"Local tavern serving comfort food with some global twists, plus brunch, in a warm-hued setting." Hamilton's is so much more than a local tavern.. I would call it a neighborhood gem. It's a place I would dine frequently in if I lived in the neighborhood. Early this summer, I dined at Hilltop Tavern located in Windsor Terrace. I loved the ambience, service and the food. Their menu offers delicious options that will appease any palate. The turkey burger was absolutely delicious and memorable. When my check arrived, it was attached to a postcard featuring Hamilton's. Georgia and Kevin Read own a wonderful trifecta: Alchemy, Hilltop Tavern and Hamilton's. I was in the mood for a Veggie Burger and decided to trek to Hamilton's. The interior is warm, wooden tables and bar, cozy lighting and a great place to meet up or dine solo. The menu offers great comfort food: chicken sandwich, burgers, salads, soups, breakfast and dinner. There is a Happy Hour Monday-Friday 3-6:30pm. "Their signature dish is a "hotchee," this hearty spin on a classic chili-cheese dog consists of a grilled hot dog in a bun, topped with a slice of American cheese, the Hamilton's signature chili, a squeeze of yellow mustard, and a generous heap of diced onions." Sounds delicious with a nice IPA. My veggie burger deluxe arrived and it was a generous portion of burger, salad, and potato wedges. I asked for a side of chipotle aioli. The veggie burger tasted good; black bean patty with sautéed onions on a brioche bun. The potato wedges were delicious and the aioli sauce had a spicy kick to it. The salad was dressed with light dressing. The lemon spritzer was tart and refreshing. I will come back of course to sample the beer. I told my waiter I loved Hilltop Tavern. His reply was " Hamilton's was first.." Hamilton's 2826 Fort Hamilton Pkwy Take B16 to Caton and 4th, 5 minute walk read more

See all

Was in the area and on a search for diner food - discovered this spot. Looks old school, and there wasn't much customer service. Overall it was just okay, nothing special. Ordered steak and eggs, it also came with some greens and potatoes (which I skipped on). We also ordered a Parmesan crusted grilled cheese, which was pretty good. read more

Hamilton's - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Cozy place with good service. Fresh food and good quality. The burger was SO good with pickles and home style fries!

Super pleasantly surprised by this place. The kale salad and veggie burger was so yummy! Such a quaint cute little spot. Will definitely be back! read more

See all

Inconsistent mediocre food for a premium price. Nothing worse than realizing you spent $300 and it was just eh

Recently stopped by for dinner, the food was good and came in a timely manner! Our server was also very friendly.

Hamilton's is a great spot for brunch in Windsor Terrace section of Brooklyn. The location is on Fort Hamilton Parkway at its intersection with E 4th. The only negative is parking. Street parking is difficult to find for this popular spot. We had to park blocks away in the midst of winter at a time when my medical specialists had not yet found a specific reason for my breathing problems. It was a difficult walk for me on portable oxygen, which I've since learned doesn't work. The plan was that after brunch we would walk to a nearby park in the opposite direction of where my son's vehicle was parked. The park would be a treat for my Grandson in return for having to endure brunch out. :) That plan was nixed because of the falling temperature & my health issues. The long walk to Hamilton's was worth it. I knew the moment we stepped in that this would be an awesome spot. The L shaped restaurant features a popular bar area facing Fort Hamilton. Table seating is available in that section, a patio & an outdoor seating area. The patio & outdoor areas, facing the cross street, were both heated & enclosed in a temporary clear protective material that allowed the same outdoor views as one would have seen in warmer weather. Dogs are allowed in the outdoor seating, which is always a huge plus. The timing of our visit was still too close to the Covid catastrophe in NYC for me to feel safe in a crowded area. Our hostess completely understood and seated us at the back table in the patio area. I felt safe. The heaters made the table comfortable. So I was completely happy. The menu was awesome. There was something for everyone from burgers & sandwiches to vegan. Our Server was very attentive. I chose the Salmon & Codcake w/chipotle aiol and arugula salad. It was delicious, definitely 5 stars. My then Vegan, now Vegetarian son chose the Organic Kale Salad with Pumpkin seeds, dried cranberries, and maple vinaigrette. It too deserves 5 stars. My grandson chose from the Kid's Menu, which runs the gamut of choices including perennial kids favorites such as Macaroni & Cheese, Grilled Cheese & Hamburger. As usual the Fries were his favorite. The Brunch Menu, available until 4, was what we chose from. It includes a Breakfast section, which is great for the late risers or those who enjoy lingering hours over coffee (like me). There is a Lunch (Bar) Menu served 4 - 5 that features Small Plates & Sandwiches. Dinner begins at 5, featuring not just entrees but also sandwiches & burgers. Hamilton's is definitely a place where I'll return. Their menu choices are terrific & it's a happy place. read more

See all

Eggs Benedict with smoked ham was delicious-poached eggs was cooked perfectly. Cobb salad with chicken large generous portion ...freshly chopped carrots avocado bacon romaine radish with sprinkle of corn kernels. Recommend paying an extra $3 to substitute thin English muffin with their signature thick flakey biscuits with chive butter to soak up the egg yolk. The peppery arugula side salad with sliced radish paired perfectly with the eggs Benedict . read more

Hamilton's - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Place to grab wine and solid eats. It's easy to support this local business. We took my in-laws when they came to visit and they enjoyed.

Came here after a half-marathon with friends and had a pleasant experience. We were sat right away in a nicely decorated outdoor section. We split a flight of beer and two freshly squeezed lemonades which were DELICIOUS. It was the right balance between sweet and tart. The food was good, fresh and came out quickly. The grilled cheese and the bacon Mac n cheese were highlights. The portions are a little small, so I do recommend getting a side or ordering multiple things for the table to try and splitting amongst everyone. Would recommend visiting with family, friends or a partner. It's also quite reasonable! read more

See all

It's dinner time. No, it's breakfast time. No, it's more like brunch and I am starving! I don't really know what I want to eat. All I know is that it has to be perfectly prepared! Hamilton's is a relatively recent emergence nestled in the heart of Windsor Terrace a mere hip, skip and a jump for the subway station. It's string of warm cozy lights, velvet seat pillows and attractive roses on every table make it immediately inviting and intimate. A perfect neighborhood place for a casual sister brunch, a family outing or a lovely romantic date. Sit back and relax and let Hamilton's do the rest. Hamiltons specializes in familiar, American dishes cooked to perfection. I first tried their delicious cod cakes with a poached egg and potatoes. Crisp on the outside and creamy on the inside. Perfect. Their jumumga buttermilk biscuits can be devoured as is, topped with sweet honey butter or served up right as a kitchen strawberry shortcake. I'm a huge fan of their steak and eggs. I spoiled myself one Saturday morning and what arrived was a skirt steak, tender and vibrant with fresh chimichurri sauce, two buttered eggs over easy (cooked to order) and a side of hash brown potatoes and peppers. No I didn't need to ask for ketchup because Hamilton's just knows. They are solid with their bar offerings and a mimosa is respected. But dining with little ones? Or not a drinker? Hamilton's offers a delectable array of exotic mock tails that can make your evening with your non-drinker special. Go for dinner and try their broiled salmon. Or their Mediterranean bowl. Or their bolognese. After the first bite, you will exclaim: "That's what I was hungry for all along!" Can't recommend this place enough. The staff are absolutely lovely! read more

Hamilton's reached out and apologized for our experience, and I really appreciate that. I was more upset about how rude the waitress was, than the mistake that was made. And they apologized for that. Food was good, I enjoyed the grilled chicken sandwich and my youngest enjoyed the Cobb. Our waitress was rude. When my daughter ordered her drink the same as mine after my drink was served, she said "I wish I knew that." Then she put in for the reg French toast instead of the children's one I ordered for my child. The regular one had nuts. The children's one did not list nuts. They had the nerve to argue with me. They later apologized since I was correct. Then they told me I couldn't have the kids French toast cause brunch was over! Then they said the chef would do it, like they were doing me the favor. Ummmm we ordered before brunch was over. They made the mistake! And they were not going to make the right order??? Then they ignored us for 30 minutes. read more

Hamilton's - Grilled Chicken Sandwich - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've stuck with this restaurant, though I only go occasionally. Our neighborhood SO badly needs a few restaurants that are consistent. The entire "scene" on Fort Hamilton is sad. Half of the restaurants are only open sporadically. As for Hamilton's, the owners should stick to food that they can consistently serve well. Last time I ordered steak it was like shoe leather. Last salad I had with optional grilled chicken, the chicken was like jerky and cold. The salad underneath was a weird mash of cheese, beans and unidentifiable veggies. Soaked in dressing. I wish I could say their burgers were good, but half the time they are overcooked. I guess maybe they just want to be a bar. The beer selection is always good. Their desserts are also decent. It's just so disappointing to spend $30-$40 and still feel hungry, and wish you'd just cooked at home. Restaurants don't need to do rocket science, just be good and fairly priced. They should look at a place like Skinflints in Bay Ridge. Terrific food at affordable price point. read more

Friendly neighborhood spot with really inviting menu. Grilled cheese was divine, and cobb salad terrific.

This is a two because the service was excellent. I ordered a Cobb salad. It was soggy and the ingredients didn't seem fresh. The avocado was sliced and dumped on the side of the bowl. I was pretty disappointed because I've had good food there before. read more

We went into this neighborhood restaurant Hamiltons while visiting some old friends. It was a perfect place to meet while still obliging all the rules of COVID-19. Social distancing was taking place and everyone was wearing a mask. My meal was was delish an artichoke salad complemented with delicious beans in a fantastic dressing of garlic and oil. Of course I had ice coffee which was bold and strong tasting. For dessert I had a yummy tasting flourless chocolate cake amazing flavor.....a party in my mouth lol. read more

Hamilton's - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Hamilton's is a true neighborhood joint that you can always depend on for a hearty meal. The interior is cozy and lived in (I mean this in a good way - some restaurants feel sterile and unrelatable, here you can be yourself). I've been here twice for brunch and have enjoyed both of my experiences. The first time I got the kale salad with chicken which was sooo delicious. Today I got huevos rancheros. It was great, but I think grating the cojita over the black beans would have made for better plating. Didn't hurt the taste though! My husband raved about the Ella Fitzgerald sandwich. You use a QR code to view the menu and to pay, but I'm pretty sure they take cash. read more

Hamilton's - Huevos Rancheros - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

*sigh* I WANT to like Hamilton's so so badly, if for no other reason that it's the closest cozy bar & eatery to my apartment. Their sister restaurant, Hilltop Tavern, is absolutely lovely - great food, great service. Hamilton's, on the other hand, is consistently hit or miss. The food is frequently lacking salt, the salads soggy, hamburger buns crumble in your hands. Service is confusing, the staff seems untrained (food runner served a hot plate directly into my hands & had to be reminded to bring silverware) and irritated by the presence of customers. I guess they stay in business by the rush of wine moms at after-school pickup... or the lack of competition in the neighborhood. (hint hint to any aspiring area restauranteurs) I'm sure I'll be back but maybe just for a drink at the bar... not sure how the kitchen forgot to salt the potatoes but they did. It was sad. read more

Excellent food Service is good Ambiance brings out the best of Bay Ridge. Whenever we are all in NYC, we drive there to have an unforgettable meal. read more

I used to live pretty close to this place and went there probably at least 10 times. They don't have a whole lot of things on their menu but what they do have is pretty good. I like their orzo which comes with spinach, feta cheese and pine nuts. They have the option to put chicken or shrimp in it but I prefer vegetarian. I had the grilled salmon a few times and at times it was perfect, crispy on the outside and tender and juicy on the inside and at times it was dry so not always consistent, however it is reasonably priced considering what grilled salmon would cost you at other places near by. I like the option of sitting outside, that works out very well if you prefer to have some privacy. I like the lights that they have outside as well and the fire heating apparatuses, whatever those are called. I really enjoyed the soju alcoholic drink they have there, my favorite being the guava jalapeño one, very tasty indeed. The service was always good, kind of laid back and their bathroom is very clean and quite charming. Even though the salmon was not always perfect, never the less it was always a good experience coming here so I give it a 5. read more

We order delivery from Hamilton's all the time and the food is always amazing. The steak is delicious. Love the chicken and polenta. Salmon is chef's kiss. The salads are also very good. And...the banana cake is yummy too! Delivery always comes very quickly too. Thank you! read more

Hamilton's has been in the neighborhood for a while and although I attest to their food, I can attest more to how wonderful the staff members are. They are always so attentive and friendly. As a community member growing up in the neighborhood, they even let me make bathroom visits if I was ever in need! Large selection of drinks! Great for happy hour or an outing with friends, especially considering there aren't frequent bars in the area. read more

I've only been here once and my visit was pleasant. I happened to come across this place while strolling around the area. It was a nice day and decided to pop in for a quick drink. The Bees Knees piqued my interest so of course I had to try it. The drink was not overly sweet. It's shaken with ice and poured into a cute little glass. But don't worry it comes with extra. The music is chill and the staff is friendly. Great place. read more

Hamilton's - The Bees Knees - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Brunch is reasonably priced, and the food is decent. The ambiance is not for every crowd, but it's spacious for couples and groups. Most of the wait staff is good. There's a cute, nice, young blond guy that greeted and seated us. However, our waitress had a bit of an attitude, total RBF, seems like the type who probably shouldn't be in the service business. Overall, the place is fine in a pinch. read more

A great neighborhood spot. Friendly folks, nice small menu, good selection of beers.

Neighborhood gem. It's my go to, around the corner place, I visit when I go home. I love the addition of the sidewalk "patio" space they added during Covid. BUT, I'm sure some Brooklynites are not happy as they lost a couple parking spaces. We can't win! Lol. So many good dishes here. I'm a sucker for pastrami and they have a good one. read more

See all

I like this spot! They have a nice outside set up these days... and the food is good. They have a brunch that goes until pretty late on the weekends ( think 3pm or later?) I got the Reuben Sandwich and it was fantastic! My friends ordered the avocado BLT & the Ella Fitzgerald sandwich - they both liked their food. Nice corner location... Nice staff... Overall I have no complaints. read more

Been working my way through the mocktail menu and everything is so fresh and delicious. This one is the elderflower/grapefruit/ginger ale, all of them are great! read more

Hamilton's - Elderflower Mocktail - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

"I love the food. I had buttered pasta. And the smoked salmon was good" - Penny age 7 read more

Hamilton's - Buttered Macaroni and Cheese - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Good food great service. They treat you with respect. Nice atmosphere clean place. Never do they gripe about tipping! read more

Poached Eggs with Hollandaise including crab cake. Decent service, although packed inside during brunch hours on a rainy autumn Sunday. Quite the neighborhood staple so can't go wrong 9/10 times read more

Hamilton's - Poached Eggs with Hollandaise including crab cake - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Never got my food. Waited 15 minutes after being seated to be told power is going down (what?) and that we would have to wait another 30 minutes to order hot food. Multiple people including the guy at the bar and the guy who sat us saw us seated for over 15 minutes without notifying us. read more

The food was great and the atmosphere was nice for a warm summer evening. The service was so helpful and pleasant. If your visiting Brooklyn this is a great low key spot. read more

Ok, so this is my new favorite place :). I really really enjoyed everything. The food was delicious. I had arugula and artichoke salad, and I added salmon. My husband had steak. For dessert we had flourless chocolate cake. People were so nice! The place itself looks super cute! I will be back ! read more

Hamilton's - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Hamilton's is a place you'd expect to see your typical pub food, but they take food quality to the next level. Both times I've been there, you could tell the food is fresh, and the food tasted great. The burger I got was cooked perfectly, and the fries were good. I got a quesadilla that was to die for. They've also got specials, such as Taco Tuesday. It was a bit pricey but the food was excellent. read more

Hamilton's - Grass Fed Beef Burger - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Hamilton's is experiencing a Covid boom. This normally sleepy restaurant is very busy because there are lot's of people working from home. They have an abundance of outdoor seating, and they are located in Windsor Terrace where there appears to be no shortage of money. I have made several trips to Hamilton's at the request of friend's and family. I can say that I have not had a bad meal, however I cannot say that anything is exceptional either. The restaurant business is like the real estate business...location, location, location. read more

Hamilton's - Bars Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Mediocre food and OVERPRICED. If you charge me $10 for a "lemon tart in a mason jar" and serve me a lemon PUDDING in a drinking glass. You served the wrong customer. $9 Kids burger -- tiny and bland burger in an English muffin with 3 pcs of what looks like cut out potatoes. You served the wrong customer. We are willing to pay the price if the service deserves it. read more

See all

The vegetarian goat cheese orzo is fabulous as well as the arugula caesar salad. I am a coffee drinker and I wasn't a fan of the coffee though. Also alcohol beverages are slightly weak, at least the warm mulled sobe drink I had It is a good brunch place, minus the lack of good coffee issue read more

We enjoyed a late lunch here today, on a Monday. Good food (Reuben sandwich, salmon and cod burger, bread pudding), drinks (nice beer selection and a not-too-sweet cider), waitstaff, atmosphere, A/C, music and street parking! Relaxing atmosphere, we did not encounter any of the issues reported by others. Nowhere is cheap any more, but we thought it was reasonably priced. We came here 3 or 4 years ago on a weekend. On that occasion, we thought it was OK, not great, but decided to give it another try. We'll be back. To the lady who complained about a lack of salt on the roast potatoes: many of us prefer them that way! read more

I forgot how long I've been coming here, but Georgia runs the best restaurant with great food and friendly service. It's one of my most favorite places in Windsor Terrace/Kensington, and it never lets me down. The Rubin! read more