Little on the pricey side, but they have good food and good people and plenty of seating room if…read moreyou wanted. Makes a makes a good pizza.

First off, pretty much a perfect slice, although smaller than most, priced at $2.50…read more Tonight, I was perusing their current takeout menu, comparing their Shrimp Parm hero price to Mountainview. The menu claimed $11.50. I also ordered 3 slices, 1 with sausage( menu claimed $2.75). $19.50, became $22.50( why bother printing paper menus if you can't honor or pen-in changes)? There were 3 tissue-thin sausage slices. The shrimp were large(4), but not properly fried to create a sufficient crust to handle sauce...it was wet mush and the hero roll was meh, not fresh for a Friday night. At 5:45, only the owner's friends were there, empty dining room...meanwhile, I picked something up at Mountainview-packed ! Will stick to the occasional slice(s), as that was not a $14 hero value.

Village has delicious pizza and generous family specials. The garlic knots are pretty top tier.read more

Best pizza around and it's not even close. If I'm anywhere within 15…read moreMin of it I driver there

four stars. slice was fine , low 7s,(see below) but the…read morechicken parm made up for it, I enjoyed both for a split meal. service was nice, no issues overall. would put them on the options list while in town. this review is like the pizzaslice : fine, gets the job done, pointy

After scanning through Pecorinos food photos I knew their pizza was going to be great. We only had…read moretime for a couple slices and they did not disappoint. There's personally nothing worse than overly saucy pizza with the cheese falling off. This was equal part cheese and sauce. Can't wait to go back and try their pasta.

Food/Drink: Pizza by the slice! Pretty good New York style pizza. Large amount of options and…read morecombos. Full Italian style menu, appetizers, entrees, pizza, soups, salads, and desserts! Pizza: Needed more crunch and little doughy. Dinning Area: Pretty large, open, area. Benches, large counter, double closed off entry way so mo breeze. Plenty of seating! Prices: Relatively cheap. 2 slice and fountain special for $12.95! Parking: Plenty of space, side lot. Bathrooms: Bathrooms were clean and regular size. Atmosphere: During the weekday lunch rush, It was empty. Staff/Attendants: Staff overall was great, and sociable. Been a few times and will return.

Grabbed a menu and was not rushed to make decision and the counter person was pretty friendly. My…read moreorder did seem to take bit longer then I would thought. The pizza slice was great, plenty of pepperoni coverage and sauce and cheese melted well, plus the crust was not burnt, but I will say the slice itself was pretty greasy. Now the panini the bread was well pressed and toasted, plus plenty of cheese, chicken and thousands island dressing, but fries on side, were a salt bomb, I mean they seasoned alright, but way too much salt on them, I had throw them out. Otherwise I mean great beside that. Now the Nutella knots, I loved those, knots cut in half and spooned on Nutella on them like little chocolate dough sliders with powdered sugar on top.

My favorite meatball parm is now crap. What is with the salt??? I could not finish my sandwich. It…read morewas so very salty. The person who took my order on the phone didn't speak enough English to understand what I wanted. They had to put someone else on the phone. In 3 months the place has gone straight to hell. I won't be back

All I really wanted was a good piece of pizza so I jumped on Yelp to find what was recommended…read morenearby. I was not disappointed with the grandma slice and regular pizza at all! The grandma was definitely my favorite, so I had to go back and get a second. What really put it over the top for me was the little bit of pesto diagonally drizzled on each slice. Yes. I had three slices and I'm not ashamed to admit it. Staff is great...and its laid-back pizza joint at the end of a mostly empty shopping center. I did notice plenty of takeout orders so the locals must know it's good, too.

The greatest deal in Middletown, the pizza is always delicious and I love talking with the owners…read morebecause they are so friendly and welcoming.

Love this place - husband and wife team work hard and produce such good food. Their entrees taste…read moresooo good.

The Pizza Beast is back for another round, and Cascarino's continues to deliver…read more When a place earns repeat visits year after year, that's usually the best review there is. The pizza still has that solid NY-style crunch, good flavor, and plenty of topping options. Whether grabbing a quick slice or ordering from the full menu, the food is consistently well-prepared and hits the mark. What really stands out is the consistency. The owner clearly takes pride in the operation, the kitchen stays on point, and the staff keeps things moving. It's not easy to maintain quality over time, but Cascarino's has managed to do exactly that. Pizza Beast Verdict: Still one of the most reliable pizza spots in the area. Great slices, solid menu, and a place I keep coming back to for a reason. Rating: 5/5 Beast Slices

We've recently just moved to the area and have been looking for a go to spot for deliciousness…read more We made the mistake of popping in last Friday (1st day of Lent) and ordered a few slices to go- that didn't go as planned... But, we've heard such great things about this place, so, we figured we'd give it another shot. Ordered a late lunch this afternoon- Clams were outstanding! Meatballs- yum! The garlic knots, though? They were spot on delicious and we literally inhaled them. Also had a couple of BYO chicken cutlet hero's- Excellent help over the phone and the delivery person was extremely pleasant and super polite. Can't wait to fall in love with this place!

Pineapple pizza is on my point, chicken bacon ranch is good. Phillies are decent, just an all…read morearound decent place for Wurtsboro

I mean I had it a few times not my fave. But I rather show my support to them than stellas across…read more209. The woman is nice, the man should not be dealing with the Public. I miss Andre being there.

Excellent food and service. We had a party of 5 and we were seated right away. The specials were…read moreall wonderful and the menu has a lot of options. Our group included some picky eaters and they were very happy. The space reminded me of the old school Italian restaurants. Our waitress was attentive and explained the menu perfectly. She even caught on that we were celebrating a birthday and arranged for the dessert to have a candle. We will definitely be back.

We recently tried out this charming little spot near our home. The food was fantastic with great…read moresized portions. The staff is so kind and welcoming. We wanted for nothing! The ricotta cheesecake was the. Eat I've had eating out! Mussels were delicious and the homemade bread was a treat! Highly recommend. We will be back to try their pizza for sure.

My family and I enjoy their pizza. Way better than mountain view's. The staff are also kind people!read more

This place is a hidden gem. For a Pizza place / Deli they go above and beyond. Daily specials that…read moreare always filled with enough food for two meals. They do pizza justice and their fried ravioli's are addicting. After reading some of the reviews you will notice some of the negative ones should be taken with a grain of salt and a raised eyebrow as 2 of them are from the same day and use the same phrases. Probably the same person using different screen names. The staff is always pleasant and the get your order ready quick.