Pretty decent. Wouldn't say it's the best pizza in town. Good heros, though the meatballs are a little mushy.

First time ordering from Gerardo's. Very pleased. Ordered delivery, came on time. Large Chicago Pizza: Very tasty, good crust, good sauce Philly Cheesesteak: Tasty, lots of meat Chef Salad: Good portion, very fresh Would definitely order again. Next time going to try the Grandma Pie. An added plus, they have Snapple. read more

Had the buffalo chicken wrap for lunch which was ok. They served it with the chicken hot which was a nice change of pace. Pros: Wrap was pretty good and served with a small side of fries. Large menu of Italian food; it all looks good. Cons: Soda comes in bottles and not fountain $10 CC MINIMUM Overall, I'd eat here again *when* they remove the CC minimum. read more

the hype is real. it's the best grandma pizza i have had. it's truly perfect... run don't walk ... the staff is also so so super nice . it will feel like you are with your family. thank you so so much! read more

WAY over priced and my pizza was a mess!!!! Their dinners are good but they aren't very friendly in there and don't seem appreciative of returning customers. Won't be back anymore read more

The BEST red sauce!!! I feel Nd the spaghetti Louisiana DELICIOUS and IRRESISTIBLE! (spicy hot)

So I had the Italian Stallion this is a good place not the best just good and the aptions are vast, however the sandwiches are nothing to write home about. The place is shanty yet quaint. Staff is friendly however there is one guy that acts kinda like a dope beware! Other then that the Pizza is their claim to fame but everything else is hit or miss. read more

Absolutely delicious! Old world Italian style of cooking. Extensive menu. Generous portions. Great service. Nice atmosphere. Plenty of parking. Reasonably priced. read more

Great service fast delivery hot pizza happy customer thanks guys I'm happy to order next time read more

We were visiting someone at the Northern Westchester Hospital in Mt Kisco today and before we left, asked one of the nurses where she recommended for a great pizza. Gerardos was the answer, and it's less than a mile from the hospital. From our cellphone we ordered a one-third cheese and two-thirds bacon and cheese pie. The guy made a stink that it had to be half and half. We then told him we needed the pizza in a box to go, but that we'd be eating a couple of slices at the place. We were curious what the final pie would look like or if the combo was even what we ordered. As soon as we got in, we got our drink and then walked to the front to buy the pie. We were told they would bring it to the table, that they don't put boxes on the table. Had the pizza, which was much better than any MA pizza I have had. We didn't study the menu, but I did see they prepare several chicken entrees (chicken Milanese, parmesan, marsala, and Francese) as well as the usual pork or eggplant dishes and calzones. Our take-out pizza turned into table service, so we felt like we had to leave a tip. Left a bad taste in our mouth, but at least the pizza made up for that, plus we have four slices of NY pizza goodness left for tomorrow. Won't go out of our way to come here, but if we're in the area, we probably would. Four stars for the pizza, but only giving three for all-around. read more

Ill start by saying that Yelp has two encounters for the same establishment. Gerardo you should fix that its hurting your rating. Place is right next to the hospital. I came here after walking into Mario's and leaving after seeing the 3 day old waxy pizza. Gerardo's was great. Pizza was great and the chicken roll was great. read more

I can't understand why this place has 3 stars. All the people that rated it 3 stars say great food so maybe they just need to learn how to review. Great atmosphere, staff was very friendly as soon as you walk in. Food is good and prices are good. What more can you ask for? read more

Great food and service.. A little pricey but you get what you pay for.. Quick and easy and polite...

Delivery is fast depending on the time you order but the wait is well worth the food!!!

Good pizza says my son and he's hard to satisfy. His friends also really like their food. I'm looking forward to going myself.

Excellent pizza. Pastas, salads, all homemade. Just bought the deli next door and opened Gerardo's deli. Dining area clean and adequate. Great for a very casual local bite. Think upscale pizzeria. read more

Best penne vodka and chicken marsala around! Grandma's pizza is awesome as well. Love the casual atmosphere and the owner is personable. Definitely will go back for dinner! read more

Pizza is great especially the Grandmas pie but pricey...$25. Dinners are so so...hit or miss. Pasta dinners ranging in price from $14-$17 do not come with salad. Sandwiches are just ok..nothing special. Place is a pizza place...not any kind of fancy place so that said prices should be a bit lower. Used to come here weekly for years but quality of food has gone down. When I asked for extra salad dressing....was charged 50 cents extra for baslamic vinegar which was surprising since I have been a regular customer for years. read more

Lived in the area for years and finally tried the pizza and it was the best pizza I've had in the neighborhood! Man i wish i found it sooner but happy to have now.Looking forward to many more nights of pizza and pasta read more

This is the best pizza in Mt Kisco hands down - great dishes too - eat here every week and have catered parties too!

ordered online and when i called to see where my order was they hung up on me. took them a whole hour and half to get my food. terrible customer service read more

Went in for a quick dinner. Had a cheese slice and a Cobb salad. Pizza was below average as was the salad. It was clean and service was pleasant. Would skip it. read more

I have been coming here for a couple years now, but the quality in food is slowly going for the worse. Recently ordered a pizza, that was delivered cold and felt that it had been out of the oven for quiet awhile. Pizza was not tasty. If you want good New York pizza, this is not the place to come. The main entrees from this restaurant are tasty and use fresh ingredients. read more

im not sure the other posts here are went to the same place i went to. upscale?? FAR from it! this place is awful. the pizza looks and tastes like it was made the day before, and has been sitting on the counter - the place is nasty, dirty, and the tv is sooo loud. i realize it's a pizzeria; not fine dining. but you wouldnt know it by the prices! one plain reg slice - one bottle of water... over 5 bucks. wait. what? how much?, i asked, "there's TAX you know!" growled the pizza man. yea - pass on this place, there are many places better - with better parking - and nicer people who aren't going to rip you off right up street. ( oh even *if* it were (about) the same price up the street, i'd still never go here again) read more

This is my go-to pizzeria in Mount Kisco! The pizza is very good, and they always have a nice selection for slices (and give their zeppole a shot!). I also enjoy their pasta dishes and wraps. I have found the prices to be on par with most pizzerias in the area. The parking is very convenient, and if you are getting something to go or picking up there is a nice area to stand. My only gripe is that if you order something from their menu with any alterations/substitutes, the changes will not happen (tried having onions removed from things over half a dozen times, it has never happened). I haven't taken advantage of delivery in years, but I do recall they had a fee for it at that time (that seems to be the way most places are going now though). Overall, very good food, amiable staff, I would definitely recommend Gerardos. read more

I come to Gerardo's often and am never disappointed. I love their selection of salads and their grandma pizza is a must try. They have new specials every day. Definitely the best pizzeria in the area and great for a casual sit down dinner. We keep coming back! read more

Beyond good! Great food, great vibe and extremely friendly employees. Whether it's a little out of your way or not, I highly recommend you indulge at this fine pizzeria! read more

I almost gave it five stars, not because it's truly that outstanding, but to offset some of the weak reviews. This is our go-to pizza place. The pizza is always good, sometimes fantastic.... a weird complaint is that to go pizzas are always too big for the box, so some edge of it has to end up folded/broken to fit in the box (it's a thin, generally crispy crust, so count on a little cracking of the crust on one side). But this isn't really a problem. Ingredients/toppings are of terrific quality. Dishes other than pizza (a couple of pastas, chicken parm rolls, a hot sandwich) have all been good. Prices for sandwiches, etc. are really reasonable, pizza prices are on the high end for Mt. Kisco, but worth it for food that's always, tasty, hot, fresh and ready when I need it. read more

I ordered from them on Seamless a few times and Gerardo's is quite possibly the best pizzeria in Westchester. Their deliveries are quick and the food is impeccable. I ordered eggplant parm last and the portion was the size of my head. The prices (in my opinion) are cheap, especially for the large quantity of food you are getting. Even the sides are phenom-the buttered ziti was well seasoned and the bread was fresh/soft. read more

ordered a shrimp dinner the other night for delivery. The shrimp was so disappointing they were smaller than they used to be or it could be the fact that they were cooked to death. Dark and Dried out, I would have called and complained but I was starving. Won't order that again. Expensive and inferior! read more

Great food all around from pizza to the dishes on the menu. I've eaten their so many times I can't count and have always had a terrific experience. I recommend going there asap! read more

Gerardos is one of the best Pizza/Italian Restaurants in a town that is inundated with pizza parlors. There is a small area with about 8 tables to sit and eat and also there is a take out area. You can get food "to go" or eat in or even get it delivered. The restaurant is always clean and the wait staff is always friendly. They serve all types of Italian food and have phenomenal pizza. Don't miss an opportunity to eat there. The only thing I can fault them with is, they only serve espresso coffee and do not serve regular/decaf coffee. I hope they will change this. Nevertheless, I suggest you eat there. read more

Best NY style pizza around...they also make a Grandma pizza thats out of this world!!

They only have one waiter who is not very nice. We ordered 4 dinners - one of which was a simple pasta with butter. We kept asking when the food would be ready and kept getting the same answer "a couple of minutes". As it turned out the incompetent waiter did not enter our order into the system until about 10-15 minutes after he took the order. If you ask for a soda, you will get a warm bottle without a glass or ice. Ask for a glass with ice and you get a dirty look. It took 20 minutes for the bread to arrive at at the table and another 5 minutes for the salad to arrive. After 1 hour from arrival, we asked again "How soon?" Again, we were told soon and that our order was just put in. We got up and left. Someone followed us out and asked why we were leaving. He tried to explain that our order was on its way out. Too late. Wont be going back. I will spend my money at a restaurant that really wants my business. read more