Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Gemelli Gelato

    4.5 (122 reviews)
    Closed 2:00 pm - 9:00 PM
    Updated 3 weeks ago

    Order Gemelli Gelato Takeout or Delivery

    Gemelli Gelato Photos

    GEMELLI GELATO ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Outdoor seating
    Dogs allowed

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Gemelli Gelato

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Chocolate Gelato
    Antoinette P.

    Such a cute spot! The waffles were delish and the ice cream was so good! Loved that they had such a nice outdoor space to hangout & my kids really enjoyed it

    a sign in front of a building
    Mariah B.

    It's not a summer without Gemelli Gelato! Just how I remembered it. The chocolate was smooth and creamy. Can't wait to go back again!

    Parking sign
    Maria G.

    Nice seating area outside You can take nice pictures infront of the place Friendly staff gelato was pretty good

    Kim K.

    Gemelli Gelato is a fun little gelato spot. Packed interior funnels you in and out and you can e joy your gelato in Adirondacks or a picnic bench on a spacious lawn. Cash only. Did not notice but don't think they had a restroom. Good variety of gelato flavors - not overwhelming but enough to make you consider your choice. Samples are available to help you decide. I liked the fun little scoop shape cup and baby cone topping. My gelato had excellent texture and was not too sweet. I would add this to your list of must visits in the area.

    Small salted carmel
    Bloss C.

    Cash only is the only downside of Gemelli Gelato I can think of. Great quality gelato, nice seating area outside with adirondack chairs to sit and enjoy your gelato. Price wise it was very reasonable, we ordered seven small cones/cups for about $45. I had the salted carmel and wished i had ordered a large. I would stop by again when in the area.

    Looks Good- (But My Strawberry Gelato Tasted Mediciny)
    Mercedes C.

    When it comes to gelato places, I'm really not sure who are the dominant players in the Hamptons. Even if I missed a couple of places, it was 8:30pm already when we decided to get some and wouldn't have given us time to get to before they closed for the night. But on Montauk Hwy in Hampton Bays, this was just a 10 minute drive from our hotel. Gemelli Gelato has a sprawling space. And talk about social distancing protocols- Adirondack chairs were set up in two's on the lawn more than 6' apart! Additionally, picnics tables on the perimeter were also spaced out accordingly. We happily popped the trunk instead- just because I can't see anybody wiping down all those chairs. Gemelli Gelato has their shop a bit away from the parking lot, so I hoofed it a bit. The owner was helpful but rushed us folks on the line too. Granted it was almost closing time. Plus he had asked me and other folks if we preordered and I nodded 'no'. The shop is clean, small and he was just letting one person in- or a family at a time. AND there was only one scooper girl- so can you imagine her scooping out "gelato" to a family of 4 let's say??? Got a small Vanilla topped with walnuts for hubs and a small strawberry for me topped with Chocolate sprinkles. Damage for those? $12- too much in my opinion. I'm not surprised if food coloring and "strawberry" artificial flavoring was added. I know what natural strawberry ice cream, gelato, heck...even a Mexican strawberry "paleta" tastes like- and THIS wasn't it! On top of that, hubs said his vanilla had the texture of frozen milk! Am I missing something because this place tops the charts here? Not sure- but this isn't what I call great gelato.

    Amy M.

    Excellent! We've been here twice and both times we had absolutely delicious gelato. It tasted magnificent. I had the Chocolate Marshmallow Chip today and my husband had the Coconut. The service was superb. We had to wait outside for a few minutes due to the new safety regulations and one guy let us know the wait wouldn't be too long. Once inside the guys behind the counter -- both wearing masks as appropriate -- were so friendly and helpful. I appreciate businesses that are being extra hygienic and careful during these times. I wouldn't hesitant to return for more yummy gelato! It was a nice addition to our holiday weekend and a great way to sit and relax and enjoy a lovely afternoon treat. I highly recommend!

    Sha S.

    Definitely get gelato from here if you take a trip to the Hamptons! It's so refreshing on a hot summer day and they have chairs all around their gigantic lawn so you can order and chill and watch the children and dogs play around. They sometimes have a line but that just shows how good they are. I'll definitely be back this summer.

    The front ambiance.
    Steven T.

    Tonight we visited Gemelli Gelato. We live in Hampton Bay's and seer it all the time, they are next to Buckleys Inn, one of our favorites. We just saw Gemelli's featured on News 12 East end and figured that it estas time for a visit. You arrive at the location where they have their oversized gellato cones on the front lawn. You walk up a long path to their quaint little structure with outside seating only. Their are lawn games to play for the kids as well. Inside, they are all staff with a young and happy crew ready to greet you and help you decide which selections are right for you. They have small spoons for tastings. We both ordered the caramel and pretzel gellati....awesome and I your mind with the sicilian cannoli gellato which as great! I will make it a point to visit there often.

    2 size-smalls
    Julianna H.

    We love the flavors at Gemelli, and the kind people there. Their portions are large which is great. They also do not use egg in their gelato (as most places in America do), so their gelato tastes like low traditional and authentic Italian gelato. I love the outdoor seating area as well.

    See all

    11 years ago

    AMAZING GELATO!!! My favorite is the Rainbow. Phenomenal taste, wonderful staff and great experience!

    Business owner information

    Photo of Gemelli G.

    Gemelli G.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Gemelli G.

    Gemelli G.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Gemelli Gelato

    Do they have Vegan or Dairy Free Options?

    Yes. We have Sorbetto’s. They do not contain dairy and are also Vegan!

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    El Enkanto Grill Restaurant - Chicken Fajitas

    El Enkanto Grill Restaurant

    4.3(6 reviews)
    0.9 mi

    I've driven by El Enkanto so many times, and tonight we decided to give it a try. The restaurant…read moreis very festive and welcoming. They have a very large bar area with many choices of Tequila among other things. We sat down and were immediately met by our waitress Jasmine. Jasmine s was a great teacher explaining all the dishes (since we were newbies). She took our drink order, Mexican beer and Marguerite Mango which my wife enjoyed to the last drop! We were brought a full bowl of tortilla chips with salsa to nosh on. We proceeded to order the nachos and an order of Guacomole. The nachos were amazing loaded with meat, queso and probably a bunch of other things (onions, peppers, jalapeño) which I caught as I was attacking this delicious dish. The Guac came in a large stone bowl loaded up and was amazingly delicious. For dinner we shared an order of chicken fajitas. The fajitas came out sizzling hot and smoking as they were placed on the table, served with plenty of fresh home made tortillas!!!! A side dish was loaded with rice, lettuce and tomato and a nice bowl of their beans. Everything was delicious and plentiful! Jasmine took great care of us and bright is some complimentary lemon cello cake made by the owner's wife, yummy! CJ the owner came and talked with us about the food and the restaurant. Everyone was great and did a wonderful job on our dining experience tonight!

    I haven't found this open during their posted ours of operation , twice recently. Sign in the…read morewindow shows hours open, but they aren't open They may be out of business

    Photos
    El Enkanto Grill Restaurant
    El Enkanto Grill Restaurant - Chicken Fajitas

    Chicken Fajitas

    El Enkanto Grill Restaurant

    See all

    Hampton Bays Bagels - Breakfast Specials

    Hampton Bays Bagels

    3.6(37 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    $

    Trust the reviews on this one. On Long Island we have some of the best bagels. Unfortunately they…read moreare not at this place. Bagels are subpar. Cream cheese is a little off and I ordered a toasted bagel with butter and as you can see by the picture it is barely toasted. The staff was very friendly and nice, but the processes of how they operate are not efficient. Not yo mention it took almost 15 minutes for a toasted bagel with butter and a bagel with cream cheese. To note, there was no one waiting ahead of me. Just 2 people who had ordered prior to me walking in. They offer many other sandwiches , smoothies and other things that might be good but this is not a good representation of bagels on the island. Maybe travel a little further down the road for a bagel.

    Hampton Bays Bagels might be the best bagel I've ever had! It's in a strip mall and doesn't look…read morelike much but don't be fooled! It's super tasty. They have mini bagels and normal sized ones. I couldn't resist and got a normal size everything bagel. The outside is crispy and inside is fluffy - just the way a bagel should be. There's just enough everything seasoning on both sides. My husband had an egg everything and he said it was delicious. Their plain cream cheese is thick and creamy. I didn't love the veggie cream cheese - lacked flavor. But the bagel made up for it! We will be back for sure next time we're in town.

    Photos
    Hampton Bays Bagels - Inside view

    Inside view

    Hampton Bays Bagels - Menu

    Menu

    Hampton Bays Bagels - Daily bagel selection

    See all

    Daily bagel selection

    Caffe Italia - When you're here, you're in Italy!

    Caffe Italia

    4.4(130 reviews)
    42.4 mi
    $

    If you think you've had great gelato, Caffe Italia will make you question everything you thought…read moreyou knew. The man behind the magic is Mike, the owner -- and he is the real deal. Born in Italy and trained by the best, making gelato isn't his job, it's his calling. You can taste that distinction in every single bite. Mike is constantly developing new recipes, hand-picking fresh fruit at the market, and importing specialty ingredients straight from Italy when he can't find what meets his standards locally. This is a man who simply refuses to cut corners. My family and I have been loyal customers for nearly 8 years, and what's remarkable is that it's just as mind-blowing today as it was the very first time we walked through the door. That kind of consistency is rare -- and it speaks volumes. Over the years, we've brought roughly 40 friends and family members here for the first time. Every single one of them has raved about it. That's not a coincidence. That's excellence. If you're visiting for the first time, do yourself a favor: try the rainbow cookie gelato. You can thank me later. And while many people get it to go, I suggest having it there. The shop is tastefully decorated, it's clean, it's comfortable. For fifteen minutes you'll think you're in Italy. Caffe Italia isn't just the best gelato in the county -- it may very well be the best you'll ever have. Don't walk. Run.

    What a nice owner. He greeted me and he also knew about potential allergens in the food. I've…read morealways had issues with restaurants and the servers or owner not knowing if it has eggs or not, but this owner knows his gelato. I got a small gelato with a scoop of strawberry and cookies and cream. It was so much, I was honestly surprised I ordered a small. It was a fantastic gelato and hit the sweet spot.

    Photos
    Caffe Italia - When you're here, you're in Italy!

    When you're here, you're in Italy!

    Caffe Italia - Strawberry and cookies and cream gelato with a wafer on top

    Strawberry and cookies and cream gelato with a wafer on top

    Caffe Italia

    See all

    Gemelli Gelato - icecream - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...