Highly recommend, great pizza and yummy dishes! My family's go-to spot for pizza, very friendly staff. read more

This pizza is AMAZING ! Tasty for sure we will return ! The owner was a real sweet lady friendly & very accommodating! The waitress was very personable! Definitely a 5 star read more

Tiny hole in the wall but the pizza was to die for! My 7 year old had 2 slices--unheard of because they are huge slices!

Great Tasting pizza . Closes thing to New York . Service was great , I give it a 8.9 out of 10 . Would definitely come back for this . read more

BEST pizza in Winter Haven. I've been coming here for years and no other pizza place compares. Great service and really fast when making the pizza. read more

Brothers NY Style Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

Solid pizza joint. Good crisp on crust. Well balanced. Not too greasy. Decent quality ingredients. Not a place I'd go way out of my way for but definitely would be in the carry out rotation if I lived nearby read more

Hard pass. All the pizza might be halfway decent, I absolutely will not spend money at any establishment that charges me extra to use my debit or credit card. I will never be back. read more

Didn't even get to try out the pizza, walked in was instantly told there was an hour wait. No greeting, no salesmanship. Turned away immediately. At least attempt to make the situation better read more

This is a great place, if you go you have to try the BLT pizza and the salads are all good size and good prices

So good. 10/10. This is a family favorite and our go to when we are ordering pizza! Never had a bad pizza here.

Great quick lunch. A little skimpy on the cheese but you can order extra cheese. For a by the slice I would say above average for sure!

Pizza is pretty good , Florida standards. So I decided to try a Chicken Parm hero. They call it a wedge, ok. I received one meatball chopped into little pieces on what looked like Naan Indian bread. Not the best sandwich I ever had but close to the worst. Stick to pizza if you venture here. Fountain drinks taste like crap too! read more

Terrible service, been waiting more than 30 minutes for a calzone. Do yourself a favor and go elsewhere.

Best pizza in town, hands down. Excellent reheated, too. We've tried so many pizza places in town but Brothers is the one that has become our regular. I love the white pizza, husband loves the supreme. Delivery is reliable, too. They're helping us survive this self-quarantine with our sanity! read more

See all

If you happen to be local to Winter Haven or if you are just in town to visit LegoLand, be sure you get a few pies delivered to you from Brothers NY Style Pizza! Best pizza in the area! Important to note though...All the pizza restaurants in the area only deliver via GrubHub or Uber Eats! We ordered thru UberEats and had a great experience. We ordered 4 large pizzas for a "working thru lunch" business meeting and they were delivered in 30 minutes. We ordered 2 large cheese thin crust, 1 veggie pizza and 1 meat lovers. All were hot, freshly prepared and delicious! Prices were good too! read more

Easily the best pizza I've had in all of Florida!!! I loved it and I'll be a regular here. read more

Brothers NY Style Pizzeria - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

This was my first time ordering from here even though I've seen it on DoorDash multiple times. I just couldn't see ordering pizza because I have my own favorites already. However I tried them today. I got mozzarella sticks, spaghetti & meatballs, and a slice of pepperoni pizza. In the defense of the restaurant the food was ordered for delivery through DoorDash so this rating is not based on temperature. The mozzarella sticks were average in comparison to every restaurant that serves them. They visually looked better than the majority that I've eaten before. The marinara was watery compared to what I'm used to. It didn't lack in flavor though and complemented the mozzarella sticks. I would order them again, especially if I dined in. The spaghetti & meatballs. The portion and quality was worth the price. I like sauce and to me it was lacking some sauce. Not horribly under-sauced however I wanted more. The sauce was flavorful and the meatballs were good as well. I would probably pass on ordering it again even though it was good. The slice of pepperoni pizza. If your business name includes it, it should be good pizza and it was. The crust was crispy and the sauce was flavorful. Out of my whole order I would definitely order more pizza from them and try the multiple varieties of toppings they offer. Even if I just wanted to grab a slice for a quick bite I would definitely do that due to the price ($2.50) and taste of the pizza. read more

See all

We've been going to Brothers since reading really good earlier reviews. We moved from NJ and worked in NY. Good pizza is lacking here but Brothers was an acceptable substitution, given other local alternatives. HOWEVER, the pies we picked up last night (for my birthday) were absolutely awful. Sausage and onion had absolutely no flavor and very few toppings. The ham and pineapple pie was the same. No flavor and hardly any toppings. I'm not sure if they've changed management or kitchen staff or what but something has changed and this last experience was no better than a Hungry Howies. Not sure where to go from here. May give them one more try but we've definitely lost confidence in the quality. read more

When I was getting ready to move down here, one thing really caught my eye and I had to try it, a month later I finally got to satisfy that craving, and it was SO worth the wait. Eggplant parm as a pizza! Also tried the TSR (Tomato, Ricotta and Spinach) to mix it up. Both of them were simply wonderful (and the cold pizza I. The morning was just as perfect!). Good chew on the crust. Big foldable slices. Great prices for the size and the quality. Can't wait to keep trying more. I'm coming for those wings! read more

Brothers NY Style Pizzeria - Left: 16. TSR Pizza. (tomato Spinach Ricotta). Right: Eggplant Pizza (Eggplant parm on a pizza crust!!) - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

I was headed to a different pizza place which turned out to be closed. We found this one and are so happy we did! The pizza was excellent, service was great. Prices reasonable. We'll be back' read more

I have never tried the pizza from here but I have ordered a few from here. Everyone always likes the pizza. It doesn't seem as greasy as some places. My go to order from here is always a small chef salad and an order of the garlic knots. Don't let the small fool you! The small salad is typically two meals for me. read more

This is the only pizza worth eating in Winter Haven - this is coming from a couple of New Yorkers. The calzones are FIRE! My favorite is jalapeños and pineapple, it's spicy in all the right ways. My kids also adore the cannolis. I advise ordering in advance so that the pizza is ready upon arrival. Happy eating! read more

Sept 10, 2021. Around 7:00 Just moved out to auburndale from kissimmee and tried finding a nyc pizza joint near me. I ended up on this place and i was actually kind of impressed. Called them up and ordered a 16' Cheese pizza and garlic knots, got there , employees were super nice service was quick was in n out. Got home, Pizza was super, super delicious. Couldn't even get a picture of it i was way too hungry lol. I'm from the bronx and it reminded of pizza back home, wasn't EXACTLY like it but they almost got it. Garlic knots were very Eh. Order came w 6 garlic knots, i ate 3 they were good but the marinara was just not that good. The other three though oh man, when i bit into them idk if it was cause it was an hour later but they were Super Super hard! Like biting into a brick literally! Whatever though maybe y'all slipped up it's whatever, my main goal was the pizza and y'all made me happy w that so i'm happy. Would've made it for 5 stars if it wasn't for that n the marinara but other than that Pizza is great! Also had the calzone w pepperoni and bacon, no disappointment there just didn't like eating it w the marinara. Edit: Got another pizza and it was great as usual! got a pic this time read more

Brothers NY Style Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

Very underrated pizza! The buffalo chicken pizza absolutely slaps you can tell the older gentlemen who makes the pizza truly has a passion for it. Staff is very nice just wish place was a little bit cleaner. Every time i go i sit on a greasy/dirty table waiting for my food. read more

Absolutely outstanding! We got a pepperoni pizza tonight and was easily the best pizza I have had in Winter Haven since moving here! I already know this is going to be my go to local pizza place; and we have tried quite a few now. Staff was super nice as well. :) read more

Ordered thru yelp and delivered by GrubHub while we stayed at LegoLand. Ordered earlier in the day to be delivered in the evening after we returned from the park. Delivery experience was great, food was not. The pizza was cold... not warm... but old and cold tasting. I am not sure if it was because of the way I ordered with later delivery or not. Delivery time was on the minute so it wasn't late. The cold pizza had the rough chewy crust texture. The toppings were plentiful. read more

Wings. No bending on Flats at all in fact when you do ask for flats they give you less flats

I am giving this restaurant one star because it is not possible to give less. The absolute worst customer service, I have experienced in my 47 years on this earth. Learn how to clean your restaurant and treat your customers with kindness. People like this should not own restaurants. I hope that everyone that considers eating at this establishment reads this review and finds a better option. read more

Ok, so I have not even tasted the pizza yet, but so far I am not impressed. I just spent $32 on a large pizza and asked for parm on the side. She hands me one little dinky container. I ask for more, as it's a large pizza. The cashier looks uncomfortably at the (who I assume) is the owner, and relinquishes one more. This is unimpressive to me. read more

I've had pizza from here before and it was pretty good but their customer service proved to me tonight I won't return again. Probably not a big deal for them because I'm from out of town. I walked in at 8:55 pm on a Friday night. There were 4 or 5 tables with just delivered pizzas. They told me the kitchen was closed. I told them I was from out of town and I asked where a good place to go to get something to eat. They told me "Olive Garden." Any restaurant owner with a good business sense would have had a better solution. I know it's a small town but you shouldn't be in the business if you can't occasionally bend a bit to keep a customer happy. read more

My go to Pizza place in Winter Haven for NY style pizza. I have been a customer for about 4 years or so and have never been disappointed in a pie! read more

Had my pizza delivered, so not sure what the place looks like . But the pizza was very good . I would say that this place is very similar to palace pizza in Bartow as far as pizza goes . read more

We decided to try out this new pizza shop we'd heard about in winter haven. Upon reading the reviews I thought wow this is going to be excellent. This is definitely new york style pizza. We however were not impressed with the flavor or the toppings on the pizza. The sauce was very bland on this meat lovers pizza. Disappointed with the amount and style of toppings also. This is definitely not the best pizza in winter haven as only one place holds that medal and it's not brothers. I needed to add my own seasoning at home to this pizza. Not certain if we will order from here again but it wasn't a horrible meal it just had no flavor and was not what the reviews made it out to be. It's a new place so maybe it'll get better. read more

Brothers NY Style Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

Wanted pizza delivered and wanted something different. Tired of the chain crap. I also am a huge fan of NYC pizza. Decided to try Brothers and I am glad I did. It was very good. It's the closest thing I have had to NY pizza in Florida. I had the 18" cheese pizza, it was extremely good. The crust was pretty close to NY pizza. If we only had true NY water in FL. Highly recommend this place! read more

This is true NY PIZZA!! I have searched since we came back from CT and finally found pizza worthy of accolades!!! Check it out!!! read more

first time order..order the Hawaii pizza large..the crust was good and the sauce...i thought they were short on ingredients because my pizza didn't have hardly any on it..don't go by the picture on website because it ain't true to picture..probably want be back..it said bacon on it also but didn't see any.. when you pay 24.50 for a pizza you expect some ingredients on it..oh well live and learn.. read more

NEVER GOING ANYWHERE ELSE TO GET MY PIZZA EXCEPT HERE!!! THE BEST!!! Customer service was lovely to say the least, extremely nice people and atmosphere! My good friend Hector recommended this place and I can't thank him enough. HE KNOWS NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA! And this place has exactly that! From the dough to the cheese it has Lady Liberty all over it! My calzone is to die for and I finished it before finishing this review... now I am sad... it's gone... my life is over until they open tomorrow... my calzone baby. read more

Brothers NY Style Pizzeria - Calzone with 2 Toppings - Pizza Near Me - Winter Haven, Florida

Really good and tasty pizza! Definitely authentic NY style pizza. My family loved it.

After reading the reviews, I was super excited about getting pizza from here. I ordered through YELP, and the order went through smoothly. However, I must say I was disappointed in the flavor of the pizza. I got a simple pepperoni and cheese... But didn't have much flavor I didn't think. I got the 16 inch, which was quite large. Was just expecting something better. It actually tasted better once it cooled down, and after reheating. The pizza was good and hot right out of the oven, I was just disappointed that there wasn't more flavor. read more

It was our first time ordering here and the wings are delicious , we chose garlic and a chicken bacon ranch pizza . I regret I can only give it four stars because what we received was some chicken on the crust with ranch and nothing else . I called them and explained I was missing the bacon off my pizza and they offered to credit me for the bacon which was nice. We all are suffering in this pandemic and we are grateful to have found you and that you deliver to our home (we are fairly new to Winter Haven) Thank you ! read more