We love their chocolate ice cream. It is delicious. Not too sweet. The staff were very polite. It…read moreis a small ice cream place with only 2 tables. Definitely worth stopping by.

Went to this place while out in new paltz. Sign on the door states they are open and so does…read moreYelp/online. Turns out they were pitch black and closed. Very disappointing.

Evelyn's is such a fun stop in Livingston Manor! They do soft serve right, classic vanilla and…read morechocolate plus a rotating special flavor, with all kinds of mix-ins and toppings to make your perfect combo. We had the mint chocolate and a strawberry sundae, and both were incredible. The mint was super refreshing and just the right amount of sweet, and the strawberry sundae tasted like a throwback to summer days. The staff was super friendly, and the vibe is casual and welcoming. Great spot for a treat, highly recommend if you're in town!

Cute mom 'n' pop ice cream shop in the Catskills! They don't have hard ice cream, only soft…read moreserve... but they have plenty of options for some delicious sundaes! When visiting Livingston Manor, this is a must to try in such a quaint town!

Service with a Huge smile. FOOD- I scream and frozen treats only The creaminess of this soft serve…read more is magnificent ~ just the right balance of custardy goodness and cocoa goodness. The ambiance is so nostalgic- stand a one of several swiftly moving lines-just enough time to reside between your flavor and size, TIP: small is three circles around the cone, medium is five and a large is seven. It's a whopper that could feed a family of four. And there is the kiddy size. Nondairy options are limited, but available

Sooooo gooood! Super creamy delicious flavors…read more Generous and not overpriced like "CSC" ;)

What a cute little ice cream shop! So many different kinds to choose from! Soft serve, sundaes,…read moreregular ice cream, shakes, you name it! Everything tasted so good! Definitely a spot anyone should try when visiting in the summer.

Amazing little gem! The entire space sits on a beautiful, green, grassy area that is a total breath…read moreof fresh air.Ugh, the food is delicious! It honestly tastes like they love their customers, and you see so many happy faces coming out of here. Their ice cream selection is nothing short of delightful. The dairy-free ice cream is heavenly--I am finally able to enjoy dessert right along with my family! The cheeseburgers are incredibly tasty, and I love that they offer gluten-free buns and so much more.My family and I actually drive all the way down from the Bronx and stay overnight at my daughter's house just to visit. Don't judge me, lol! The ride down is spectacular, the service is excellent, and they offer free parking. Please enjoy these pictures! Just don't eat all the dairy-free flavors before I get back. That ice cream is sooo smooth and the taste is perfect not overly sweet or weird flavor. Many dairy flavors to choose from if you want reg milk versions.

This was kind of an odd-ish experience in an odd-ish kind of place. Monticello seems like it has…read moreseen better days, and definitely has a very unique combination of inhabitants. We ended up here for a post-dinner treat, and it was quite busy. There is little to no room inside the place, so you're constantly trying to squeeze and shuffle around as the whole ordering process is a complete human free-for-all. We ended up with a gentleman who greeted us by saying "this is my first time working in three years!" Well OK then! He managed to get one of us a malted and vanilla twist soft serve on a cone, but the malted didn't really taste like anything other than an unpronounced chocolate flavor. The other one of us got a Snickers sundae that was so massive and just completely overtopped with Snickers pieces and fudge. Like, we're not complaining--all too happy to consume these thousands of calories!--but it was a bit of a wild mess. Kind of a surreal experience, but we're not necessarily mad about it and would probably even come back if we were ever in the area again. Be prepared to wait and to have a furrowed brow if you go.

Recently visited on our vacation and this place was cute and had so many options. The staff which…read morewas two young ladies were very nice and had great customer service. If we were visiting again I would definitely stop by a get another sweet treat.

Best brookies I've ever had great cookies as well, all around good service great communication.very…read moreprofessional nice small business to support .

I loved visiting this cozy cafe during my trip to the Catskills. The shop features charming…read moredisplays throughout, showcasing local vendors. There's both indoor and outdoor seating, making it a perfect spot for lunch. I ordered a matcha and a turkey sandwich on brioche--both were delicious! With just two staff members running the show, service took a little longer, but it was worth the wait. This is a wonderful local gem and I'd definitely return.

Not a bad experience overall. The shop is cute, with retail items like candles and honey for sale…read more I haven't had ice cream or food here, but have visited a few times for coffee. The first time I went my order was perfect. The second time I visited I asked for a cortado (typically equal parts milk and espresso) and was handed a lukewarm 12oz latte full of milk and foam. (I think an employee was being trained on the bar? If not...) To the baristas' credit, they quickly remade my drink when I asked, which I appreciated- though my second coffee was so hot it burnt my tongue. I've noticed they also upcharge quite a lot: for alt milks, syrups, to go cups, etc. I think with a bit more training on standards this could be a really great spot!

My first experience was disappointing. I read a review praising the gyro, and thought I'd give your…read moreplace one more shot. I had a perfectly fine ice cream cone, and decided to see if you made a good sundae. The gyro and the sundae were disappointing. But coming back after a bad experience and trying two things I hadn't tried----How is that confusing? I stayed onsite because the creek is beautiful, and I was visiting with family. Also not confusing. You did not "allow me to leave with the order". You ran the payment twice, delivered my order, and then interrupted our meal twice to try to resolve your card reader issue. I showed you the charges on my Apple Cash App, and you still demanded that I tap my payment a third time. You approached while talking to someone on speakerphone, and handed me the receiver saying, "I have the rep from our card reader on the line. You can talk to him." You never once asked how we liked anything, until you recognized my name, while attempting to capture payment for the FOURTH time. Only then, after you demanded to know whether I was "the same Sierra" who left a negative review, did you ask about my experience. Not to improve it but, just as you did in this reply, as an accusation: "Why'd you come back if I you didn't like it?" There was no time at all spent "trying to address MY concerns." The sole aim of your interaction was to secure payment. Why didn't I "request a refund or replacement?" Really? I told you what was unsatisfactory, and stood by my earlier review. You dismissed my complaint and invoked my responsibility to "support small businesses", while still demanding that I give you cash (which is, in fact, an untraceable payment method), and running my card repeatedly, right in front of several "NO REFUNDS" signs. All three food items I've tried have been very poor--why would I request more? You were not denied the opportunity to make things right. You simply refused to make any attempt to do so. I really think your response does a better job of making my point than I can.

I love the ambiance and icecream so much! They are very kind. It's the best in the area for sure!read more