Great pizza, cool atmosphere, and very clean! The decor gives the place a fun, unique vibe, and the lighting adds to the experience. Everything was spotless, the staff was friendly, and the pizza was delicious. Definitely a spot I'll be coming back to! read more

Food: Pizza are great. my choice is meat lover and the pizza is great.you never get wrong with others items they have Service: friendly and super fast Ambiance: i would say small but is great for after work and to hang out. F read more

Good Fellas Pizza - lemon chicken - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

See all

Pizza was just okay. Really enjoyed the crust with thr garlic butter, but overall the pizza wasn't anything special. $30 for a giant which was the same size as a large pizza elsewhere or maybe they got my order wrong and gave me a large but charged me for a giant idk. The staff was super nice though. read more

Food is great! The quality is there. Love the pizza special. The service is always excellent as well!

I was so excited to try this place and I was very disappointed. Pros: The service is great. The cashier was very nice and even offered me a drink for my longer than expected wait. I really appreciated that. It was also very clean and I loved the pictures inside. Cons: The food wasn't as good as it looked. The mozzarella sticks don't really taste like regular mozzarella sticks. The batter is different and not what I expected. The pizza was a 5/10 if I'm being honest. Honestly, every item tasted sweet in a way and I'm not sure why. Also it was so hot in there. I understand we're going through a heatwave but why was it hotter inside than outside?? There's no way that's ok for those guys to work in this kind of environment. I was sweating just sitting there. read more

See all

If I could I'd give their pizza 6 stars!! I'm just amazed at how delicious their pizza is and just happy it's so close to home. As a West Whittier local I'm all about supporting small businesses, eating local and boosting our local economy but this place would have my business even if it was the next city over. The pizza is that good! I tried their pepperoni with mushroom since it's my wife's favorite and it's honestly the best pizza I've had in years. I'm a fan of pepperoni and mushroom pizzas so getting a pizza which has tons of toppings, robust flavors and delicious from the first to last bite I'm very pleased. I found the sauce to be perfectly seasoned and the crust was moist and crunchy in all the right places and still hot by the time i got home. A few things I found interesting was their local specials on Instagram, their wide variety but not complex menu and decent space for dining in. I can honestly say this place fills that pizza void I've had in my heart for a while since I'm very picky when it comes to quality and ingredients. I hope this review helped you decide to give this place a shot and hopefully you like it just as much as I did read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Pepperoni & mushroom deliciousness - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

The pizza here is really good, inexpensive and slices can be purchased. The customer service is inviting. I visited a few weeks ago and they were closed due to construction. I'm not sure if they've opened yet. There is another location on Whittier Boulevard but the parking there can be tricky. read more

Alrighty, brutal honesty time. When this spot opened up to replace the burger place, I was stoked. Who doesn't love pizza? Especially so close to where I live? We're really lacking in a reliably good pizza joint. Well, I'll be up front and say I'm a loyalist to a certain spot in Montebello and have been for the past sixteen or so years, so I am a tough audience to please. My mom picked up and order to go and she said that service was good and the people working there were kind, which I always a appreciate and when she arrived home and I took the boxes and bags from her and opened everything up, I could sort of tell something was off. The pizza seemed to have a lot of crust to pie ratio, and it was burnt black. I know some people like that, but I'm not one of them. The toppings looked good and the sauce looked promising (I'd read that they have a good recipe for their dough and their sauce), but first bite in, there wasn't much to write home about. It was bland and the dough really didn't have anything different aside from places like dominos. We also ordered some wings, which didn't have much meat on them and the sauce was pretty standard. The sampler, which came with French fries, zucchini fries, and cheese sticks was surprising because I could instantly tell that the zucchini fries were frozen and the cheese sticks just crumbled in my hand. I'd say that there is potential here, given the brand and imaging. I think it is a great concept, but as far as the culinary component, there is much room for improvement. I really hope that some improvements can be made, because it would be so exciting to have a great neighborhood pizza joint. read more

Great special with pizza slices! Very good pizza! Great service! I go there at least once every week. read more

Pizza slice special is a great price and very convenient when in a rush vs grabbing fast food. Highly recommend for a good meal! read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Cashier - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

The food and the service is consistently good. The pizza is excellent and always nice and hot. The prices are high but fair for the quality and serving size. Highly recommend this pizza spot! read more

We were so excited to try this place as it's right down the street from our house. I went directly to the website and called the phone number listed on that menu. No one answered, and we tried a few times, but kept getting the automated message saying the voice mailbox hadn't been set up. So we tried the number on Yelp (it's a different number) and got that same message. Tried again a few minutes later and someone answered. He wasn't super friendly, but whatever, we were still excited to try it. We went to pickup our order expecting it to be really busy due to the unanswered phones, but it didn't seem to be. Unfortunately, we ordered a pepperoni sausage and not only didn't get the sausage, but hardly any pepperoni (see photo). We looked at the receipt upon pick up which showed we'd been charged for the sausage, but didn't actually open the box to double check. Pizza was just ok. Mozzarella sticks were just ok too. As someone mentioned before, not typical breading but more of a fried fish type batter, just fyi. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - This was the pepperoni sausage pizza we ordered. No sausage and not much pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

Worst pizza I've ever tried on par with Costco pizza , chicken wings, maybe chicken jerky. Absolutely gross. $53 down the drain

Honestly I came in here on accident. I was exhausted and didn't notice I went to the wrong pizza place nor did I realize until I ordered. By the time I noticed it was too late so I rolled the dice. Best dice I've rolled this week. Guys inside were super chill. Ordered a calzone it was fire. Will be coming back again for sure. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Calzone Sausage and Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

Just tried Good Fellas Pizza for the first time and my family and I are definitely going back again!!! The traditional wings were so delicious!!! And finding a gluten free pizza around our city is so difficult and they had it!!! Thank you!!! It was amazing!!!! Truly recommend it! read more

Goodfellas Pizza is hands-down my favorite restaurant in Whittier--no competition. The food is always fresh, piping hot, and ridiculously delicious. Their crust is the perfect combo of crispy and chewy, the sauce has that homemade taste, and the cheese? Just the right amount of gooey goodness. Every bite feels like a hug from an Italian grandma who means it. Not only is the food top-tier, but the prices are super affordable, which is rare these days for something that tastes this good. You get quality without breaking the bank, and the portions are generous (aka leftover heaven). Whether I'm picking up for a chill night in or grabbing lunch with friends, the service is fast and friendly. It just feels like a local spot that actually cares--because they do. If you're in Whittier and haven't been to Goodfellas yet... fix your life. You're welcome. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - DELICIOUS!!! This is Caesar Salad and Pepperoni Pizza by the Slice ! This is definitely the BEST pizza/sub/salad spot in Whittier !! - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

Food was surprisingly good. I usually eat in Uptown and tried this place randomly on my way home. I've been there at least once a week for the last 2 months. Solid pizza spot read more

Was presently surprised at this local pizza place had some pretty decent pizza. The seller was pretty good as well. Definitely won't go back. read more

Great pizza at reasonable prices. Sauce and crust are good. The service is also top notch. Sauce

Just finished having dinner at this location. The people here really take pride in their work. They are the most respectful and dedicated staff. The quality of the food is so fresh, Gordon Ramsey would be proud to eat here. If Albert and Marvin are working you will be in the best of hands. They will make sure your food experience is unforgettable. You will be back for more just because of the great experience you will have. The cleanliness of the locations is great. You could eat off the floor. I recommend you come and try what they have to offer. The menu is full of awesome items Please stop by and enjoy pizza the way it should be made. Gooey cheese fresh sauce and a nice crispy crust. You will not be disappointed. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Marvin and Albert. - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

See all

Raw uncooked over priced garbage don't waste your time and if you do eat by mistake and find your self here make sure you have extra toilet paper at home they should close this place down immediately read more

Im make this simple. Was craving pizza, had heard of Good Fellas Pizza but hadn't tried it yet, there's one not too far from where I live in Pico. Ordered delivery from the one on Beverly blvd in Whittier. Ordered large pepperoni pizza and lemon pepper wings. Pizza came fast, hot and fresh. Great pizza, no complaints. Wings were good, nothing off the charts. I will definitely be having pizza from Good Fellas again. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Large pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

This is a very great tasting pizza. If looking for great tasting pizza try this place. Small little place but great tasting pizza. I do go out of my way to drive to get pizza here. read more

First time ordering and let me tell you this is my new spot. Dank af, the seasoning is so good, the amount of sauce is nice and the crust is perfect. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

Over priced, hate to leave such a low rating it's the fact that I'm ordering a slice and drink for 6.99 and I still end up with a total of $19 for just 2 combos. The slices are big and split into 2 but nothing compared to Costco size, and that's only 1.99. I just think in all honesty they should consider more to add to the deal or change the price read more

BOMB BOMB pizza from Vegas to L.A! This is some of the most delicious pizza we've ever tasted here in L.A. Really high quality ingredients. PERFECT crust! Crusty on the outside, soft on the inside. CRAZY good wings, potato wedges! Super friendly staff. Overall, really good experience!!! read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

We found the food to be pretty good and the service great. We ordered the BBQ chicken pizza and my son loved it. Will definitely come back again. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - BBQ chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

Great service! The pizza slices are huge and so good! Was in town for the week for work and tried this place. Wow so glad I did. Will definitely be returning! read more

First time at Good Fellas Pizza, very welcoming and friendly. My husband asked me to get him a slice of pizza and I ask him "Where am I suppose to get a slice of pizza?" So I yelped and Good Fellas pop-up on Norwalk & Beverly. Loved it! Definitely going back to get a whole pizza! read more

First time having this pizza great service pizza Chef was very informative. Very confident love it. Our pizzas were absolutely delicious. Will be back soon. read more

To clarify... they did sell pizza slices.... that's what I wanted a slice but with added toppings.

Had takeout. Pizza was hot & yummy. Has Italian Seasoning on the pizza. Makes for a different flavor than say Pizzamanias was. Which was a 9.5/10. Closed due to fire as most know. Service was very good . Owners very kind & the place is clean. I would give this pizza a 8/10. Only because I am not a fan of Italian seasoning on my pizza. Definitely worth giving it a folks. read more

Came here for the first time tried a bit of everything, Wow! Everything we ordered was so deliciousgive them a 10/10

The ambiance was creative and I enjoyed the decor and Italian foto on the wall. This was my first time at this location and I was pleasantly surprised. I ordered an extra large pizza with cheese, pepperoni and pineapples and Lasagna with Garlic bread to go. The pizza was extraordinary and the Lasagna was excellent. I will return again. read more

Food is always fresh. Staff is helpful and sometimes they have unadvertised specials. Happy to support this local business

We had pepperoni pizza, anti-pasta salad and Garlic knots! Both the food and service were amazing. We will definitely be returning.

Great customer service, spacious parking, friendly staff and clean facility. The food Price and Quality are very good The Food was Delicious I can confidently say that they're my favorite restaurant read more

Great food Great customer service! Pizza and Buffalo wings are fantastic . I have been going Good fellas almost every week.

I like this little place. It is perfect for a relaxing bite out on the patio. Their pizzas are just the right thickness, and I like their salad too. read more

I've been coming here a few times. I haven't had any problems. Food is great, atmosphere is cool. And customer service is excellent