The food was amazing! Service went well beyond what was expected. Recommend filet mignon. read more

George's Steak Pit - This was a great find! We ordered filet mignon, ribeye butt with asparagus & baked potato. Such a charming place! - Steakhouses Near Me - Sheffield, Alabama

The servers were attentive. We had a private room. The cheesecake was the best. The other food items were bland and very poorly seasoned and cooked. It is outrageous that the food is priced way above what it should be based on quality and appearance. George's, look around at other local restaurants for hints on how you can do better. For approximately $100 per person George's is WAY off the game. We will never return. read more

After learning there was a classic upscale steakhouse open since 1956 near where we were staying, we were excited to visit. Unfortunately we left pretty disappointed. Started with a beer served in the can, waitress returned with a chilled glass and poured. No big deal, just interesting. I'd never seen a beer can in an upscale steakhouse before. Wife complemented her lemon martini. Oyster rockefeller, served in a dish instead of in the shell. A couple were a little gritty, a little much raw onion for my taste and served with tiny cocktail forks that made it a bit of a challenge to eat. House salad was small; the Roquefort dressing I asked for on the side was excellent. Ordered the George special ribeye as it looked to be their signature steak. No hint of the wood grill flavor I'd been really looking forward to. It was a tough cut, and the flavor a bit off, perhaps they season with lemon? Or maybe the cut was a bit past its prime? Anyway, the steak fries it came with were a real highlight of the meal. Wife, wanting a lighter meal, ordered the lobster tail. Her side, badly overcooked and burnt brussel sprouts, was bad. Replaced with steamed mixed vegetables which she liked a lot more. It's a pleasant place in an unexpected location, and service was very friendly and helpful. I want to send love to a locally owned spot like George's, but it's not a place we'd return to. When we want a great steak in a wonderful atmosphere, at about the same price, in the area, sorry guys, but we'll be at the 360 grille. read more

Wonder steaks and service. Had chopped steak and brussel sprouts The sauce had a wine base and enhanced the steak. read more

George's is a must try if you are in the Shoals. We went there for dinner and it was great. We were seated quickly and had a nice corner table. I had the grilled shrimp with a baked potato and a salad. My husband had the NY strip with a baked potato and salad. The food is a little bit pricey, but in my opinion, it's worth it. The quality of food and service was top notch. We made reservations and we were glad we did. We got there pretty early about 5:15 PM and it worked perfect for us. It began getting really busy after that. We will back back. read more

George's Steak Pit - NY strip - Steakhouses Near Me - Sheffield, Alabama

See all

The service and ambiance were good. However, the food was only average and very overpriced. We got the oysters Rockefeller for our appetizer, and it was not very good. The signature ribeye was tough and not what you would expect for a $65 steak. All steaks are listed as market price, which seems a little unusual. My wife got the French onion soup which was not good. I got the seafood bisque for an upcharge (they didn't say what the up-charge was, but later found out it was $15) It was good, but I would not have gotten it if I had known the up-charge. For the cost of the meal, you're better off going to the 360 Grille or Odette. read more

My wife said it was absolutely adorable. When we pulled up, she thought it was a barbecue joint. Steaks were delicious, right off the open pit, we enjoyed a beautiful French Bordeaux and the steaks were scrumptious. Also had a little fried shrimp. read more

Appetizer (shrimp cocktail)- chewy, bland 2 Salad, ceasar- bland, no garlic, no flavor 2 Dinner- salmon flavorful and properly cooked 5, prime rib was VERY tough/hard to cut, fatty 1.5 House Cabernet was good, Chardonnay was not Service was VERY rushed 2 read more

Steak has no seasoning, this place is way overrated IMO. Buy a steak get some wood and there you go, you have a boring steak just like they serve read more

I'll admit that I last ate here in 1997, but that experience was great. The steak was perfectly prepared, and the rest of the meal was just as good. Service was awesome even through it was a busy Saturday evening. Now that I live in the area again, I should go back. read more

Little expense for what you get. The atmosphere is fine but it's dark. Waiters and waitresses are great, just the price for what you get is out of line. I myself think longhorns has little better steak and a better price for what you get , but that's just me. read more

Great food, great service, great atmosphere-the perfect place to celebrate our special occasions. Sarah was an excellent server and very attentive to all of our needs. We will definitely be back! read more

Yes, it will seem expensive to many people because the place has big city prices like Nashville or Chicago, but their ribeye steaks are oh so good! Treat yourself to it once in a while. Garrett is a very good waiter. read more

Amazing historical place with great food. Owner is amazing. Steak was top notch. Highly recommend.

I've never left a restaurant and felt more ripped off. My $54 steak came with an iceberg lettuce salad absolutely drenched in a soupy blue cheese dressing and a wimpy baked potato. The taste of the steak was very average and my wife had to send her med-rare steak back because it was absolutely frigid in the middle. We like a good mid rare steak but it was almost frozen in the middle. The bar area will melt your eyeballs with the 2 giant TV screens that surround you. Don't look up at the filthy beat up ceiling - eek! And don't look too closely at those weird carts they roll your food out on. My beer in the can I ordered was green (gone bad). Our food took FOREVER to come out. We really expected more from this place especially given that we had a party of 6 (including two kids who just ate chicken tenders) and our bill was $350!!!! read more

Everything was excellent from the service, taste of the mouth-watering delicious food to the romantic, clean ambiance!

Dined alone at the bar but never felt that way. Scott and his wife made me feel very welcome and the service was great. Scott recommended his favorite, Prime Rib blackened and seared with a baked potato. Had the house made Roka blue cheese dressing on my house salad. The meal did not disappoint, cooked perfectly, tender and tasty. Fun atmosphere in the bar area made the experience complete. Could see the expert chef grilling on the wood fired grill from my seat. I can't wait to go back and try the blue crab claw appetizer, it looked delicious. Will surely be back soon. read more

George's Steak Pit - Prime Rib - Steakhouses Near Me - Sheffield, Alabama

Had our Anniversary dinner there. Last minute change to plans as the restaurant we had planned to eat at was unexpectedly closed. Got right in, sat immediately and service was prompt and polite. Great experience, very nice setting, and the food was out of this world. Highly recommend. Yelp saved the night, and George's delivered an unforgettable experience. read more

Incredibly beautiful location, friendly, accommodating staff and the best Filet mignon I've ever seen or eaten. As i understand the same chef has been in the kitchen 50+ years and it shows. Everything from the Wine Menu to the Greek Salad all just perfectly executed. Made for a perfect evening to propose. Would recommend to anyone. read more

George's Steak Pit - Filet Mignon (Rare) - Steakhouses Near Me - Sheffield, Alabama

See all

Streak was average, Brussel Sprouts and Salad Dressing were solid. Bartender wasn't super warm. Other patrons were welcoming.

At first I want to say that the food is superb. My chicken breast and filet mignon was extremely tender and well seasoned. BEWARE- the grilled shrimp is cooked on the same grill as the filet mignon ! Hence cross contamination! I am allergic to shellfish and after only 3 bites of my filet mignon I broke out in a severe rash with itching. When asked if their shellfish and filet mignon are cooked together I was told yes. It was our 32nd wedding anniversary and I was looking for a nice place to eat (we are not local but here for work). I still had to pay for my meal! I would have understood paying for my husbands meal and our drinks but not my meal. food is great! service was not that good since the waiter told me that in their restaurant everything is cooked together. read more

I am on my way home from a trip to Augusta, GA (The Masters) and a visit to some of the golf courses on the Robert Trent Jones (RTJ) Golf Trail. We drove in from Augusta today and were interested in a good steakhouse after a long day of driving. We hit the jackpot with George's as this restaurant is an upscale, but very down home establishment. Our waiter, Brent, was very knowledgeable and made recommendations that were spot on. We met the current owner, Scott, who personally came by our table to see how we liked our meal. The food was absolutely outstanding and the wait staff superb. I am already planning on a repeat visit next April when we venture out from OKC to Augusta for next year's masters. I highly recommend the stuffed mushrooms and ribeye steak with loaded baked potato. read more

Went here for mine and my girlfriends anniversary and had a fantastic experience. The first thing you notice about George's is the atmosphere. The restaurant itself is very nice and well put together and is able to feel welcoming while also upscale. The salad was fine but they were gonna charge me extra for cucumber which doesn't make much sense. Other than this though it was a good salad The double delight was in fact a double delight. I ordered the steak medium and it was cooked to perfection. The steak was incredibly juicy and was also seasoned very well. The shrimp were huge and were crisp but not too oily. This is some of the best fried shrimp that I have had period. The potato as well was very good. All in all I would definitely return. It is a bit pricey but you don't feel like you are overpaying. read more

George's Steak Pit - Double Delight with the 8oz ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Sheffield, Alabama

We had a fantastic experience at Georges! We were in the Shoals visiting our sons at UNA and had the opportunity to get out of downtown Florence for dinner. I had seen great reviews and decided we would make a special trip to George's Steak Pit. It was about 8:00 on a Thursday night, so honestly we were worried about the experience. From the name, I really was expecting a simple steakhouse, but was sssssoooo wrong in my assumption! We received the best welcome from the owners, assuring us that our two college kids were dressed appropriately, we were worried due to the dress code posted (which we were in FULL SUPPORT OF!). How great to eat somewhere with standards like that, it only makes me look forward to my dining experience. And that experience was awesome. Steaks and sides were so good, but the desserts really took the cake! Crème brûlée and cheesecakes were amazing! Thank you for such a great meal! It made a great impression meeting our son's gf for the first time! read more

Ended up here for a business dinner. Heard raves from the locals about this place. "Best steak ever". Now I want to say this with a caveat. I live in iowa and we have one of the best steak houses in the country near us so I have a preconceived notion on what constitutes the "Best steak ever". When we arrived and were seated I ordered the ribeye. I mean if you are going to test how good a steak place is, a ribeye is what you go for. Steak came out, and was perfectly cooked. As for it being the best steak ever. Not really close. Again, my baseline is high due to the part of the country I live in. The steak was better than average but not the best. What made this place exceptional really want the food, it was the atmosphere and service. Our waitress was amazing and really did a good job taking care of a very large group of hungry (and thirsty) people. If I am in the neighborhood. I will make this a regular stop. read more

For date night it's hands down our favorite place. The atmosphere is fantastic service is above and beyond and the food is indescribable fantastic. It's not your every day steak house. They are truly one of a kind. The best kind. read more

See all

This restaurant is fabulous. The food is outstanding. The atmosphere will take you back to the 60s/70s restaurants with intimate seating. The prime rib is cooked to perfection. Their salads are scrumptious. Their seafood entrees are great, too. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

George's Steak Pit - Steakhouses Near Me - Sheffield, Alabama

The whole dinner was outstanding the service was excellent. We both had the 8and half oz filet, best steak around. The restaurant is very nice everything was top notch read more

An amazing date night location! The steaks were mouth watering and our server was so sweet!

I returned after many years and found as good as ever. All items well prepared. Ribeye was excellent. Even when our entrees an a little quick the waitress explained that the grill items came a little fast and she sorry. What more can one ask? If you don't want steak, fish is just as good. George's has always and continues to be an excellent choice. read more

This was only our second time to eat at George's. We don't get to Florence very often. First time was last yeat, abs we lived our dining experience. So, this year for my husband's birthday we decided this is where we wanted to go. And believe me, it didn't disappoint. The food is fresh and delicious and the servers are very attentive and helpful. Hubby had prime rib cooked to perfection. I had lobster tail m, and it was sweet and yummy. We will definitely go back. read more

My husband decided to surprise me last night and take me to a place I had never been, and didn't tell me where until we were on our way. If his surprises are going to be like this, he needs to continue surprising me! Outstanding! George's Steak Pit, a Sheffield landmark for 69 years, somehow unknown to me until now, but now on our list for future date nights, for sure. They are known for their steaks so that's what we went with but I added seared ahi tuna because I'm a seafood kinda gal. The steak, seared and cooked perfectly medium rare for both of us, was smoky and tender and so flavorful. The best steak we've had in a long time! The ahi tuna was good. The deep fried Brussels sprouts were SO delicious, but a little overdone and a bit too greasy. The flavor was on point though! Alternatively, the steak fries were a bit underdone, but still good. Our house salad and Greek salad were both really good. They make all their dressings, and that is evident. The taste is unlike what you're gonna get in a pre-made dressing. We started with the crab claws and they did not disappoint! We also shared a French onion soup and it was very good. We ordered a piece of cheesecake with caramel and chocolate sauce to go and devoured it when we got home. The ambience, friendly staff, and amazing food made for a fantastic experience that we would love to have again very soon. (For honesty purposes: given the aforementioned things, and the price, the plating could have been better on some of the dishes). Verdict: get yourself to George's! Also, shoutout to Stephanie for the great service! #HeatherEats read more

Excellent service. Clean restaurant. Fried shrimp good for North Alabama. Menu prices are on the high side but you get what you pay for.

Great food and awesome service. Ask for Anna Kate, she is a very friendly and great waitress!

Outstanding Restaurants with great Owners and Wonderful Staff that ensure you enjoy your Night Out....I set up Reservations for 8 for Wife Birthday and the Event was very enjoyable...The Foods and Drinks are outstanding..... read more

George's Steak Pit - 23 Ounces Bone In Ribeye with Bake Potato-Well Done-Outstanding - Steakhouses Near Me - Sheffield, Alabama

See all

Excellent food and service. Our steaks were cooked perfectly! We were too hungry to snap pics

Buck fitty for (2)small steak and lobsters (no booze)(2deserts)... service was pretty incredible first off! ...Salad was iceberg but definitely good! Wife had fillet (loved it) I had ribeye (loved it) potatoes were good ! The lobster was room temp at best on the first bite .. and the butter for dipping was ? Off a bit ? Like maybe oil mixed in with it ? Idk ? But if I ever go back it will definitely be a steak only .. oh and also the bread was two bites and left it uneaten.. pretty cool music playing on a side note ! read more

Very good steak. The steak had a smoky flavor and was cooked just right. Our server was very pleasant and service was spot on. Drinks were good. Nice spot, I recommend and i will return read more

Not sure what has happened to George's restaurant since our last visit. We have happily dined at this restaurant for nearly 40 years. Over the last 2 years (up until last August) I had been gifted several gift cards. The last time I used one was last August. This evening we came into town and decided to have a special dinner at George's restaurant and planned on using our last gift cards. I included the cards and my cc with the bill. The owner (new???) or person running the show came out to tell me the gift cards had expired and actually were no longer accepted by the new ownership. Additionally, when reviewing the bill I noticed that they are now charging for using a credit card. I can't recall the last time I went for dinner at a restaurant and did not use a cc. Charging patrons for using a cc for a high priced meal is about as low as it gets in my book. This is definitely not the George's Restaurant a have frequented over the last 40 years. You have lost me and my family members forever. Good luck with your new "all I care about is making money " restaurant theme. read more

Very nice and elegant restaurant, service was very good and food was good. I had the prime rib and it was good but not great, my wife had the filet and she said it was excellent. Will definitely go again. read more