Passed by this spot several times but never gone in. About to become regulars. I got the Philly cheesesteak and it was the comfort food I needed. We'll be back. read more

See all

Some of the best sammiches in the city!! Love both locations, they're accommodating & the food is fresh

5/5 100x over!! You order at the counter and they make your meal to order. We got the buffalo chicken wrap (hot), Italian (hot) and engine 45 (mix of chopped cheese & Philly cheese steak). Combos come with fries and a drink. The sandwiches were all amazing. Hubs loved the buffalo chicken wrap. I loved the chopped cheese. Everything was delicious and If we lived closer, I would be here more. Workers were friendly and helped give suggestions. No tables inside/ only to-go option. read more

I love the Philly cheesesteak wrap. I usually get the spinach wrap. The service is quick, the space is clean, and the food is delicious. The steak is tender and juicy! Colby cheese and other goodies finish it off! read more

A taste of the bodega comes to the Nap! The best chopped cheese you're gonna find in town! Get the seasoned waffle fries and one of the unique selection of beverages! Don't sleep on that cherry limeade slice! read more

See all

Greeted when I walked in which was awesome. Gave me time to look at the menu and didn't rush me. Very good customer service. Very clean inside and all the food areas near and everything covered. Looks terrific! Perfect anytime but platters o only during breakfast hours. there is a ramp for access and marked handicap spots in front. The door opens out with no automation, so I'm not sure if that's accessible. There is definitely no eat in. This is definitely take away inside. You can also find chips some specialty water ice cream to purchase and some candy so it's kind of a little bit like a convenience store. I ordered the New Yorker, which is hot pastrami with Swiss cheese and mustard. I upgraded to the tots and you get a can of soda as well. The sandwich was hot and delicious. It was on a roll and it had melted cheese and the meat was slightly spicy. Yum reminds me when I lived in New Jersey. I will definitely be back. read more

See all

The food is 10/10. They make it fresh, so it's hot when you get it and not sitting in a warmer. This is going to be my new favorite breakfast sandwich spot! I've actually been wanting to try this place for so long but was hesitant because of the Boar's Head recall last year. Definitely don't let that stop you from trying this place!!! The food is safe to eat, the place is clean, and they have signage posted addressing the recall and their commitment to food safety. The employees were very patient, nice, and helpful. I can see why this place has great reviews! definitely will be back! read more

See all

Good old fashioned deli!! Food is fresh and delicious !! There isn't any sitting area , it's an order and go type of place. The Cajun Chicken Sandwich was great! Also, they have a huge selection of pops from back in the day that you cannot find anywhere. I will be visiting this spot when I come back. read more

Good food if you're on the go and want some comfort food. I usually get the chicken Philly cheesesteak and fries. I also recommend the wings and fries! read more

Good food and good service and always friendly when I come and fast service, I highly recommend

First time stopping in and have to say I'm a fan and will be back!!! It's a carry out only joint, but who cares. We ordered the chopped cheese and Philly. Both were prepared fresh and in front of us. I like going to a place where I can see not only the food storage but also into the kitchen. The place was clean and the two people working were friendly. I got the chopped cheese with mustard instead of ketchup and it was delicious! My mom got the Philly cheese and loved it! She was finished before me! My new go to sandwich shop! Can't wait to come back and try the bagel egg n cheese and more sandwiches but gotta say, going to be hard to not get the chopped cheese again! read more

NY Gourmet Deli - Philly cheesesteak - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

They are off 38st going towards the west side. Sitting on the corner, you can't miss it. I've had the NY Deli out east and it's good but something about it is heavy on my stomach at both locations. I ordered the chipotle grilled chicken wrap but they were out of grilled chicken. It must be a popular item because they had a phone order who wanted the exact same thing lol Gotta keep the grilled chicken in stock NYGD! Instead, I got the crispy chicken wrap which came w/ lettuce, tomato, Mayo and Muenster cheese. I added onion. It was good but not was I had a taste for. I only could finish half due to the heaviness and my stomach gurgling through. I got potato wedges as my side, so good. With a 7up tropical, which I never had or seen but was delish. The service was great. While waiting, a phone order came in before I made it to the counter, as I was waiting to out in my order, the other gentlemen swooped in and took my order. Quick service. The staff prepped as they went along. The inside is a bodega, which is what they are going for. Boxes always out for stocking purposes and only standing room cause you won't be there long. I don't think I would go again because of ingredients used don't work for me but PLEASE go try them for yourself! read more

NY Gourmet Deli - Crispy chicken cutlet wrap but - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This place rules. Quality ingredients, tons of flavor, and reasonable prices (especially when you consider portion sizes). The staff is always friendly and they make your sandwiches fast. Awesome addition to the neighborhood. read more

NY Gourmet Deli - Sign - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Ordered lunch here today with my colleagues for the first time. I ordered a Philly cheesesteak wrap combo. My meal was made cook to order. My meal was delicious. It was busy, but meals were prepared timely. I will definitely return and recommend to others. read more

I've been seeing this spot pop up on Yelp and I knew I needed to try it! So glad I finally did!! I got the Chopped Cheese and my husband got the Tavern Fire. Both were !! The sandwiches are large and we are saving the other half for a snack later or lunch tomorrow. I don't imagine they'll last until tomorrow because we are already craving more. I can't wait to go back and try some of the other sandwiches. Tons of chips and sodas to pick from as well as a lot of snacks. Good amount of parking in their lot. Can't wait to go back! read more

Can't judge a book by its cover. The restaurant is not one that is great in ambience but the food was great. The Ruben was good. The key lime pie was down right awesome. I'd had gotten another one if not for already had gotten the last one. I would come back just for the pie. But all the food was good. read more

Beef and cheese sandwich is excellent. We will be back soon! Good prices as well. Love NY Gourmet Deli!!!!

One bite of the Philly cheesesteak sandwich and I bowed my head slightly and wagged my index finger toward heaven like I just won a championship. Ordering was easy and the food was made quickly. Debate away on what makes a good Philly cheesesteak but this one is just how I remember them in NYC. read more

NY Gourmet Deli - Deli meats and cheeses. - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I live a couple of blocks from New York deli and was so glad to see it open. I've gotten Carrie out sandwiches several times and have had consistently good experiences each time. A family favorite is the chopped cheese. Each time we've gone, there have been at least a couple of other customers at the deli. Our weight has never been longer than 10 minutes, even on busy days. My kids love, but there is a wide selection of beverages and chips more so than any other deli they've been to in Indy. They get a thrill out of trying something new each time. Personally, I'm glad to see that there are increasingly more options with slightly less sugar (example: flavored core water). That said, this is not necessarily a place to go if you're looking for a highly nutritious meal. Though, the veggies on the sandwiches I've always been fresh and there is a lot of variety regarding meat and cheeses. The gentlemen working the register as always kind and very efficient when taking our order. read more

Very clean, great customer service and an assortment of sandwiches to choose from for one's liking. Great location and easy to get to off main street. Can make any sandwich into a wrap. They offer a variety of wraps as well. You can also modify any sandwich; adding or removing items. Tried the Ragin Cajun Turkey sandwich that I made into a wrap. I omitted the cheese and mayo and requested honey mustard. And I chose to have it grilled. Grabbed a bag of Grippos Sweet Onion Maui and a brownie. Omg!!!! If anything sticks out to me from my visit, it's the brownie!!! I'll be going back this week to get another one; maybe even two. I can't remember the brand, but it tastes homemade and has everything you want in a good brownie. Get yourself a brownie. You'll thank me later. read more

See all

I wasn't sure if they were open for a while, but i finally took a chance and decided to give it a try. I am so happy that i did!! Their sandwiches are phenomenal! They use Board Head meat, so it's awesome quality and you can tell they care about the food they prepare. The service was outstanding and the man that took my order was so kind. I've been back twice in a week and sent my boyfriend back too. It's soo good and so close to home. I'm happily satisfied read more

See all

I was happy to see this place open up because who doesn't like a New York Deli? I got sandwiches for the family chop cheese, Italian with boars head meats, and a buffalo chicken wrap. All were delicious solid bread and a good portion of meat. The owner was friendly and the place was clean. I had to wait about 10min for my food to be ready so if you need it quickly I bet you can call ahead. I will definitely be back! read more

See all

Bomb! That's what I have to say about this place, amazing. I don't think highly of too many places here in Indianapolis but I'll tell you one thing the chopped cheese sandwich and number 45 which is a chopped cheese mixed with a Philly cheese steak, can't miss. I usually like to try things when they are piping hot, fresh to order, the first time my husband went I was able to try it immediately and I knew that it was a banger. The second time he went, picked it up and brought it home, it was still warm. I love the wedges, and while I don't eat pork my husband enjoyed the hot Italian sandwich, his only wishes that there were more mayo. The bread was nice and soft and just flavorful overall. read more

See all

After my last trip to NYC, I haven't been able to stop craving a chopped cheese sandwich. I was ecstatic (& now a little apprehensive for my wallet) to see NY Gourmet Deli open down the street. We ordered the Chopped Cheese and Bronx Special. I can only attest to the Chopped Cheese because the Bronx was gone before I could ask for a bite. He reports, "really good!". Mine was great & I was able to save half for later, it's hefty. Your sandwiches are made to order, so expect a little wait. With a few people in front of me it was probably 15-20 minutes. There are breakfast options as well at a great price as well as chips and other convenience store items. read more

See all

Cashiers was taking orders. He was super friendly, helpful and patient. Food was great. I had a lemon chicken wrap and husband had a pastrami. They both were very good and were served warm. read more

As an East Coast transplant I have missed my Montreal Subs living in California. I visited NY Gourmet Deli at the Ruckle location street twice, 5 mos apart. To say I was blown away is an understatement. This place is a hidden gem-cannot wait to go back. Unique and fresh flavor that lingers in your craving chamber long after you have eaten their deeeeeelicious subs and fries. Everything exceeded my expectations. Service Food quality Taste Pricing were excellent. The service is personable and genuine. If you are lucky to live in Indianapolis, don't miss this treat!!! read more

What a gem. NY Deli has become a favorite go-to spot for my family of 5. Our to-go orders can become quite extensive in both quantity and variety. At some sandwich establishments, this becomes a problem. Always resulting in an incorrect order or missing items. This has never been the case at NY Deli. The owner is so kind and patient. Everything is made to order and packed nicely. And like any good deli, you can grab some Boar's Head deli meat sliced for you on the spot to take home. They have a variety of chips, candy, and drinks that you can browse through while you wait and I guarantee you'll end up throwing some items on the counter to purchase even after you've already ordered. It's always clean, floors swept, counter wiped. Order anything! Everything! You cannot go wrong. We are so happy that this spot has found a home near our neighborhood. read more

great people great food. solid prices and high quality meat and bread. great selection of drinks and chips too

Cheesesteak is phenomenal! Juicy and perfectly balance with toppings and the bread is crusty yet soft and delicate which is an unheard of combo in the fast food sub shops. Looking forward to trying the pastrami next. On a side note the empty box/bag from my sandwich smelled so delicious it made me crave it again. Do y'all understand now? read more

10/10 recommend my new favorite sandwich shop! I've been here twice now and have ordered the Philly Cheesesteak both times. Next time I go I will definitely be trying something new. Really nice people and great food! I recommend calling ahead and ordering if you don't want to wait 10-15 in the shop. read more

Best pastrami sandwich in the city! Love that this NY deli is in the neighborhood. I really enjoy their breakfast sandwiches as well. The owner is kind and always helpful. read more

NY Gourmet Deli - Pastrami sandwich with pepper jack cheese add onions! So so good. - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Chopped cheese in Indy - what else do you need? Service is always quick, staff is friendly. Quickly became a weekly staple after moving into the area. read more

NY Gourmet Deli - Chopped Cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I've stopped by here for food a few times now. The man at the counter is always friendly and helpful. Food is prepared to order so you have to wait a few minutes. The store has many different drinks and unusual snacks/chips to take with you. There is no seating. The store is clean. read more

The most delicious, chill, and friendly deli in the whole city. They got a life long customer outta me all day!

Delicious and perfect food every time. Best part? They never ask for a tip. They never do that weird turn of the screen "It's going to ask you a question?" This place is amazing! Best chopped cheese, best OG BLT, amazing Reuben. Fries and tater tots are so hot! Go here now. read more

Food was good and not too long of a wait. Their phone number wasn't available on yelp, but if you google it came up.

My daughter and I were looking for somewhere to eat lunch after a college visit to Butler. Happy to say we found NY Gourmet Deli. My daughter had the grilled cheese and I had the Italian. The sandwiches were very good and reasonably priced. The service was friendly. Only issue for us is that we needed to eat our sandwiches in the car as there are no tables. Check this place out. I know I will be back the next time I am in Indianapolis. read more

Let me start by echoing everyone else's sentiments - welcoming, friendly service. High quality sandwiches from the bread to the meats, cheese and veg. Everything made fresh to order. Breakfast options also look yummy so will need to try those, too! Love that they have Grippos, Mike Sells and other chips I have not heard of but look delicious and must try. And they have Tahitian Treat! Looking forward to coming back and trying more. read more

Yum! We've been here twice now and I love this place. My boys love the cheeseburgers and I love the Sammy. We highly recommend this neighborhood gem. The staff is great as well and took good care of us. read more

See all

Stopped by here the other day and it was delicious. Great, fast service. Got two chopped cheese, mozz sticks and of course the bev. Would recommend and will be returning. read more