Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Gem City Saloon

    4.6 (41 reviews)
    ModeratePizza
    Closed 11:00 am - 2:00 AM (Next day)

    Gem City Saloon Photos

    GEM CITY SALOON ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Good for groups
    Dogs allowed

    You might also consider

    More like Gem City Saloon

    Recommended Reviews - Gem City Saloon

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos - Gem City Saloon

    Spinach Artichoke Dip
    Amber S.

    Overall happy with our experience here. Pretty sure the spinach artichoke dip was microwaved to heat up. But still tasted good. The BBQ chicken pizza was amazing. Definitely more than enough food for 2 people. Prices are reasonable as well. Service was quick. The menu isn't extensive but the things we tried were good. Would definitely consider stopping again.

    We took a ride out from The Dells and found this nice place. Friendly staff and AWESOME pizza... We WILL be back!

    Dining area
    Haley W.

    We stopped for dinner after a long day of skiing. The interior itself is a bit basic, mostly just a bunch of TVs streaming golf. Our server was curt but nice enough. The cheese curds were a hit at our table so I definitely recommend ordering, especially if you're an out-of-towner! The standout meal was the pizza - they have huge deep dishes that are tasty and filling. We had the veggie option which was completely loaded with mushrooms, peppers, olives, etc. it's definitely enough to share for 2-3 people.

    Delux
    Megan K.

    Prompt service- great place to watch college basketball. Food is a new favorite in my book for pizza. Great historic joint, look forward to returning when in the area!

    Pan pizza
    Michelle E.

    A local in Baraboo recommended we try the Gem City Saloon for their pizza, so we went, and it was amazing! Pictured here is the pan pizza with cheese, mushroom, sausage, and olives. I definitely recommend Gem City to anyone visiting the Baraboo area!

    Gem City Deluxe
    Bobb S.

    What a "gem" of a place in Baraboo. A spacious interior with table seating as well as an expansive bar to drink and eat. A respectable tap list as well as menu featuring appetizer, sandwiches, salad and what I stopped on for-pizza. It was my first time stopping in and was super impressed by their pan style offering. A super rich crust with a crispy bottom piled high with toppings. I went with the deluxe-sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, onions, olives, mushroom and peppers. It is absolutely massive and perfectly cooked. What impressed me was the sauce. It wasn't a traditional tomato sauce but almost a bechamel/cheese sauce. I still don't know what it was but absolutely delicious. Definitely wouldn't hesitate stopping in if ever traveling through Baraboo again.

    Deluxe monster!
    Brian J.

    This place is always a stop when in the Baraboo area! The large Gem city deluxe was huge with massive sausage and very filling . Excellent bang for the buck! Just go there!

    a pizza with a slice missing

    See all

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Gem City Saloon

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,507 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Mike's Italian Restaurant

    Mike's Italian Restaurant

    4.8
    (79 reviews)
    1.6 mi

    I'll admit I was skeptical walking in. The restaurant is attached to a hotel that isn't the nicest,…read moreand the entrance had a strong hotel‑cleaning‑supply smell that made me apprehensive. But from the moment we sat down, it was all uphill from there. The Italian wedding soup was excellent, rich, flavorful, and clearly homemade. The pizza was decent, nothing extraordinary but solid with plenty of cheese. We also ordered the lasagna, the spicy chicken dish, and spaghetti and meatballs. The standout was the spicy chicken: the "spicy red sauce" turned out to be more of a creamy, spicy blend, and it was fantastic. Everything came out piping hot, which I really appreciated. They also bring out warm rolls, and those were surprisingly tasty, soft, fresh, and perfect for dipping. Overall, I highly recommend this place. Despite the rough first impression, it turned out to be one of the best restaurants in the area.

    Oh my goodness--I truly felt like I was back in Italy while dining at Mike's! My husband and I…read morefirst met Mike when he was part owner of Mama Mia's on the square in Baraboo, and now he's opened his own restaurant as the sole owner. Mike immigrated here legally from Albania and became a U.S. citizen, and you can taste the pride he puts into every dish--everything is homemade, even the pasta. I had the spicy chicken arrabbiata with Alfredo sauce, and it was absolutely delicious. The homemade garlic knots were mouthwatering, and the salads were fresh and crisp. My friend ordered the shrimp pasta and loved it. I also brought home two pizzas for my family, and they said it was the best pizza they've ever had! The service was excellent, and the restaurant itself is spacious with a great bar area. From now on, Mike's Italian Restaurant will be our go-to spot whenever we're in Baraboo. If you're in the area, give Mike a try--you won't be disappointed!

    Photos
    Mike's Italian Restaurant
    House Stromboli
    House Stromboli
    Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    See all

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza
    Driftless Glen Restaurant

    Driftless Glen Restaurant

    4.5
    (503 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$

    We visited Baraboo for my Birthday & selected Driftless Glen for my birthday dinner, best choice I…read moreever made! The food is easily in the top tier we've ever had. Quality, flavor, presentation were simply top notch! It just so happened to be oyr servers birthday as well, so that was fun & she was so sweet & accommodating... the atmosphere is is wonderful with the distillery, gift shop & a view of the river right out on the terrace if you want to eat outside. We saw a mother & baby deer right across from us and a whole family of geese with their gosling. We loved the place so much, we came back 2 days later for lunch before leaving the area. Take the Distillery tour & buy some amazing infused balsamic vinegars, oils, bourbon, brandy, bourbon BBQ sauce, scented candles & other before leaving. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! We will come back & visit more of Baraboo just to eat here again!

    My bf and I came here for quick "something to do" while visiting Baraboo. We only did the tour, but…read morefor $20 I found it to be enjoyable and knowledgeable. You do get to try up to five tastings of your choice, which was nice since you can double up on a tasting if you really enjoy the taste. Our guide was funny and did a great job providing the information. As far as the cocktails go, I did get a tasty mojito! The cool thing is if you arrive earlier to your tasting, you can bring the drink with during the tour. I love the atmosphere and really enjoyed the tour guide!

    Photos
    Driftless Glen Restaurant
    Miso Pork Belly Crostini
    Miso Pork Belly Crostini
    Mango Habanero Burger

    See all

    Mango Habanero Burger

    Gem City Saloon - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...