Cancel

Open app

Search

Guilty Bakery

4.0 (1 review)

Guilty Bakery Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Guilty Bakery

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Fatboy S.
7
781
3637

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

White Lion Baking Company

White Lion Baking Company

4.2
(45 reviews)
1.5 mi
$$

For my daughter's birthday, I ordered a cake to be shipped to her at college. WLB was fantastic to…read morework with and she (and her friends) LOVED LOVED LOVED the cake (flourless chocolate with raspberry sauce). Thank you WLB for helping make a GF/DF 21st birthday special!! (Especially appreciate your turning the order around so quickly after a very busy Easter/Passover week!) (Note for those ordering on line, the shopping cart buttons can be confusing - if you click "ship" and it looks grayed out, it's actually selected and you can proceed on to checkout (don't be alarmed that the "store pickup" button is showing as white). Next screen will show shipping costs, details, etc.)

This place is small but freakin' impressive gluten free bakery. The variety and quality is…read moreexcellent. I love how not everything is dairy free and some items have nuts which I love. So, we bought 8 different items to try. And 4 of us were sampling the items. While people were slowly sampling I went back inside to quickly take 4 pictures and before I could return, the entire turtle cheesecake was eaten. That's the one with the chocolate, caramel, and nuts on top. I was annoyed since I literally had a tiny bite so I ran back in to get the last one and boy was I happy. The flavors, presentation, and quality are there. This is a great dessert place to hit. We didn't try the breads or anything else so I don't want to comment on that. Owner was there working and was friendly. Overall great place and anyone gluten free should definitely visit if they're hitting the Cape.

Photos
Wedding/Engagement/Bridal Shower cakes & cupcake towers available!
Wedding/Engagement/Bridal Shower cakes & cupcake towers available!
Vegan chocolate cupcakes
Vegan chocolate cupcakes
Vegan vanilla cupcakes with strawberry frosting

See all

Vegan vanilla cupcakes with strawberry frosting
AMIE Bakery

AMIE Bakery

3.3
(123 reviews)
5.3 mi
$$

Thanks to our server (Peg?) and some delicious offerings, the very limited (and pricey) Mother's…read moreDay afternoon tea was a hit with my family (and me). Gratuity was included, but our service was so wonderful, we tipped on top of the tip. The turkey salad sandwich was the table favorite, and we were delighted to learn its on their regular menu! Guess we will be taking out a sandwich or two in the future... IF we can bypass buying one of their AMAZING SEAFOOD PIES in luscious sherry sauce and exploding with scallops, shrimp, fish... but I digresss. We were here for ME day (ok, so I DID take a pie on my way out...). $65 bought you 3 sandwiches, one of which was less than petite and oh so delicious with its home made pesto and brioche bun. The baby cranberry orange American scones were delicious and light (a light scone, right? Crazy), mini blueberry muffins, 3 lovely pastries and a croissant. Also included was champagne (or mimosa) and a cordial shot for your tea. It was all wonderful. Now, I'd take away a star for the young and weird counter staff. Seemed like either high school girls or early college - not really well trained (they didn't know much about anything, and were mostly confused and more interested in talking among each other)... I picked up a bag of croutons and it had a hole in it... their "fix" was to pour it into another bag! (GASP! REALLY? I hate to say this but it was a Legally Blonde moment). Thank goodness an "adult" or more mature professional stepped in and asked if I'd like a new bag... DUH, YES, RIGHT ANSWER. So the croutons and one of those evil seafood pies made it home for mom. I think the girls just need training (and some growing up to do - they weren't unpleasant, just... immature). All in all this place is beautiful, their offerings are wonderful and for the most part, the staff is great. Now that I'm here from my beloved Hudson (ok, I'm still mourning my Hudson town and former home), I expect to make Amie one of my favorite stops. OH, did I mention their coffee is also great? Time to think about one of their classes or other fancy pants-y events. Because it is "kinda" snooty with a down to earth feeling of "they LOVE what they do and do it exceedingly well".

The owner responded by saying I should've asked for a manager, however when I did ask for…read moreAssistance and told them that they made the Matcha wrong after I had asked for it to be made with almond milk and not oat milk I basically got an eye roll no, I'm sorry and it came out terrible I think they purposely made it bad so no asking for assistance in this case actually made my situation worse.

Photos
AMIE Bakery
Coffee cup back home
Coffee cup back home
AMIE Bakery

See all

Guilty Bakery - bakeries - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...