We stopped by the because someone told us they had a lunch buffet. We got there and they had one pizza on the buffet. We were the only people in the building. We asked what came with the buffet and he pointed to the one pizza and said it came with a drink also. It was a very weird experience- we just decided to order a medium pizza and we left. read more

Was craving some pizza on a Friday night and decided to try here since it was just down the road. Ended up ordering carryout to enjoy at home. We ordered a large pizza and some breadsticks with cheese. The food was hot and they didn't skimp on the toppings at all. The employees were really nice when we went to pick it up even though they were pretty busy. Definitely will be going here again and probably ordering the same pizza with cheese and pepperoni read more

First time at a Monical's pizza. It was about what I expected. The interior has a very "mom and pop shop" feel. Almost like a small town pizza joint. The place is a lot bigger on the inside than I thought it was! I got a "individual pleaser" which has different options but I got the 8" pizza, salad, and drink. The salad was just shredded lettuce, carrots, tomatoes, and dressing. If it had croutons it would've been better! But overall, not bad - again that mom and pop shop feel. The pizza was good, about what I expected. It came out HOT and the crust was crispy. For $15 (with tax and tip) I was pretty happy. I'll be back. I would love to try the lunch buffet and some of their garlic or cheese breads. Only downside - they were pretty busy when I was in there and it seemed like they only had one server attending the Dining room so I never got a refill on my drink, but he was very nice and my order was correct. (And honestly handling that many tables alone was impressive) read more

Monical's Pizza - Personal pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I'm a sucker for a great thin-crust pizza, and Monical's delivers that remarkably well! Some places make the crust too thin, and the term cracker crust is appropriate. Monical's does it just right. It's crisp but not too crisp. I found myself fighting the urge for just one more piece. I visited on my lunch break and met Matt Guthrie at the front. I explained that it was my first time and asked him to give me the rundown on what makes Monical's great. Matt shared some of his favorites at Monical's and told me they have a great lunch buffet with all-you-can-eat pizza and a drink for 10.99 on the weekdays. He said they'd have a great variety of pizza for me to try. I'd just finished my workout next door at Exercise Inc, and I was starving, so the buffet was the perfect choice. The pizza is Delicious. I could see why Monical's has been around for so many years. As I was leaving, I noticed they had options for you to take home a pizza to cook at your place, similar to Papa Murphy's. Britney George talked with me about what I liked and shared some of her favorites . I called a good friend of mine who loves pizza of all types and styles and asked if he wanted to make Monical's our next location for meetings coming up this week. He happily agreed. I look forward to my next time. read more

Monical's Pizza - Pepperoni, Sausage, and BLT pizza covered with Parmesan cheese. - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Came to grab a personal pizza for lunch, and noticed the have a lunch buffet. If I had more time, I definitely would try it. I was greeted immediately with a smile, but there are no menus so you just have to guess on what they offer. It is a pizza place, so it would be easy to guess, but it is still nice having one in front of you when you're somewhere new. Ended up getting a personal veggie pizza and an order of garlic cheese bread. The cheese bread is delicious, and somehow the marinara to dip it in is even better. It's is crispy and light, cheesy and well seasoned. The pizza was also great. I love pan pizza because of the crust, and this one doesn't disappoint. The veggies are fresh and there's a good cheese:sauce ratio. I also noticed that they sell frozen pizzas. There is a vintage pizza feel inside, and I could see this being a great place for families. Can't wait to try again. read more

See all

We picked up a family pleaser and the pizza was burnt to a crisp. I can't believe they would send that out with someone!

Embarrassed to serve Monical's pizza to guests! I would have been better off to offer them frozen Totinos! Every single plate that I cleared from the table had pieces that I threw away. For an expensive pizza, the quality was just sad! The toppings were minimal, and burnt pieces were just hanging on the bottom! read more

Monical's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Perhaps it was because I'd spent the entire morning and much of the afternoon apartment hunting and that experience is almost always atrocious. Or perhaps it was because I hadn't eaten anything all day, so by the time I got there around 2:45 I was so hungry I could fart fresh air. But I thought this place was terrific. It's set back a little off State Road 37, so if you're flying by in your car you'd probably miss it. But it's worth the stop. The service provided by Layla was very good. The restaurant was very clean and looked orderly. I ordered a thin crush specialty pizza called a Delight, which is essentially a deluxe without every possible bell and whistle (they have another one that does have every possible topping). I asked if they'd be kind enough to substitute onions (which I hate) for black olives (which I like), and they did so without an upcharge, so I thought that was nice. Throw in an iced tea and a decent tip, and the freight came in around $30. Totally worth it. The pizza was just really good. The toppings were generously proportioned and tasted fresh. The sauce was not too sweet, but not too tangy. The crust didn't taste like a salt bomb. It was just plain old good pizza. I ordered a 12-inch and ate every bit of it. I'd recommend this place to quite literally anyone, even pizza snobs who want to argue about NY pizza versus Chicago pizza versus Detroit-style pizza, etc etc etc. No, it's no Jockamo's or Bazbeaux. But it was on par with Ale Emporium or anywhere else. I'd recommend giving it a try. read more

Monical's Pizza - The Delight, 12", with black olives instead of onions. - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

My wife and I have been here numerous times. We get a thin crust pepperoni. We usually have a female server that is awesome and we have a nice meal without much fanfare. Last time we went our server was very nice young man. However, my biggest issue is when server's are real handsy with my food. His thumb was literally on the plate he brought. The kitchen is not going to win any cleanliness awards. In today's world it's paramount that the young people have a few classes on cleanliness! If it were not for his thumb they would have gotten another star!! read more

Great pizza and Service with thin crust and fresh toppings. In a nice clean old-fashioned pizza restaurant setting. I will definitely come here again read more

When we arrived I thought they were closed because no one was in there, however we were quickly greeted and taken care of. The service was great and the food was excellent. We got our food promptly. The environment was a downfall. With no one in the restaurant, I would have expected a cleaner place. Spilled drinks on the floor, food on the floor, and walking back to the bathroom looked rough. Not well maintained. Random fridge in a doorway, half stocked service stations. Overall I am giving it five stars and benefit of the doubt. It was the end of the night, maybe short staffed, etc. read more

Monical's Pizza - Dining area - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Pizza and a large salad. I ordered online and it was ready and delicious. The pizza was loaded with excellent ingredients and the salad was as good as I've had in a long while. We will definitely be back. read more

I don't think I ever tried anything else after buffalo chicken, it was so good. And every time I go, that is a must to have.

The place was different, and I do like to try new places. It was overall decent. The pizza was good.

Nice pizza place. Clean and cozy with friendly, courteous staff. Pizza had a nicely tangy sauce and the pepperollies were a delicious appetizer. Overall the food was good and reasonably priced. read more

Monical's Pizza - Mighty Meats pan pizza (8") - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Great pizza! I'm gluten free and I love that they have both a pasta and pizza option!

This is pretty legit pizza. Big fan of a big pie with sausage, olives, mushrooms and double cheese. Definite perfection. Give this place a shot. read more

Glad to find a Monicals in Fishers. I ordered the lunch chicken bacon ranch thin crust. It arrived quickly and hot. It delicious! I'll be back. read more

Monical's Pizza - Chicken bacon ranch thin crust individual size - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Monical's has been one of our favorite local pizza place to meet up with friends. We learned several years ago that their family pleaser easily satisfies a party of 4, for only $25 plus tip. You get a pizza, large bowl of salad to share and a pitcher of soda. We get the deep dish, and often leave with at least one or 2 pieces of pizza to take home. Most of us are full after eating a bowl of salad and a piece of pizza. The deep dish IS a lot of crust. The place is pretty much ran by local teens, but we have never had a server that wasn't cheerful and pleasant. We've been here many, many times over the years and always had great service. I really only have 2 issues that keep me from giving them 5 stars. First, they freeze the tomatoes that they use on their salad. It makes them absolutely disgusting. Mushy tomatoes make me gag. They didn't use to do that, when we first discovered them, and the salad was SO good. Then they started freezing them for some strange reason and it just totally ruined it. Secondly, when it's cold outside, the whole front of the restaurant is really cold and drafty. But they only want larger parties to sit in the back. Otherwise, their pizza is pretty good and it's a great value. read more

Monical's Pizza - Toddler approved. He also enjoyed coloring, while he waited for his food. - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

A phenomenal hit, without miss every time. The pizzas, (1) 14", (2) 8", were cooked in a manner which honored and accentuated the reputation of Monical's Pizza. Certainly, one could find something to complain about regarding any eatery. However, if you possess over half a brain, you can recognize that restaurants are there to provide great food, not conduct white-glove inspections or hire 5 star staff. Nevertheless, I bring all of my out of state friends to Monical's as a means of showcasing that there's more than corn in Indiana. They always leave with a strengthened respect for the state's cuisine. read more

My husband had to wait an additional 20 mins on our pizza on top of the estimated time. I believe they tried to make it right by giving us some wings....my husband said they just handed them to him. Awesome gesture which is appreciated but the wings were not good. Very chewy and thick mushy skin. We all said the pizza was good, but not that good. I gave it a 6 out of 10. Not horrible, but just not a place I would likely order from in the future. read more

Monical's has been a part of the pizza scene for over 40 years! Italian special as family pleaser style! read more

Monical's Pizza - Restaurant COVID-19 style! - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Ordered the margarita pizza and it had no pizza sauce on it, no basil and the tomatoes werent roma tomatoes! Threw my whole pizza away! My husbands pizza was good so i had some of his. I def will not eat there again. Dont order the margarita pizza as it was cheese w regular tomatoes on it! Smh to even serve tht! I wanted to go up there to show thm wat thy gave to me! read more

Monical's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

One of my daughters' favorite places to eat lunch. We don't even need a menu anymore to order. Lunch buffet is available weekdays. Ordering a pitcher of drinks which is refillable is a better deal than ordering individual drinks if you are getting the same flavor. Sign up for emails and receive coupons each month for discounts. They have a backroom section that you can reserve for meetings and parties at no extra charge. Each Monical's location varies slightly so you might notice some differences from location to location. read more

Quick delivery, excellent pizza and breadsticks. My only complaint would be that they use canned mushrooms vs. fresh on our pizza.

First time-Last time Went in during our lunch. Told they had a buffet...so we said sure. Well pizza is only thing on buffet....nothing else...... Pizza was cold and old....asked if they would bring out fresh....they brought a couple and they tasted about like a $.99 Totinos out of the frozen section...lol.. What a waste of money. read more

We have always been fans of Monical's. My wife's family is from Illinois, so we've been eating it for years. We moved here from Avon where customer service and delivery was always great. This Fishers location has some serious staffing issues. Customer service and communication on deliveries is poor. If something is going to take an hour fine, if it's 90 minutes, we can plan for that, but to be told 45 minutes and then I have to call to get an update after 90 min that our pizzas are on the ways...you're in a service driven business. On top of that, when I called she was rude and short. I would not recommend this location and I hope the owners pay attention to their brand and make staffing changes. read more

The waitress was friendly enough but did not clearly explain the options for gluten free pizza choice. $15 for a 9' thin crust pizza is ridiculous! The manager did give us a discount. However, it was the worst tasting pizza I've ever had. Will not go back. read more

best pizza place ever! the service is great and the overall inside is good! i love the seating arrangements

This is one of my favorite pizza places-you know, the one you crave. I look forward to being on that side of town because it has always been worth the drive. I hate to admit that tonight I was disappointed. The kids pizza was undercooked and although they offered to bake some more, there was no adjustment to our price. My pizza had too much pepper on it and the inside of the restaurant didn't feel very clean. I really hope this is just a one-time experience. read more

This is my all time favorite pizza! I grew up eating this pizza in Peoria, IL and then moved to Indiana where they didn't have Monicals. I was driving by and saw this place and couldn't resist stopping. I love their thin crust pizza. It is more expensive than most pizza chains but definitely worth the extra money in my opinion. Also recommend the family pleaser for salad with your pizza. read more

I used to go to Monicals pizza in fishers all of the time in high school but I went here recently and was just not impressed anymore. I ordered the wings and they very fatty and barely had any meat on them at all. My boyfriend ordered the mighty meat pizza and it didn't have a good flavor and just looked to be thrown together at the last minute. Also the peanut butter cookies had no flavor and tasted stale. I won't be going here any more. read more

The quality of food at Monicals has gone down significantly. We used to order from here regularly but the last several times have been unacceptable. See attached for pictures of kids lasagna and BBQ wings, which we didn't even eat after looking at them. The pizza was average at best. read more

Monical's Pizza - Kids Meal Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

This is worst place on earth. Health department should be alerted. It's not just bad tasting food but it's health hazard. Staffs are rude on the top. Just avoid this place. read more

It was okay. The place was a ghost town when we came in so service was good, except forgetting an item . The margherita pizza on thin crust was not very flavorful and the tomato chunks were huge. The buffalo chicken on pan crust was pretty good. Skip the salad, it's more like coleslaw. With all the pizza choices in the Fishers/ Noblesville area will not be going there again. read more

Wife and I ordered from here a few months ago since we live down the street. When picking up my pizza, I asked the guy if paying $20+ for a pizza was worth it. He said "it's the best pizza place in Indy..." I took his word for it and couldn't wait to eat the pizza. I took a bite out of the first slice and noticed the dough was straight up raw. I called the place back and they said they'd make me a new one. I was ok with that and went back to the place. The guy said "hey sorry man...sucks it was your first time too..." I told him "all good stuff happens..." I got home with the remade pizza...and guess what, dough was raw again. I called the place back and they guy was like "you're not coming back here are you?...like ever..." I told him "No." I'd be ok with the experience if it wasn't $20+ for a pizza. read more

The service was horrible.. waitress came up with no hello or how are you just asked what we wanted about 10 minutes after we came in. Also if you want beer your out of luck, they don't serve alcohol. It's also very hot in there and didn't feel like there was any air conditioning. Overall it was not a good experience, we ended up leaving right after we got there. We've had the pizza before and it is good but the restaurant experience was not. read more

Great pizza. I always get the thin crust- which is super thin and crunchy. Upgrade it to a family pleaser and you get a salad, and drinks with your pizza. They have a really tasty veggie pizza. Yummy breadsticks. I recommend the nacho cheese sauce. read more

Found this place a while ago. Love their thin crust Hawaiian added bacon and green olives. I love the oregano they add. It's true...this is not a fancy place, but a pizza joint. My husband was not a fan of pan pizza crust tonight. It was a little greasy for his taste. But he does like the thin crust when he ordered it. They put plenty of toppings on so every bit has all your toppings. Just the way I like it. The thin crust is not overly saucy. There are plenty of options from the crust, sauces, and toppings. read more

I am a little biased when it comes to Monical's Pizza or pizzas in general. I grew up eating Monical's in Illinois was very glad when they showed up in the Indianapolis area. The pizza tonight was cooked perfectly service was excellent. If you're in the area they do have a very good priced lunch buffet that they keep stocked. read more