I've been going there for YEARS. This is what I got after asking the dude if it was fresh...he said 20 min out...sorry,, this is not 20 min out. It's a burned out bottom. Threw both slices in the trash. And I'm devastated about having to give this review...granted, I did call, and the owner answered after my 2nd call, (1st call, I was hung up one and I was NOT rude or nasty) I assume, offered to replace, however, I am not leaving my house again to pick up slices again after I specifically asked if they were fresh. Nor do I want to make some poor delivery guy deliver when I am NOT going to tip him. And, the prices have gone up...if I wanted burned pizza slices, I could make my own or buy frozen. It's just totally unacceptable. I will pay higher prices...I get it, but NOT for burned food that I cannot eat. read more

Lucio's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

Their Sicilian pizza is my favorite!! Unfortunately I live a bit far by anytime im nearby at cold stone I stop by for a slice :)

Amazing pizza, sandwiches and entrees. I particularly like their rolls and sandwiches.

Delicious! The take out line moves quickly and the pizza was absolutely delicious. It was a clean venue with helpful friendly servers.

Great pizza, great atmosphere, great folks, always been my favorite for a slice, whole pie or main dish. Pleasantville's best

Every time we go here, the prices are different nuff said. The places to remain the same every time you go there.

Not my type of pizza. VERY cheesy VERY greasy VERY Doughy If this sounds like your type of pizza then look no further. For me on the other hand is a no no. read more

Lucio's Pizzeria - two slices of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

Delicious quaint spot. Wasn't busy at all and the aroma drew us to have brunch for breakfast. The service was friendly and the food is delicious! We also enjoyed watching the locals (and kids)come in and buy their pizza. It gave it a very warm welcoming family feel to the place. Definitely will be back next time we visit NY. read more

Lucio's Pizzeria - Deliciousness! - Pizza Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

Lucios is the best! If you're someone who loves a great dough, red sauce to die for, and great family ambiance this place is for you. We've been coming since we started as freshmen at Pace and still choose Lucios. They catered our engagement party and what a great experience! Food tasted no different catered than if we'd gotten it served up fresh at the restaurant. John and Lucio were so accommodating. read more

Been there a few times. They have a posting for best pizza place from years ago. Take it down. Not the best pizza place anymore.

Small sit down area and take out keeping locals very happy. I stopped in and tried a chicken Marsala gourmet slice and, Wow! - did they do it right! Not too salty and well balanced on the ingredients and satisfyingly filling. Whether you're among the neighborhood frequenting or from out of town, well worth it with a variety of styles and choices on the menu. read more

Wow, that was really great pizza. I grew up in this area, but live in DC now where I can't get good pizza. So every time I'm back in NYC or Westchester, I try to grab a slice. Hadn't been to Lucio's before but had business in Pleasantville. Very friendly staff. Great pizza for me and my husband loved his calzone ;-) read more

Food is always fresh and hot and delicious and authentic Italian, I'm going here for years and the portions are amazing for the price, I will always recommend Lucios to anybody who wants good pizza and or a good Italian food !! read more

Covid update - Lucio's is amazing food to begin with. This Brooklyn raised boy knows his pizza. The good news during these challenging times is that they haven't skipped a beat. The same fantastic food is available curbside or delivered . This business is totally worth supporting right now read more

Great pizza, Buffalo chicken sandwiches and chicken sandwiches! They were very nice and welcoming. I would recommend this pizza place to anybody!! Plus look at how huge the slices were (which were amazing)! read more

Lucio's Pizzeria - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

The food was very good, especially the pizza! It was a huge slice and the crust was really soft. The service was great and the people there are very nice. I definitely recommend! read more

Has been an awesome place since opening. All the haters should go somewhere else. Lucio thank you for being in business as long as you've been and continue to make everything fresh. Chicken on a bun hasn't changed in 25 years. Today's order was 2 chicken in a bun 2 thin Sicilian and bruschetta bread. All great. read more

Last time we were there we got saggy pizza and cheesesteak that had almost no meat! Owner seems to always be bored and angry with something.... What a disappointment! Found better place 2 mins away... read more

This is probably my favorite pizzeria in Westchester. They do have a free parking lot, but if it's full, you can just park out in the front. The staff is really welcoming and it feels homey inside. The slices are huge and I always get two to satisfy my hunger. Perfectly melted cheese, robust tomato sauce, and thin crispy crust - what more could you ask for in a pizza? YUMMYYYYY! If I could come everyday, I would! read more

Lucio's Pizzeria - Plain slice and a plain slice with mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

See all

Don't pass this place up! My family was visiting from Houston and searched for the "best pizza in the area" and I'm so glad we picked this one. Staff was super friendly and the pizza was MASSIVE. So so so good! read more

Lucio's Pizzeria - a view of the inside of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

Lucio has the best people working for him. With Lucio the customer comes first. Is Lucio's pizza the best? I think it is. He keeps coming up with new types of pizza and they keep getting better. Im reading about the guy with the supposedly burnt pizza. Just bring it back. probably just looking for a freebee. Who doesn't like well done pizza? Then the comment about "communities behavior of color". Pleasantville is not a prejudice community and Lucio and his workers are not prejudice. So Raveen you didn't like your food. It happens. Life goes on. Try not to use the prejudice card. Just try... God Bless read more

I've had this delivered 2x both times pie was under cooked! Even tho I ask for it well done! It got to my house in 12 minutes, not even enough time to prepare a pizza let alone cook it! read more

Picked up a pizza. Got home and found the entire bottom was burnt. Called and asked for another delivered. Guy on the other end wanted the pizza to be brought back for proof. Wouldn't take a picture or drive another one over to pick it up themselves. Might be the "Best Pizza in Pleasantville" but definitely the worst service! read more

Hold on.... I gotta pause my Netflix for this man... Holy cow... Lucio's did it... I don't know how or who cooked this pizza but guys if you are listening , whoever made the grandma pie with sausage, meatballs, and onions on 2/20/17 at about 3:30 PM deserves some recognition. I had to stop mid show to write this review because it was that damn good. Thank you... Just thank you. Best pizza I've ever had.... period! You ever go to Spumoni Gardens? You know how their dough just makes the whole dish?.... Omg.. they got it. I gotta say, as a lifelong NYC Pizza lover Lucio's is pretty darn amazing. Even the sausage on the pizza tastes like Arthur Avenue sweet Italian sausage. I feel so lucky to have this place so close to my house. read more

I tried a couple of different kinds of pizza from here. I would give five stars but I am only giving four for a couple of reasons - one, this is definitely a no frills pizzeria - a little decor wouldn't hurt...second, I felt they could be a little more friendly with their customers - not just me personally, but everyone in there. That's just my opinion when people are in any service industry. All in all, in terms of the pizza, no complaints whatsoever! Their pizza was outstanding. Far better than I imagined. Marg style and a classic slice and YUM. I will definitely be back. Just hope they can at least smile next time, or I suppose in today's circumstances, just sport a mask with a smile (not that I'm a fan of masks)! I have worked in restaurants, retail, you name it...and even if you aren't having the best day at work, it's crucial in these types of businesses to appreciate the fact that customers pick up on vibes and want to eat, shop, etc. where they feel welcome. As I said, I'll be back, and maybe I will be able to update my review to five stars! :) read more

Worst pizza I've had in a while. Ordered delivery. Pie was here in a reasonable amount of time, but the quality was sub par. It was like a doughy mess. They have great chicken roles however! read more

Lucio's Pizzeria - Couldn't stomach the leftovers - Pizza Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

Lunch time and I stop for pizza. I've eaten here before, before my Yelp days to be specific. The food must have been better because based on what I had today, I'm never going back. The pizza was tasteless. Not a bad flavor or a so-so flavor...NO FLAVOR. Not the sauce, not the cheese, NOTHING. The place is clean and neat and there's parking right in front, if you're lucky enough to get a spot. But there has to be better pizza in this town than this...and I aim to find it. read more

Lucio's vegetable pizza (I am glutten and dairy free) is the best I have ever eaten. He als makes the best chicken soup and tortelino soup. I used to work across the street at the insurance agency, Robert T. Kirkwood, Inc. for many years. Lunch at Lucio's was always ready for me when I called ahead. When I was still eating dairy I loved his pizzas even then. read more

There is a lot of competition for pizza supremacy in this area. Lucio's is one of the best. I have gone here for years. Coming from the Bronx, I know what pizza should taste like. Lucio's makes a great pizza. The crust is crisp. They don't overdo it with cheese. In some places I have to ask for extra sauce and well done. Here I just order and it is the way I like it. They also have good sandwiches. My topping of choice here on my pizza is the chicken Parm. read more

Lucio's Pizzeria - Chicken parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

I absolutely love this shop! It's a great family owned business that makes pretty much everything from scratch. They have a ton of delicious options to choose from as well. I live in Rhode Island and every time I come to New York I HAVE to stop in and grab pizza and usually take another full pizza back with me. My personal favorite is half buffalo chicken and half barbecue chicken which they will always make with whatever toppings your heart desires so it's your way. Whenever I come in, I'm treated as family which is not something you see in many places anymore. If you're passing through or just looking for the best pizza in NY I highly recommend Lucio's! read more

Lucio's Pizzeria - Half buffalo chicken & half barbecue chicken pizza w/ranch! Had to update my review to show how amazing it is. - Pizza Near Me - Pleasantville, New York

My coworker and I often visit this place for the pasta. They're usually nice people. In the past when we've ordered stuffed shells we have received 4, because we split them. Today we received 3 and were told that's the amount they usually give. That's a lie. Once we began to eat the shells we realized they were cold on the inside. No one apologized or was even remotely sorry. They just put it back in the oven and when it was done had us to come and get it. I was already contemplating not coming here anymore because of the communities behavior people of color, but Im annoyed now and won't be coming here any more. read more

Meh. Way too much cheese thick undercooked crust. Greasy. No bueno. Just not for me. Better slices in the area.. Gonna have to pass on this place. read more

Good pizza but sometimes their pies are hit or miss. One day, you could get a stellar pie; another day it's a very doughy disappointment. I find these guys are better on weekdays than during the Friday-Saturday dinner rush. They do non-pizza items pretty well like hot chicken parm and egglplant parm wedges. Not to be overlooked: their calzones and their fried zucchini sticks - good stuff. read more

Great pizza. Was in the area and in the mood for a good slice, so I checked yelp and decided to come here. Got a plain slice and a grandma slice. The plain slice was awesome, probably one of the better slices I've had. I would absolutely return just for that alone if I am in the area. The crust to sauce to cheese ratio was perfect, and was seasoned very well. I didnt even need to add my usual garlic & red pepper. The grandma slice on the other hand wasn't great. I think partially it was too much cheese, and partially they overcooked it a bit when heating it up for me. But even with that not being great, I'd still return for the plain slice. Service was great also, and very friendly. read more

Great family owned pizza spot. Also opens early if you are hungry early like I usually am. I ordered a large pepperoni a couple of days ago and have been eating it all week. It's a great deal. Lovely crust. Very New York style. Oh, and free fast delivery. read more

Lucio's Pizzeria is my go to spot in Pleasantville.... I've been patronizing this establishment for more than 15 years. Great people, Great food, Great service overall... read more

I can't speak to the pizza because I've never ordered it, but I can attest to the fact that this is the absolute BEST PENNE VODKA WITH CHICKEN I have found in Westchester. The owner seems a bit cranky, the parking situation isn't perfect (metered), and they serve cold bread, but did I mention the Penne Vodka with Chicken? read more

Lucio's Pizzeria is pretty good. If you buy it there, the pizza quality is the best ever. If you deliver it, the quality is still good. For the most part, it's cheap. (except for there pepperoni rolls and other rolls which are like 7 dollars). Anyways, Lucio's is very good and if you are nearby you should come by. read more

They are not observing mask etiquette. We picked up pizza from here a couple of weeks ago and they didn't have masks on (though they put them on after we were inside) and so we gave them one more chance tonight. Unfortunately, they still weren't wearing masks and they didn't even have the door propped open. This time around the employees never put on their masks while we were there. Personally, this makes us very nervous and other people should know that mask protocols are not in place there before choosing to go. (this isn't reflective of their food... we simply think people should know ahead of time that it doesn't seem that masks are worn) read more

The Chicken Franchese & Chicken Parm dinners are excellent! When you order a pizza from Lucios the box has weight to it! As opposed to other places locally. read more