Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Godfather’s Pizza

    3.0 (5 reviews)

    Order Godfather’s Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Godfather’s Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Godfather’s Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Godfather’s Pizza

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 8,616 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Brooklyn Char

    Brooklyn Char

    4.3
    (96 reviews)
    3.5 mi

    Why was this pizza crust crispier than the nyc pizzas I've had…read moreCrust 9/10 The amount of toppings is balanced for me. Just wish there was more hot honey and their proteins are on the salty side. Overall, it was yummy, and I like their tomato sauce a lot, very tangy

    My husband is a huge pizza fan, so we decided to check this place out after driving past on our way…read moreto get massages in the same plaza. After said massage, I was relaxed and decided that I did not want to cook dinner when we got home, so we popped in without having any context on its popularity. The place is really small. There is a bit of counter/bar seating, one large table and one smaller table in the corner inside. Outside, there are 3-4 more tables in a covered area. We reviewed the menu online, as they seemed to only have one printed menu that was being passed around from table to table. We decided on the Godzilla pizza (Pepperoni, Jalapeno, Serrano, Ricotta, Mozzarella, Grana Padano, Tomato Sauce, Pecorino, Mike's Hot Honey, Fresh Basil, Olive Oil). The pizzas only come in one size, so there's no ordering a small pie to see how you like it. It is all or nothing! We sat at the one available table inside with our beverages and waited for the pie to be made. The table was dirty and there were cobwebs in the corner, but as I read the reviews online, I began to get excited for what was to come. It didn't take very long for us to receive our pie (20 minutes tops) and we had to try some fresh out of the oven. The slices were huge, barely fitting on the plate. The crust was nice and crisp. I wasn't really a fan of the fresh jalapeno and serrano peppers (I guess I expected them to be pickled), but they were sliced paper thin. They were all over the pizza. The most generous topping, by far. There was no picking around them, so next time, I would opt to have them removed entirely or at least have them go light on the peppers. They didn't add any spice, in my opinion. My favorite topping was the ricotta. It was very creamy and added a nice balance to everything else the pie had going on. I would try them again if my husband wanted to, but they aren't at the top of my list. Edit: I am editing my review in response to the Business Manager's comment on my review. It was defensive and argumentative in nature, which I deem as bad customer service. I have since posted my pictures from that visit, including ones showing the cobwebs in the corner of where our table was located. Going through my pictures, I remembered that the cheese sauce we ordered was also given to us cold. It took at least 10 minutes to have it warmed and given back to us, and by then the pizza was cold. We boxed everything up and went home, but reheating is never as good as fresh out of the oven. The manager stressed how extremely busy the one front of house person is, so why then would they suggest that we should've asked that she clean our table? We were perfectly capable of doing so ourselves, and so we did. I was simply recounting my true and honest experience, but I suppose that any constructive criticism or less than glowing feedback is not appreciated. Perhaps, with all of your popularity and success you should consider hiring additional help to rectify these issues rather than making excuses and placing blame on an overworked/overwhelmed member of your staff. One additional star removed for management's snarky remarks.

    Photos
    Brooklyn Char
    Pepperoni pizza
    Pepperoni pizza
    Pepperoni and mushroom pizza.

    See all

    Pepperoni and mushroom pizza.
    Bier Brewery

    Bier Brewery

    4.4
    (93 reviews)
    2.5 mi
    $$

    This is the place to be! Hands down the best patio in Noblesville. They have a ton of fun outdoor…read moregames for kids and a ton of different seating option. Great place to host parties or gather. I went with my book club and we ordered so much food - fried pickles, breadsticks and wings, cheese curds and pizza. I recommend the fried pickles, wings and breadsticks! The pizza was OK but the other items I mentioned were 10/10! The patio is pet friendly I think they charge a small fee to bring them in. This is also kid friendly they offer sensory bags for purchase and have a ton of outdoor games to keep kids entertained. Check them out! Cheers!

    Really enjoyed our visit here! The brewery has a huge outdoor space with a laid-back,…read morefamily-friendly atmosphere. There are games, a playground for kids, picnic tables, string lights, and multiple fire pits. I think it'll be an awesome spot in the fall. I had the Caprese pizza on the gluten-free cauliflower crust and it was delicious. The pizza trays are HOT, so the staff carries them. If you've never been, you order at the counter, get a buzzer, and when your food is ready they provide plates and utensils and walk the pizza back to your table with you. There was a torrential downpour about two bites into my pizza, so we quickly moved under the covered patio. They also had live music, which added to the laid-back vibe. I'll definitely be back!

    Photos
    Flight of Bier
    Flight of Bier
    Party room
    Party room
    Wings

    See all

    Wings
    Bronko’s Pizza And Sandwich Shop

    Bronko’s Pizza And Sandwich Shop

    4.6
    (91 reviews)
    9.5 mi

    What an excellent local pizza place! The breadsticks are absolutely addictive. I'm a breadstick…read moreconnoisseur and here are some of the best I have found anywhere. Pizza is delicious too. The toppings are really piled on, with a generous amount of cheese. No skimpy pizzas here. Service was very friendly. This place does a huge amount of business but they manage to get the pizzas out at the quoted times. Highly recommend stopping by when you are in the area. Actually it is worth a road trip too.

    I had some free time on a Sunday, close to noon, and drove from Westfield to Cicero to check out…read moreBronko's. From the Yelp photos I've seen, this seemed like my kind of place. Service and ambiance were both fantastic. I was one of the first customers of the day, and I dined-in. My server was delightful and attentive. There are a very small number of tables and booths available, but that's perfectly fine for a small-town pizza joint. As much as it pains me to say this, I found the pizza to be underwhelming. I was a bit surprised at the overall lack of bold flavors. The price point is great, and you get a lot of pizza for the dollar, but I was expecting much more of a flavor explosion. I had high hopes, because visually this pizza closely resembles my hometown favorite pizza as a kid (Volcano Pizza in Elkhart), but it just didn't live up to the expectations. I'm sure I'll give this place another try at some point, and maybe experiment with some other pizza combinations on the menu.

    Photos
    Outside of the pizza place
    Outside of the pizza place
    Medium Da Region pizza with regular crust
    Medium Da Region pizza with regular crust
    Ham salad with house made ranch dressing

    See all

    Ham salad with house made ranch dressing
    Colosseo Pizzeria

    Colosseo Pizzeria

    4.7
    (33 reviews)
    1.6 mi

    Visited Colosseo Pizzeria for the first time. The atmosphere is very casual. There were only seven…read moredining tables, or seating for about 30. A very small dining area. The menu consists of Antipasti, pasta, salads, and pizza. They also have desserts of tiramisu, cannelloni and cheesecake. We ordered the Amanti Della Carne pizza. It consisted of mozzarella, pepperoni, homemade sausage, signature, tomato sauce, ham, and mortadella. All pizzas are 12 inch and thin crust. Our pizza was $17. We also ordered the spring salad for $7. It consisted of spring mix, tomatoes, and homemade balsamic vinaigrette. The spring salad was good. The lettuce was fresh and nicely seasoned with the dressing. We really liked the homemade balsamic dressing. The pizza was very good and had a lot of toppings. As mentioned there is no variety or choice of size. The pizza only comes in a 12 inch, which was eight slices. Also, there is no choice of crust thickness. It is all a reasonably thin crust. Not a cracker thin crust, but thinner than most pizzas. We really liked it. The table next to us ordered pasta. They said it was delicious. They asked our server if the pasta was made fresh in the house. The server replied that it was. Service was very good, friendly, and prompt. It appears they do a big takeout business as while we were dining we saw several people come in and pick up pizzas to go. We recommend if you were in the area

    Ordered from here a while back. Originally tried it after seeing their pictures on social media and…read moreit looked great. I went super basic and just got a cheese pizza, as I am a pretty basic eater. When I walked in, I was greeted happily and they were super helpful. I took the pizza to go, but there was plenty of nice seating inside. The pizza was cooked very well. Crispy but not too crispy. The sauce tasted great. All in all, I thought this was a very solid option for true pizza in Fishers and hope this place does great!

    Photos
    Colosseo Pizzeria
    Colosseo Pizzeria
    Colosseo Pizzeria

    See all

    Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse

    Crafters Pizza and Drafthouse

    4.5
    (315 reviews)
    6.2 mi
    $$

    Spectacular pizza! They have some creative options too. I got a pizza with brisket and BBQ sauce…read morethat was about as good as pizza can be. They had a nice selection of draft beers for a pizza place. There were about 12 different drafts and they weren't your typical selections. They serve a drink called a Louisville Lip (basically a whiskey sour with amaretto) that was dynamite. It was really crowded for a Sunday night. It was hard to find a parking spot. The staff was A+.

    I tried this place based on the great reviews from other Yelpers. We went on a Friday night at 6pm…read moreand this place was packed. My advice is get here early or you'll be standing in a long line of 20-30 people outside. I ordered the Cuban sandwich on pita bread. It was ok. It wasn't the best I've had and I probably won't order it again. The toasted pita bread made it harder to eat and it came with deep fried chips that may have been a little overcooked. My wife had the Meatball sub and said it was very tasty. It came with 11 meatballs and my wife commented you needed to eat the meatballs down the middle of the sub first before you could eat it as a sub. There were a lot of meatballs and it also came with same overcooked chips. I'm not sure what the draw is for this place. Maybe it's the pizza. It seems they serve a lot of them both in the restaurant and take out. If I come back I will try the pizza to see if that's what the hype is all about. We will try coming back on a week night to avoid the crowd.

    Photos
    The bar
    The bar
    Chicken Alfredo pasta
    Chicken Alfredo pasta
    Twix skillet cookie.

    See all

    Twix skillet cookie.

    Godfather’s Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...