The staff is fine so long as you don't have any problem…read more However, if you have any issue, they treat you with such disdain as though you are the lowest of the low. I had a product that came up at the register at a different price than was shown on the shelf. As the line got longer and longer and people were getting more and more annoyed with me (as if it was my fault), the cashier was befuddled as what to do. Finally, she called for a manager. The manager came over, as though disturbed from her very important other work. Took her time going to the shelf to verify what I was saying. Again, the line behind me is growing longer and more annoyed, she finally saunters back to say I was correct. No apology, (used to be you got the item for free but forget about that happening). One shops there because they have to, not for friendly, helpful service.

St. Louis ribs were on sale today, I believe 299 a pound, so I picked up two packages. They are…read moreuntrimed that's fine , but what the Butcher does is takes the rib tip cut offs from another customers trimmed ribs put them in the package folded inside the packages I purchased, so you cannot see it until you open them, that way they get to charge you another pound , real slick, NEVER buy from there again

Delicious wood fired pizzas-- We ordered the Lombardi's Love Lane & a Farmer's Market ($16 pies)…read more The pies are sizable and definitely shareable for two. They are generous with the toppings. Dough is very close to Italian pizzas--soft pillowy. Cranberry Walnut Salad by the weight was very expensive although it did taste good. 32 oz container came out to $9! It was a nice side dish to the pizza.

This is a very , very nice Italian Market with an extensive variety of foods and products…read more Pastas , salads , sides, deli products , specialty cheeses , butcher , pizza , panini station and much more . There are tables to sit inside and a few outdoor tables as well . The service was wondering , everyone was so friendly and helpful . I went in for lunch and purchased a delicious hero , The Italy , packed with chicken , eggplant , mozzarella and roasted peppers . It was one of the best hero's I've ever had , so well made , fresh and tasty ! It was big and plenty to share or enjoy for a second meal . I will definitely be back when in the area !

Only Greek market on the North Fork. Has several Greek feta (including my favorite Dodonis &…read moreArahova) and cheeses (manouri, kasseri, etc.) and other Greek products like Iliada olive oil, olives, fresh desserts, teas, rusks, cookies, canned products (dolmades, octopus, beans), wheats (barley, semolina, pastas & many others), frozen goods (tyropita, spanakopita, bougatsa, pastitsio, moussaka, etc.), Ion chocolate, and much more. . Also has some clothing/gifts and Joanne & Tony who run the store are the nicest people. Can't leave without buying a hot spanakopita to go from their hot tray.

We took a short walk while waiting for a take-out order from around the corner, and wound up at…read moreAgora! What a little gem off the beaten path of Love Lane in Mattituck! We ended up buying a couple cans of dolmas (stuffed grape leaves), fig salami (vegetarian), homemade baklava, and some New-York-made soap! They have a great variety of Greek selections, from canned and dried goods, to home-baked goods, to frozen items to take home. They also carry an interesting selection of art and soaps. Everything was very reasonably priced. Perhaps the best part of our visit was the lovely chat we had with the very friendly owners! They take such pride in their business and made us feel welcome and appreciated. We will definitely be back to visit next time we are in Mattituck!

Incredible authentic Spanish food that will blow you away!!! Bodega style to go and very…read moreinexpensive. Hot Food daily. Cash only.

My husband and I came in here to get a few things, and decided to try some of their hot food. We…read morefell in love!! It's probably the best deli style Spanish food we've ever had!! Everything is super fresh, and cooked perfectly! Our favorite is the beef with carrots and potatoes. The beef is cooked so perfectly it melts in your mouth! I also love the pork. The pork falls right off the bone. The sauce that it comes in is amazing also! The rice and beans are always a must also when we come here! We come here at least once a week now. Not only is the food amazing but the service is even better. Everyone is super friendly that works here, and it's very clean!! Everything about this place is A+++ If you haven't tried this little hidden gem yet, you need to!!

Adorable cheese shop with some of the friendliest staff around! They are very knowledgeable about…read morethe cheese they sell and generous with samples too. I also love that they sell charcuterie and crackers and jams alongside the cheese. Prices are fairly reasonable and they have a great selection of local and international cheeses. I loved my visit here and will definitely stop by the next time I'm in town. There's plenty of street parking (and a lot around the corner) too.

After eating at a nearby restaurant my girlfriend and I went to the village cheese shop as a…read morerecommendation from someone we were sitting next to. Upon entering there were no other customers in the store. The store was neat and clean. A blonde woman standing at the back counter looked up from her phone at us and then went back to her phone. As another couple walked in someone else came out from the back and greeted the new couple. We worked our way back to the woman at the back counter and inquired about a cheese board. She told us we could order one and the amount of time it would take to have one made. We asked if they did cheese boards to sit and have to eat now, and I quote, "No we are not a cafe, we don't serve food in store like that". As we continued around the shop many more couples entered the store. We worked our way back around to the cheese counter to place our order. Once it was our turn the blonde woman, who originally snubbed us as we walked in, asked what we needed. As we started to order she asked us to hold on and called another girl from the back to continue helping us. The other girl was very friendly, and informational and even made some recommendations. We purchased a number of cheeses and other accoutrements. As we were checking out, a couple walked in and asked if they did fondue. The blonde woman was friendly and set them up at a table in the back to have fondue for 2. We proceeded to take our items and leave. If you like Brie you need to try the Truffle Brie! It is absolutely delicious! So much so that my girlfriend went back in to buy more for guests we were having over the next day. The cheese and the selection is great. The shop is cute and clean and apparently depending on who you are or who you're with, depends on how you will be treated.

This farm stand has been going down hill for the last 2 years. I stopped by their new stand which…read moreis closer for me as I come from Orient. I prefer the main Laurel location, but selection is same.. Also, he might have been the owner (I believe he is, not sure. Had a hat on maybe in 40's) doesn't need to look so miserable. He looked like he would rather be doing anything else but serving me. I asked him a question about the corn and he literally snapped at me for asking about it. That doesn't really make customers want to come back. Attitudes could be better. Just sayin.

The freshest vegetables on the North Fork. The best corn, strawberries, snap peas. Nearly…read moreeverything is from their own fields.

Great liquor store Good selection, knowledgeable staff. Highly recommended. Conveniently locatedread more

I can't find a way to add any more stars, "Great" seems so minimal for this shop…read more This is the ONLY on or off-island store that offers free delivery to Shelter Island. If I stop in, the staff is always welcoming and eager to lug a case or two out to my car. Grocery store typically charge a $10 delivery fee if they deliver to the island at all, and there aren't many who do! The staff, selection, and prices are wonderful! I love to shop by price range as that, unfortunately, is necessary but made so pleasant by you folks!

When you head out to the North Fork, make sure you leave yourself time and head out to the Sang Lee…read moreFarms. They have many different varieties of herbs, tomatoes, watermelons, non-GMO corn and squash among other items! We wanted some garlic and had to sort through the multiple varieties to find the best one for what we needed. That's where their amazing staff comes in. The team here is wonderful and incredibly knowledgeable. Besides all the wonderful certified organic fruits and veggies, lot of Asian vegetables (Chinese string beans, kohlrabi, young ginger, bok Choy), they have plenty of plants for your garden. This was a great spot to pick up some nive varieties of tomatoes, parsley, etc,, They also offer refrigerated items and baked goods. They have a great selection of pastas among other items. A must visit for all. KUDOs to the team at Sang Lee Farms.

Sang Lee is one of our favorite organic farm stands in Peconic out on the East End. We've been…read morecustomers for over fifteen years. Plenty of organically grown produce. They also sell gourmet cheese, condiments, kimchi, pesto, fresh seasonal flowers, and delicious prepared dips in the shop fridge. A perfect stop for local produce in the North Fork.