First experience with your restaurant and the food was awesome! We so loved the eggplant ricotta pizza! The flavor was smooth, toppings were plentiful, and the crust was yummy. When toast delivery sat with our pizza for over an hour literally, before delivering, we called the restaurant and they were extremely helpful in offering to making a fresh new one for us! As we left to go pick it up, the original one had just been placed outside our home cold and shriveled up. Great customer service in house, awesome attitudes and so helpful. Thankfully, we had a convection oven, and it warmed up beautifully and back to life lol! Awesome pizza! We will go into the restaurant next time to enjoy the ambiance and a warm, freshly made pizza : ). read more

Great pie. TERRIBLE delivery service. Been searching for a good pizza since moving to this area. Wow. This pie is the real deal. Delivery experience didn't ruin the warmed-up pie. read more

This is quickly become one of our favorite pizza places. Recently, we've been getting the Caesar pizza and classic cheese or pepperoni. We love the crust and the overall flavor of the pizza sauce. We haven't had a bad slice yet. read more

The perfect spot to get a slice of NY pizza in the area. I love coming here for a simple cheese pizza and garlic knots. Makes me feel like I'm in New York again! Thanks Grandmas, we can't wait to be back!! read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Cheese pizza - Desserts Near Me - Cumming, Georgia

Every employee was on a phone call. Spent $50 for a 14" pizza, a Caesar Salad, and 2 waters. Food was quick, pizza was terrible. Sweet tomato sauce, no cheese, under cooked toppings, and a greasy mess. Good thing was they had every seasoning available to make it taste somewhat descent. read more

Really wanted to like this place. It's walking distance and would save me a lot of headaches with the kids. I have tried it 3 times (relucantly this time due to snow). I will never return. First, I'm not sure what planet other reviewers are from but $24.95 for a plain cheese grandmas pizza (nearly $35 for supreme) is NOT "reasonably priced." It's insane. And, thats before a delivery AND seperate "service" fee. Second, the pizza is awful. I'm not a pizza snob. I just have a certain expectation of what a plain cheese pizza should look, feel and taste like. Never have I experienced such a disaster that wasn't trying to be different. Strangely, they make like 3 styles and they are all hard and oily. They don't claim artsy pizza. They claim NY style pizza. I'm not saying some people wont like it. I'm just saying they failed to make a pizza. I get the plain cheese because i have kids who prefer them plain and I feel like I have let them down. Oh, lets do a note on service. Today's "extra" experience: first order was messed up. Called but couldnt seem to communicate with them, took the hit and placed a second order. Now for a small plain neopolitan in the hopes my daughter would eat it. Apparently "contactless" delivery means they leave it on your doorstep in 30 degree temps with NO notification of delivery, no doorbell ring, nothing. Kid is crying, now starving as its been 2 hours (including the first delivery), and when we locate it, its frozen. I'm now $91.69 into this mistake and everyone is still hungry. read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - hard cheese on toast - Desserts Near Me - Cumming, Georgia

That was some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life. I love NY style pizza and this very well lived up to and exceeded expectations. Will be coming back for more very soon read more

This was the worst pizza I have ever tasted. Not only was the dough wet and greasy, the cheese and the ingredients slid right off when you picked up a slice. Grandma needs to retire! read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Desserts Near Me - Cumming, Georgia

We absolutely LOVE everything we have eaten at this restaurant! The pizza crust is delicious and their GF crust is, too. Their penne pasta with vodka sauce and meatballs is a must try. Even their rolls are just yummy! We have introduced several friends who are now hooked. SO GOOD!!!!! read more

I order from this place all the time on Uber eats! The pizzas are amazing!!. I always get the grandmas pie and they are beautiful. A little greasy but the sauce is amazing! If you have never tried a meatball pizza, I highly recommend it read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Grandma's Pie 1-Topping 16 Inches - Desserts Near Me - Cumming, Georgia

Mediocre at best. Ordered a New York style pizza, a Sicilian, and garlic rolls. The dough tasted old and the garlic rolls were burnt. Will not be eating here again. read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - a tray of buns and sauces - Desserts Near Me - Cumming, Georgia

Ordered pizza for pick up. It was a good size reasonably priced. The place was small but sufficient for service. Unfortunately, the sauce was on the sweeter side, husband did not like it at all. Sorry, for that, we won't be back. read more

Hand down the best pizza I've had in Cumming! Grandma's is a small family owned pizzeria with lots of options for pizzas, gelato, salads, and calzones. I did an online order for a large grandma's pie, which was $16 total and fresh out of the oven and being cut when I walked in at their given time. The slices were massive and the perfect amount of sauce, cheese, and an amazing crunchy thin crust. I can't wait to come back and try their other pies and also pick up some gelato too for dessert! read more

Might be the closest you get to a NY Neapolitan style pizza. I'm from New York, grew up eating 99cent slices with Brisk Iced/ Snapple Tea. The crust meat could be more cheesy and and slices should be 1/2 inch wider. I wanna fold them in halves. I ordered thru phone and was there within 12 minutes. Pizza was luke warm and definitely didn't taste fresh. I think Costco makes better $9 pizza I'm sorry but in Georgia Costco beats this place. It's good every once in a while but not real thing. read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Desserts Near Me - Cumming, Georgia

Food is incredible, perfect crust. Employees are polite, limited seating but I've never seen it particularly crowded. Overall one of the best pizza places in cumming. read more

I wasn't over fond of this style pizza but it did taste good. However I think they need more mature wait staff.

I'm from NJ originally and have not found a place here that reminds me of home till now! Pizza is absolutely amazing and delicious! They were quick to make the pizza, the timeframe for pick up was legit. And the location is nice and clean! 100% will be going again for pizza night read more

Great pizza! And it was ready for pick up on a Friday night in 20 minutes! I was very impressed! Definitely will order from Grandma's Pizza again! read more

Great pizzeria very nice people I order from them often. They have two places the other place is in Lawrenceville.

The grandma pie is THE BEST. We drive a distance just to get this pizza. Louie is a great host. Come here. You won't be disappointed.

Good flavor however my pizza was l ice cold Insulated delivery bag may be beneficial. read more

So far, the only pizza place in Georgia, allowed to use N.Y. in its name. Kind of a typical "hole in the wall" motifs. Everything is new, clean, well like I said, NY. Cooking and serving area wasn't an issue, there is just no table wiping going on. It does seem they want and rely heavily on take out. The dine in area is small. We sat at the window bar, facing the lot. NY style again. What is really like NY is the shakers on the table with Cheese,Pepper, Garlic Powder etc. Now we only had a Sicilian Pie and a large Caesar Salad. On the scale of quality with ten being best I ever had, both earned the same grade of 8.5. I lived in Brooklyn, Manhattan, Even Little Italy. I grew up with my Italian Immigrant Grandparents. I spent a good deal of time touring Italy on 2 occasions, sampling pizza along the way. I tell you this so you know 8.5, isn't t shabby. read more

Get the Grandma's Pie.. trust me! Best pizza in North suburbs. Always fresh ingredients, and friendly staff.

Great pizza!! They have it by the pie or by the slice. Now I'm a southern girl so I don't have the same credibility has my fellow New Yorkers but this pizza is so good and rivals any of the pizza joints I been to in NYC. Give it a try! read more

See all

The best Sicilian in Georgia. Fresh crust and great sauce. Most try! I'll try garlic knots next time I'm there but look great!

Wow wow wow FINALLY we found REAL NYC Pizza...only took 4 years after we got here from Queens NYC...Thank you guys...I almost feel like crying LOL!!! read more

My wife and I have been back to Grandma's and each time we have loved the pizza. The crust is cooked to order and the tomato sauce is EXCELLENT ! The sauce is not your average pizza sauce, the tomatoes are rich in flavor and compliment all the extra toppings. The garlic is added in just the right amount and the toppings are fresh and plentiful. The owner is very friendly and very attentive to our request. We love Grandma's! read more

Worst pizza I ever had. The cheese was not even melted. And pizza was completely wet with the buffalo sauce. read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - a slice of cheese pizza - Desserts Near Me - Cumming, Georgia

My husband and I were born and raised in New York city. We moved to GA 4 years ago and tried different pizza places but none came close to the pizza we missed. My sister and I were going to go to Zoes in Suwanee one day when the pizza owner next door called us over to introduce himself. He encouraged us to have pizza instead. We agreed. We were shocked. It was delicious. It is exactly like NY. Tonight my husband and I ordered from the cumming location. My very picky husband hands down agreed. It is the best pizza we ever had down here. The pizza place is small just like the ones in Queens NY. We found our new pizza place forever. It is authentic New York pizza for sure read more

The most bland pizza i've ever had. Crust tastes like cardboard. Do not waste your money. Also, The sign on their front door says they are keeping the restaurant safe & clean BUT the guy making the pizza has no mask on. Go somewhere else! read more

My wife and I have picked up pizza from here 4-5 times now, and we've been happy and impressed every time. The crust is crisp and flavorful. The sauce has the right amount of kick, and a true measure of a great pizza - a plain cheese pie is the best way to go. I also recommend their chicken wings, which are much better than you'd expect from a pizza place. The staff is also very friendly. read more

Just moved to the neighborhood. Pizza was good. We will be back. Tasty and hot; got my New York pizza fix in with Grandma's. Also ordered pasta and a salad and they were pretty tasty too. read more

Customer service wasn't so great (couldn't be bothered to look up and say hello) and the pizza was mediocre. Since they're a local business and not a big chain, I may give them another chance. Maybe their calzones and salads are better. read more

This is a genuine NY slice fo sho. Priced right and served with a smile (when you pick it up or have it delivered)

The grandmas pie is amazing and the dough here is delicious! Everytime we order we enjoy it.

As an authentic Chicagoan I am disappointed. The food was decent at best but doesn't taste like home. I gave it a shot cuz it was close by but it wasn't great read more

I stopped in hoping for a good slice of NY Pizza and was so surprised at how BAD the pizza was. I ordered a slice of the veggie pizza and the person who put it together basically gave me a slice of pizza with so many onions on it I couldn't eat it without removing the toppings to get the onions off. It was a slice of onion pizza. The toppings consisted of green pepper, onion, and tomatoes, so they clearly weren't familiar with their own menu and just winged it. Menu lists normal veggie pizza toppings. Overall, I've had much better frozen pizza. If you're looking for a good NY pizza, keep looking. So disappointed!! read more

I was looking for a authentic NY style Pizza and I found it is Granma's is the best I drove for 1 1/2 hrs and was worth it I always will come back read more

Incredible food. My husband and I have ordered from here a handful of times and we have yet to be disappointed. The white pizza and pinwheels are my favorite menu items. The cheese they use is amazing. This is definitely my favorite spot for pizza in the Cumming area. read more

I placed an order tonight and was told it would be ready in 20 minutes. After an hour and 20 minutes, I called to check on my order. As I was asking, I realized that I never told them this was supposed to be delivery. I apologized and said I would be there in a minute to pick it up. I walked in to pick it up and the young lady who I talked to apologized to me and handed me a bag. She said, "This is from Grandmas." I told her again that this was all my fault and we loved them. When I got home, I looked in the bag. It was a piece of their chocolate cake. read more