I went to Pullmans with a group of six people at noon. We were greeted and seated in a friendly manner. They were well prepared for our group. Everyone had something different, and all enjoyed their food. I had a portobello mushroom sandwich and would definitely have it again. I like the ambiance too. A very pleasant dining experience. read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - Portabello mushroom sandwich - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Not bad but nothing exciting. Odd cheese curds. Decent but not incredible walleye sandwiches. Too much bread - if you want a big roll, get some Leisenheimers. I'd go back but I'm not dreaming of it. Really good service! read more

Went for 5pm, it wasn't crowed, people dining inside and out, its right on the river, so beautiful venue. Old Fashions were $8 for tall glasses, waitress was extremely nice and attentive. There were 6 of us, 4 had French dip sandwich, i had the shrimp/lobster rosado, and it was very good, lots of shrimp in it. They brought warm dinner rolls to the table, and had strawberry cheesecake for dessert. Enjoyable evening read more

I took my son and his beautiful girlfriend to Pullman's to celebrate her becoming a nurse. Because of the ambience and location, I thought I would be spending a whole lot of money. I was happily wrong. The menu is diverse, giving options, regardless of what you're hungry for. My lovely wife enjoyed a salad. I had the French dip. My son enjoyed some type of spicy chicken dish. The young lady whose achievement we were celebrating enjoyed an amazing looking chicken sandwich. To call it a chicken sandwich doesn't do it justice. It was a thing of beauty. We will be back at Pullman's whether celebrating or just going out for a delicious meal. read more

Ambiance is great. Right by the water, overlooking. Large space for large and small groups. Dim lighting. Service was okay. Did not seem like they liked their job but it was midday, late lunch on a Monday. No traffics during this time. Food was meh. Very surprising at how subpar it was. Bland options. Did like that the menu was simple. Drink menu also simple but again, the depth and taste was not there. Would come back just for view not food. Maybe drinks and view?! Happy eating! read more

See all

I like this place. Had it been nicer I would've sat outside. Ordered Chicken salad sandwich with cheese curds. Good. Waitress attentive. read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - Wonderful outside view - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

I had my wife's graduation party here after she received her PHD. Pullman's did a great job of accommodating 37 of us for the event. I had never been there before and neither had most of my attendees. I was impressed with how the establishment looked inside, beautifully decorated! Being right on the water was a plus as well. The manager met me and showed me where our three tables would be. She did a great job of explaining everything and was very helpful. Unfortunately I forgot her name but she was key to setting this up. The staff was pleasant and accommodating. They really made everyone feel at home. As far as the food goes, excellent! There wasn't one complaint. Everything was served hot and seasoned just right. I really enjoyed the Ahi tuna , yum . Several people mentioned how much they liked it there and that they wanted to come back for drinks sometime. Well done Pullman's. My wife picked the perfect spot for the celebration. We will definitely go again and again! read more

WHEELCHAIR PERSPECTIVE: Outside on the cement ramp there was a big lip that made it difficult to get the wheels over. Took many attempts. Very frustrating. Almost considered leaving. Once inside it was okay. SERVICE PERSPECTIVE: Were seated outside on the patio. The chairs all have arms on the sides and are on the smaller side. Mesh iron chairs. My sons are very tall and big and barely fit in them. Squished. Asked our server if there were armless chairs. She went to get them, but she told us the manager said "NO" Chairs from inside were not allowed outside. Waitress was friendly. FOOD: Overpriced burgers. Nothing special. ATMOSPHERE: Historic. Beautiful on the patio. OVERALL EXPERIENCE: NOT wheelchair friendly at the entrance. NOT comfortable seating. Mediocre food. Overpriced. Pleasant atmosphere. Friendly server. read more

Location was tremendous (restaurant sits right next to a river), setting was comfortable (booths, tables, and lots of large windows), service was generally genial and attentive, and the prices were reasonable. But the meal itself was problematic. Our appetizer, the Spinach Artichoke Dip, was poorly prepared and basically inedible: They used way too much mayonnaise! And it wasn't successfully incorporated into the dip, so when you used your chips to scoop out a portion, you had to work your way around the gobs of mayonnaise. The dish was also only lightly seasoned and the parmesan cheese wasn't fully melted. To the restaurant's credit, the dip's portion seemed extra-large. But that was offset by the taste. (It was a twist on the old joke from that movie: Diner #1: 'Boy, the food at this place is really terrible.' Diner #2: 'Yeah, I know; and such small portions.') I raised this politely at the time with our server. He said he would share my comment with the kitchen. What I expected to happen next, though, never occurred: 1-No one from the kitchen came out to our table to discuss; 2-No manager came to our table to offer an apology; 3-We were not offered a new replacement appetizer; 4-Our waiter did not remove the appetizer from our bill. My entree (Shrimp Scampi Pasta) was generally bland, partially maybe because the Parmesan cheese seemed to be unmelted and I could barely taste the garlic butter sauce. Yes, we'll probably return, because the location and view were amazing! But we'll be more judicious about our dining selections. read more

Very nice place, great patio along the river! Food & service were amazing! 3 of us had the Walnut Parmesan crusted haddock, best haddock we've ever had! read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - Walnut/parmesan crusted haddock! - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

The food ordered was served promptly and exceptionally prepared. We had an appetizer of giant shrimp with bang bang sauce and chose an entree salad of arugula and sesame tuna with delicious sesame dressing. Service was exceptional. Outdoor seating was delightful on a summer evening. read more

Food is just ok for the price. Nice being able to sit outside with a view of the river. Service was fine but could be more attentive on drinks. read more

I would give a zero if I could First things 1st I come here all the time but not at this time of day. So if I were you DO NOT COME HERE BEFORE 5pm. They didn't give us rolls until after we asked then we got one each LITERALLY. I asked for a strawberry mojito with "Bacardi" not Bacardi lemon or lime I can tell the difference flavor liquor give me a headache. I drunk the 1st drink not knowing the 2nd one comes it taste different I go to the bar asked if they used Bacardi he's like yeah and proceeds to pour it with lime ‍ as if I didn't want it JUST PLAIN how hard is that to understand. Then I get the salmon like I always do well done I tell the waitress this twice cause I'm like it's a different time of day and sometimes people just don't understand. They bring it out pink as hell I got loaded mash on the side she's going to say would I like to keep it no cause by the time you bring a new salmon out it a be cold. Only they never brought a new one out they brought the exact same one out still pink as hell not sure what they did. THEY LOST customers I mean regulars today didn't even try to make the situation better. Last time they messed up this bad we got free cheesecake that was so good I gave them a few more chances. Guess it's new management whatever. read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - Strawberry mojito that taste like watered down koolaid - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Had a great lunch at Pullman's. Ate outside, along the beautiful Fox River. Food was very good. I had the Fish and Chips and I thought is was one of the better Fish/Chips I have had. 2 big battered pieces of Cod along with perfectly seasoned fries. Will most defiantly be back for this meal! Unfortunately, we did experience some issues that might be hard to control. I don't know if it's the time of year, or if this is a spring/summer long issue, but the bugs were really annoying. They weren't the biting type, just the ones that crawl up your pants leg or walk around your arm or down your shirt! I guess this could easily be fixed by eating inside! The Bar and Dinning areas are pretty cool and interestingly decorated. Lots of TV's to watch the game. Our other issue was a tough one. I'm pretty sure we got a brand new waiter. He was very awkward and his inexperience was evident. I completely understand that help is tough to find, so I hope that he will be further trained and improves. I'm sure he made some mistakes in our order because it actually took us an hour and 40mins from start to finish to eat and pay for our lunch. We weren't in a big hurry, but guests were seated well after us, they ate, paid their bill and were gone before us. Part of the hold up was that for some reason he (the waiter) split our bills, then somehow lost a copy of our receipt. Too bad... the food was definitely a five star! read more

See all

I used to come to Pullmans for homecoming dinner in high school. Huge place with lots of room for large parties. Our server, Kyle, was great! My friend is gluten free and he brought her a separate little basket of gluten free toast, so thoughtful. We both got the salmon, delicious! I got the Thai ginger glaze (sort of a teriyaki base, very good) and my friend got the dill - both good but I'd recommend the Thai. I'd get cheese curds next time, they looked great. read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - Salmon with Thai Ginger Glaze - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

Came here with a large group to celebrate my cousins graduation and we all had a great time! The service was good and the food was delicious. I got the tenderloin and it was cooked to a perfect medium rare. The prices are a little high but the atmosphere and scenery make up for it. I would highly recommend! read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - Tenderloin with mashed potatoes and broccoli - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

I was here with a group of 8 on a Friday night. Since we were having a special family dinner, we had called ahead to make reservations, and they put us in a private room off to the side (not sure if that was asked for, or just given, but either way a nice touch). We had a server who was also attending to the bar/room outside our private room, so her service was a little slow, but she was very friendly and accommodating with our couple of special requests. We ordered calamari, cheese curds, and the combo platter for appetizers, and everything was good (the cheese curds were nice and soft how I like them). I had the pecan chicken wrap for my dinner, with sweet potato fries, and that was kind of a letdown. The chicken in the wrap was dry, and although it had a sauce it wasn't evenly distributed through so it didn't help (I'd get one bite of just dry chicken and the next bite would be just sauce). The sweet potato fries had good flavor, but were overcooked. I did enjoy the flavor of the garden tortilla used on my wrap, though. Since there was a (small) bar outside our room, people started gathering there and it got kind of loud, even with the doors to our room shut (they were also glass doors so we could see out/others could see in). The room was also pretty cold. Prices were very reasonable, though, and since they were able to give us a private room and help with our requests, I'll give them them benefit of the doubt and do 4 stars. read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - Pecan Chicken Wrap with sweet potato fries - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Lovely menu variety and use of quality ingredients. Outdoor seating was spacious and comfy along the Fox River. Server Stephanie was friendly and food was timely! Seasonal drinks (yay!) with fresh herbs and garnishes just added to the experience. We definitely will be back again! read more

The location is great, right on the river, outside dining is awesome & cocktails & appetizers while watching a band outside in the summer is amazing;) Inside dining room is spacious. The food is ok. The service is ok. Definitely a place to cocktail & pizza outside during the summer listening to the band. read more

What a great find! Sat on the outside patio overlooking the river. Husband and I split the french onion soup and each had a salad. Everything we had was delicious. Brian our server was very attentive and friendly. Would stop again next time we are driving through Appleton. read more

Just visiting Appleton and went for lunch. We got here around 3pm for a late lunch. Everything was quick, our table, drinks, food. The food was good, nothing special I'd drive across the country for, again. We sat outside which was nice to do for a change. When we left Louisiana we had highs of 105, get here and it's 79! So yes we sat outside! read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - Toast Italian - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Stopped in here for dinner while traveling for business. The decor is adorable! The staff was nice. Prices seemed reasonable but it seemed like way too much food! I asked if I could get a small portion of anything on the dinner menu (since I can still hear my mom yelling at me to clean my plate) and they let me get something off the lunch menu. It was still more than enough food for dinner and tasted fantastic! I had a glass of wine with my dinner and then tried their Irish Mule special drink and both were also very good! read more

See all

Our dinner was fantastic! Everyone loved what they ordered, appetizers were great and the specialty cocktails were too! Cant wait to come back next time I'm in the area. Service was good, we got our appetizer before we got our drinks but they followed shortly after. I had the portobella mushroom sandwich w sweet potato fries. read more

Very good food and very good service! The restaurant is beautiful. Loved the crab Rangoon dip!

Just got done eating at Pullmans. The saltiest food I've had in a long time. My chicken consisted of mostly fat. The stir fry seemed like it came straight from the freezer and my burger was well undercooked. The pulled pork was mid. Not that great of service... never filled up my water. Resturant wasn't busy at all yet the service sucked. Wouldn't recommend to a friend. read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

Had dinner there today. Normally Pullmans is one of our preferred restaurants for tasty quality food. Ordered the Friday perch dinner special and the Grilled Salmon dinner for my wife. She stated the Salmon was good but smothered in dill sauce. Knowing that, she would have ordered sauce on the side. The perch seemed over breaded and deep fried to a dark redish brown, instead of light golden brown. It was crunchy and I would say over done. If that is their normal method, I won't order it again, which I wont anyway. A side note, being Friday I was looking forward to having clam chowder soup. Not on the menu. Disappointed. read more

Discombobulated waiter, salty food of sub par quality, slow service, bad cocktails. Not good experience and actually embarrassing for this resturant. Hard pass. read more

Food and ambiance is outstanding. The servers were top notch and attentive. What a great place...on the river, plenty of seating...just lovely. Great place for meeting or special occasions! read more

We went to Pullmans for the first time on 12/28/19. We stopped here before we went to the comedy club which was right across the street. We went for dinner around 5:30 PM so it wasn't too busy since it was a little earlier in the evening. There were six of us total in our group. We got seated right away. The The server was friendly and attentive. My husband and I had the chicken Cordon Bleu and the salmon with lobster sauce. We were very happy with our dinner selections. They were tasty and well prepared. The rest of the people in our group were happy with their dinners as well. We would definitely go back to Pullmans! read more

See all

Had the NY strip and a baked potato, it was good, needed something else though. I'd go back to figure out just what it was missing! *update* I did forget to mention- the service was great and I did have this vanilla bean cheesecake that was great. I will definitely go back! read more

Food and service were great! It was recommended to me and I would would recommend as well

Nice ambiance. Food was ok. Burger was pretty greasy and onion rings not crisp at all. Tried a bit of my friend's mushroom ravioli which was actually really tasty but very salty. read more

Over-priced, Bennigans-quality food. The surf and turf (8oz filet, 4 fried shrimp with a side) was $30. The filet was the lowest quality they could get away with and there wasn't anything special about the shrimp or side (not great but not bad either). The kicker was when I ordered a parmesan crusted topping for the steak, and got lied to about it by the server when asking why there was no topping. "It's infused in the meat". How do you "infuse" something when it's supposed to be a topping? Won't go back. If you want better food for similar prices just go to Apollon or Rye up the street. read more

I absolutely love to go to Pullman's in the summer time. Their outside patio is second to none with a huge man made waterfall, 5-6 gas fireplaces for your private use with padded lounge chairs, and drinks/appetizers available with wait...all located on the edge of the Fox river down in the locks of Appleton. I'm a bit of a regular and love their Southwest chicken wrap or pizza. Others rave about their Lobster bisque soup. There is live music on Tuesday evenings in the summer as well. Many use this venue for wedding receptions or large parties. Outside dining available at patio tables with full menu offered. read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - Outside patio - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

See all

One of the best tenderloins I've ever had, bacon wrapped with blu cheese so yummy! The black cherry old fashioned was delicious as well! Food and atmosphere on the river side was a definite 5/5! The only upsetting part was the fact we were going for another round of drinks and were going to get dessert as well. We were given our checks immediately after our plates were cleared without a second thought. Sort of disappointing considering Cheesecake Factory cheesecake would have been an outstanding top to our fantastic meal.. good thing Culver's custard also hit the spot! Considering it was the waitress and not the restaurant that ruined the fabulous experience, I fully recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a great night out with an outstanding meal! Just hope you get better service that we experienced. read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - Bacon wrapped tenderloin with blu cheese dressing, red skin mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

It must have been an off night or perhaps an unhappy waitress serving us. My wife and I went here for dinner on Friday,6/2,23, evening. Waited patiently at the bar with couple drinks. It wasn't a long wait as we didn't even finish our cocktail drinks. We got our table and put in our dinner order right away. 30 mins went by and haven't seen the waitress back or no food. 10 mins later (40 mins after we put in our order) the waitress came out and let us know that they ran out of perch (I ordered the lake perch) and if I would like to order another dish, I put in another dish thinking that it would just be another 10 mins before my order would be ready. We waited another 30 mins and no food. So after over 1 hr of waiting and very inattentive waitress, we decided to leave. I would have stayed if the waitress would have asked if we wanted to order any drinks while we waited. She only stopped by our table twice. I've been to this restaurant several times before and this is the worst service I've had! Will not be back. read more

I hate to do this. I wasn't even going to post about this until I talked to the manager and was so upset with how they handled the situation. We went there for dinner and the experience was over all good. But a few hours later I became horribly sick with food poisoning. (I knew it was from dinner because I hadn't eaten anything else that day and didn't feel well after leaving the restaurant). I was miserably sick for the better part of 24 hours and another 24 to recover from what my body had been through. Out of concern of anyone else getting sick I called and talked to a manager. When I told her I had gotten sick she didn't even care. There was no apology. Her response was "...well we make those things fresh every day so I don't know what to tell you". I was shocked. read more

Met here with 4 generations of my family. Unfortunately, the rain forced us to dine inside as the river view is wonderful. I had the Pullman's Fillet with the Appleton Brewing Company's Hefeweizen. The beer is excellent, and worth a trip to the Fox Cities. The mushroom risotto was perfectly prepared and served. The broccoli cook to perfection with just enough "crunch". My steak was almost everything I enjoy in a tenderloin. Unfortunately, somewhere between the tenderloin itself, and the bacon & bleu cheese sauce, too much salt was added. However, I would return again, as we all enjoyed our Friday Night out. read more

Pullmans At Trolley Square - American Near Me - Appleton, Wisconsin

In my opinion it's indisputable that the food here is great-- well worth the price in amount and quality. However, the service was not what I expected. We had a family dinner here with a party of 8, and we were seated within a few minutes when our host went out of his way to create an area for us. We all ordered our drinks, got some appetizers for the table, and everything was great up until the point that we ordered our entrees. Six of us got their entrees while two of us (myself included) were told there was a slight delay and ours would be out shortly. About fifteen minutes later, we got our food. I had the lobster ravioli which was to die for, and another woman in our party ordered fish with some sort of glaze. The ingredients weren't fully listed on the menu and it wasn't what she was expecting, so she apologetically sent it back and asked for fish without the glaze. Our server said this happened often with that particular dish and she was happy to oblige. Thirty minutes later, we had all finished our food while the last person was still waiting for the return of her dish. When we asked the server what was going on she looked surprised and ran off to the kitchen. One of the cooks came out shortly after to apologize and gave her a gift card to the restaurant. She never got her food. When the check came, the fish dish was still on it. We were a bit confused because we figured the gift card had been an apology thing, not a complicated way of paying for a dish we never received. When we sent the check back and asked about it, I decided to step out for a cigarette and overheard our server talking to a man who appeared to be the manager. All I heard was "Seriously? That table again?" Before he saw me and stopped talking and promptly walked inside. I get that the food industry is a pain, I've been there on both the server side and the management side but to be made fun of for expecting to not have to pay for a dish that was never eaten, let alone delivered to our table, is a bit rude and outlandish. This restaurant has been the spot for many family get togethers in the past but I don't think that tradition will continue. Maybe I'll try again sometime in the future but not anytime soon. read more

First time to eat at this restaurant that I had very good reviews. Our experience with a large work group was matched to reputation. Service was good & atmosphere was nice with the original Green Bay Trolley Car being displayed. I got the crab cakes which was way larger than expected. The crab cakes were tasty & came with 3 shaped like large pancakes. The chocolate cake desert had nice presentation & was enough for 2 people & very tasty. read more

See all