Best New York style pizza in Winter Haven! We had been getting pizza from other places for months for our pizza night, then when we found Giovanni's it was a game changer. Also, their wings are so good, too. read more

Servise is lost on them. Manager fights with you vs listen and attempting to fix their mistake. Food used to be good, but food quality is gone and replaced by rudeness. read more

Giovanni's New York Pizza - This was my cheese only pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

Great NY pizza. Great pasta and generous portions. The taste of little Italy which reminds of the St Genaro feast.

It's a good pizza. We had the vegetarian and found it tasty. Only recommendation is to ask for extra sauce. Other than that I'd order it again.. The pizza was ready on time so service was excellent. Ambiance was only fair so only good for take out. read more

We ordered as we were leaving legoland and it was ready when we got there. The crust, flavors, toppings, cheese-sticks, marinara all tasted home made, super fresh, and not greasy! The kids ate and approved it. 100% recommend! read more

Giovanni's New York Pizza - Sausage, onion and pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

People who are giving this place a low rating are smoking crack. Pizza is great and the kids love how huge it is. Giovanni's has never disappointed us. We go everytime we are at Lego Land! read more

See all

We're visiting from out of town and got rained out of the theme park and wanted some good, comforting, italian food. This place fit the bill. We ordered a little of everything; pizza, pasta, salads, knots, zeppolis. This is the first time a large takeout order was 100% correct. The workers were also very friendly and accommodating. If we lived closer, this would be a regular spot for us. read more

Super nasty place. Never seen the cook wear gloves and the restaurant is filthy. Still go there because my company likes pizza from there. Just purchased $150 worth of pizza and they said paper plates are extra read more

Giovanni's New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

Food is great order the home made meatballs and spaghetti with sauerkraut dinner meatballs are great the flavor is like I made them my self. Order pizza yesterday and it was great pizza sauce is really yummy read more

I have ordered pizza from this place before and it was good but today I decided to order a meatball sub for lunch, bad decision! To begin the sandwich was so dry! There was hardly any sauce. There was plenty of melted cheese but without any sauce it basically made it feel like there was too much cheese...but the to the worst part, the meatballs! I don't know how old these meatballs were but they must have gotten them from the back of the freezer after being there for 6 months. They were so hard I had to spit it out. I decided to dissect the second half and found that the meatballs were indeed old and dry! Will never order from this place again. I have other options in the neighborhood and I will be using them. read more

See all

I've been patronizing Giovanni's since they open here in Winter Haven many years now. I don't know what's happened but the food quality has gone for the worst. Order spaghetti dinner and a side of fried zucchini with a side salad. The appearance not appetizing at the least. The salad was the core of iceberg lettuce and it was brown our whole meal was like thrown together without and care at all fried zucchini was all soggy and falling apart spaghetti with meat sauce sux big time. And problem is I've had all this here before and it was good enough to make me choose them for spaghetti meal tonight what a Friggin disappointment. I'm done. These people just don't care about quality. Sad. read more

I have mixed feelings because the food is amazing here and the kitchen crew is absolutely amazing but the woman who answers the phone has a disgusting nasty attitude that needs to be dealt with immediately if they ever want mobile orders to have any success in their busines. She was rude to my wife who was just trying to check on an order she had placed on uber eats, rushing her off the phone having an attitude from working all day. Its unacceptable for her poor customer service to continue at the location bc the food is honestly 10/10. read more

They used to have the best pizza at reasonable prices there owners must have changed hands the pizza is not the same and the prices are crazy it was more than 10 dollars more for the pizza I have ordered numerous other times read more

My husband used to love this place so much so I had them as my contact list. It's been a while that we order from them. I place an order for pick up and the price was for an xtra large pizza and garlics knots came out to $20.00! What a steal. Something was off. The pizza was off. Not sure why it it was. The garlic knot were tasty as ever swimming in a pool of garlic butter. The service was quick and easy. read more

Gross. Not hygienic. First the woman who handled my food sneezed in her hands, didn't wash and made a sad attempt at putting on one single blue glove (and proceeded to touch everything with her dirty hand as well). I asked for two slices with fresh garlic and Basil. She sprinkled nasty canned garlic on my pizza and dried basil. Worst pizza experience. Never coming back. read more

Giovanni's New York Pizza - Gross nasty pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

We stopped in after bowling at Incredibowl. The place is old school. Nothing fancy. Don't let that fool you. This place has great pizza. We ordered the eggplant Parmigiano pizza. Now, I like a thin crust, well done pie. I didn't ask for it, but that's how it was done, and done well. We will be back, and soon. The pizza was really well done, tasty and fresh!! read more

Came in over an hour before closing to the smell of bleach and glares from every worker, cleaning over an hour before closing and immediately commenting about how we came in as you cleaned. Very rude service and smelled, wouldn't recommend unless you intended on coming in just as they open maybe, didn't even give it a chance as the first thing that is said to us is "Just as you started cleaning here comes a family of four", floored by this comment we left immediately. read more

Amy was friendly and wonderful and the food was great. They made our pizza exactly like we asked and we enjoyed it.

To be honest, I hate having to give bad reviews but this establishment deserves it. We came in for dinner and the staff was extremely rude, unfriendly and impatient. They didn't really greet or welcome us, they just told us to grab a seat. We thought that meant someone would come to our table and give us menus, etc. But that wasn't the case. We had to order at the front, which is completely fine, but again the staff was so cold and rude. Almost like they didn't want us coming in to begin with. Food looked great but lacked on the taste. We tried their garlic knots, Sicilian pizza and Strombolis. Garlic knots were good but the Mariana to dip it in was NOT. Pizza and Stromboli were also very subpar. Definitely not going back there again. Hope they get it together and teach their staff the importance of customer service soon. read more

See all

I'm from New York. I do know good pizza from bad pizza. In Florida, there is a lot more bad than good. In the case of Giovanni's, this place is the real deal. I know when I order a pie, I'm getting something as close to New York as possible. I don't open the box and get disappointed. They really make a great pie. I made the mistake of trying a competitor recently based on a recommendation. It was a huge mistake. I highly recommend Giovanni's. The food is delicious. The prices are reasonable. If you've never had a New York pie, go here. It's cheaper than flying to New York. read more

Worst pizza ever!!!! We ordered a Sicilian pizza and got a soft pepperoni with no sauce. No square cut. No crisp. Just dough, cheese and sloppy applied pepperoni. Stay away! read more

Giovanni's New York Pizza - Horrible pizza. No sauce and this is supposed to be a Sicilian!!!! No square crust or sauce. Joke!!! - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

First, we received the wrong pizza. We ordered Primavera and we got a pizza with broccoli, spinach, and tomatoes. We figured it's partially our fault because we didn't check before leaving. Second, the pizza does not have good flavor. The cheese pizza and garlic rolls didn't have flavor. It was so weird. Also, it did not smell appetizing, it was terrible. At least now we know, but for sure I'd skip pizza here in the future. read more

I ordered this place on door dash and just let me tell you to say the least this place was Amazing. We ordered the baked spaghetti, lasagna, and the 3 meat Stromboli. Everything was piping hot and just the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. The noodles were cooked just right and if I stayed here in Florida this would definitely be in my top 10 of places to eat. read more

Good food, great service. No idea why people are giving low ratings to be honest. Would recommend to anyone wanting pizza and wings especially in football seasons. read more

This has to be the worst pizza ever. The crust is always undercooked and has no flavor. The sauce is nasty and their is nothing New York about it. We are born and raised in Long Island, NY and this place is not new York pizza. Please don't hold Long Island to that... read more

The pizza at this place is delish, I'm not sure if it's the sauce, cheese or the dough, either way stop by and get some. If you come in the summer, get it to go, it's hot up in there. But, anytime of the year the service is on point. read more

How in the world does Giovanni's only have 2.5 stars?!?! I'm not a gourmet but this was great pizza! We ordered the XL Meat Lovers to go. It wasn't super busy at 8p and our order was brought out quickly! The pizza was wonderful! Definitely NY style with a thin crust! There was only 3 of us and we completely polished off the whole pizza! We got our pizza to go so we weren't totally affected by the heat inside of the restaurant. The air conditioner didn't feel like it was on and the front door was propped open. That didn't affect us at all so I didn't take it into account. We will definitely go back! read more

See all

The absolute BEST pizza around. I believe these negative reviews are from competitors NOT real customers. Their pizza is freaking awesome and they actually LISTEN when you ask for extra cheese! I make it a point to stop her for a great pizza every time I'm in town. Thank you guys! You are still my FAVORITE!!!! read more

this is the best pizza I have had since moving here, we are also from NY and this is the closest you will ever get without going back to NY. PERFECT!!!!!!!! read more

Not what I expected real family place. Service was good. Pizza was ok. Not a lot of varieties of pizza. Reasonably priced. Just appeared to be recently opened or most customers call for take out or delivery. read more

Giovanni's New York Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

We order delivery from the Winter Haven Store food is good and price ok on the high side quality of the food upon arrival from delivery was very good would order from here again as we like variety so as for pizza their in our circle read more

We ordered here one night. I had a difficult time finding the place from my condo. However arrived and my order wasn't ready yet. They appeared to be a bit confused and took additional time. I received apologies, but no discount on the food. The pizza and breadsticks were okay. I was really hoping that it all would have been much better, being an Italian family in Florida. read more

Great quality as Always highly recommended. Our favorite for our Pizza Frayays if you have not tried Giovanni's Do it right now

I love this place, you get great food and their customer service is top notch. You want a real slice of NY in FL come over it's right here. Delivery holds up well but it's best to eat fresh if you can. read more

New to winter haven area and so far things are not going very well in my quest for a decent pie. Never a good sign when the pizza joint uses boxes from another restaurant. So let's discuss the ongoing issue this area seems to be experiencing. Sicilian pizza is thick, crisp and airy. The Sicilian from here and floridinos are not anything close to a true Sicilian. Yes I am a pizza snob being from NY but some places down here get it right, like palace in Lakeland. read more

Giovanni's New York Pizza - "Sicilian" - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

See all

It's okay. They use canned mushrooms and other ingredients that aren't fresh. The Italian sausage is pretty bland. I've been to New York and this is not remotely like New York or even Chicago to be honest. It's Florida pizza. read more

Calzone was really good and included ricotta. Garlic knots were hard and not much flavor. Wings were okay. Tiramisu came completely frozen, once it unthawed, I tried it, and it tasted freezer burnt. read more

the pizza is bomb but the employees seem dirty. they were wearing flip flops in the kitchen and the guy making the pizza had his long hair all over the place and at some point I caught him picking his nose while he continued to make the pizza dough. I wont be back. I loved the pizza but after this encounter. Never again. read more

The garlic knots are always amazing. The mamas boy pizza with like tomatoes is gas. What else do I get from there? oh well I pretty much tried everything and I like it all but the calzones is the main thing read more

We ordered delivery to Legoland hotel. The pizza arrived in a timely manner. We got two pizzas and garlic knots. The sauce was a but bland but ok. The garlic bread knots did not come with any dipping sauce. Overall the food was OK. I can't remember anything really good or bad about it. The food got the job done... ended hunger. read more