Ordered by phone and the food was ready for pick up with great service. The inside is small But cozy. I'm amazed at how good the lox bagel tasted. All of my tastebuds were satisfied. The lox bagel consisted of smoked salmon, capers , red onions and creamed cheese . Chef's Kiss read more

See all

Definitely reminds us of NYC bagels! Service was great and food came out quick. Small bagel shop but definitely worth stopping by. Plenty of options as well. Will definitely be back. read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Steak Steak, Egg and Cheese - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Bagel sandos have been in my morning rotation lately. First up was a bacon, scrambled egg and cheese on jalapeno Asiago. Second up a classic sausage, egg and cheese on everything. This spot has a mere 4.1 out of 5 on Google reviews. Why though? They tasted fine to me. Maybe I'm not some bagel elitist scum bag. Support your neighbors! Plus it's cheaper than the absolutely horrible bagel sandos at Dunkin and Mackers. If you're hungry looking for a nice little bagel sandwich, this is your joint. If you're from NYC and compare every little detail in life to NYC, you'll probably find a reason to hate it. read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

For work, I've been sent to Jacksonville to open up a new site. One morning, I found myself craving a bagel breakfast sandwich. Uber eats listed this location, and having jalapeño bagel flavors always entices me to try. Uber eats delivered to my office fairly quickly, and made my morning to be able to kick back, relax and enjoy a sandwich. Overall, it's not the best bagel I've had and I didn't care for the brand of orange juice but it was pretty solid. Plan to try other locations, but not opposed to trying again. read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Egg and Cheese Sandwich - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Bagels are the best, so many flavors to choose. Iced coffee was great as well. I had a very last minute large order of 3 dozen assorted. They got it ready quickly and everyone was asking about them. The owners are so nice. Food is awesome. read more

Tried two bagels from this place and only one of them was tasty. Service was great, we got a couple bagels to go. The shop is small and seems reasonably decorated but we didn't stay for long. We tried one asiago bagel with jalapeno cream cheese, and this bagel was awesome. I do wish the bagel itself was thicker and more fluffy, but the cream cheese and the asiago flavor made it all taste great. However, on the other end, we got a garlic bagel with egg and cheese, and this was sadly lacking. The flavor of the bagel didnt come through well, and the egg and cheese just didnt add a whole lot. I felt as though this was something I could've whipped together at home. Maybe adding cream cheese or a stronger cheese would've helped? Not sure. read more

* Bagel with flavor cream cheese ( They didn't added the flavor cream cheese I asked for. Gave me plain ) with a cinnamon raisin bagel tasteless . * Fruity Pebbles Waffle was yummy! ( Can't go wrong with Fruity Pebbles ) * Holey Moley Sandwiches was tasteless and flavorless. Rather go to Einstein Bagels way better! read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

When we went to this restaurant last month it looked in disrepair, and not just the front entrance. The employee (owner?) said that someone had driven their car into the front of the restaurant. There were cease and desist notices on the front door for lack of permitting. The food was ok. I had a bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel. It was good, but nothing to write home about. My husband had pancakes and eggs, which he claims was average. Lastly, there is Christian music blasting into the dining room, which could be a turnoff for non-Christians, but I suppose the name is Holey Moley, so maybe it goes with the territory. Overall, I would give it 2.5 tars if I could. I would not return. read more

Loved the bagel sandwiches. BLT on Asiago Avocado, Spinach and egg on multigrain All really good. Excellent, friendly service Very casual nothing fancy inside. Several tables inside to eat. Seems like they do a lot of takeout business. read more

The flavor of the overall sandwich was good. There were just some aspects lacking... One thing I don't appreciate is hidden fees. I don't recall seeing anything about up charge for choice of bagel or cream cheese choice but there sure was... The person who took our order was lackluster, I'm not sure if it was his confusion on how to operate the register or just a bad day but felt like we were inconveniencing him by being there. Overall the lox was good and fresh, the bagel is pretty dense and could have been benefitted from extra toasting but it wasn't bad The decor is a little dingy, not sure if that's part of the older building status quo or what. If we were nearby we'd try again but we definitely wouldn't go out of our way to eat here. read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Lox Bagel Sandwich - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Bagels are huge and they don't skimp on the cream cheese We also tried the bagel egg and cheese with bacon . They have a lot of different choices . Close to NY bagels as you can get read more

Stopped in for a quick lunch. You walk in and can see the bagel display right away. Then you order at the counter and they bring out the order to you. I was able to order right away. Got an Asiago everything bagel ( two of my favorites in one! ) with cream cheese and a fountain drink. It came out to $8.05 which I felt was expensive. The bagel came out warm with the cream cheese already on. The cream cheese was thicker than the half of the bagel. Which isn't my favorite but it was tasty. The bagel was soft and chewy even lightly toasted. The inside is pretty sparse with decorations and there was an empty deli case and a beverage case that was out if order. It seemed clean in the dining area and the open kitchen area. It was good but just be aware it was a bit pricy. read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Assiago Everything Bagel. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Awesome Bagels and breakfast sandwiches!!! Very tasty! Big selection!!! Delicious food!!! read more

We tried the Holey Moley Bagel Shop because of it's proximity to our home on a foggy Saturday morning! We were not disappointed! We ordered two breakfast sandwiches; my wife enjoyed the bagel with local and I tasted the Philly Cheese Steak on a Jalapeño Asiago bagel that was VERY good and certainly brought the right amount of heat. In addition, we ordered a few assorted bagels to take home (saving them for a later snack)! All in all the staff were friendly and extremely helpful and patient helping us navigate their extensive menu options ... this was our first visit but it will not be our last. read more

How is this place still in business? It looks disgusting. The walls are boarded up with wood. There are THREE "cease and desist" notices on the front door! From November of 2024! This place is a potential hazard and they have no permit. Orders also state there are electrical issues? read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Stop work orders and door. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Growing up in New Jersey, I've been to many bagel shops and have had lots of bagels in my life. Holey Moley Bagel Shop was very disappointing. Their bagels are just okay, nothing special. Definitely nowhere near as good as a NY/NJ style bagel. They do not seem to function as a typical bagel shop either. When I order a bagel with cream cheese, I expect to be asked if I want the bagel toasted. Then to have the cream cheese put on the bagel. They did not so that. Instead they gave us cream cheese on the side and charged us way too much for enough cream cheese for half a bagel. This is just unacceptable. The service was spotty at best. It seemed like their employees were not trained well. I will not be back to Holey Moley. read more

I hate, no, strongly dislike having to get up early to do software releases, especially on an empty stomach. Usually the boss will bring in donuts and bagels from a well-known chain but this doesn't happen for beta releases. I should though haha. Both me and my manager were hungry and he asked me if I was going to order break fast (his exact words) and from where. I wasn't immediately sure so after scrolling UberEats I saw a suggestion for this business. I literally said, "I can order delivery from Holey Moley? I've been hearing about them for at least 2 years!" This was my chance. We both got a bagel sandwich. I got the ham, egg, and smoked gouda cheese on a blueberry bagel while he got a sausage, egg, and cheddar cheese on a jalapeno asiago bagel. I really liked my bagel! That was the softest, chewiest, bagel I've ever had. He said that his was alright and that it didn't have enough seasoning for his palate since it is so sophisticated haha. He exaggerates though and we'll order from them again. read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Ham, egg, and smoked gouda cheese on blueberry bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

I've been searching for a bagel shop near me, so when this came up, I was pretty excited to try it. The place itself is pretty cute. I like the graffiti wall and the menu display. The selection of bagels, though, pretty disappointing. We were planning on getting a dozen bagels but changed our minds when we got there. I love the smell of a bagel shop, but this one was a turnoff. Smelled like dirty water. We ended up just getting breakfast sandwiches...I guess I would sum up by saying, if you are hungry and close, stop in. I wouldn't go out of my way though. read more

Just Ok. Definitely not a fancy place but they make a good bagel . The plaza feels empty as does the store. The staff was very nice and gave me a cookie with my bagel. I was looking for a quiet place to read but the radio was to loud for me. read more

See all

Recently opened and last I visited last week, was told that they were still in soft opening phase. So on my 1st visit, I ordered some breakfast items as well as any available bagels they had in store. Fast forward another week, and it looks like they got more stuff in place. I say give them another 2 weeks or so and they should be fully operational. If you some Uglies, aka Apple Fritters, theirs are pretty good...where an Uglies never tasted so Pretty. This and along with their breakfast items and of course, the bagels. Holey Moley good. #SupportLocal read more

See all

I wanted to try this place for a while because they said it was like NY bagels and it wasn't. The service for the person at the counter was great and the place looked clean, but my bagel was not toasted and there was too much cream cheese for my liking. I will be giving them a second try soon. read more

See all

came to this store and was ignored until I had to say "hello" multiple times and when the lady came out she was very rude saying "we are busy I will cancel your order". definitely not eating here, poor customer service. read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - The staff who was angry that I was saying "hello" to get some assistance. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Craving a bagel this morning and came across Holey Moly bagel. We ordered the Chopped cheese and the Lox bagel. The chopped cheese was great, good flavor and a big size. The Lox bagel was disappointing, not enough cream cheese and not a lot of Lox. Probably wouldn't get this again for the price. Will be back for the chopped cheese and I'll be asking for extra cream cheese in the future :) the bagel was nice and chewy and the veggies fresh. read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Chopped cheese on everything bagel - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

You're just the G.O.A.T... You're just undeniably the greatest of all time with the chopped cheese breakfast bagel. Whoever made it... you're the GOAT too. Just speechless. read more

These are THE WORST bagels I have ever had.ordered an egg sandwich a d a bagel with cream cheese had 1 bite out of each and to the garbage with the rest. read more

I was excited to try this place and their rainbow bagels. I ordered an Asiago bagel with "garlic and herb" cream cheese and a rainbow bagel with honey walnut cream cheese. The Asiago bagel was disappointing to say the least. Their "garlic and herb" cream cheese is just plain cream cheese with some seasoning. And the rainbow bagel was disappointing because it was such a chore to chew. I'm not sure if it was just underproved or if their bagels are just like that, but they were not pleasant. My partner also disliked how the restaurant looked when we picked up our food. It was a little dark and dirty inside. Overall, Holey Moley offered a below average experience at an average price. We won't be coming back :/ read more

See all

We were super excited to try the new bagel place in the neighborhood so we came early Saturday morning. From initial looks, it could be a hidden gem nestled in the shopping center behind the McDonalds. First actual impressions were not that great. The decor made the place feel old, dirty and run down. The big sticker on the table made me think there was a plate of food there. They offer about 10 different sandwiches which are all very similar to another. I really wanted a bagel but their supply was pretty low for a Saturday morning and I didn't notice they even carried a whole wheat/oat/sesame seed option. So I chose to get a ham, egg and cheese on a croissant and my boyfriend got a bacon egg and cheese plain bagel and we split some home fries. My croissant was burnt and I really didn't like that. The potatoes are cut so small you can't even use a plastic fork to eat them. And the seasoning on them wasn't bad but it also wasn't great and they were room temp, not hot or fresh. We were also disappointed that they didn't really offer more coffee drinks. Maybe once they get on their feet and into the swing of things they could consider offering espresso drinks. The customer service was great and they were very friendly. But I don't think we will be back soon. I hope they take this feedback and can work on being a great place for breakfast in the neighborhood. I think the potential is there. I'd also recommend considering narrowing down their sandwich menu to just like 5 that they can really master and are unique from one another. read more

Honestly pretty alright bagel for Jax, iced coffee wasn't the greatest unfortunately it tasted exactly how you would expect it to. The home fries weren't personally MY cup of tea but it may be yours! Honestly I'll be back I love bagels and this is the closest bagel sandwich joint to my house. Also this is now NY bagels not holey moley? Oh and the service was amazing loved those girls vibe was perfect as well. The Weeknd was the only artist playing and I was obsessed. read more

My husband and I came to this shop in the summer last year l, and we were not impressed. Seemed a little dirty and not well kept. The food was just ok. Our family that are locals told us that they are recently under new management so we decided to give it another try. I am a huge bagel fan and I must say they have redeemed themselves! My daughter had a fruity pebble waffle that smelled like cake. I was able to get a little bite lol and loved it. My son ordered the Holey Smokes. The sausage was mildly spiced. He ate the whole thing. My husband had the Giulia. From the prosciutto to the arugula, it all tasted so fresh. And of course I ordered the Lox with chive and onion cream cheese. The salmon was very good and fresh. All the ingredients were perfectly balanced. I had never had one with cucumber and was a little skeptical but honestly it was just perfect. This place has a friendly staff and a clean and tidy ambience. We will definitely be back! Bravo on an impeccable and delicious bagel shop! We can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Ham egg and cheese on an Asiago and jalapeño HOMEMADE bagel with light scallion garlic and herb cream cheese. WOW amazing experience great food and awesome staff!!!! Really the NY style bagel which is hard to find down here. Numerous bagel and cream cheese flavors for all your cravings. Highly recommend!!!! Go support!! read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

As a native NYer, very disappointed. Under impressed. Seemed like store bought bagels. Not fresh. Got BEC on a Kaiser roll - underwhelmed! Blah. HEC on bagel - again underwhelmed. Plain bagel was mediocre at best. The place smelled like everything was burnt. Being new to the area I was excited to try a New York style bagel place. I will not try it again. The counter helpers were very nice. Fast service. Suggestions: Clean the grill. Ask if a customer wants their egg fried vs scrambled. read more

This bagel shop is tasty and reasonably priced! The man who took my order was very sweet and he carried my food directly to me instead of having me walk up which I thought was sweet. I got the 3 pancake platter and a lox bagel. The pancakes were perfect and syrup was provided. The lox bagel was good and the amount of cream cheese was great but could have been toasted a little more. I will definitely be back here for breakfast again in the future! read more

See all

If I went to hell, this is the restaurant satan would bring me to everyday. The bagels taste like they are store bought. The crème cheese tastes like plaster. I get flashbacks when I walk into the place. Red. Yellow. Red. Blue. The sounds. The noises. It keeps me up at night. I wake up in sweat, convinced the Austro-Hungarians were on my tail. I open my eyes and I realize it's just a bagel shop. My heart is cold, and my eyes, colder. The people that run the place are really nice and it is very clean. They need new bagel recipes though. The war to end all wars did not end the war between me and Sandra over the custody of the kids. read more

I cannot say anything about the service and ambiance because I always order from here thru Uber Eats. I am glad I have this place a try. I order from here when I am at work. I was jumping with joy when I found out they have the Pork Roll! I had their sandwiches either in a bagel or the roll. Both bread and the egg and cheese with pork roll or bacon or sausage satisfy my craving for the North Deli sandwiches. For those who are from up north, this place is worth trying. Sorry no pictures because I ate my sandwiches at work. Probably next time if I remember. Lol. read more

So so good, had the holey smokes bagel with jalepeno cream cheese The man was so kind and gave us both cookies with our bagels. Will 100% be back read more

Holey Moley Bagel Shop - Holey Smokes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

First time visitor. I ordered the Holey Moley bagel. The sausage was delicious but the rest of it was just ok. The building looks very old so it felt not very clean inside, the staff didn't seem very welcoming either. Not sure if I'll be back. read more

Eating from here is a great start to my day! Food is delicious and always made fresh! Staff is very attentive, fast, and friendly. The waffles topped with icing and fruity pebbles cereal is a favorite, the waffle has a good sweet flavor itself you can eat it plain. They have a steak croissant that's topped with egg and cheese...omg. Where did you get the bacon from because that's the meatiest most flavorful bacon I've had at any breakfast spot in Jax. I could eat here every morning. read more

See all

Delicious food and friendly workers. Always a quick turnaround from order to receiving!!

I had heard good things, and the name is fun, so I thought why not? My husband and I walked into the shop early in the morning, it was empty. The owner took some time to go over all the menu items with us, and offered an apple fritter bite while we waited. We ended up with an order of those cause they are so so good. I had a sausage egg and cheese on a garlic bagel, he went with a pork roll egg and cheese also on a garlic bagel. I had my egg scrambled, pro tip..they will fry your egg unless you ask for another preparation. The food was done super fast, and it was really tasty and fresh. The owner was pleasant and joked with us a little, also talking about all the different items they have. I can see myself coming back here, I hate that its hidden in a plaza behind a chain restaurant and not visible from the street. I feel like the combinations of bagels, cream cheeses and sandwiches is endless! read more

See all

Went here for the first time on Wednesday morning for breakfast. Customer service was excellent and so was the food. I ordered the sausage, egg, and cheese on a bagel sandwich and it was very good. I will be returning here soon. Thank You. read more