. One of the employees was so pleasant and wonderful. The 2 thumbs down? The shakes. Skip em. Over $10/shake and they taste like a glass of milk. The prices are extremely high for the quality. read more

Davey's Ice Cream - Flavors - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I'm a soft serve girl but the strawberry and speculous flavors slapppp. The strawberry is super fresh and the speculous has lots of good cookie bites in there :) only complaint is that it's a bit pricey for being ice creammmm read more

Delicious ice cream, friendly staff, and great vegan options!! A must visit for ice cream lovers!! read more

See all

Worst banana spit ever! All 3 flavors of ice cream tasted the same. The whipped cream was totally collapsed and the hot fudge was non-existent. Nothing worse than deciding to splurge on some calories and it totally not being worth it. Thanks for nothing Davey's! read more

Their rice crispy treats are out of this world and their brownies sundaes and milkshakes are my favorite. Their ice cream is rich and creamy and quality is always consistent! Love Davey's! read more

Incredible experience. First thing that happened when I walked through the boutique retro entrance, was the owner started yelling at me. "NO NFTs ALLOWED. IF I SEE A JPEG, YOU'RE OUT" I have no idea whan an NFT is, and why it was such a problem. The person before me was apparently really distraught (he was wearing a BAYC hoodie). The Owner, dressed in a dapper black suit with a DAVECORP label, came over and slapped the phone out of the man's hand and threw him out, followed by his phone tossed in the gutter. I've never seen anything like it. "DO YOU HAVE AN NFT BRO?" The owner asked me. "No, I don't even know what an NFT is, but I'd love some ice cream" - I said, careful not disclose my huge portfolio of underwater NFT bags. He patted me on the back, went behind the counter in his dapper suit, and made by hand the best damn ice cream sandwhich I've ever eaten. Unbelievable. 11/10. read more

Curated top shelf ice cream. I've been a fan of Davey's for years. They have a relatively small number of flavors but don't be fooled. Each flavor is excellent and carefully prepared. And they have all the main flavors to keep any ice cream fan satisfied. Quality over quantity. For example, there are only a couple of places that I can just enjoy the vanilla and Davey's is one of them. But sit down boys and girls and let me tell you about my recent trip. I indulged in their dark chocolate which is really rich and satisfying. And also their peppermint chip, which was new for me. So this is essential Mint Chocolate Chip and I can say without hesitation that this is the BEST mint chocolate chip in the city, maybe everywhere? I like to think of myself as a mint chocolate connoisseur, having started eating this flavor as a young lad like 40 years ago. And the best of the best used to be a place in NJ called Grunnings. Google it to learn more. Their mint chip used shaved flakes of chocolate rather than chips or chunks. The latter tend to get really hard and while still delicious, Grunnings really nailed it with the shaved chocolate because it kind of melted in your mouth. Well guess what? My boy Davey ( I met him once years ago when they first opened on 1st ave) has used this fabulous method of shaved chocolate. Plus real peppermint! Many other places commit the sin of using spearmint and it makes me want to cry. So indulge my friends. I do not know how long this peppermint chip flavor will be there so run over and grab some and you'll appreciate it from the first bite. Mint chocolate chip artwork if you ask me. Pair it with the dark chocolate for a perfect combo. Thank you Davey's for bringing back the flavor and texture (minus the artificial green color) of real mint chocolate chip. It's quite refreshing. And if you're going to indulge in ice cream, Davey's is the place to go! read more

Great atmosphere and staff ! The ice cream was so delicious creamy & fresh. As soon as you walk in you feel welcomed