Ordered a pizza via Slice app. The pizza arrived smashed into the corner of the box with a grease stain on the top inside where the pizza hit upon impact. The box was damaged. I'm a local and decided to try this place for the first time. I won't return. I gave the delivery driver a 20% tip because the job is challenging. I regret it because there is no excuse for dodging responsibility for a mistake. An apology or being told upfront would have gone a long way. Accidents happen. Taking onus and fixing the situation is not Gerardo's forté Slice offered a 20% discount. The pizzeria should have refunded the entire price. They said their pizza is bigger than the box so it may looked smashed. The pictures below are so future potential customers can decide for themselves . I supposed this is what the "new management" means per the sign outside. read more

See all

The people that work at this establishment are incompetent. Not even trying to be a hater this is just unacceptable. I was waiting for over ten minutes just for them to tell me they gave my order to someone else and had to remake it, causing me to wait an additional ten minutes read more

Food is good, not great. What i should say is i have had really good food and some bad food. Service is good, friendly. Place is kept pretty clean.. read more

The food was great. The service was fast . I ordered the grilled chicken and broccoli. Very very very tasty . read more

Gerardos Pizzeria - Grilled chicken and broccoli - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

Food is consistently delicious. new owners who are very nice. highly recommend supporting our local businesses especially when food so good. read more

Got a chicken cutlet garlic knot sandwich with spicy vodka sauce! Absolutely amazing and so cheap too! read more

Gerardos Pizzeria - Garlic knot chicken cutlet & spicy vodka sauce sandwich! Absolutely amazing & so cheap too. Excellent quality. - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

Super nice place. Delicious slices, good pricing and friendly staff. And the slices are great in size. read more

Gerardos Pizzeria - Margherita Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

The food is alright on some days but what I'm here for are the charges. The pricing changes every time my coworkers and I order. The menu lists one price they charge another. Honestly food isn't that great to be changing the pricing every other day. Sad because I liked their options. Highly recommend asking for an itemized receipt every time! read more

Although I have eaten at Gerado`s Pizza many times over the years, I have to say the new management and owners are horrible. The man who own`s the pizzeria now has a very bad attitude, he is rude to the customers as well as his employee`s. I tried to give it another chance but he was just as rude today as well. I will not be returning to this establishment. read more

I hate to write this review, but since the old owners sold the pizzeria nothing has really been the same except the name on the front of the building. The old owners were tired and miserable, but they ran a tight ship and put out a good product. I will trade a little attitude for a good product any day. After all it's a NY pizza joint, that's expected right? The new guys look overwhelmed, barely speak English and have burnt my slices the last 2 times I've been there with no one else in the place. The product isn't the same, the service isn't the same, it's more expensive and unfortunately a little dirtier. Used to be my go to pizzeria in Kisco, but I'll have to move on to greener pastures and pray to find a pizzeria where I trade being yelled at for great pizza. Gerardo's has lost its soul. Hopefully they can find it again somewhere in the future, if so I'll be happy to update the review. read more

So my company always orders from here we order as a group or sometime I order on my own I know several times I have ordered from here there's things missing or timing is longer than expected I get it things happen but when I order a salad and expect what is stated to be in it n is not is upsetting order gazzo salad came w no avocado no tomato ni fresh mozz like if you don't have the ingredients fit something why make it or st least tell the customer you will substitute or just state is not in me u today hate to eat something I paid for with no desire. And is not the first time but figured it will be a different outcome. The food and pizzas salads etc are good just didn't like that my salad had no ingredients stated read more

Great pizza, friendly staff. Definitely my favorite pizza place in the area. Recommend to anyone who wants some good pizza and wings.

We ordered a large pizza and fries to enjoy as part of our weekly football pizza party. When I say party, I hope you understand I am talking about the two of us. The food came quicker than expected on a Sunday afternoon. The pizza was appropriately sized with a thin crust, tasty sauce, and adequate amount of cheese. It was a very solid NY pie. Unfortunately, the fries were soggy and undercooked. They could've really benefited from some time in our air fryer but I didn't feel like cleaning that shit afterwards so we ate them as is. When looking at pizza delivery a few weeks later, I compared prices and this place is more expensive than some other places in the area. read more

This guy completely rips you off every time - watch your credit card charge and the change you get back. Totally slimy.

I'm a native resident and I've given these guys a handful of chances over the years and each time I'm dissapointed. The owners / managers have a horrible attitude. read more

Ok so first off this is a giant no from me. We ordered a Sicilian pie half meatball half pepperoni and a 2 L of Coke. Not only did they take well over an hour to deliver probably only about five blocks from me but they charged us $6.75 for a bottle of Coca-Cola. Only ordered one we didn't order three or four we only ordered one and they charged us $6.75 for it. The pizza also wasn't anything extraordinary. It really tasted like they just put it in the microwave and then gave it to us. I won't be ordering from here again. read more

Gerardos Pizzeria - Over charge on 2-Liter Soda - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

Expensive but the foods good. Nice ambience in there and feels cozy imo. Workers are nice

Very disappointed about the food,was looking forward to eating Chicken scarpariello, the chicken came out very tough to eat, pasta was not cooked enough, garlic was not cooked, sausage was overdone. Looks like it was throw together very poorly. Will not be ordering from them again, as we had let the gentleman know about the quality of the food and no response. read more

Grabbed pizza last night, absolutely the best pizza in Westchester. It makes me happy to see that someone hasn't stopped using quality products and making quality food. read more

The pizza here has gone way downhill in the last month or two, and it's consistently been that way. We get pizza here every week and now the dough is always overproofed, with the crust failing to rise and thick chunks of old wet flour cooked onto the crust. The pizza doesn't taste as good either. Don't know what's going on but it's not the same read more

We just moved to Mount Kisco, it took us a while to find a pizza place that had good food and delivered. Gerardo's fit the bill perfectly! The pizza quality is excellent and consistent. Delivery is fast and friendly! Give them a try, you won't be disappointed! read more

Does this look like a good cheese pizza? Yes, yes it does. But I ordered extra cheese. I'm tired of being charged a fortune for a pizza and having the restaurants skimping out. It's tasty, for sure. But I could have gotten the same thing without the extra cheese charge. read more

Gerardos Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

Good pizza. But for $24.90 for a pizza half sausage I'll pass. That was for pickup. If you don't like what you do sell the business. Owner didn't even give me the 10 cents back! Inflation isn't this bad fellas! read more

Hands down one of the best pizzeria in westchester county.The owners are great and really know how to make good pizza

I've been eating in Gerardo's and ordering food for years. The past year or so their prices have gotten exorbitant and recently we ordered clams oragenata and shrimp scampi for my birthday dinner. Instead of giving me clams oregonata, I got clams casino which I don't like. They were super salty and so was the shrimp scampi. When I called to tell them I received the wrong order, they told me just eat those clams, you'll like them, which I didn't. After spending over $60 dollars for dinner, they made no effort to rectify their mistake or offer me credit. I wouldn't give them business because they don't care if they get any. read more

Delivery person ignored multiple signs demanding they wear a mask during a global pandemic. Unfortunately, the apartment building doesn't have a full time guard so he shamelessly waltzed right in, walked up to elderly relatives door (which also has a mask required sign on it), and knocks. Parents are over 80 years old with pre-existing conditions. When I called to ask Gerardo's about it, they could not care less - they said they don't police their delivery people and as long as the order was correct, no problem. After all this incompetence, the pizza tasted like something out of the freezer. We could have gotten an Elio's for 1/10th of the price and it would have tasted better. This place was never good, not compared to Basilico, Sinapi's, Mario's, hell, even Miraggio's... but it seems as though they've just laid down and given up. Sad really. read more

Great service - pizza and meatballs were perfect. Tastes great - like New York should! read more

Gerardos Pizzeria - Awesome Special Slice - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

We've ordered from here a few times. Love the grandma style pizza!! Nice amount of sauce and easy delivery. The wings and salad we've ordered were good too read more

I really love this place! The food is very good and the pizza is the best I've tried in mount kisco. They're a very kind group of folks too. If you order online they give you loyalty points too! read more

Wonderful pizza lunch today - great variety and quality. Remember a fabulous pizzeria restaurant in this same location years ago - continuing the legacy. read more

Gerardos Pizzeria - Wonderful assortment of delicious pizza today. - Pizza Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

See all

Excellent pizza and Italian food. Gourmet food with friendly service. They treat you like family.

The best pizza in Westchester. The grandma is amazing and on point . They have the best chicken parm too. The prices are great and the customer service is great read more

Very solid pizza and Italian food. Meat sauce is very tasty for their pasta dishes. They have a nice sit-down area with waited tables or you can grab a high stool and people watch out the window. read more

This is by far the best pizza in mount kisco, hands down. Their grandma pie is my absolute favorite, but I must honestly say, every single thing I have ever ordered off their menu (and I've ordered a lot) is exceptional. I would highly recommend ordering from Gerardos every time you've got the craving for some pizza ! read more

Wow!! Pizza is excellent. Had some work done to my car so I asked the guy if Sinapi's was any good since it's close by. He sent me to this place instead which is a few miles further. Glad he did. Since the specialty slices looked like they were there for a while I went with the freshly made plain slice. read more

Food was not great. Staff that answered the phone was rude. Two of the three items I asked for they were out of at the time and the staff went on to Tell me how it will be available tomorrow which did me no good at all!Snuck in a 2.50$ delivery charge without telling me after I'd already tipped the delivery boy 5$. And also overcharged me on the original order which was also wrong at delivery. staff totally acted like they were doing you a favor by taking your money! Terrible ,terrible service. I will never spend another dime there again! read more

We were traveling through New York from Connecticut, what a very welcoming restaurant, even more welcoming was the owner who greeted us very friendly! The pizza was off the hook!!! Highly recommended!!! read more

Not just a pizzeria... delicious food. Doesn't disappoint and delivery guy is a friendly older gentleman! Friendly place.

I must say I am an Intailian food snob. the kitchen at this placer made a special dsh for me....pasta with chicken, mushrooms, eggplant and fresh garlic. It was Amazing!!'I invited a friend there who couldnt believe I wanted to get food at a "Pizza Place". She was blown away and since then,. she has gone back with her friends!! Overall, one of my 2 favorite places in Northern Westchester Josh F read more

Gerardos is a regular for my family and me whenever we're driving through Mt. Kisco at dinnertime. If we lived closer, we'd be there even more frequently. Though it's got a middle class decor and isn't that fancy (the restaurant half is right next to the pizza half), the prepared meals are absolutely first rate. Particularly good is the chicken francese, which my wife and I love. (It comes with pasta, salad, and warm bread.) The portions are very generous. And the wait staff--male and female--is terrific, very personable and attentive. Gerardos will even accommodate unusual requests, such as for a plain chopped iceberg salad in place of the more elaborate salad it usually offers. Can't speak to the pizza, but the prepared meals are terrific. Highly recommended. read more