Cara was the best server!!!! You should definitely request her section next time you go. Food was delicious as well!

I love this location! Compared to the downtown spot, it's smaller but has a cozy, neighborhood feel. I especially enjoy sitting by the garage door cut-out, great people watching. I stopped in for lunch and had the smoked brisket sandwich (amazing), which comes with potato chips. The staff is always helpful and very friendly here. Small patio outside as well! read more

Fat Dan's - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Wife and I stop in Fat Dans today and had lunch. Love Fat Dans this was my second visit. The smoked wings are some of the best we have ever had! We order extra just to take them home and eat later. We also ordered the Ribs, what a disappointment! Everything we ever had there has been very good except the Ribs! They were under cooked and no flavor. My rating above is based on the ribs. Please fix your ribs! read more

My friend Alana & I went because we had been talking about it for weeks! They understood the assignment. Sat outside enjoy the weather. I believe our server was the only server, serving over 6 tables and she was great. She checked in, brought samples. Only minor downside is we asked for a one extra pickle since we were splitting our sammy & she brought out several & charged us without a a heads up. We ordered a 10 count wing (honey Dijon & their hot sauce on the side) m, fries & their version of a patty melt called a fatty melt. Everything and I mean everything was DELICIOUS! We were absolutely satisfied. Not one of our top Patty melts but very delicious. We put malt vinegar on our "fries," it's like 2 different cut style fries and house made chips-AHMAZING!! So happy we made it for lunch. Absolutely delicious & such a great experience. read more

Fat Dan's - Fatty Melt, Fries & Dry Rub Wings - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

On a quest to find a good local Italian beef, and although the original Mr. Beef in Chicago remains my GOAT (thanks, The Bear!), Fat Dan's puts up a very respectable sandwich. A generous size, and I appreciated that it was wrapped in foil and served with a plastic knife and fork. I asked for mine "dipped," and felt like it could have been MORE dipped. I really like the bread sopping wet with jus, this was a little dry. Still, tasty! Be forewarned, when they say spicy giardineira, they are NOT kidding. Whew. My kiddo and I each got a sandwich (served with potato chips), which turned out to be way more food than we needed on top of sharing an order of dirty tots (with pulled pork, cheese sauce, hot sauce and scallions). We could have easily gotten away with splitting one beef, and took home enough food for at least another whole meal. The patio was lovely on a warm, fall evening, and our server was great. read more

Fat Dan's - Dirty Tots - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Great food, nice staff, boisterous atmosphere. Full menu of tasty dishes! Off street parking available. read more

I highly recommend the beef sandwich. We also ordered the Reuben which was very good. Fresh cut fries were delicious. There is a parking lot behind the building. Lots of pot holes so watch out for that. This location is near Butler University. The service was quick and friendly. I ordered my beef sandwich dry with the gravy on the side and got the usual "look" because that's not how to order it. But I don't like soggy bread. The restaurant has dive bar vibes. It was a nice place for a quick lunch after attending the Nutcracker Ballet at Clowes. read more

See all

In loving memory of Troy Reeder and William Walls, the greatest Dan's advocates of their time. You want a landing spot, let it be this. It's proven sufficient time and again. Let proof be the "going for two" order from my last visitation. First burger was so good I had to get another. I'll revisit this incident momentarily. Look at the chalkboard for display, yet as always, order an Old Style. Look over the menu and pick something different, it's all worth a goer at least once. Each loyal tenant will find a favorite, but keeps a host of viable options for rainy days and off nights. If you need a starting block, my friends swear by the "crunchy nugs" with honey mustard. What prompted this review, after many neglected opportunities to write, was my showstopper. She'd never sat before me, but has since left an impression. The Blackened Wells St. Fat Burger. I'm never afraid of a flavor-induced exclamation, yet this took a step further. Proudly sighing, some may even say moaning, next to three grown men. That's the quality of this burger. Laugh at me, sure, but don't count me a fool! This will remain my FDD staple for some time to come. My last parting word of wisdom is to get a large fry for the table. The grubby hands climbing this pile of potato is enough to get any table talking. Loosen ya right up for what's to come! Much love to Dan and his disciples, y'all rock. read more

See all

Place is super fun. Great environment and the ambiance is nice. Servers are hit or miss. They are super busy, so you don't get a friendly vibe. Food is amazing. I love their sandwiches and the fries. My gosh. I could eat a whole table full of the fries. read more

I love Fat Dans and have been coming here for years now. No matter what you get it's always fresh and delicious. Can't beat a cheeseburger and Old Style with a side of fries. Great place to watch the game whether Butler, Bears, etc. read more

Fat Dan's - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

If you're missing Chicago, this place has you covered with plenty of hometown eats and beers. Not gonna lie--the fryer oil has seen fresher days, but the wings? Worth every trip back. They're the real MVP here. read more

See all

Fat Dan Chicago barbecue is da joint. Freaking unbelievable good stuff. My rockstar favorite is smoked meatloaf sandwich on Wednesdays. It is so delicious and rich you can't eat tots too. If you have never been here you are making a big mistake. The Carmel location is just as perfect as college Avenue. College Avenue has doubled their space, so they rock 'n' roll. Definitely a shining star in the Indianapolis area for food and drink. We are lucky to have ya!!! read more

Fat Dan's has been my go to for comfort food. Went yesterday for a low key Valentine's Day lunch and had the ribs. They have always been excellent. I found them to be undercooked. Flavor was OK but not fall off the bone. They were undercooked a bit "tough" and I should have complained but did not so that's on me. Next time I will order the half slab to make sure their quality is back. Just a bit disappointed read more

See all

We stopped in for a quick lunch today after an event out of town. Service was very speedy and our food was great. My friend had Italian beef and I had the pastrami sandwich. I love the atmosphere of the bar and how it relates back to Chicago and the Chicago Cubs. They had some good drink specials, but we were unable to partake because of work. Will certainly come back again soon. read more

Fat Dan's - Hot Pastrami & Corned Beef - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The burgers are always amazing! This is my favorite spot to this day! The beers are ok, I'm here for the burgers and either tots or fries. Very so often I get chicken wings and the dry rub is the best! The bartenders are always busy but they are always on top of it! I usually sit at the bar so I can get a good view of the tv during games. On game nights is always packed but never rowdy. It's a great place to bring the family. One thing, if you're sensitive to smells, they do have an open kitchen so you'll leave smelling like it. read more

Fat Dan's - Ghost burger - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Definitely a dive bar but not sketchy. Since it's nice out finally the door all open and curbside seating also. Have a friendly welcoming staff. We have been here numerous times. Reasonable prices, super cold beer, fun happy hour! Very lively bar but also accommodating for families. Fast service but they don't push you out the door if you like to linger. Chicago dogs, beef sandwiches, tater tots, Rueben, meatloaf sandwiches on Wednesday. Nice neighborhood joint or easy walking distance to Murat. read more

We were greeted the minute we walked in. Our waiter brought water and asked for drink order. We weren't sure about the draft beer selections. We tasted two beers that the server nailed on description. I ordered a Chicago dog, my husband ordered a corn dog. (We were eating light due to dinner plans). Both were good. We ordered a chocolate porter also good. The restaurant itself is funky. Chicago signs, funny beer signs, high top tables. Just a fun place. While paying our check the waiter asked if we had a chance to look at the back side of the menu. We did not and were surprised to see many more items. Seems it would be a great place for a bar food dinner. We will give it another try! read more

Food: The burger was by far my favorite! Ribs were moist. Wings were good smoked but I think I just prefer mine fried. Beer cheese fries were good. They're creamy and very filling. They have no ranch in the facility so don't ask. lol. It's a running joke at the establishment. Service: Very good. Attentive but not overwhelming. Ambiance: Pretty good parking availability. Outdoor seating available. Tables and high bar seats available. I like how this location can open up the "garage doors" so it's open air. Makes for a nice ambiance on a really good summer day. read more

See all

We used to live in Bloomington, so we are very familiar with Fat Dans. And this location is no different - *chefs kiss*! While we always mix up the entree, my husband and I order ONE order of the most perfect fries, to share (it's a giant order). The smoked wings are some of the best I've ever had and my husband enjoyed his Italian Sausage. You really can't go wrong here, and it's so affordable! read more

Fat Dan's - Italian Sausage, Smoked Wings, and fries. - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Fat Dan's Deli is a great place to get some heavy, fried, good for the soul, bad for the heart kind of meal. We got the loaded tater tots which were incredible, and burgers which were also fantastic. This food will fill you up quick but every bite is delicious. The service here was amazing, as our server did a great job of being attentive and friendly without hovering. We sat out on the patio area which is on College Ave. which would occasionally get loud due to passing cars but was really nice for people watching and enjoying Broad Ripple. read more

Fat Dan's - Dirty Tots, Fat Dan's Fat Burger, Wells St. Fat Burger - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We love Fat Dan's! The vibe is really chill and the staff is always friendly and helpful. We love the loaded tots and I always get the Brisket. This is a spot we often take please who visit from out of town because it's consistent and delicious. read more

Fat Dan's Deli is aptly named. It'll make you fat because it's delicious. #worth it On my most recent visit, I got one of the appetizers for my meal & I was insanely full & a bit embarrassed that I ate the whole thing. It's cringingly called "You the Champ, Champ", and yes, you have to say the whole thing, otherwise the waitstaff won't know what you're trying to order. Whatever. You are an adult, you can look another adult in the eyes and cling to your dignity while ordering that thing because you'll shortly be lost in the tasty goodness of an entire basket of tater-tots, corned beef, cheese and onions. I've heard people enjoy the beer, but if you're like me & beer isn't your thing, there are still solid adult-beverage options, too. Just ask your server! read more

By farrrrrr the best wings in Indianapolis and it's not even close. They smoke their wings and they are completely fall off the bone. House made hot sauce is incredible. 10/10. I highly recommend going there as it is a great little bar with an awesome outdoor patio when it's warm. But I have also ordered wings to go many times and the quality does not change read more

Fat Dan's - Fat Dan's Slow Smoked Wings - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Fat Dan's is a charming little gem. Great food, great service great beer and music. We had burgers, pastrami, and the Rueben, smothered tots and plain French fries. Everything was outstanding. If you're looking for a chill little spot to hang out, drink a beer and have a sandwich this is it. read more

I had their Wake N Bake hamburger and it was delicious! The service was good and quick. You have to order the fries because it only comes with potato chips. (I've been told the fries are really good here.) read more

A divey, local haunt with a good range of beers, draught and bottled. Add an excellent selection of burgers, dogs & other creative sammies. Had a 'wet' Italian beef & brat sandwich today for a great lunch with friends. read more

I lived five minutes away from Fat Dan's for four years and I didn't go until I lived 30 minutes away. why? no good reason. their food is like every bar food guilty pleasure you could ever want food was amazing, service was great, and if you close one eye, it's almost like you are in the windy city! read more

Fat Dan's - Dirty Tots and IPA Beer Cheez Fries - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Showed up trying to kill some time with a craving for a burger and a beer. Saw the menu and immediately changed my mind. There's a lot on the menu that sounded great but I ended up pulling the trigger on a house smoked reuben with fries. The fries are addicting. So addicting I considered ordering more to go but I couldn't muster up a way to reheat them without losing the magic. There's random sides of a potato mixed in with like what you'd see in waffle fries. Little treasures like finding an onion ring in your fries as a young kid. The reuben had the thickest cut corned beef I've seen. The beef is the star on this bad boy, not overwhelmed with sauce or kraut. I think the thick cut beef helps hold the sandwich together better since it isn't a mountain of piled up meat equating to a lopsided sandwich. The food came out quick. Fries were fresh af and piping hot. Definitely coming back. There is too much on the menu that caught my eye not to. read more

Fat Dan's - House Smoked Reuben and Best Fries in the Universe, or Not - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Was about to order the Reuben and heard our bartender recommend the NY Fat Burger, her description sold me and I'd missed it when looking at the menu. Holy cow! So good! One of the best burgers I've had lately. Strongly recommend trying one if you stop in! read more

Fat Dan's - NY Fat burger - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Enjoyed a Sunday outing at Fat Dan's Deli on College Ave. As an avid sports fan, I loved the sports memorabilia and the many TVs for watching games. Although depicted as a sports bar, it is family friendly restaurant. I selected the dirty tots and smoked chicken wings. My goodness, the food was delicious with a yummy smoky taste. I loved that their sauces are made in-house. The downside of this visit was the not-so-friendly waitress. I am chalking it up to her possibly having had a bad day, as she wasn't friendly with the other guests around us either. read more

Fat Dan's - Slow Smoked Wings and Dirty Tots - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Good wings. Good service. Cool ambiance. Got fries & tots together. Large portions Had to take some home. read more

Fat dans is an absolute gem and staple to the Sobro area. My husband and I come here often especially during the summer when the doors are open. The food hits every time, you truly cannot go wrong with your order. Service is always fast and friendly! It's just laid back inside & open seating. This is one of our top places in the city to eat, and one we always recommend for anyone visiting read more

Fat Dan's - Basket of Tots, Chicago Italian Beef, Fat Dan's Slow Smoked Wings, Fat Dan's Fat Burger - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The ambiance gives bar/deli vibes. The service was great, it was our first time and our waiter was super helpful! The food was amazing! I've been fantasizing about the smoke wings since I had em the other day. read more

See all

Fat Dan's smoked wings are an Indianapolis treasure! The restaurant has multiple offerings from their smoker including the wings, ribs, brisket, pork, and meatloaf (Wednesdays only). They don't have ranch - opt for one of their delicious house sauces instead: FD's Hot, Hot BBQ, BBQ, Garlic Dijon, Teriyaki, Blue cheese, Honey Dijon, and/or hot cheese. You can also get a classic Chicago dog, Italian beef (dipped, please, sweet and hot peppers), a selection of burgers, a pressed Cubano, and other delicious bar food. Get the fries and share with your friends. Food comes out on a big paper for the table and individual boats for the different items ordered. Rolls of paper towels are available on each table, contributing to the laid back, sports bar atmosphere. They have a solid selection of beers on tap as well. Fat Dan's is such a staple and the smoked wings keep me coming back! read more

Great burger and I thought the side of chips instead of fries added a nice crunch to my meal. Oddest thing was that they don't offer ranch as a condiment. I would recommend for a quick lunch or dinner for sure read more

Fat Dan's - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

A little slice of Chicago right in SoBro. I've lived up the street from Fat Dan's for years, but never stopped in. I regret that because it's great! Really feels a lot like being in a Chicago neighborhood pub with lots of Chicago memorabilia and just a cool hometown vibe. The only thing that wasn't authentically Chicago is that the servers still had Hoosier hospitality. It's definitely worth stopping in if you're in the area and want a burger. read more

Fat Dan's - Turkey burger. No fries. Chip. - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Good atmosphere, great food. Wings are delicious, great burgers, sandwiches, and sides as well. We lived in Chicago for a bit, this place hits the mark for the places we enjoyed in Chi. read more

My neighbor talks about how good "Fat Dans" is. I had it at his house during a carry out order, and finally decided to experience Fat Dans at the restaurant. We took our dog and sat outside. We had a great waitress, talked as a family and had some good fun. Then the meal came. They brought it on a big sheet of paper with a big mess of fries. My burger was one of the best I've had. The fries were Los delicious. The outdoor seating is in the back and was fun. I liked it and will be back! read more

Fat Dan's - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

You got a love Fat Dans for what it is, straight up bar and hang over for food! And the ladder is exactly the reason I came here, I needed something to soak up the good times I had the night before, and an Italian beef with hot peppers and french fries hit the spot. I love that they have a large order of french fries that they just pour on the table and you can share with your friends, if you're feeling nice, that is! Bonus points for carrying coke products! Stellar place to watch a game as well if you can find a seat! read more

Fat Dan's - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

A very indulgent experience but totally worth it. Feels like a dive bar but that's kind of what you'd hope for! Cool place and really good burgers read more