Hilby&#x27;s

This place is SO overrated! The food is marginal at best. Salad bar has iceberg lettuce and a few…read moreother toppings - nothing more than I could whip up at home in 5 minutes.

Great food and ambiance. I look forward to going there again for the great steak and lobster combo…read moreI had. I took home leftovers that were enough for 2 more meals. The staff was friendly and came at exactly the right time to take our drink and food orders. The bartenders made a good cocktail

Menu as of June 2025

See all

Scallops, ribeye and mashed potatoes

Pine Tree Supper Club

3.6(46 reviews)

4.1 mi

Been waiting to try this place! Under new ownership and they are so friendly and made our…read moreexperience fantastic! Husband and I both thought it was the best French onion soup we've ever had! I even tried to get the secret from the chef! Full salad bar that everyone craves when they go to a supper club! Huge portions! I must have had a pound of sautéed mushrooms and a whole onion on my steak. Great bartender too except I didn't get any pickled mushrooms for my old fashioned because they were out. Luckily I lived to see another day! Cute back room to watch a Brewer game too with a drink in hand. Please don't go here because I don't want to ever have to wait hours to get in

On 4/10/26, we got to the restaurant at 6.30 and didn't get our table until 8pm and when they…read morebought the salad the carrots were dried out, the tomatoes were hard, and when they bought out the dinners they were Cold , my partner got the wrong patatos, I ordered mushrooms and onions and they were cold. And my partners steak looked terrible. My steak was cold to the touch and when I asked to talk to the manager I was told there wasn't one. We refused to pay for a meal we couldn't eat and we left.

Now offer twice baked potatoes

No longer a shared salad bowl

See all

Potato ham soup

Jolly Roger's Pizzeria

4.4(30 reviews)

0.2 mi

Food was okay. Nachos are like nachos you would get from a school lunch. Pizza was decent. Wait…read moretime was insane. We waited almost a full hour for our food while dinning in. Drinks were never refilled. Would not recommend.

It's a little bit of a drive for me but on Wednesday the special is awesome, you basically get free…read moredesert. You only need to buy a large pizza. The food is pretty good the service has never been bad and the overall look is pirate themed. I don't come here as much as id like but if I do its on Wednesday.

Jolly Bob on left

See all

Harvey's Restaurant

2.3(4 reviews)

0.0 mi

Food.. No. Literal, raw bacon on my burger, and kitchen sent different bacon to correct it? Didn't…read moretake back anything, just sent a plate with new bacon, still raw. RAW bacon.. Contaminant no? Also raw fries. Burgers were actually, gray. I'm sad to see this considering how great the food used to be..

Over priced and under staffed! Stay far-far away from this place. Food is average at best!read more

See all

Black Otter Supper Club

3.9(179 reviews)

6.5 mi

My wife and I went to the Black Otter for our anniversary. It was our first time there. When we…read morearrived we checked in and were given a number. We sat at the bar and ordered our first drink as we waited for our table. Before we were seated, our order was taken. I had the queen prime rib, my wife had the seafood platter. After a short wait, we were seated at our table and were invited to the salad bar. Unlike other supper clubs, there are servers at the salad bar and they give you whatever you like and as much as you like. I was served by a very young looking server, he was no more than 14 years old, but was courteous and trained well. After we sat back down at the table, our appetizer as well as the bread arrived. The cheese curds were excellent. Vey tasty. The salad bar was also very tasty and the vegetables were crisp and the soup was fantastic. Our meal arrived shortly after, by this time, my wife and I were staring at each other wondering if we had left any room for our meal...we did...slightly. The prime rib was phenomenal. Medium rare. Seasoned well. Very good. The seafood platter, was generous. Lots of fish. Perch, bluegill, walleye, haddock, shrimp, scallops, all very well prepared and my wife enjoyed the sampling of seafood. The prices were as expected. After drinks, appetizers and our meal, we left and paid for the meal and it was all around $100 or so. A good place for special occasions and if you are super hungry. We will be back.

Was so excited to go here for a great meal Unfortunately,…read morethat was not the case!! Very, very disappointed again!! The ribeye was more than half fat! The manager/chef was very arrogant and rude!! Our waitress was very, very nice.

Salad bar

Steak and potatoes

See all

Hardtails Saloon

5.0(8 reviews)

6.2 mi

3rd visit today. Omelet was excellent and huge. Wife had the pancakes and said they were probably…read morethe best she has ever had at a restaurant. Service was quick and very friendly. It is a shame we are 1300 miles away or we would visit more often. Thanks for another great meal.

Sunday breakfast is great plus the specials change every week also…read more My son and I love the Monday wings and fries,5-9 (he's boneless barbecue and I'm bone in hot)

See all

AWESOME ATMOSPHERE! !!

Marly's Restaurant

3.2(13 reviews)

0.2 mi

Food was amazing and the service was great! Our waitress was very friendly and super helpful!read more

Went to Marley's today at 4:30 pm. There were about 12…read morecustomers already seated. We were told to seat ourselves. We sat in a booth. After about 10 minutes of not being acknowledged another couple came in and sat in the booth directly behind us. The waitress came over and brought them water and menus. My dining companion stated that we were there first. The waitress responded that our booth was another waitress's booth. She did apologize for our wait and did bring us paper placemats, but no menus or water. Just the paper placemats and she walked away. After 17 minutes of not even getting menus or service of any kind we left. I could see if they were busy but it was rather empty. There was an employee by the cash register and one making a salad at the salad bar. Neither acknowledged us as we walked by on our way out. The employee at the salad bar seemed to be making something for personal consumption, not setting up or servicing the salad bar. I can only rate the service because we never even got a chance to see a menu. The place looked rather clean, typical diner decor.

Great Hashbrowns!

See all

Ham and Cheese Omelet w/ loaded Hash Browns

Charlie's Drive-In

4.6(34 reviews)

5.8 mi

Cheap, fast, and delicious. Gosh darn it, their cheese burger hit the spot. I would go as far as to…read moresay their fries are better than Culver's guys. They are more crispy, less floppy and less greasy. I stopped in at 12:00. It was fairly busy and i got my food at 12:15 for three people. Theres a large place for kids to play too with mini cars, cornhole, and lots of shaded and unshaded seating. It has a wholesome vibe, like eating at a cookout.

Love everything about this place!! Atmosphere, food and…read moreservice is great and a real nostalgia experience in the heartlands of Midwest.

Out front

Hamburger, cheese curd, fries. I drank the root beer float too fast. Didn't get a picture. Worth the drive!

See all

Root beer float

Damn Yankees Watering Hole

2.7(22 reviews)

5.3 mi

Stopped in to check out the Friday fish fry. Had the breaded perch and it was crunchy and…read moredelicious. Service was excellent! Pretty view of the river. Reasonably priced as an added bonus. Very clean!

Wow! I could write a book on much I like this place. We walked in as a group of 9 with no warning…read more They had us seated instantly. They had drinks out to us almost immediately and had our order placed all within 15 minutes. The food did take a little longer but wow it was worth the wait. Not one of the 9 guest didn't like what they had. The food here is delicious. I couldn't eat enough of it. Almost everyone at the table finished their plate. If you're in the area this is a must!

Wolf River

Damn Yankees

See all

Side of building

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Phillip K.

10 years ago

Great food! Awesome environment. Very nice updated sports bar.

Hilby's - tradamerican - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Hilby's also viewed

Dick And Joan's 220 Club

3.3

(92 reviews)

This is a hidden gem. Fantastic food. Great salad bar. The waitress was super friendly, attentive…read moreand funny. Great broasted chicken, perch and prime rib. Side dishe were just as tasty. Putting this one in the rotation

This place has changed and it's not for the better. I love the supper club and miss it where I…read morelive now. I'm basing this rating on just my experience...others in my party like their food better than I. Both this and the last time we were there, when you arrive, you check in with the bartender and they give you the menu. Then, once you're ready to order, the server comes out to take your order. A few minutes later, they tell you which table to sit at in the dining room. I really don't like this system. I understand doing this if you're waiting for a table because you're drinking at the bar or a table because they're full. The only time we were offered to order a drink was at the bar...the server never asked. What an easy upsell! I know we could have ordered something, but we all stuck with the water as we had been out touring all day. Has she offered, I would have gotten something. 4/5 of the meals we had came with the salad bar. Which I was really looking forward to. She never directed us up there...we just went. Food was only ok. My tenderloin didn't have a lot of flavor. I couldn't eat all of it because of the fat. The meat used to be better. Other people in our group had haddock, prime rib and a hamburger. They liked theirs. The potato and salad bar were good. When you walk by the kitchen, which is at the end of the salad bar and near the bathroom, it smelled like urine. I don't know if it was one of the older people there or if it was a building issue. I'm done giving them a chance. I live out of state now and I used to look forward to going there. I'm over that, now. I'll drive out of town for a different supper club.

Stone Toad Bar & Grill

3.0

(62 reviews)

I came here for lunch on a weekday and it wasn't super busy. There was a party going on for some…read moresenior citizens but otherwise it was pretty dead. Service was quick. I ordered 1/2 order of boneless wings with the chippers with onion dip. Delicious. Great price too. Cost me a whole $10.

Horrible, can't remember the last time the whole meal was bad!!! But the perch wasn't cooked, the…read morebatter was still wet! The baked potato was black in areas and the rest was brown. The coleslaw was warm and it was 3/4 cup of liquid-gross. The topper was a molded half wet roll. Please save your $$$ go anywhere else!

Batley's Grill & Bar

3.5

(85 reviews)

If you're not subscribed to their email list, go ahead and do that! You'll get a free coupon for…read moretheir soft pretzel breadsticks with cheese. This place was hopping when we got here on Friday night. I ordered their salmon blt and enjoyed it. There are several side items to choose from. I went with their tater tots. Our server was kind and fast. Batley's is attached to the Best Western hotel so imagine they get a lot of traffic from there.

Our family of six ate here for dinner on a Monday evening on our last day in WI. We had the sirloin…read moresteak, the pork chop, the meatloaf, the prime rib sandwich, the rye sandwich and the pecan salad with shrimp. It was all very fresh and prepared perfectly. The pretzel sticks were a nice appetizer and the Moscow mules were excellent. The place was very clean and looked great. The service was also excellent. We highly recommend this restaurant and we will definitely be back the next time we visit WI.

Four Seasons Family Restaurant

3.4

(10 reviews)

If you're simply looking for food, you'll find "diner elite" here. The portions are huge and…read moreexceed your typical impression of a diner breakfast. But, who comes to a diner just for the food? You come with friends, right? Or, you simply want to chew the fat with the locals. My favorite part of Four Seasons is the wait staff. They are all super cheery and a lot of fun. You might even get a hug when you leave.

Really good food and service is solid. My breakfast is always hot and fresh. They have so many…read moreoptions. Currently loving the Irish skillet, I also really like the Greek skillet. I really appreciate that the eggs are real eggs. Sometimes places use egg substitute when you order scrambled eggs but not here. Coffee (albeit standard Neenah diner weak-not a single restaurant in this city has good coffee) is always replenished and portions are decent. For the price, this is a reliable choice.

Thirst Bar and Grill

3.7

(10 reviews)

Expensive and the food is typical of a bar, edible but nothing to go for specifically. Seems like…read moreyou are paying for the ambiance more than the quality of anything. This location has gone through a number of bar and grill businesses and I do t think this one is an improvement.

Been here several times and each time was very satisfied with the food and the service.read more

Triple O Bar & Supper Club

3.3

(15 reviews)

I went back and forth before settling on a three star review; however, the kicker was three out of…read morefour dinners being disappointing. I had seen positive things about this restaurant on Facebook, going in my expectations were high. The end result was expectations not being met. I phoned ahead and was able to make a reservation. When my group pulled into the parking lot at 5PM, it wasn't full. This is generally not a good sign for a Saturday night. When we entered, it looked old school (big bar, televisions and a pool table). I generally see this as a positive indicator. The drinks we received were well made and the bartender was a nice guy. He gave us menus and we were waited on in the bar area. Both waitresses we were served by were very neutral in having us as guests. No extra chit chat. After ordering, we were directed to our table and were told we could go to the salad bar. I was looking forward to the salad bar as other social media raved about it. It was nice and all the items were fresh; however, it wasn't very big. The soup, available on the salad bar, was very good. The homemade dinner rolls were also good. The main meal is where things went backwards. One dining partner had a scallops and ribeye combo. When it was delivered to the table, the scallops looked pathetically small and the steak looked paper thin. Unfortunately, my impression of it being bad was what my dining partner experienced. They described the scallops of having a fish stick taste. They were disappointed in the meal. Another dining partner had the beef tip special. It was well prepared and was quite a large portion. It was an enjoyable meal. As luck would have it, myself and another dining partner both ordered the Triple O ribeye, a 16 oz cut covered with mushrooms, onions and peppers. We each ordered the garlic mashed potatoes. When it was delivered to our table it looked good. Sadly, while tasting good the potatoes weren't very warm. Having to move the topping to find the steak, I found my first piece a little difficult to cut, but prepared to order. After a few bites and after the final waitress appearance, I told my dining partner that I did not think my steak was a ribeye. They said they were thinking the same thing. Although generous in size, it appeared to be sirloin steak and while well-prepared, lacking flavor. Having eaten a good chunk, I decided not to make an issue but found the steak disappointing. If you look at my other reviews, I think you find them to be pretty generous. After contemplating this for a couple of days, I'd say people may want to try another restaurant when looking for a quality supper club experience.

Food was amazing! Bartender Jo and waitress Kenzie did a wonderful job. Great service and great…read morepersonalities and hospitality! Will be back!

Greene's Pour House

3.7

(175 reviews)

Beer and packers and Greenes And beer and packers…read moreAnd some nachos and a fish sandwich and a quesadilla All the food was great Lots of beer choices and bucket specials

Pretty good bar and pub! Food is heavy, but that's to be expected for a bar! Their Bloody Mary bar…read moreon Saturdays is a great deal and very tasty!

Thirsty Perch

3.2

(13 reviews)

Great place friendly staff and owners are there often. Food is good so are the drinks. Great small…read moretown atmosphere! Highly recommend.

The view & old fashions were great. But we were under whelmed by the food. Timing was off. Food…read moreorder was wrong. Waitress was very kind and attentive. Not much she could do. Not sure we'd be back again.

Pullmans At Trolley Square

3.2

(174 reviews)