I love this place. The atmosphere is unpretentious but clean They have managed to bring the best of the Philly sandwich scene to Indy. Down to the Wiz. Check it out! read more

Counter service deli on the outskirts of Butler university. Service when ordering was marginal. My wife didn't care for it but I attributed it to cultural differences and the way Philly folks are. I had the PhillySpecial which was good but I would have gotten a simpler Philly if I had to do it again. Too much going on there. Wife had the bacon wrapped hot dog (can't remember menu name) but it was amazing! We had the loaded beer cheese fries too and they were the bomb. This is a PA/Philly joint so if you like the Eagles and Phillies, it is your vibe for sure. Right next to a brewery as well which had great beer. You can order your food and sit at the brewery bar. Highly recommend. read more

Went with a friend and had 2 basic cheesesteaks and split chilli cheese fries. The food was basic and bland. Nothing special. I can think of 3 better cheesesteaks in Indy off the top of my head and they would've been less expensive. Tried to buy a beer at the bar but the guy running the bar was so far in the weeds with his 3 customers, I just gave up after 5-10 minutes of waiting. I'm still trying to figure out how this place has such a high rating. I won't be back read more

This was my first visit. I had no idea it was trivia night. Everyone was friendly. The bathroom was clean. They offered indoor and outdoor seating. It took about 40m for us to get our food. I ordered the jackfruit hoagie. It lacked flavor and seasoning. I did however enjoy the vegan sausage and fries. I was told that the chicken philly was pretty good. read more

See all

Okay, I've ordered carry out sandwiches many times and they get 4 and 5 stars. I ate in this time and ordered their chilly and cheese dog and red skinned potato salad. The dog was overstuffed with chili and cheese, quite messy. I wonder if any of the staff tried eating it. Anyway the salad was a little cup of large-ish cut red potatoes and mayo. Its grandma's recipe. My grandma did better. read more

They're very generous. That the first thing that comes to mind. A very generous amount of protein. Good flavor. Not too many condiments, which is what a lot of hoagie shops do wrong. So far, I've tried their cheesesteak hoagie and a roast beef sandwich. Both solid! No complaints at all. We Door Dashed twice in a week, so I can't speak to the inside, decor, bathrooms, service, etc., but the sandwiches were packaged up well. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Cheesesteak Hoagie - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Really laid-back place to come to when you want an authentic Philly cheesesteak or a couple drinks. I have read that they order some of their ingredients from Jersey and Pennsylvania so that is pretty cool. It is my favorite place in the 317 when craving a traditional cheesesteak! read more

Hoagies & Hops - Not a beer girl so red wine it is! An accidental big pour but no complaints here - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I came with my coworkers for lunch but we had to order to go to make sure we could get back to office on time. The service was good. I ordered the Hog Island Italian sandwich which was tasty and big! I also ordered fries. It was kind of dark inside for ambiance. Overall it was cool and I would come back read more

Had a great evening at Hoagies and Hops. We quickly had our order taken, and plenty of tables to sit at. Felt clean, and not too loud despite sitting close to the bar. The food was fantastic. I had a classic Philly cheesesteak- seasoned well, plenty of cheese and toppings. The Philly fries were well seasoned (not too salty), and packed with flavor. Loved that they carried ash and elm cider and support a local brewery. Will definitely return. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Classic cheesesteak with lettuce - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

If you want an authentic cheesesteak, and this is the only place to go. Whether you eat it there or take it home it's absolutely fantastic counter. Staff is always polite and friendly. read more

Hoagies & Hops - The counter - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Absolutely delicious! And they have great beers on tap. I always get my sandwich quickly and exactly how I ordered it, can't guarantee I keep clean though. There are many regulars who come here and I can see why, everyone it so nice. It's not a white table cloth experience but it's clean and there is lots of seating available for any sized group. Perfect walking distance to Butler. read more

Finally got the opportunity to try this place and I can't believe it's taken me this long to come here. When we first came in it was a little confusing as we wasn't sure how the ordering process for sure went but once someone came from the back it went quick and smooth. You order at the counter and then you get your drink yourself and then they let you know when your food is ready and you can go to the other side and grab a beer. They offer a tab or pay as you drink. They have a decent amount of seating on both sides and outside. Food came out fast and fresh and piping hot We both ordered the large cheesesteak traditional and wow was it was huge we could have easily split it. The fries and onion rings were decent but nothing special about them Only complaint I had was I wish the beer glasses were cold. It caused the beer to get warm too quick. Other than that I will definitely be returning. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I would give this place another shot but our sandwiches were pretty average especially for the price. We also got some sort of molasses brownie. I think is the best way I could describe it. I want to say it was called the sidecar. I'm trying to be polite but it was not good and I will eat literally anything especially sweets. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Heard good things about H&H (that's what the cool kids call it (jk I have no idea if that's true)) but wasn't impressed. TO BE FAIR I ordered carryout and I'm sure that eating at the restaurant would be better for the ambiance and freshness of the food. But, I did order a regular philly cheesesteak with fried onions and provolone cheese and that shit was dry as hell. Needed some juices of any kind. I'll definitely try this place again due to their variety of subs, and maybe I made a mistake by not ordering it the right way. Second chances, people. read more

Super indulgent food, delicious, and a great choice in this area. We got it to go and had a car picnic ahead of an event at Butler. It was a little too messy (and soggy) for us considering the car situation, but I still recommend it. read more

Hot dogs were phenomenal to say the least. I wanted to try everything on the menu! Everything we ordered was perfect, ambience was fun and casual and the staff were great. read more

See all

Stoped in for a Hog Island sandwich. As usual the service was courteous and fast. This sandwich is packed full of flavor with meats and veggies!! I love this place and can't wait to come back for another sandwich! read more

Hoagies & Hops - Hog Island - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Happened in during a Penn State football watch party. What a fun atmosphere! Hot dogs, veggie offerings, sandwiches and pretzels were all great. Soda fountain or Chilly Water Beer....decisions decisions! Mama Tried was the perfect pairing. Fun time, great food, thank you! read more

Hoagies & Hops - Chili Cheese Dog, Philly Pretzel, Keystone Hoagie - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Every time I work at Butler, I pass by this little place...today I decided to give it a try. Finding parking was the only thing I figured would be a little bit of a challenge. Not bad plus I got a little walk in a block or two. Cute neighborhood. As soon as I walked in I was greeted by the owner Christina and her energy is just incredibly lovely. Friendly and welcoming but also very informative. I love that she gave me recommendations for items to try and I'll definitely have to come back and try the things I didn't today. Back to the food, it's a bit cool out so I had my heart set on a warm sandwich rather than a cold one. I got the Philly cheese with onions and provolone with a side of her Nan's potato salad. As I waited for my food I looked around and it's such a cute little place. It's an Eagle's (Philly) decor along with Indy's teams being represented as well. I love that I can have a Philly steak cheese sandwich and not have to go to PA. My sandwich was great. Fresh and delicious, the bread was definitely nothing from Indy and anyone who knows me knows I do love a good bread. The potato salad was absolutely delicious. Simple but very tasty. I love that it was Christina's Nan's recipe. Sure was a nice little lunch visit. I'm not much of a drinker but it's neat it's connected with Chilly Water. Definitely will have to check out some of the other menu items she mentioned. Check it out if you're looking for a little taste of Philly. You won't be disappointed. Supporting small businesses is what's up read more

See all

I won a gift card on Instagram from a person I follow so my family and I visited Hoagies & Hops on a week night! The owner was super friendly and helpful when ordering. They were busy but they were moving and fulfilling orders fast! We order 3 kids meals and two hoagies with fries and onion rings. The food had great flavor and tasted very fresh. We sat outside and enjoyed the nice evening. Everything tasted great and we will definitely be back! read more

Sportsy decor Friendly staff Kid friendly Bar connected What more do you need?! Had my first visit to Hoagies & Hops today and it won't be the last! Kids had a grilled cheese meal that comes with fries and a drink for about $7 which is a good price on my opinion. We ordered Chicken Phillys, I loved that the cheese and grilled onions made the sandwich gooey without making the bread super soggy. I had both provolone and cheese wiz on my sandwich and loved it! Fries were perfectly seasoned! Next time I'll get them with cheese because why not! They have a selection of desserts too. Didn't try any this time but I saw some cookies and Oreo balls that I'll definitely get next time I stop by! This place has been on the Devour Indy selection as well so be sure to check them out! read more

See all

This is the best cheesesteak I have had in Indianapolis and can't wait to go back and try other items off of the menu! They have a great patio and connected to a brewery if you want a beer with your hoagie. I inhaled the cheesesteak so I didn't get a picture but the bread was so soft, steak and onions were cooked to perfection, and is was smothered in cheese. Would love a downtown location! read more

I have been here a few times and service has been hit-or-miss. The staff can sometimes be really nice or they can be straight up rude. The food can also come out really great or... not so great . During my last visit I stopped in for carryout to take back to work with another coworker who is from Pennsylvania and is obsessed with this place. Our food came out as it was supposed to (not burnt or missing ingredients like the last time I visited for dine-in). If every visit was like that one, then I would come here more often. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I stopped in here really quick one day after work because I heard they had some vegan/vegetarian options so I was excited to try them out. I'm a tad ashamed at how fast I inhaled my hot dog lol but it was so good. I'd also ordered the onion rings which were also tasty. I promptly ordered one to go also. I have been able to return for a 2nd visit and also tried the veggie fries. The flavors of the beer cheese with other veggies go together well but did need a tiny bit of seasoning. The atmosphere was very laid back and they seem to favor a specific city lol. It does have an adjoining bar area on the other side. read more

See all

Yeah we drove this time, picked it up, and sped home. When it's hot 5/5. We've been back multiple times and we are going to keep coming back. Still haven't sat inside their low lit and chill dining area (my diehard penguins fan girlfriend finds the flyer banner 'offensive') their friendly and efficient staff and delicious food makes it easy for me too recommend them whole heartedly read more

Hoagies & Hops - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I don't have enough hoagie experience to be fair... this is my 2nd Cheesesteak in my life. It was good but not better than the one I got in Philly but good... fresh, grilled onions, cheesy and pickles... fries could be better. read more

See all

Love the proximity to my house this great sandwich place is. As much as I'd to like the uber cheesy and heavy cheesesteak, I much prefer their cheesesteak that is lighter with the lettuce tomato and onion. The subs are super filling - and I love that they have the brewery next door. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

It was packed for Saturday lunch. Tried their two vegetarian subs: Little it's veggie, Reading terminal. I would return for the Reading terminal sandwich. The Little its veggie hot sandwich was bland, although it was packed with filling. The employees were working with a sense of urgency, trying to fill orders, even as they were busy with guests eating in-house and some takeout orders too. Street parking is limited, but there are some spaces in the surrounding area. read more

This is located very close to Butler. There's no parking lot so you just park on the street. I went during the week so it was easy to find a spot around the block. The place had trivia going on. I did not participate but it looked fun. They both have cold and hot subs. I chose the cheesesteak sub (hot). You can choose the meat and cheese. I chose ribeye and American cheese. My order only took 5 minutes which was nice as I was very hungry. The place did not seem so busy but inside was a bit dirty (tables and especially the floor). It was nice outside so we sat in the patio. The cheesesteak, as my photo shows, was generous amount. I loved it. It was juicy and satisfying. I am not a huge fan of subs and don't usually order one, but I liked this one a lot! If you like hanging out with drinks, subs while playing trivia this place is perfect. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Cheesesteak - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I grew up just outside of Philadelphia, so I was excited to try Hoagies & Hops while I was out running errands. I ordered my hoagie without cheese, as I have a milk allergy. I made sure to tell the lady at the register about the allergy, and she said it was no problem. Ordered a side of fries as well, both to go. The wait was quick, and my food was soon ready. I got my bag and headed to my car. Once I arrived at my car, I unwrapped the sandwich to check for cheese. I didn't see any, so I headed on my way. I was three bites in when I found it: provolone cheese. I had to spit out the bite in my mouth and rush home; luckily I hadn't eaten much and my reaction was minor. The sandwich tasted good (what I ate of it), and the fries were great (maybe salted a tad too heavily). Unfortunately, I probably won't be back because I can't trust them to adhere to my specifications (no cheese) when preparing my order. read more

Amazing hoagies & cheesesteaks! Many items shipped in from Philly. Be prepared to wait on your order whether you pre-order or walk in. They have small eat in dining area, but also patio seating in front. They also share a pass through to a small wine bar next door. read more

What I ordered: Blood on the Tracks, Blood Orange IPA, 7.4% - refreshing, nice orange bite! Classic Cheesesteak, with light onion and whiz, crinkle fries with whiz on the side - I've been searching high and low for a cheesesteak that reminded me of Woody's in Atlanta, the search is over, this is it! Love love love! Tender meat, a nice hoagie roll, perfect amount of cheese, did not make bread soggy! Ambiance feels homey, very cute, small place, connected to Chilly Water, a brewery. Service was friendly, pretty quiet in here today. Parking located on either side, does have a ramp for easy accessibility. Sandwiches and sides sold separately read more

Hoagies & Hops - Cheesesteak Hoagie - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

After a family day at Newfields Museum we decided cheese steaks sound good so jumped on over. This place does not disappoint. It truly is the closest tasting steak & cheese I've had outside of Philadelphia. All three of us left very full and happy. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I had been wanting a Philly cheesesteak for two months. I didn't want to cheat myself and go Subway Or Penn Station. I needed a real deal cheesesteak. I'm so glad I didn't settle for anything lesser than. H&H got me right! Bread quality was perfect. I got a mixture of Cooper Sharp and American. The onions were the perfect size and cooked to perfection. The steak was perfectly seasoned, sliced and cooked. I had to earn this cheat meal and it was worth every calorie! Also, the owner is super nice. I didn't see her this time, but every time I do she's super sweet. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Cheesesteak - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I LOVE THIS PLACE!!! I have had several different sandwiches here, and I cannot choose a favorite. They have their rolls shipped in from Philly every week. They use fresh meats, cheeses and veggies. One side is the restaurant, and the other is a bar. It's a very cool sports bar vibe, even with all the Philadelphia Eagles stuff on the wall. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Brotherly Love and Onion Rings - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Amazing food! went on the search for the best philly in town, and this has won! the phillys wwre amazing, super hot when they came out, i got two traditional and it was great read more

See all

On the corner of 42nd and Boulevard this business is in the same building with Chilli Water Butler Brewing. Philadelphia sports memorabilia hangs on the walls. Bread is flown in from Jersey. Walk up to the register to order your Hoagie (Philly Style Cheesesteaks, various sandwiches, wings, salads and sides of onion rings and fries. Also a cooler with deserts. I had a special, a 6 inch London Broil with spicey cheese whiz and a side of fries. The sandwiches and fries were freshly made. They have a fountain machine and a cooler for various sodas and water. Walk to the South side of the establishment to get a pour of some great beers, ciders and fizzy lifting drinks. Although the place is not large it offers adequate seating. Can be a bit noisy when crowded. The restaurant side will seat kids. read more

See all

Absolutely delicious cheesesteak! super quick and has plenty of seating. don't make the same mistake I did and forget to add peppers or some sort! read more

See all

We visit my husband's side of the family in Reading, PA twice a year and always spend a day or two in Philly. Needless to say, we're spoiled by their world famous cheesesteak sandwiches. Hoagies and Hops in the Bulter area is as good as it gets, though, from the Cooper cheese to the long-hots, it was fantastic authentic Philly/ PA Dutch food. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Cheesesteak with Cooper cheese with fried onions and don't forget to add the long-hots, it was fantastic authentic Philly cheesesteak! - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This gem is located in the Butler Tarkington area and I don't have much to say but that they have THE BEST sandwiches in the city. They make a killer Philly Cheesesteak and their Italian Cold Cut Sandwich is amazing. The ingredients are top notch, the food is well priced for the size options and it all tastes amazing! They also sell wine and beer which is a nice addition. Some of the crafted beers are on tap. We did go on a Thursday evening and to our surprise they had a jazz band playing and they were also amazing. If you are looking for a warm and cozy neighborhood hangout with great food, live music and libations, this is your spot. There is also outdoor seating and easy parking. Will I be back? Yelp. read more

Hoagies & Hops - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana