On our way back from Binghamton we stopped here to meet a friend for dinner. A great spot to get to as it was two minutes off the hwy in a large shopping center with plenty of parking. We walked in to an extremely pleasant pizzeria / restaurant / bar and were very well greeted and seated. You can always tell the successfui local shops by the amount of regulars that are here and jow well the servers know the guests. A very comfortable cool-calming venue that just makes you feel comfortable. Our server came over quickly amd gave us a few minutes to speak amoung ourselves and eventually order. There were threee of us and I did have an opportunity to sample all plates. 1 - Personal pan meatball pizza - Excellent. Plenty of sauce and cheese with tasty meatballs on a thin crust 1 - Mozzarella and tomatoes - A sizable portion easy to share of tasty mozz and ripe juicy tomatoes 1- Mozzarella, tomatoes with fried calamari. - Another excellent dish of mozz and tomatoes with the addition of a crispy-tasty calamari All the folks sitting around our table enjoyed their meal. My friend lives up here and this is a local shop for them. If I'm in the neighborhood, I would definitely feel comfortable enough to return KUDOs to the team at Carlo's Cucina Restaurant read more

See all

This was my favorite local spot however I called the last Monday for catering pricing. The staff had no idea how to answer my questions and asked I call back. Sure thing, boss. So I called the next day and this staffer alluded to the catering pricing are changing but could not tell me in what direction or when. He told me to go online. Thank you, chief. Online mentioned nothing of the price change but you can submit an online contact request form. I have questions. I've sent in three contact requests and a week later - not call or email. Carlos has lost this catering bid and my business. read more

Carlo's Cucina Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Goshen, New York

Pizza isn't the best but Zeppoles are the bomb!! I'm always here for those tasty treats. read more

Carlo's Cucina Restaurant - Sausage slice - Italian Near Me - Goshen, New York

The good, nice interior, clean and bright. Friendly staff. Great place to get a reasobably priced Italian lunch/dinner in a comfortable setting. the bad, the pizza tastes like garlic oil is poured on it. The garlic is overwhelming. All I taste is garlic so pizza is a no go for me. I love garlic but not on my pizza when I didn't order garlic. The garlic bread is another example, there's so much jaric on the bread it has a spicy hot taste. Wow, throwing a ton of garlic on things doesn't make them better in fact it has the opposite effect. read more

Had the sausage and Spaghetti lunch_ was amazing, also calamari appetizer. Very Good all freshly made.

Nice place, nice atmosphere to spend time with friends and family , food is great too! read more

See all

The Gluten Free Eggplant Parmesan I paid close to $30 with tax and tip was inedible. The pasta wasn't cooked and it was 5 pieces of cold eggplant with no sauce . read more

See all

I have been to this location twice so far. I ordered the Christy chicken California both times and it was delicious!!!! You can tell everything is fresh! It is absolutely beautiful in the restaurant too, very trendy. Service was excellent both times. I'll definitely be back. read more

Being of Italian descent and growing up in Brooklyn I've been exposed to some of the best pizzas on earth. Moving to Orange County 15+ years ago my search for the perfect slice has been futile till now, Carlos Cuccina Restaurant in Goshen has ended my search THE Perfect Slice read more

I was in the mood for some buffalo wings so i ordered 8 hot wings here. It was good but the customer service was lacking. Although the staff member that took my order was nice, the kitchen staff kept looking at me awkwardly, they then placed my order on top of the oven without communicating to the front staff that the order was ready. I sat for an additional 15 min waiting for an order that was already ready. Talk about of communication. I asked the girl at the front desk"hey, would that happen to be my order?" And she checked and said yes. There was no apology or anything. Other than that, the place seemed cool. Also, it was very empty. I didn't try the pizza but from the looks of it, it seemed a bit old and dry. read more

Ordered three meals and two appetizers, and yet again, the order was missing items. I called mainly concerned about a side of grilled chicken( and garlic knots), and finally agree to remake after much confusion. I went to pick it up, there was no apology for the inconvenience, just rudeness and accusing me of trying to get a side of grilled chicken without paying. We eat or get take out from here regularly since they opened. I left the food there( after his nastiness I would be afraid he'd done something to it) and will never set foot in that place again. It would behove the manger to remember he is in a service business, as there are many other options and this is a small town. read more

I have had the pizza from Franks in Middletown behind Walmart as well as the Carlos' on Wawayanda Ave (all the same business) and this new location in Goshen. Always great pizza. The buffalo chicken, avacado/chicken, thai shrimp, chicken bacon ranch and Grandma slices are among my favorites. As far as entree's, which my wife and I have only had from the Goshen are great. Between the 2 of us, we have has the Shrimp Parmesan, Shrimp Fradiavlo and Penne A La Vodka dinners and they are absolutely fantastic. Whether Carlos' in Goshen or Middletown or Frank's in Middletown, you will enjoy your meal! read more

Best mojitos in town, happy hour is the time to go enjoy your wings and drinks. Never disappointed and the food and drinks always have a consistent flavor. read more

Carlo's Cucina Restaurant - Kiwi Mojito, hands down the best in the county I even dare say in the state!!! - Italian Near Me - Goshen, New York

Grab the barbecue chicken pizza for dinner and it was delicious. I would come here again.

Tried this place last week and was not disappointed. Pizza was delicious! Will definitely order food again

I had an eggplant parm hero delivered to my home. I was very disappointed. The bread was soggy and the eggplant seemed like it was cooked in a lot of oil. The next day I had an upset stomach. read more

Went there to eat at the restaurant and it was fine. Nothing special. Typical red sauce American Italian food. Ordered delivery of stuffed rigatoni with mozzarella and ricotta. They delivered stuffed shells which were not hot. Ok, they got one order wrong and delivered the rigatoni about a half hour later. Tonight we ordered the rigatoni with mozzarella and ricotta for takeout. When we brought it home, guess what, WRONG order again and again the food was not hot. They gave us baked ziti instead of the rigatoni. Once again, I called and about a half hour later the rigatoni was delivered. Twice is unacceptable. I will NEVER order from them again. The food isn't worth it. If they can't handle Friday night rush hour, they shouldn't be in the business. read more

Place is incredibly noisy! Service was okay...they are clearly new and need time to develop an understanding of service. Food was okay. I had the linguine with broccoli and red garlic sauce. The sauce was both tasty and really greasy. They served way too much sauce and not enough pasta. The garlic bread was dry and over cooked. The salad was pretty limp. Of course, being seated at the table 3 feet from the bathroom, probably didn't help my opinion of this restaurant read more

I wish I could give you a separate review for food- which is so delicious- and plentiful to bring home for the next day!! but the service was so disappointing :(. perhaps you may consider hiring extra help for the summer?! our party of 6 had 7 pm reservations- seated right away, but no one came to our table - by 7:20 my hubby went to front counter to nicely ask man in yellow shirt if we should consider going elsewhere, since they looked super busy! then by 7:35 my adult daughter went to front - to request 6 glasses of waters!! so not typical of this restaurant or Franks Rest in Middletown! we finally got a waitress to take our dinner/drinks order at 7:42pm!! hoping you can take measures to improve your service! again- your food is Delicios!!! read more

I don't know what happened tonight, 3/2/24 normally I would give a 5 star, not today, but my review will be fair regardless. I ordered over the phone and this was the first inkling of a problem. The girl (S) asked repeatedly what the order was, the phone connection was far from acceptable so we reviewed it a few times, finally, she had the order correct, and low and behold, it was NOT right. (Big surprise there). The Lasagna dinner was like a ball of cheese, and plain with no flavor, , the LIGHTLY toasted garlic bread was burnt and dry,(what happened to the butter and garlic?) and the Zeppolies looked like dough balls with sugar... I'm not sure what they were but they were heavy, they forgot a drink, no napkins and 1 small dressing for three salads. However, the Chicken Murphy dinner was great and the Meatball Parm dinner was plentyfully. For the money that was spent, it should have been better. I think we will stick to slices only from now on. read more

The food was very good and the service was great. We were there with a large group of family. The waitress was excellent and everything was great read more

Nice atmosphere and bar area. Food average at best. Ordered a chicken parm and spaghetti, it was ok and a wrap that was soggy and oily. A lot of pizza selection that looked good. Will most likely pass on food and stick to the pizza. read more

Horrible pizza. Many varieties done poorly very chain like quality. No concept of proportion of toppings just mushy pizza.

Highly recommend Carlos Cucina in Goshen,NY. The food is wonderful, they have gluten free options, their staff is very friendly and attentive, and the restaurant has a bright and welcoming atmosphere. read more

We love Carlos it has become our favorite pizza place in goshen. The wings are perfectly cooked and covered in just the right amount of sauce . Standard salad for a pizza place . There is so many selections of pizza that are all fantastic. We also got a meatball sub that wasn't for us , (meatballs felt dry and had too much of a parm taste) . We keep trying different dishes and are always happy with the our choices . read more

Like everyone else in Goshen, I was like 'oh great, what do we need, another pizza place? Well yes, we needed Carlo's!! Finally another option in the area for vegan cheese substitutes!! And it is DELICIOUS! My first visit to Carlo's I got a personal pie with vegan cheese and broccoli and I was a little disappointed that the broccoli was frozen but the pie was still delicious. Good sauce and perfect crust. Today I ordered a personal pie with vegan cheese and fresh spinach and basil and it's one of the best vegan pies I've ever had, even including vegan specialty pies in the city. Aside from some of the veggies being frozen and not fresh and the prices I have no complaints! I'd love to see some more vegan options (like vegan ricotta or meat substitutes) but 10/10 on the vegan pies! And the staff are all so kind and lovely and willing to accommodate special requests. Super stoked on this new spot!! read more