I'd put Grace Pizza and Shakes in the 5-star tier. It has a strong enough overall impression to feel like a clear favorite. This is one I'd be glad to choose again. read more

It's located right in downtown Papillion, which is one of my favorite areas to walk around. There is plenty of parking nearby, making it easy to visit. We recently stopped in for dinner because we were in the area walking around. The restaurant was clean and it wasn't busy so the wait staff was friendly and attentive. We started with the cheesy garlic bread, and it was excellent. The drink selection is decent and I enjoyed a nice glass of wine with dinner. I do wish they offered a few more local beers on tap, but there were still plenty of options to choose from. Prices seemed pretty average and about what I would expect for a local pizza place. As for the pizza, the results were mixed. I'm a huge fan of Margherita pizza, but this version missed the mark for me. It had far too much sauce, large chunks of garlic that overpowered the other flavors, and very little basil. The balance just wasn't there. On the other hand, we also ordered a meat pizza, and it was much better It's just okay for me. I feel like we have much better options in the area for good pizza. read more

See all

I've been coming to Grace's since they first opened and have always tried to give them the benefit of the doubt, but lately the experience has gone downhill significantly. When we came in for lunch, there was only one other table seated, yet it took over an hour for our two appetizers to come out. During that time, nobody checked on us or even asked if we needed anything. After sitting there for an hour with only water, we finally had to ask to order drinks and our pizza. There was absolutely no sense of urgency whatsoever, and honestly we felt completely forgotten about the entire visit. Unfortunately, when the pizza finally arrived, it was overcooked -- and sadly this isn't the first time this has happened with both the pizza and garlic knots. Every visit lately has been disappointing, and I kept hoping it was just an off day, but it seems to be getting worse each time. To top it all off, after we finished eating, we waited another 20-25 minutes just to get the check. I eventually had to get up myself and ask the employee sitting at the bar on his phone and laptop for our bill. It's honestly sad because this used to be one of my favorite places. I used to rave about Grace's and recommend it to my friends and members on my food page all the time, but now it feels like every time I go, the experience is worse than the last. Definitely just not happy overall. read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Burnt Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

See all

The whipped ricotta appetizer was sizable and perfect amount of sweet and savory but be warned of the giant baked garlic cloves in! It was a bit of a surprise biting into it. The pizza menu is pretty extensive. We got the haiwaiin and a spicy one with all meat. The toppings themselves were good, but both pizzas had a LOT of crust- it seemed almost half of the surface area. Overall it was a good stop and I'd go back if I was in the area. read more

Will definitely be back! We started with thick and cheesy beer cheese soup with roast pieces; rich with a very light beer taste. Our main course was the Sweet Perfection pizza. The crust is great--a slightly crisp outside with fluffy inside. The atmosphere is trendy but clean and comfortable and service was attentive. A neighboring table got one of the shakes with sweet on top (piece of cake, cinnamon roll, etc...). We didn't have one but looked tasty! read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Sweet Perfection - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

Had Grace for first time tonight. Very solid. 4.5 out of 5 stars. Service was fantastic . Attentive and friendly. Food didn't take long and they were pretty busy. We had the Pattons pepperoni and a custom pie with Italian sausage, mushrooms and bell peppers. Loved the jalapeño ranch for didn't the crust. The crazy cheese bread is essentially a cheese pizza lol. But also very good. Will be back for sure. read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Italian sausage, mushrooms and bell peppers - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

See all

This is now going to be our go to special pizza night! Grace Pizza is such a hidden gem on the back side of downtown Papillon. Yes parking is going to take two extra minutes to find, but it is worth it! While the restaurant is small, the atmosphere is so warm and inviting. The service was excellent! The entire staff was kind and friendly. Don't skip the appetizers!!! read more

See all

The place was so packed the first time I went! We were able to get seating at the bar pretty quickly! The pizza was Delicious and the crust was crunchy and very just the way I like it! I was not a fan of the meatballs it was more of a texture thing for me! We got a milkshake and it wasn't as sweet as I thought it would be! Second time I went we were able to get a table quite fast! The pizza we got was my Favorite it was a little spicy and I enjoyed that! read more

See all

Great option if you're craving for Pizza! Highly recommend the Green Goddess and the whipped honey ricotta! The BBQ yard bird....not much. And the Supreme Grace was OK. The service was good, but the place can get busy so wait times may be longer. read more

See all

Food: Delicious, fresh, authentic. Service: Bartender Gavin very accommodating and friendly. Ambiance: nice seating selection from indoor bar stool, booth ans table to outdoor umbrella tables (for to go orders) So glad we found this amazing foodie spot in little downtown Papillion. Look forward to returning to try each item on the menu. Tonight's selections of Waygu meatballs, mixed green salad with feta and pepperoni/mushroom pizza were absolutely delicious. Great environment and cool vibe. Make the trip...ots worth it!! read more

See all

I went to Grace with a large group of friends. The service was fast and attentive. The restaurant looked nice and clean. The music did seem to get louder the longer we were there. The food looked good. My son enjoyed his Yard Bird pizza. I ordered the Randolph Calzone. I ended up receiving the Mediterranean Greek calzone. Not sure if mine got mixed up with someone else's order but I ended up eating it anyway. I wish I would have said something but they were busy so I didn't. I was looking forward to eating there for the first time but I was pretty disappointed by what I got. I also thought the bill was high for what we ordered. read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Yard Bird pizza - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

See all

Grace Pizza & Shakes in downtown Papillion now serves brunch on sundays from 11am-3pm and you have got to check it out!!!! breakfast pizzas, calzones, pizza rolls, & cocktails. their regular menu is also still available during brunch. my personal fav brunch item was the breakfast wagon pizza. I also love a good mimosa or tequila sunrise too. super fun option for Sunday brunch! read more

Ambiance and was great, cozy and modern feel. The drink and pizza were delicious. The waygu meatball and ricotta were a first for me on a pizza and I was happily surprised with the taste. read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Supreme Grace Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

See all

We LOVED Grace! The pizza was amazing, the stone oven crust was crispy and the pizza had tons of toppings and really interesting combinations you wouldn't typically see! The shakes were also delicious such a fun treat but they are pretty much icecream and very sweet so be prepared I do wish we hadn't gotten ours to go because they looked so cool on other tables when they were made in house! Cute environment and good service! read more

See all

Pizzas came out quick, although the place was packed and very busy. They had different varieties of pizza to choose from and you can add additional toppings. Parking was a little difficult to find due to how busy it was and we went on a Wednesday. The pizzas were good, but i wouldn't recommend to get the pasta Mediterranean - very bland, no flavor at all. Fun atmosphere! read more

See all

Super cool pizza place, fancy but casual. Great service from the servers and wait staff. Everything was delicious as you can see my husband enjoy my son's leftover shake. The only thing is, I think they must've forgotten my son fettuccine because it came out as we finished lunch. We have been here for at least an hour and the waitress did let us know and apologized. read more

See all

We ordered some garlic knots with marinara as an appetizer and I would recommend them. We also ordered a few pizzas. My daughter loved her cheese pizza and I took some of the melted cheese from her pizza and added it to mine. I didn't carefully read what I ordered and didn't realize feta was the only cheese on it and I asked for no feta. I think my pizza was overcooked and the cauliflower crust was hard. I like well done crusts so I didn't mind. I may go back to try the pasta dishes. No kids menu but our server mentioned two kids items. I think one was a fettuccine Alfredo. No kids drinks and we paid $3.50 for a kid drink. Service was great and ambience is nice. They have big tvs so I could be fun during football season. It is a small restaurant inside but there's some room outside. read more

See all

This is a tiny little spot in downtown Papillion. There's several seats at the bar, a large booth, and a few tables. It can definitely fill up fast! During lunch time on a weekend, it was fully packed. But we didn't have to wait more than a few minutes for a table. It can be quite loud inside. Its got a casual modern warehouse vibe. The menu offers a lot of appetizers, various pizzas, pastas, and more. So it's a lot more than just pizza and shakes. But with pizza in the name, we had to go for pizza. We each ordered a pizza for ourselves. They are big enough to share. I took home half my pizza. Many of the pizza creations were tempting! Especially those outside of the norm. I finally settled on the La Grande Vita. Wagyu meatballs, jalapenos, etc. It was crazy delicious. And it was just as good the next day. The pizzas are perfectly cooked. The crust is fabulous. And they offer sides of dipping sauces (like a jalapeno ranch). Our server was attentive and friendly. But it was difficult for him to hear us and us to hear him due to the noise level. All in all, great food and a good time was had! read more

See all

Our third time here, every time seems to be better than that last. We sat at the bar and the service was great. We both had Spicy Margaritas, they were well made with a good amount of spice. Started with the Whipped Honey Riccota, very creamy with a nice kick and sweetness from the honey. For pizza had the Supreme Grace, loaded with topping and flavor. Pepparoni, Italian Sausage, Wagyu Meatball, and Bacon with Basil and. Ranch Swirl. I don't know how many times I said "this is delicious." Wow! Don't be deterred by the wait times, they go fast. Definitely recommend! read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

I think Graces will be really good for Papillion. While we weren't necessarily impressed, both couples sitting beside us were raving about it. It was quick service and packed. We really enjoyed the crust on the pizza but both our pizzas of Margherita, and the Ranch Meat Wagon fell a little short. With it just opening, I'm not sure if they're going to be getting a drink menu but I hope they do. Overall, I wouldn't say it's disappointing or bad just underwhelming. read more

See all

A delightful new addition to downtown Papillion. Located off the main drag behind the Twisted Vine. Modern vibe with dark accents. Bar seating available for approximately 14 and another 10 or so tables in the main dining area. Not an overly large restaurant - fills up fast. We sat at the bar. Bartender was very engaging and informative. Menu has pizza, pasta, salads, and sandwiches along with a selection of appetizers. Started with the Spinach Dip. It was served with fresh baked flat bread. Dip was cheesy and delicious and the flat bread had a lot of garlic (tasty). Wife got one of the brick oven pizzas. Pizza's are approximately 12 inches and 6 slices. Went with Ashlyn's Art which is a cauliflower crust, sauce, feta, spinach, red onions, roasted garlic, roasted peppers, fresh basil and balsamic glaze. It was good, but she would have liked to have a bit more cheese on the pizza. I went with the Mike and Jen pasta dish. It consists of bow tie pasta, grilled chicken, garlic, mushrooms, sun dried tomatoes, capers, and romano cream sauce. It was absolutely delicious. Got the opportunity to meet one of the owners; Anna. She was a delight to speak with. Staff friendly. Prices are a bit higher, but worth it. Definitely worth a visit and makes for a good date night. Check it out. read more

See all

We had an amazing time at Grace Pizza and Shakes! Everything we tried was delicious, and the experience was full of fun and flavor. We started with the Illegal Cheese Bread--and wow, it lives up to the name! The ricotta had this Alfredo-like richness that made it absolutely addictive. Highly recommend. I had the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, and it was easily one of the best versions I've had. The blue cheese crumbles and perfectly balanced swirl of buffalo sauce really set it apart. The portion was huge--easily shareable, though I'm not mad about having leftovers. For dessert, I went with a Brownie Shake (subbed vanilla ice cream for chocolate). It came with an entire brownie on top, which slowly sank into the shake while I tried to eat around it--pro tip: remove the topping like my partner did with his Celebration Shake. Still tasty, just a little chaotic! My partner got the Heat Wave and was obsessed with the generous helping of meat and the hot honey drizzle. A friend ordered her go-to Mediterranean Calzone, which was a bit overdone this time. She opted not to wait for a remake since they were slammed--but she's a regular, so clearly it's usually a hit. We spent around $80 for my partner and me, with plenty of leftovers. Totally worth it for the portion sizes and quality, we could have shared most of what we ordered. Service was top-notch--everyone we interacted with was friendly and welcoming. We waited about an hour to be seated, but communication with the host stand was great and the shaded outdoor tables made the wait enjoyable. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

The food is good but didnt WOW me. The service was very nice. Unfortunately, it was really slow. Maybe they were under staffed so I would definitely try them again but my first visit wasn't amazing. read more

Tried Grace Pizza in Papillion and had a great experience! The pizza was solid, with plenty of good flavor. The white pizza was likely my favorite--rich and delicious, though I do wish the toppings had been distributed a bit more evenly. The Caesar salad was fresh and tasty, though a little light on the dressing for my preference. I really appreciated that it was packed separately from the hot food, preventing the lettuce from wilting--something most places don't do anymore! The meatballs were pretty good, though I was expecting a bit more from them. The pepperoni roll was very good, and the calzone was absolutely packed--definitely not lacking in filling! Overall, a solid spot with thoughtful presentation. I'd certainly return! read more

See all

Place is so cute in old Papillion area! Kind of small but still a lot of seating. Right when you walk in you can see some of the kitchen window and them making the pizzas. The salad dressing for the Caesar salad was delicious and perfectly portioned. We also got the heat wave pizza and those peppers were spicy!! For the spicy lovers for sure. Perfect crust and super filling. The bolognese wasn't my favorite sauce but the noodles were perfectly cooked. read more

See all

Online ordering was easy. Their cauliflower crust is gluten free, I got the Ashlyn's Art and I added Italian sausage. It was delicious. I normally go for plain boring pizzas but I wanted something "fancier" this time, and this hit the spot. I did add a side of their butter too, I'm not even sure if it's a garlic butter but with the cauliflower crust being pretty thin, the melted butter made the edges perfect. read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Ashlyn's Art gluten free cauliflower crust - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

See all

This place is a must to visit! Let me warn you tho- you will become a regular after first visit. The experience was wonderful. Atmosphere, staff, food options, and more went above and beyond what I was expecting. I have heard good things so went last night. It was almost closing time and I didn't exp to be able to order, however they welcomed us in and took great care of us with no rush and no problem accommodating us. The staff were wonderful and helpful/cheerful and the food was beyond what words can say. Outstanding quality and options for sure! I recommend the Greek gyro pizza which was so light and perfectly balanced that it was hard to eat the whole thing! Portions are a good size so be careful not to over-indulge! I didn't get dessert but I saw a milkshake that looked amazing! We will definitely be back often and I hope to see y'all there! read more

GREAT pizza. Crust is the perfect thickness-Cauliflower crust option also. I didn't get a chance to try the shakes but they looked amazing. Inside is small but has a good atmosphere. read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Triple pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

Second visit and just as awesome as the first. Garlic knots are delicious and will keep vampires away lol. One size pizza fits all. You can do half and half if the base sauce is the same on both halves. We had Margarita and pepperoni. The crust is light and airy and crisp -so so delicious! Again no room for dessert, sad. Next time maybe just apps and dessert. Waiter was good. It was lunchtime and they weren't too busy, we got seated right away. It's comfortable and casual! Enjoy! read more

See all

Great place! We got seated at the bar and we served pretty soon after that. The staff was very friendly. Though the place was packed our food didn't take too long to come out. I didn't give them a 5 stars only because the meatballs came out a little cold and weren't our favorite but we loved the pizza and the milkshake was so so good and not too sweet. It's a chill family friendly place and I would definitely come back! I tried the heat wave pizza and my friend tried their version of a meat lovers. read more

See all

Yesterday, my wife, my father-in-law, and I came in for lunch with reasonable expectations and functioning taste buds. What we got instead was 1 1/2 hours of a suspense film titled "Will the Food Ever Be Warm?" Spoiler: it was not. Item by item, because this receipt earned it: Grace-Roni Rolls - Cold. Not "could be warmer." Cold. Dr Pepper (x2) - Cold. Correct Regular Lemonade - Cold. Correct Half The Meat-A-Baller Pizza - Cold. Bold name, zero follow-through. Half Adrian's Art (no ricotta) - Cold. The only art was how fast it cooled. Patton's Pepperoni Pizza - Cold. So cold it felt intentional. Side of Hot Honey - Cold. A literal contradiction. Not to mention I think was literally just honey, no heat whatsoever. Beer Cheese Soup (2 cups) - Did not resemble beer cheese soup in look or taste. It looked like Italian meatball soup and had no detectable cheese flavor. Just confusion in a bowl. Service didn't help. Took the appetizer 45 minutes, part of the food 20 minutes after that, sauce sides about 10 minutes after that, and the food temperature still cold. Time to get our server's attention was about 10-15 minutes each time You weren't slammed. You weren't busy. You were just slow, like urgency called in sick and never came back. This was easily the worst visit I've had here since you opened. I wanted it to be good. Instead, I paid $79 for cold food, long waits, and soup with an identity crisis. I'm not angry, I'm not yelling, I'm just deeply disappointed with my experience. read more

Inadequate parking. No atmosphere. Absorbent pricing. Much better pasta at the Olive Garden. Average Pizza. Can you believe a $20 Shake?

Have been to Grace's this will be the fourth time now. The first time we took our 6.5 lb miniature Poodle and Maltese mix. He is a very well behaved boy. He is my spouses therapy/service dog for anxiety. Most times he has a service dog tag which also causes the wife anxiety because she thinks people are judging her for having a service animal. He travels with her in a purse, not on aa leash. So it's not like he is running around Most people don't even know he is there. Anyway we were grilled about if the dog was a service dog which he clearly was. Why the 20 questions. You should not do that. The food and pizza were good. we left with no further incident. Second visit, same situation, not one question about the dog in the purse. Good food shakes were amazing. Third visit, again with the 20 questions, and we were told if the dog was a pet that we could be seated on the patio or at the tables out front. We said we wanted to sit inside as was required by the ADA. They acquiesced. So the fourth time, tonight, we returned with intentions to go straight to the patio and were told that the patio has been closed by the city because there was an "unsafe" situation with a fence and the tables out front of the restaurant were owned by the city on city property and they could not serve us there but that we could get the food to go and sit there. They "just couldn't wait on us there". This was told to us by what appeared to be a 14 year old hostess. Again started the 20 questions about the service dog. We left and went to SPIN PIZZA on 84th St. and Highway 370, Great pizza, nice patio, no questions about the dog at all, great service and even brought a bowl of water and a slice of bacon for him. read more

They need to charge a different price for their to go shakes. I've gotten these shakes to go elsewhere, so I know it's doable. But if you can't pull it off at least charge less when you're delivering so much less. Kids were really disappointed. They've lost me after this. read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - $12 Oreo milkshake - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

See all

Grace's Pizza and Shakes is one of those rare places that instantly feels like home. It's more than a restaurant--it's a warm, joyful experience from the moment you walk in. The food? Consistently incredible. The Supreme Grace, their signature pizza, is everything a pizza should be--crispy crust, perfectly balanced toppings, and bold flavor in every bite. I've also tasted the Buffalo Chicken, BBQ Brisket, and Margherita--each uniquely satisfying, clearly made with heart. Their appetizers set the tone beautifully. I'm especially fond of the Garlic Cheese Bread, Fried Ravioli, and Truffle Parmesan Fries. Each bite invites connection--perfect for sharing over good conversation. And the shakes? Playful, over-the-top, and impossible not to smile about. Whether you're treating yourself or celebrating something small, they make the moment feel special. If you're searching for the best pizza in Omaha and a place that genuinely values people and flavor, Grace's Pizza and Shakes is it. Where great food and good vibes come standard. read more

Food is really good, but if you don't have a table reserved be prepared for some sh!tty service! Also it's a little on the pricey side. It took forever to get waited on. I will give her some grace though they had her waiting tables and serving a full bar. If I eat here again it'll def be to go. That's a strong if tho read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

See all

We went crazy and got a pizza, their special macaroni, and brisket melt, AND cinnamon shake. Surprisingly the pizza was my least favorite but it was still good, we got the Sweet Perfection i think? It was just too sweet for my taste but the crust was made very well. You have to get a shake when you go, they're insanely delicious. All the staff is extremely friendly and attentive as well read more

The Sweet Perfection is just that, Perfection...minus the peppers since they don't sit well with me! The combination of toppings is amazing! Service was great and there was no waiting on a Monday night! read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Sweet Perfection minus peppers - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

Wow! This place is AWESOME! We tried a lot of things and loved it all! Pizzas were the best wood fired we've had in a while and even the Cauliflower Crust was amazing! Service was top notch and the space itself is really cool. What a great addition to downtown Papillion! read more

Grace Pizza and Shakes - Pizza Near Me - Papillion, Nebraska

I've been here once and thought it was pretty good. A little tight inside but food was tasty. Recently got take out and they forgot the pineapple on the Hawaiian pizza. Silverware for the salads. And I don't know if the chicken was supposed to be cold on the salad but it was if it's not. Other than that everything els seemed to be okay. Just sad they forgot the main part of a Hawaiian pizza. read more