Our party of 2 had a hankering for pancakes at 2:30 in the afternoon, so we decided to give Goodfella's a try. I'm sure we'll be back. :) The service was especially friendly and fast, and we genuinely appreciated our server's good humor. The ambience was quiet, eclectic and funny; comfy booths available. We ordered a variety of breakfast items, including eggs, bacon, toast, hash browns, and of course, pancakes. The bacon was actually the star of the show, so good I'd go back just for that. But the pancakes and eggs were tasty, too. Thumbs up! read more

Super yum! Our waitress was so sweet and kind. The haystack is a great idea, a little mix of everything so you do not have to decide. Great diner with all the classics. Made me think of the diners in the Midwest, carries a home like feeling. I would definitely recommend and will be back next time I am in the area. read more

Love this place , lunch time on the patio , sun , umbrellas and exceptional service from Alejandra , enjoying their version on the club. read more

Goodfella's Diner - Club with golden fries, mmm yummy - American Near Me - Longmont, Colorado

I wish we had more diners like Goodfella's. Great food with great prices. Fast friendly service. Awesome atmosphere with a 1960's vibe in the 21st century. Had the Haystack with hashbrowns, 2 eggs and sausage plus it comes with toast or pancakes for $15 my wife had the 2 eggs and hash browns for $10. Tons of food at very reasonable prices! read more

I like supporting small businesses and Goodfellas seemed like a good start today. Diner atmosphere which I like. I ordered the chicken fried steak and eggs. They even have take-home pies and oversized cinnamon rolls. MeTV was playing 1950s sitcoms and the music was from the 50s - 70s. Witty dad jokes are displayed on the dividers separating the booths. read more

See all

Cute little diner! Food was delicious and our server was nice. We will definitely be back for future meals. read more

See all

Food was just okay. Server did not know her job very well. Explanation of food was subpar and overcharged me for my order. Asked for a manager and said there was no manager there. read more

ADA / ACCESSIBILITY RATING OUT OF 10 = 8 1/3 Well done!! (1.0 out of 1.0 for each) -Stairs/ramps/elevators -Sturdy tables -Space between tables Passable (0.75 out of 1.0 for each) -Entry/exit through main, bathroom doors: Front doors heavy & difficult to open from wheelchair or scooter -Parking/parking lot ramp(s): Do well with ramps but serious parking lot repair needed. Makes navigation in wheelchair, scooter, crutches, walker difficult -Easy in/out seating: No arms on chairs -Bathroom space for wheelchair/scooter -Bathroom grab bar placement -Tight turns, clear aisles/hallways: 90 degree turn into women's restroom read more

Goodfella's is a solid diner and a good place for breakfast. I love diners. Yelp led me here and it was a good recommendation. I get the feeling that very few tourists come here. The crowd seemed local and the staff knew all of them. There was a slight wait to be seated but in less than 15 minutes, we had a table and were ordering. Service was very friendly and surprisingly prompt based on how busy they were. There were funny dad-style jokes written in each booth which I greatly appreciated. Now I have new material to make people groan at my cheesiness. The Denver omelet was perfectly done and had a great filling-to-egg ratio. That is key in omelets and if there is too much egg they are no good. You have the option of a chili-style sauce which I recommend. It is very common out west but uncommon back home. I don't even know what it is but it is good. Pricing was comparable to other breakfast joints. If you find yourself in Longmont, you should eat here. read more

Food and service okay. Food quality tastes like whichever cook does the cooking. Some definitely better tan others

Order the Fellas House Burger! We think this is one of the best burgers in Longmont. Whodathunk? We always get onion rings too, because they're really good. I can't review the other food because we always get that amazing, delicious burger read more

Classic American Diner with friendly staff and a dope environment. Cool stuff and interesting art left and right so you'll be occupied while you wait. Great food, cool challenges, deserts and clean. Consistent every time and keeps you waiting to come back. Thanks guys!! read more

Diner food done right! If you are looking for an elevated, snooty brunch, don't come here. However, service is always fast. Food is yummy. Omelettes and home fries good with toast and jam from those little plastic single serve containers. Last time I was there I noticed that the half and half was a pseudo milk, but I can deal with that. I'm not here for health food. ;-) read more

Wow! What a great find. I was totally blown away with the food, ambiance and Mandy, our server. The servings were huge and the food was delicious. I had the chili Relleno Breakfast platter with the pancakes. It was one of the best rellenos I've ever had the pancakes were huge. If you haven't been to this gem....check it out soon. read more

Service was much better than the food. Didn't have to wait but the place was definitely hoping!! Also Had the German pancake as a starter & because it seemed to be very popular to order. read more

See all

Two stars for the service only (which was good). Everything we ate, apart from the eggs, tasted like it came from a can or a box. The staff seem sincere, and I felt like asking "honest opinion - would you serve this food to your own mother? If you did, what do you think she'd say?" Nice atmosphere too. What a pity. read more

Food and service is always great! I love having brunch here with my daughter. It's one of my favorite places to eat here in Longmont.

Placed order online for pickup through their website- 1:16pm. Email said pickup at 1:36pm. I got stuck in traffic. Arrived at 1:45pm. Hostess said my order just came through it would be, about 15 minutes. At 2:19pm got another email said food was ready. So I patiently waited. At 2:29 I was finally given my food. After I asked for a 2nd time. Don't recommend using their website. Also staff was rude and no one inquiried, why I was sitting in the lobby for 45 minutes. read more

Love this place so much. Food is amazing. Staff is so friendly. We love coming here. So good.

We stopped on our way home. What a great find, food comes out quick and it was great. It was free pie so we each got a piece of pie. We plan on making a trip back to try their breakfast. Everyone is very friendly. read more

See all

I was in the area and a bit hungry. This place, though in the out lot of a strip mall, looked inviting. The entrance is covered with community notices, an eating challenge victory (and failure) wall, and other stuff. Seems like they are inviting to the locals which is great! I was greeted and seated quickly. A person brought over water and the waitress, Brandy, came over shortly after. I ordered what I thought I could eat - a 4 egg omelet and a side of pancakes. It didn't take a long time to get the food. It looked and smelled wonderful. I then tried to pace myself but since I LOVE breakfast any time of the day it was tough. Brandy checked on me now and then without being pushy. I was never left wanting water refill or extra napkins. Locals started wandering in and I felt like I was in Cheers (ie "Norm!"). I think it speaks highly of a place when they get a loyal following. I, too, might make this a regular stop if I lived in the area. read more

We had Pam as are waitresses she was awesome! Good food, good service! I would definitely recommend if you're in the area.

Our first time there for breakfast and we were impressed. The service was great! And the prices are very reasonable. Enjoyed our breakfast and we will be back. read more

Excellent local diner! Lots of regulars. Portions were very large and prices were solid. I will definitely be going back! read more

This is a cute old school diner! It was all decorated for fall and Halloween when I went. Great prices and friendly staff. I got a yummy sandwich with bacon and avocado, I don't remember what it was called. This is just old school simple comfort food. The pies looked good! read more

Goodfella's Diner - a sandwich on a plate - American Near Me - Longmont, Colorado

I stopped for breakfast after an appointment in Longmont. I had the Philly steak skillet and it was really good. My waitress was friendly and attentive. I'll stop in again next time I'm up that way read more

Love the decor, open and inviting. Staff was very attentive. I love that they bring a cup of hot water as well as a teapot, and 2 teabags. Menu was decent, and food was done nicely. It's a diner, not fancy, just good. read more

Good old fashion breakfast. But wait it has a twist try the chili Relleno for breakfast with eggs and a hash browns. It will blow your mind. read more

I love the diner atmosphere at Goodfella's The staff is well trained and considerate,. The vegetable beef soup is delicious , c I have a couple of favorites, chicken fried chicken with real mashed potatoes! Yummy! I love the Rueben too! Tender corned beef on swirled rye,wow! But last week the chicken pot pie was so disappointing, mostly peas and carrots with lots of gravy. It was recommended by our waitress, I was going to have the Rueben, but thought I'd give the chicken pot pie a try. I've never left hungry from good fellas but did last week. Giving it four stars, cause there are other items on the menu that are very good! read more

I visited Goodfella's for breakfast one morning - it's a greasy spoon diner - and apparently a bakery. I ordered the biscuits and gravy with two eggs over easy, and a sausage patty. Plus coffee and water. The sausage gravy was rather disappointing - it had very little flavor. The gravy could have been anything. It needed a major sausage infusion. The eggs were cooked perfectly, and the sausage patty was tasty. Coffee was good enough. Service was good. I'd come back and try something else on the menu. #GoodfellasDiner read more

See all

Ordered a chocolate pie online for the holidays. Service at pick up was great, fair price, beautiful bakery box presentation, & pie was spectacular! Well done Goodfella's. read more

My mother and I came in and ordered a cake to go from this restaurant on sunday and before I start to eat it i call them to make sure there are no tree-nuts in this cake because I am deathly allergic. The man I was speaking to (who I later found out was the general manager) assured me there were no nuts. I ate the cake and later on I start to feel my throat start to swell up and I begin having an allergic reaction to tree-nuts and have to use my epipen. My dad looks at the cake I was eating and further examines to find a whole bunch of nuts in the frosting and in the middle of the cake. We then called back to let them know what had happened and when the manager spoke to me he said "You asked about the cake, not the frosting" , I then told him once again he could have killed me in which he replied "You're being redundant" and hung up on me. Around 3am the next morning I started having a grand mal seizure and was throwing up until 10 that morning. The manager Jef treated my life as though it was a joke, and because I value my life I will not be coming back. read more

Classic diner with good food and friendly service. Stopped in Longmont for a wedding and have eaten breakfast here twice already. Solid breakfast spot with reasonable prices. The Relleno Skillet was pretty good! read more

Goodfella's Diner - Menu - American Near Me - Longmont, Colorado

See all

I Love the pancakes and the milkshake was delicious but my brother loves the Dino chicken nuggets!!! And they have good hash-browns and nice fall decorations . Our server was also very nice read more

So impressed with this little diner! We accidentally came upon in it after coming from a different place and never getting waited on. We were seated instantly and waited on by the sweetest waitress! We got a delicious HUGE warm cinnamon roll for $4.99 it was so awesome! Then shared a club sandwich and fries. The entire dining experience was A+ we will for sure make the drive to eat here again and highly recommend it!! read more

Everything we ordered was good. My husband had the fish and chips, my daugher was THRILLED to have dino nuggets and I had an omelette. We were very happy with the prices for sure. Also we randomly got free pie. Super happy with our experience here. read more

I normally enjoy this place. The service is good, but last night I ordered eggs Benedict and the hollandaise sauce was awful. It was not creamy at all. I just picked the egg and meat aside and ate that. The hash browns were overdone also- way too crunchy. read more

I started eating at Good Fellas about six months ago. It's sort of like stepping back in time. It looks ordinary from the outside, but inside you find friendly staff and homemade pies, cakes, and meals. After I ate here for several months i I convinced my husband to give it a try. We live in Berthoud and we are both very picky eaters. It's difficult for us to find a restaurant that we both like, but we both enjoy good food, a good atmosphere (mostly that's me), great service, a clean restaurant, good prices, good music in the background (again, that's me), a good variety on the menu to choose from, and my husband especially likes large quantities of food as he's a big man with a giant appetite. Good Fellas checked all of the above boxes for us both! A rare and special find for us ! We are now going there every week for dinner, sometimes twice. Their spaghetti is the best I've ever found since childhood (and I'm now 61 and have tried every Italian restaurant I could all throughout adulthood. It's literally phenomenal. We both highly recommend this restaurant if you like a large variety of food to choose from, good prices, large quantities, great service, and great music. read more

Food was delicious, I had the rellenos and eggs and my wife had a burger, and the staff was fast and friendly

We've been here for both breakfast and dinner and never had a bad meal! We will definitely be back. This is a must visit if you're in the Longmont area! read more