Food was amazing... made to order such variety... the service was stellar too owner operated gave lots of options... chill vibe no adult bevies though read more

We ended up eating here purely by accident. The place where we planned to eat didn't have a chef, so we took off walking to find a different place to try instead of repeating some place we've already been. I suppose everything happens for a reason, because I can't begin to tell you how many times I've walked by this place and just chalked it up as "just grilled cheese". After all, we can all make this...right? Well, let me tell you...NO! I don't know what kind of unicorn magic they put in that sandwich, but it wasn't in site long enough to identify before it disappeared...simply magical! Up front, the décor inside and out is cute and fun...and definitely different from anything else in St. Augustine. I like how they have reused a church pew and chairs and given them life again. The crew working the day we went was Skylar & Michelle. The service was simply impeccable! It is one of those places where you place your order and pay at the counter (which I'm normally not a fan of), but they take care of the rest and then some. They certainly don't forget about you once you get your food. I got The Duchess...which was lobster, 4 cheeses, with spices on artisan white with a dipper of tomato soup. Oh My Goodness...it was absolutely delicious!!! Skylar (the chef) must be part unicorn himself because that sandwich was magical! My son had the Mondial, which included prosciutto, mozzarella, and fig...amazing! Sandwiches do not come with a side and must be ordered separately. The dipper that comes with the sandwich is not a side, nor sample, but a "dipper". You use the dipper to dip your sandwich and it's just the right amount for doing so. They do offer a few sides, salads, soups, & desserts. My friend and I ordered the fries to share and this is the only thing we weren't impressed with. For being sea salt fries...they lacked in the salt department and once they cooled...nope...but certainly not a reason to ding a star. Maybe they would have been better with some of that poutine gravy...hmmm? There's a thought! They have most of the typical drinks and I forget what off brand they carry, but they have fresh raspberry hibiscus tea! It is not sweet and it is good without sweetener, but I do like it sweet. Michelle was kind enough to bring me a cup of hot water and sugar to make simple syrup...perfect!!! Thanks for everything Skylar & Michelle! We are already talking about going back...curiosity has the best of us and we want to try a few more sandwiches. For anyone else reading this...I highly recommend this place. If you visit St Augustine for the first time or often and are looking for something different or "new to you"...then give this place a go! End note: They offer a veteran/uniformed discount with proof of ID...WOO HOO! Awesomeness! Thank you for this! read more

See all

The food and service were fantastic! Definitely recommend. Great ambience! My 6 year old daughter danced while she ate her grilled cheese.

Came for the gluten free bread and got the grilled chicken instead of crispy. Fabulous! Comes with a condiment cup of soup for dipping but I recommend getting more. Soup is amazing! read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - Was too hungry to take "before" photo - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Really cool concept. In the heart of St Augustine, we found this gem walking by, the unicorn caught my daughters eye so we stopped & read the menu. The grilled cheese was cooked perfectly and the menu has a wide variety. There are 4 locations, one in Cape Cod all owned by the same person. The very friendly & helpful woman behind the counter is the owners mother, she told us that this place opened about one year ago. We wish it well! read more

See all

The food was absolutely delicious!! I would definitely come back Also the service was great! read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - This was absolutely delicious!! Food was fantastic, would % come back - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Walking in the music was amazing and there was a cute, quaint vibe to it. You go up to order and there were so many good options to choose from. The food came out in a timely manner. Grilled cheese comes served with small serving of soup and a little cup of some kind of mayo mix. It was a delicious, faster food option. read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - The Southern Belle Sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Surprisingly fun comfort food. Who doesn't love a grilled cheese sandwich? Clever serving arrangement where the sandwich drips into a small serving of tomato soup (which is also good). Several varieties of sandwich to choose from and the price won't break the bank. Thumbs up. read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - Interior - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

We tried The Duchess and The Country Boy grilled cheese sandwiches today. They tasted great and hit the spot! The Duchess tasted like a fancy-shmanshy tuna- melt. Our favorite of the two was The County Boy. The mac n cheese in it was creamy with just enough BBQ pork. The sauce had a good taste too. The staff was friendly. There was plenty of seating, but I wasn't crazy about look/decor. Maybe I expected it to be a more whimsical with the unicorn and all. Overall, we had pleasant experience. read more

See all

This place is a total vibe! The staff is awesome and the service is great. Really small space but the food is amazing. If you're a fan of grilled cheese you're in for a treat! read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - A Night in Amsterdam Sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

The food was amazing and the service from Nancy and Shah can't be over stated! Two of the most genuine people who want to ensure that you have the best experience is amazing to see. My wife had Celiacs and they were very attentive and accommodating. We would most definitely recommend visiting! Just to add one more thing, our 16 year old son said the playlist was "hittin ands epic"! read more

amazing!!!!! Wanted to try one of everything. From northern Maine and these poutines put all the French Acadian ones to shame!

Amazing options of grilled cheese sandwiches to choose from. Their poutine is amazing. I would highly recommend this restaurant.

Decided to stop in here with my best friend while we were visiting St. Augustine last year. I cannot tell you how much I loved the food! The grilled cheese was AMAZING! The poutine fries were delicious and the tomato soup...chef's kiss! I can't wait to go back with my sister next month when we visit for a getaway weekend! read more

The sandwich/food was amazing! The service was very nice and polite, ambience is relaxed and chill. The tomato soup was very very good! This was 13$ read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - Steak grilled cheese - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Loaded steak melt was to die for. I could've eaten 2 of them easily. Whenever I'm back in saint Augustine this is a must. read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - The Loaded Steak Melt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Absolutely amazing service and the food was out of this world. Perfect balance. Great music plenty of space perfect place to stop for lunch or a snack read more

It's a mom & pop shop, so I'm rounding up to 4/5, even though it felt more like 3.5/5, which is why Yelp needs this option IMO! The side of FRENCH FRIES (2/5) were meant to be used for poutine and needed to be freshly dropped - instead they were soft. The gravy used for the SCARLETT POUTINE (3/5) was overly salty...someone was def. heavy handed - topped with a good amount of grilled chicken (needed to be warmer). The SOUTHEREN BELLE (4/5) sandwich included soft strips of chicken & a lot of cheesiness with a golden & crispy exterior from the butter - highly recommend dipping it in the small container of tomato bisque, which I wish we got more because it was so yummy. I loved it that they brought the food over within 10-15 min. of ordering from Ancient City Brewing while my family & I tried to cool down with a couple beers each after walking around downtown St. Augustine in the intense heat! read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - Southern Belle Sandwich: 4/5 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Tomato basil soup is excellent, as per other reviews, but honestly, everything was fantastic!!! The Pump Daddy Mac & cheese sandwich and the Mondial magical grilled cheese...were indeed magical!! Must stop whenever visiting the old city!!! read more

My husband and I are big foodies and we can say with full confidence that this is our new favorite spot. The grilled cheeses hit spots of satisfaction that we didn't even know existed. The BBQ sauce they make in house exceeded our expectations. It's sweet but also has its own flavor and the crispy bread ascends you into a different dimension. (No we were not inebriated when we tried this place out. This review is 100% sober.) Also the staff is 10/10. Definitely coming back!!!!!!! read more

This place was chosen as a quick an easy option for an outing involving small children and was well received by the little ones. A simple grilled cheese place with a tight interior, this place has a little spread out variety and some unique features. They had advertised a soup of the day in addition to the tomato basil and learned that they are one in the same. The poutine had a little tang to it, but was pretty good. The fries were a little bland but were okay with ketchup. The sandwich was a good quality, and I liked the thick bread they used. The pork tasted like legit meat and the sauce wasn't overly BBQ to the point it masked all other flavors. The girl who took our order was new and slipped up in a few areas, but the experience girl cooking was able to help us get set for success. It wasn't a bad experience by any means, but a little seasoning on the bread would go a LONG way here. read more

See all

Best gourmet grilled cheese I've ever had. I got the Mondial and it came with a side of balsamic vinegar and tomato basil soup. Absolutely delicious. Wife is vegan with lots of allergies. They made sure her sandwich was safe. She got the Artist and subbed for vegan cheese (they use voila brand). They assured us they use oil instead of butter which was nice. Hers also came with balsamic vinegar and tomato basil soup. She devoured it and finished before me(never happens)! The staff were great and answered all of our questions and were super friendly and made small talk with us too. Will definitely be back next time we're in town! read more

Delicious!!!!!! Best grilled cheese I've had and very friendly staff! We will be back! read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - Delicious!!!!!!!!!!!! Enough said. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Grilled cheese yummmness. The new Amsterdam Sammy and the regular poutine. We shared. Alex at the tomato soup dip. Great small Sammy shop. read more

See all

Excellent food--I ordered the "Night in Amsterdam", and it was as close to a technically perfect grilled cheese as one can get. My wife ordered the Mac n' Cheese grilled cheese, and loved it. Hats off for the little cup of tomato soup for dipping, and great oldies music selection, too! read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - A Night in Amsterdam Grilled Cheese - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

Grill cheese Gallery is awesome little hole in the wall with creative name for their sandwiches in the downtown of St Augustine. The service is excellent and seating inside and outside but limited. This is a good place for a quick snack or satisfying your palates. Would come here again and try other items on the menu. read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - Pimp Daddy with Tomato Soup - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Being from Tennessee, we wanted to try new things. My wife saw the Grilled Cheese Gallery on social media and she wanted it, so we tried it. We shared the poutine. It was so tasty. It's hard to find good poutine in Tennessee, so I was very happy to find it here. We both got the Mac and Cheese grilled cheese sandwiches, mine with bacon, and they absolutely did not disappoint. My wife was doing her happy dance of approval after the first bite. Everything was awesome about this place. The staff were nice and friendly. The music in ybr background was great for the atmosphere. Would highly recommend. read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - The Pimp Daddy. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This location has the best grilled cheese in town. There prices are reasonable and have a lot of great options for adults and kids. I eat the original grilled cheese top off with and excellent tomato base soup. Location is great in the heart of downtown. read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

super cute place. kind of gives nightclub vibes ngl. service was great :) and the pimp daddy was delicious-o. thanks guys :3 read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - The Pimp Daddy yummers! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

It wasn't unpalatable, but the flavors in their sandwiches were hard to find. We love grilled cheese. When we are here, it seemed hit or miss because mine was good, but my husband's was bland. We also got bread pudding. It was dry and grilled on both sides. Why? Who knows but it was a let down. We definitely wouldn't go there again, nor would we recommend this place to our friends. read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - Crunchy, dry, and grilled-on-both-sides bread pudding. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Fantastic food and relaxed atmosphere. Had the Amsterdam and tomato soup and it was perfectly made. Look forward to trying this place on cape cod this summer. read more

Great food and wonderful staff. Tons of unique choices and we had a tough time deciding on what to get. Everything was delicious and we'll definitely be back. read more

See all

This was worth our trip to St. Augustine - grilled cheese with pulled pork, BBQ sauce, with tomato dipping sauce! Yes, tomato dipping sauce! I realize how it sounds, but it taste amazing!! Small, inviting, cozy spot! Staff was super friendly, COVID protocols in place! Highly recommend read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - Signage! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

The best grilled cheeses I've ever had and never forget to stop here when I'm in town

Shared The Dutchess with my husband after drooling over this place on Yelp. Took an oldly long time of a grilled cheese to come out and the place was much smaller than expected. I was still very excited to try this but quickly let down. My first bite had shell in it. Off-putting but I understand it happens. Second bite, fine. Third, large piece of cartridge or whatever you call it. Fourth, shell again. At this point I just spit it out and gave up. I'm sure many of the other dishes would be fine but avoid the lobster options. $14 wasted. read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - The Duchess Sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

AMAZING delicious local find in St. Augustine! We are a gluten free family and it was one of our favorite spots during our vacation. 10 out of 10! read more

We were looking for a place for lunch and found this gem on yelp! The sandwiches were amazing! Gourmet grilled cheeses! We ordered the vegan disco and the artist! Both of which were delicious!! The lady greeted us was super nice and got us seated quickly! Definitely going to come back! read more

See all

Grilled Cheese Gallery was everything I needed and more after an exhausting day on my feet. My hubby and I were drinking at the brewery next door and stumbled across their menu. After placing the order in person, they offered to deliver the food when it was ready which was a nice touch. We ordered the Queen Brie sandwich and The Scarlett's Poutine to share. Both items were delicious. I will say we were a tad disappointed with the size of the sandwich. We are from Orlando, so we are used to paying a higher cost for food, which we don't mind if the item was worth it. I just felt it could have been a little bigger for $11. The poutine; however, was a ton of food. It was honestly so delicious after a long day and were starving! We couldn't even finish it because there was so much. Overall, I'd still recommend Grilled Cheese Gallery to anyone looking for a quick but yummy bite to eat. read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - Queen Brie sandwich and The Scarlette Poutine - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Would come again!! I got the pimp daddy grilled cheese and my mom got the house salad and added grilled chicken. It was very good! Customer service was also pleasant. read more

Grilled Cheese Gallery - The House Salad w/grilled chicken - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

You can't go wrong with a grilled cheese! This yummy, buttery contraption will delight your taste buds! They have some great combinations to choose from on their menu. The tomato soup dipper was great as well. read more