I have been meaning to try High Noon since it opened and a few reviewers were so adamant about how good it was. We ordered via phone because it wasn't obvious what the menu was from the Yelp page, probably a good idea to link the toast account to the landing page to make it easier on your patrons. We had an Extra Large 16" pepperoni pizza, cheesy bread and a dessert cookie, so I'll take them in order. While the pizza was tasty, good cheese quality and quantity, and nice sauce, it was not only not the best I have ever had, it was not even the best I have had on this side of the lake. It was a bit overcooked, similar to other pictures I have seen, but maybe I'm in the minority not wanting my pizza crispy. The cheese sticks were very good, but like the pizza they could have come out of the oven a minute or two earlier and were actually burnt around the edges. Finally the dessert cookie was very good, a huge one and went well with milk. Ambiance isn't really a factor as we got it to go, but I do like that they have some seating. Overall a good, strong 4 stars, and we will definitely put High Noon in our pizza rotation as we work through their menu. read more

Great pizza we tried the cheese (didn't get a pic) and the pepperoni with ranch. Obviously I had to eat a piece on the way home read more

High Noon - Pepperoni pizza and homemade ranch dressing - Pizza Near Me - Canyon Lake, Texas

I wanted to like this spot so badly because of its proximity to me and after hearing of other good reviews, however, I don't think it lived up to its hype. I will say we were excited to find a spot that has a slightly larger gluten free pizza (thank you!) at 14"! The high roller was ok, but we had bigger gripes with everything else- the traditional wings (bbq and garlic parm) lacked flavor and were very burnt. The Philly was very disappointing. It hardly had any meat, very poor quality veggies and wasn't filling at all. Unfortunately outside of the gluten free pizza options, I don't think we'll be returning. read more

See all

Very tasty and at a decent price. Would recommend ordering ahead as they are slow to make the pizzas. Bacon jalapeño cheesy bread was SO good read more

So done! 1st time was a disaster and after the owner called after seeing my unfavorable review, she refunded me so I removed it. Time passed and gave it another try this evening. Ordered 1 medium and 1 large pizza along with 18 wings (80 bucks after delivery). After almost an hour and a half wait, I called, spoke to the owner and she confirmed it was on the way - they got super busy and didn't expect the crowd. So, about a 2 hour wait once fonally delivered and our pizza was not hot or crispy as we had ordered, piled on top of each other, and the wings were not great either (ranch dip we never received). Another not so great experience. Will continue with Dominoes or drive to Bootleggers! read more

This place can't handle your business. Ordered a medium pizza and 6 wings. They ran out of wings and it was going to take an another 30 minutes to go get some at another location. The pizza wasn't started after an hour. It was going to take 2 hours for the food to get to me. STAY AWAY!!!!!!! read more

Great pizza and great service! High roller is delicious, as well as the bread sticks and cheesy sticks.

I tried to support a local business, but never again for this location. Placed an online order, arrived at pickup time as instructed, order not made yet. Fair enough. After waiting an additional 30 minutes inside the location watching and listening to high school antics, between the staff and 4-5 friends that were there as customers, I asked for an update only to be informed that have not made it yet. This was a Tuesday at 6pm and there were no other customers ahead of me. I asked for a refund to be told I had to wait the standard 3-5 days for it. I will not be back. read more

We tried High noon pizza last month. The meat pizza was really good. Some people in our group liked the buffalo pizza as well. We had a to go order. The store was cute and people were kind. The only thing I would add would be some extra Buffalo sauce. read more

AMAZING PIZZA!!! This place is so good. We got the pepperoni and the high roller pizza with pineapple and jalepenos added. The pizza is fresh and dough is homemade. The ranch is also homemade and delicious. Do yourself a favor and order the cinnamon sticks. Beyond delicious. Love this place and finally have a good pizza place to go to!!! read more

See all

We want to support local so we ordered a pizza, came in 30 minutes later to pick it up and it hadn't even been made yet. There was no body waiting ahead of us. Not what we were expecting. read more

Small unpretentious place but don't let that fool you, the pizza is Great. I ordered The High Roller & it was delicious! Best pizza at the lake! They were also very friendly.A little pricey but maybe they will offer specials? Don't sleep on this pizza read more

Best calzone I've ever had, make sure to get the garlic butter brushed finish, amazing!!

My husband loves the all meat pizza. I prefer the chicken Alfredo pizza but it needs more chicken. Pleasant people and great cookies.

Not only does High Noon pizza have THE BEST pizza in this entire area, but they are just good, awesome people. They're nice, hardworking, clean, and again... they kick ass. Welcome to town..!!! read more

Outstanding! I just had my first order at High Noon and the entire experience was pleasant from start to finish. I ordered a large Your Way pizza and all of the ingredients were fresh and abundant. The crust is fantastic and very flavorful. When I went to pick up my order, I was greeted with a warm smile and I felt welcomed immediately. The cookies at the counter look incredibly delicious and I will have to try one with my next order. I definitely plan to be back. Thanks High Noon! read more

It was okay, but the crust is too thick for my liking. Customer service was fine. Not my first choice.