Stopped on my way back from a day of Erie fishing going back to Pittsburgh and this place has a…read morereal frank and shirleys feel had the steak sandwich so mf good actually

*Sunday's breakfast buffet is an excellent way to start the day. The food is delicious, kept hot…read moreand eggs are served to order. It Takes place on the 4th Sunday of each month. My husband and I dine here often. The staff are all incredibly friendly and welcoming, as well as efficient with service. We've never had a single issue nor complaint. The menu is very "American Family Diner" done right! The prices are very reasonable, you won't leave here hungry, nor with a giant hole in your pocketbook. 5 out of 5 stars

Havent had anything here I didn't like. Large variety of items on the menu including all day…read morebreakfast, delicious desserts, great coffee, stir fry, HUGE salads, and daily specials. Service is great and the vibe is casual

I have always had a great meal here at the West Middlesex Diner. Never had anything that was not…read moreperfectly cooked served hot, and just what I wanted. I recommend the country fried steak, get it with the chicken gravy. It is outstanding! The veg are seasoned and hot no matter what the veg of the day is. It's clean, bright, and if you are in the area, not to be missed. The service is great. The waitress was personable, good advice as to what to get that day or any day. I eat at the Middlesex Diner over the spots in Sharon when I'm in the area. You should too!

Stopped in for a little sweet treat since we have never been here before. Comfortable booth with a…read morerelaxed, diner type atmosphere. Service was excellent. Dan was our waiter and was polite and knowledgeable. We had the cheesecake with strawberry topping and coconut cream pie. Cheesecake was the winner.

I love this restaurant. Whether I get a meal or just stop in for a cup of coffee with friends, we…read moreare greeted with a smile. The food is wonderful, very reasonably price and we have never met anyone that didn't give their all! It feels like sitting at mom's. Just walking in makes me smile.

Updating the review to include pictures. The food is still just as great! They accommodate changes…read moreto the menu. My kids wanted chocolate chip pancakes instead of the sprinkle pancakes listed. I think the bacon is a little too thick cut for little kids. They usually love bacon but didn't like this type. The Nashville Hot Sandwich had a smokier taste than Buffalo.

This is the easiest review I will ever write -it doesn't matter what you order here- it will not…read moredisappoint. When we come into town, this is our spot. The interior is inviting and makes for THE place to meet up but the food does all the talk'n. Check out everything they did right this time ..in my pics. My favorite (not pictured) was the brown sugared bacon waffles with homemade whip cream. It didn't even need syrup . I usually can't eat more than a few bites of sweet breakfast dishes ... this is one of the few exceptions. Can't wait to come back!

Local Gem with a Killer Breakfast Menu…read more This spot is a true local favorite, and for good reason. They serve a delicious breakfast with tons of options. Their famous cinnamon flip and flip potatoes are must-try sides. I had the crab and eggs dish and I'm hooked, huge portion, super tasty, and priced right. It does get really busy during peak hours, so expect a wait, but it's totally worth it.

4/19/25 Ate List: The…read moreRon Swanson - 8.2 The concept alone had me VERY intrigued - a cornbread pancake?!? Sold. Stuffed with Ham & Bacon. Topped with two eggs. This dish is meant for those brave enough to try it. And if the flavors sound appetizing then you will certainly be rewarded. I say this is for the brave because this dish feels HEAVY. Not a "drowning" sort of heavy but this plate in it's entirety adds up. Definitely coming back. Every dish coming to the tables around us looked amazing.

Checked this diner out, this past Sunday, well in town visiting my late adopted grandma Ann,…read moredaughter in law. She suggested we stop there as the food was excellent. The atmosphere and vive were your retro, back in time that diners bring. The service was fast, and food was excellent. Their was even metal artwork on the wall, red & white checkered pattern, and menu items, had the 60s theme. Highly recommend this local business, if your looking for some place different, and I look forward next time, I'm in town getting one of their milkshakes. What's a visit to a diner, without a milkshake???

I ventured out to Hermitage, PA for another one of my food road trips. I've known Donna for well…read moreover 17 years, but I never ordered a dish at her little pride and joy before. I paid a visit to enjoy one of her classic Donna Burgers. The Avocado turned the patty sinful with the creamy filling it boasted, and the chips were about as crispy as they come. The ambience acts as a functioning time machine, except the prices were stuck in present day. I was disappointed after receiving such great service, because I had to return to reality immediately. I'll be back after I share my ideas with Doc so we can finally pay 1950s prices for real. The bathroom was freezing.

Great experience all around! The staff was incredibly kind and welcoming and did an amazing job…read moreaccommodating our large group of 50+ swimmers after a meet. Everything was organized ahead of time, and they were extremely accommodating with various dietary needs, and so the whole dinner ran smoothly and stress-free. They were patient, friendly, and handled such a big group with ease, which we really appreciated. The food was very tasty and everyone got something they liked! Awesome local family spot that is worth the stop! Would definitely recommend!

Been there about three times every time I get to Grove City if it's around lunch or supper time. I…read moreeat there and I've never had a bad meal. Good food

The food here was delicious the fried chicken on my Cordon Bleu sandwich was perfection. The…read moresandwich had well balanced flavors and the fair fries were crispy deliciousness. Spouse had a Monte Cristo that she loved. Menu has a great variety for breakfast and lunch. Service was quick and the server checked back multiple times without being overwhelming. Can't wait to go back.

Amazing food! Everything we ordered was awesome. We will be going back if we're ever in that area…read moreagain.