Pizza made with old, dry cheese. Bland and not flavorful at all. We were duped into an up charge situation where we were told all medium pizzas were "sold out" and only large was available. After we reluctantly agreed, we watched as other tables were readily served the medium size we were denied. After waiting out the extremely slow service, we got our disappointing large pie. Buyer beware! read more

This is a diamond in a small town . You are welcomed as soon as you walk in the food is made to order and the owner always comes out of the kitchen to greet you . If we are here for 3 days we here 3 days in a row read more

See all

Everything is 5 star here All of it Spaghetti Pizza Pepperoni Cheese Breadsticks Service is casual and perfect We had tons of leftovers!! read more

See all

The food is great and the service is fantastic. Could definitely feed 2-3 people with the huge Calzone and the Cannolis are some of the best I've ever had! read more

When in town you need to stop by the grumpy Italian and try everything. We had sandwiches and pizza and it was all sooooooo good. You will not be disappointed. read more

I only had the Italian club to go, which was fantastic and priced well. A nearby table had a large all meat pizza that looked amazing so I see a five star in the near future. read more

This is it best cheese tortellini soup and sandwiches. I come from Italian's this is belle mangia! Every body stop in this is the food you long for. Big plates so careful what you order. Hot fresh yummmy! When he heard I wad traveling gave me meatballs. Just like my gma or mama would do. Eat read more

See all

This place is awesome!!! The food is fantastic!! The flavors are amazing and everything is homemade. The owner came out several times from the kitchen to make sure our meal was to our liking. The Calzone is huge! It is a must have!! The music in the background sets the mood with old classics from Frank Sinatra, Dean Martin & other crooners. We will definitely be going back!! read more

This is a great little eatery. The waitress was very friendly and the food delicious. It's not fast food, but wonderful homemade meals. The cannoli were fabulous. Saratoga, a small town, is lucky to have such a jewel. read more

Hey, would like to try everything on the menu. I have food was over the top delicious. The service was amazing. Ambience was quaint and fun!

Absolutely the best food in Wyoming. Every item is a 10!!! The service is excellent and Eden, Steve and family are the best

Amazing pizza and friendly owners! We had the margarita pizza which was fresh and delicious.

I Don't know how to explain this place I had the margarita pizza and it was amazing there was plenty of cheese, sauce and bread read more

Grumpy Italian Eatery - Margarita pizza - Italian Near Me - Saratoga, Wyoming

Superb service & food. Grumpy & family greet you with smiles as they provide a delicious sandwich , salad or pizza.

The food is amazing!!! It reminds me of my grandparents cooking and I love that it is all freshly homemade it makes it that much better. The chef Mr grumpy Italian himself came out of the kitchen multiple times to check on us and make sure our food was to our liking everyone employee checked on us multiple times it was some of the best service that I've ever had! The general feel of the building is amazing! The classic music playing is awesome the old timey pictures are awesome! Everything about it is awesome! I love this place and eat here every time I'm coming through Saratoga! Go eat here! read more

Steve and his wife Eden run a great little restaurant here in Saratoga. Food is excellent as well as the atmosphere. Amazing meal and you get treated like family read more

Grumpy Italian Eatery - Italian Near Me - Saratoga, Wyoming

Was there two weeks ago for our anniversary. The wonderful smell hits you as soon as you walk in. Old school atmosphere. Food was fabulous. I had spaghetti. My wife pizza. The owner was super friendly. Just a terrific place read more

The place was small and quaint and I really didn't think we were going to be able to be seated for dinner. All of the tables were taken, besides the table we were able to get. The menu was pretty straightforward with the choices that they offer. For our table we had two orders of spaghetti and meatballs, a salami panini, a meatball sandwich, and a caprese salad that was big enough to share. All of the food was made to order and they all came out hot. The food was all really good, and the caprese was a hit with us. We shared tiramisu that was also delicious. Being that the dessert was so good, I ordered the chocolate banana cake to go and some cheesecake. Outside of having good food, the owners were very friendly, and they personally asked everyone if they were satisfied with their meals. This is a place you come for a sit down meal where you can talk with friends and family and enjoy the chill vibe. I will be coming back to the grumpy Italian for sure. read more

Grumpy Italian Eatery - Italian Near Me - Saratoga, Wyoming

Great Italian food, not just for Saratoga, WY but some of the best I have had. Has a small family Italian restaurant feel from back in the day, which it sort of is. read more

If you find yourself driving through the small town of Saratoga you have GOT to check out The Grumpy Italian. This little spot is absolutely perfect for a quick bite to eat, a hang out spot or even a casual date night. The decor is clean, rustic and just the right amount of Italian charm. I loved the mosaic tile tables, Jenga and a deck of cards at every table, an oversized panoramic of the Brooklyn Bridge and family photos hung with pride. The Grumpy Italian reminds me of Luke's from Gilmore Girls where all the locals come for good food, community and don't forget the prominent 'no cell phone' sign - rather The Grumpy Italian does not offer wi-fi and strongly encourages patrons to 'talk to each other'. The food: the pizza was fantastic, perfectly wood fired without all the burnt black bits that normally accompany wood fired pizza. Check it out - you won't regret it. read more

See all

Ceasar salad, Gemeli, Calzone...authentic, rustic Italian! Don't be fooled, this is how Italians eat!!!!! read more

Grumpy Italian Eatery - Italian Near Me - Saratoga, Wyoming

Veggie with sausage....excellent....will do it again....got there at 5PM with a few tables open....few minutes later place was Packed....

Very delicious pizza and salad. This is a family business and doing things right . We were warmly greeted and the service and food were great. Glad we stumbled on to it. read more

This place is amazing, awesome food great amount of food. Funny,easy goin owners who work their own restaurant/business. Just all around hands down 10 outta 10 place to eat in saratoga Wyoming! Authentic Italian food you can't go wrong ordering anything off the menu. read more

See all

Great family establishment with friendly service and great food. I wish they'd open a branch in Laramie!

A true hidden gem. Great Italian food made from scratch (even the pepperoni is made in-house). The owners are warm and friendly, and the restaurant has a great vibe. Pizza prices are a bit high, but worth it when you think about the work that goes into each one, plus they are pretty big. As soon as you step in the door and the delicious smells hit you, you know you are in for a treat. The walls are covered in pictures of all the people who have eaten before you. Chances are the owners son is doing homework on an empty table while one of owners (husband/wife) greet you. The owner truly makes it all. If you come in early in the day you'll see him in back making dough, sauce, or slicing salami. You can't really go wrong with what you order. The paninis are great, as is the meatball sandwich. It's a classic made in homemade, soft bread with a massive portion of mozzarella cheese melting on top. However, the New York style pizza is what gets the most attention. The huge pizzas come out with a chewy, foldable crust. The sauce is flavorful, toppings are generously added, and the cheese is great. If you are looking for delicious food in a casual environment, this is a perfect option. read more

The BEST restaurant in Saratoga!!!! Great food, fantastic service! You won't be disappointed! read more

Grumpy Italian Eatery - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Saratoga, Wyoming

See all

Amazing food, incredible service! Authentic Italian food with authentic home style environment!

Our first trip to the Grumpy Italian was AMAZING! Pizza was incredible, cheesy bread was the best I've ever had, and my grumpy combo was the best Italian sandwich I've had in a long time! Definitely will be back!! read more

Gluten free options are always a plus, service was very good and the setting was way cool!

Nice Italian eatery in small town. We had the spaghetti and meatballs and a large pizza both were very good

We will definitely come back to the Grumpy Italian! Their Italian Beef sandwich is amazing! The Grumpy Combo Sandwhich is delicious as well! We finished the meal off with dark chocolate Gelato and canoli! The owners are very friendly and greet their customers individually! read more

An all-around great experience! The food is delicious, we had the all meat pizza, caprese salad, and soup, and enjoyed them all. The eatery is great for kids with card games, jenga, chess, and several books and coloring options. The only con is that there is no public bathroom. read more

Amazing place and awesome food. Owner and staff were outstanding - fun, personable, friendly, outgoing and professional. The pizza was to die for, wife had the meatballs and a bite of the panini and said it was amazing. The homemade cheesecake was the best we ever had. A must visit if you're ever in the area! read more

Grumpy Italian Eatery - Best pizza this side of the planet! - Italian Near Me - Saratoga, Wyoming

Steven and Eden make us feel like family every time we come in. The food is always delicious!! We are so blessed to have them in our little town. read more

Saw the reviews were good so my coworker and I stopped in, we were not disappointed, nice atmosphere, great music, the staff was very friendly, not to mention the pizza OUTSANDING! Will definitely be back when I am in town, and will be recommending it to everyone I talk to in the next couple days that's for sure! read more

I think this might be the best pizza I've ever had. Desserts were wonderful too. The owner was very friendly - not grumpy at all. Everyone in the restaurant seemed to know one another and it had a welcoming atmosphere. Not fast food but good food. Cards on the table to play while we waited - fun. read more

My son and I stopped to eat after visiting the hot springs. Amazing food! We're from California, and honestly one of the better pizza's I've had in a long time. We ordered half all meat and half veggie. And for dessert the chocolate cake with chocolate sauce. One word YUM! This is obviously a family owned restaurant. We felt welcomed and appreciated as guest in the kitchen. The love they have definitely spills over to the food. read more

Fantastic pizza and friendly service. Fantastic flavors and such fresh veggies made our veggie pizza so good. The kids loved the pepperoni. Good atmosphere with games at the table to keep you busy while you wait. read more

This was a pleasant surprise! We had been mountain biking the Pole Mountains, body sliding in the snowy range, and then down to the hot Springs (there in Saratoga). We were tired and hungry far from her campsite and wanted something local but hold some. This more than did the trick! Great Italian food with large servings for hungry teenagers. Adults actually split their orders and shared salad and calzone. Fresh ingredients. Well made. Very tasty. Not greasy. Filling. Husband-wife owners and operators. Very attentive to service. Simple but good atmosphere. Obviously a popular place given the number of patrons on a week day evening. Even table distractions with vintage games such as rock'em sock'em robots, Jenga, cards, and others. We actually did not eat their pizza, but looking at other patrons--and smelling at--they were clearly as good as the food we did order. Paninis and calzones and tortellini soups and spaghetti with real handmade meatballs were all quite satisfying. Too bad we do not have a place like this at home, we have to be there weekly. read more