Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Godfathers Pizza

    4.2 (10 reviews)

    Godfathers Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Godfathers Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Grant N.
    13
    104
    65

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Ordered online and picked up. The pizza was ready on time, hot, and delicious. Price was right too. Very pleased.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Pizza and wings are really good! They are open later than a lot of the places around town.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Good pizza glad to see Godfathers back on the map.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Godfathers Pizza

    Review Highlights - Godfathers Pizza

    It's located inside the loves gas station which goes with the town theme and is newly renovated and has multiple types of personal sized pizzas ready to be carried out.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 151 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Gourmet Noodle - Italian Cake (use the lemon;)

    The Gourmet Noodle

    3.9(202 reviews)
    45.6 mi
    $$

    Sadly we tried dozens of times to make a reservation for days but the website never would work. We…read moreloved this place when Michael owned it. The reviews are not so great but we wanted to make our own decision but no such luck. Hope they get the website straightened out.

    SUMMARY: Mediocre food…read more Despite the great reputation, well adorned facility, stellar location, and impressive menu, everything I ordered proved consistently disappointing. Calling this food ordinary is, at best, an overstatement. At each turn, my efforts invoked in salvaging the (food) entries was met with failure. Starting with a simple Caesar salad, the lettuce tasted several days old. Drenched in ordinary tasting salad dressing, the romaine lettuce became soggy from the presence of excessive dressing. The dressing was too strong in taste, akin to store bought lower priced varieties, and from this, proved difficult to eat. The portion was generous, however. WARNING: Do not order the minestrone soup. To explain: The minestrone soup proved ultra disappointing. With the amount that I paid, $12, for a bowl, I was expecting it to be of meal-like quality. Instead, it was also challenging to consume, being so vinegary, possessing a handful of some tomato slices and little else. It arrived lukewarm. Instead of ample carrots, beans, celery, onion, etc., with typically a delicious broth, all that I could detect was slimy tomato slices in a pool of vinegar. The "chef" needs to study quality minestrone soup recipes and completely start over, especially if customers are charged $12 for such. I was so looking forward to a quality and hearty minestrone soup. I haven't tasted anything so pathetic yet simultaneously overpriced, in years. Have they tasted this? It pains me to speak so passionately about something like this. But it was a disaster. The house bread? It was crunchy, also seeming to be dated, not stale, just not fresh. It wasn't warm. It was dry. The garlic butter was fine, but following the theme, ordinary, at best. I tried everything to make at least the bread come alive, heaping massive piles of garlic butter on it. Nothing could rescue the bread either. No olive oil was to be found anywhere on the table or tables in my vicinity. Very friendly staff was present, but their inexperience and lack of polish became annoying. Whatever virtue that the "soup" might have had was lost as it got even colder while she was talking ceaselessly to me. Yes, it arrived lukewarm before she was conversing. Friendly service, even if awfully informal, can't compensate for such a poor price - value relationship and mediocre food. I cannot recommend this restaurant. Perhaps they do a superior job on pasta dishes. Yet, upon perusing the menu, I couldn't find just a small or half portion of spaghetti. A jr. high aged boy near me somehow managed to order a small plate of spaghetti. While it looked ordinary, such would likely have proven sufficient tonight, even if such was likely only available on the children's menu. If this restaurant once served fresh and delicious food, something, at least of late, has woefully gone awry in the kitchen.

    Photos
    The Gourmet Noodle
    The Gourmet Noodle - Undercooked chicken

    Undercooked chicken

    The Gourmet Noodle - Red sauce

    See all

    Red sauce

    Mario's Pizza & Pasta

    Mario's Pizza & Pasta

    4.0(241 reviews)
    47.6 mi
    $$

    Dropped in with family and was greeted right away with friendly service and smiles all around. This…read moreplace has been here a while and I've been a few times over the years when I visit so this is the first Yelp. A casual setting and clean! We ordered a large pizza (Chicago deep dish) and their salad. It's very chill and relaxed! Again pizza! Stop in and check it out!!

    I found Mario's about 20 years ago and put the number in my phone a couple years later for ordering…read moreahead on the way through town. It's still in there. We wanted to take a break on a long drive, so we sat down inside. We got lucky--no line. Our server was quick to greet us and brought cokes in big glasses with crushed ice. Yes. While we waited on food, I looked around and soaked in the vibe. This is a local's place in the purest sense, but has always felt welcoming, no matter where I'm living. Pizza--and buttered spaghetti w meatball for the younger diner--arrived quickly enough and we dug in. Mario's pizza stands out as "normal" pizza with every ingredient and flavor on point. You'll have to drive a long way to find any on par with Mario's pies. They're in my top three Colorado mountain town pizza joints and I've been to my fair share. The meatball from the kids' spaghetti was moist and tasty--good, not great. Five stars for simple excellence, good service, and the 60-70s pizza joint decor.

    Photos
    Mario's Pizza & Pasta
    Mario's Pizza & Pasta - Deep dish pepperoni, eaten so fast I only got a photo of the last two pieces...

    Deep dish pepperoni, eaten so fast I only got a photo of the last two pieces...

    Mario's Pizza & Pasta

    See all

    Garlic Mike's

    Garlic Mike's

    3.7(274 reviews)
    46.1 mi
    $$

    Our second time coming here in two weeks. Fridays are must because they have their grilled oysters…read morewhich we had to have again! The owner cooks them himself and they are just incredible! I got a Hugo spritz this time which was nice a refreshing! We tried the meatballs (super juicy and the bread was fluffy and delicious), pickle cream cheese bombs (recommended by the best server Quinn) were fantastic and then we had to get some dessert to go! We spent our whole time at the river bar this time and left with fully belly's! Quinn's the best server, he's so friendly and has great recommendations! He is super attentive even with having so many tables to tend to!

    Arrived at 7:30pm on a Saturday after fishing to no wait and were not given any strange looks for…read morewearing extreme dress casual (cargo pants and T-shirts). Bread and garlic butter for the table was already insanely good and I could tell I was going to be in trouble already. We ordered the garlic fries with tabasco mayo and I had to stop myself from getting too full on them. Next was soup and salad the wife got the ceasar salad and was silent until it was done, fine, I got the cream of mushroom soup and was glad I didn't have to reply I would've thought about ignoring her so I could keep eating. The wife got the chicken piccata, one of her favorite dishes and expressed in somewhat vague terms that she wanted to kiss the chef on the lips. Silent treatment is ok but advances on other men... getting weird but it was really good so I can't say I blame her too much. I had ordered the steak carbonara but might have been too quiet while ordering and was served a steak. No harm no foul, it was my second choice anyways but it was seasoned strangely, I could tell it was very well done and cooked exactly how I requested but the seasoning wasn't my cup of tea. Against our better judgement we ordered dessert, the wife got an espresso martini and I ordered the chocolate lava cake. Jessica our gourmet food delivery woman and friend for the night found out we were celebrating our anniversary and got us cannolis on the house as well. It was the only course I got a picture of because we had to pace ourselves by then. "La vie en rose" started playing as I ate the lava cake and I felt my ADD calm down for a while. The wife was also very cagey about the cannolis she had claimed but I managed to steal some, also very good but I didn't want to share too much of my chocolate heaven on a plate. Biggest complaint was the serving sizes were large and the food was very good, so sad we were in a hotel and were leaving the next day so couldn't take anything home with us.

    Photos
    Garlic Mike's - View from where I was sitting

    View from where I was sitting

    Garlic Mike's - Personal Chef, Garlic Mike-at your service. go to Garlicmikes.com

    Personal Chef, Garlic Mike-at your service. go to Garlicmikes.com

    Garlic Mike's

    See all

    Godfathers Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...