Holmdel Bagel Market

124

128

151

7 months ago

You are always greeted with a friendly welcome. The service is fast and the food is good. The prices are great. You cannot dine in at this establishment but the wait is shorter than you'd think. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Denise M.

0

70

14

7 months ago

Bagels are excellent! Crusty outside, and a soft inside, as they should be. The owner, Daniel, is friendly and customer service oriented. His prices can't be beat, very fair. Great dozen bagel deal on Wednesday's! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Taylor G.

305

229

426

3 years ago

Pretty solid bagel joint. Got the pumpernickel and rye bagel and everything bagel, both bacon, egg and cheese. We also got a crumb cake to go. Bagels are fresh. Pretty good but what would make the flavor better would be to use fresh white American cheese and not the plastic orange stuff. That would make the B.E.C. perfect. Otherwise pretty good read more

Holmdel Bagel Market - Pumpernickel and Rye B.E.C. - Bagels Near Me - Holmdel, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kanea M.

34

229

419

2 years ago

This place is such a great place to stop in and get a quality breakfast or lunch order. The owner and his family are super nice, they really do have the warmest and nicest people working inside to get your order started and ready within minutes. They do get extremely busy, so being patient is a must but it's worth it when you get your order. You can always call ahead and pay at pick up too. We order here all the time and come here at least once a week or every other week. Prices are fair and food is always good! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nancy M.

0

3

0

7 months ago

Best bagels around...and their bialies are amazing. Dan is a great guy and it's overall a wonderful little place with good food and great heart! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cristiana C.

3

96

101

1 year ago

service was quick and easy. the staff is always so nice and welcoming, the bagels are toasted perfectly with the right amount of cream cheese (especially if you like a little more) and so tasty. a great morning pick up bagel spot for breakfast on the go. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

barbara s.

0

2

1

7 months ago

The owner and staff are so sweet! The bagels are soooo good! We love getting breakfast here. Not a dine in establishment!l but the wait is never long and usually the line is mostly short enough to stand inside. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Deana A.

0

4

0

11 months ago

Bagels are delicious. Everyone is friendly. Love bagel deal on Wednesday. Muffins. Sandwiches. Everything is good

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jackie A.

Elite 25

30

628

92

2 years ago

Went on a Saturday, at around 09:30 and man, were they packed! A line jutted out the door, but moved swiftly. Those behind the counter, were cranking them out - by the dozen or sandwiches. Happy customers coming and going. Next door is a coffee shop, a perfect pairing. My lox everything bagel sandwich, held a decent amount of lox, a thick shmear of chive cream cheese, loaded with sliced onions, tomatoes and capers. The bagel is smaller than most (fine by me) and had a nice chew, ample toppings. Liked this place so much, that I went on Monday, later on in the day (around 1PM) and requested a dozen bagels, to go. The lady behind the counter, flat out rejected this request, stating those bagels were for sandwiches, only. I was taken aback, because of this comment. This area, seemingly has Many bagel shops, I'm sure one of them would gladly sell me a dozen bagels. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Zalak A.

258

33

37

2 years ago

Bagels were super fresh and soft. Great and simple. Line is long, but you can call ahead and place your order for pickup. read more

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Anthony G.

26

51

215

3 years ago

What can I honestly say that I haven't said already about this place? Awesome bagels, and great sandwiches! read more

Holmdel Bagel Market - a man standing in a kitchen - Bagels Near Me - Holmdel, New Jersey

Holmdel Bagel Market - Bagels Near Me - Holmdel, New Jersey

Holmdel Bagel Market - Multigrain bagel toasted with turkey bacon, egg, cheese, pepper, and ketchup. - Bagels Near Me - Holmdel, New Jersey

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Thomas P.

3

124

61

4 years ago

Friendly service, no long lines and tasty bagels. Bakers dozen. Maybe a little light on the raisins?

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jaden K.

0

1

0

2 years ago

Been here before, and will not be returning! Awful service, I ordered a scallion cream cheese on the side and they put it all over my bagel! Who wants a mountain of cream cheese stuffed between a mediocre bagel? Terrible. Do better. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christina D.

0

3

6

3 years ago

Fast, reliable service. Solid bagel sandwiches and they get our order right every single time which is hard with other spots, we don't eat cheese and they never mess that up. Local, family owned and operated and the owner pours his heart and soul into this place. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Leanne S.

Elite 23

31

134

261

4 years ago

I was next door grabbing coffee and decided to stop in because there was a decently long line. If any bagel shop has a line going outside, you've gotta stop in. We ordered a cinnamon raisin bagel with strawberry cream cheese and an onion bagel with chive cream cheese. The bagels were bomb! Crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside. The cream cheese to bagel ratio was perfect. I overheard a few orders for BECs and sausage egg and cheese and it smelled delicious. Also, the gentleman taking our order who I assume may also be the owner was so pleasant. He even reminded us to grab napkins on the way out. I'm Not from the area so I'm Not sure if I'll make it back but is you're around defintely stop in! read more

Holmdel Bagel Market - Outside - Bagels Near Me - Holmdel, New Jersey

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Sumin C.

Elite 23

861

393

1512

6 years ago

A pretty good bagel spot! We tried their bagel with pork roll, egg, and cheese, and it was delicious. We were slightly short on a few cents, but the owner of the store let us leave with our bagel. He was so nice!! The bagels here are so affordable and yummy, but I believe it's cash only even though somehow it says on Yelp that they take credit cards (?) read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Gabrielle N.

0

43

84

4 years ago

Bagels here are always fresh. I love the vegetable cream cheese from here. The staff is very friendly and it's never a long wait for your food even if they are very busy! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michelle S.

Elite 22

197

449

742

5 years ago

This is the best bagel spot in town! I've been coming here 3-4 times a week since I moved a few minutes away and I am always super happy with my food. Everything is always so tasty and fresh and they have never messed up my order, which is always highly appreciated. The staff is always pleasant and they make sure to greet every single person that walks through the door. The area itself is small and there are no seats for sitting, but like they say, good things come in small packages. They're also super good with letting you preorder and pick up so you don't have to wait. This spot BLOWS Gems overpriced and not so great food out of the water. Oh, and they're coffee is good too! I pay $1.5 for an iced as opposed to the $5 I pay next door lol. read more

Helpful 16

Thanks 0

Love this 10

Oh no 0

Kristina C.

11

1

0

2 years ago

Always fresh! Amazing crew. And always delicious. We have been enjoying the bagels, Rueben's, and pastries for over 13 years. Our boys were brought up with them too read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Paulie X K.

76

94

4

4 years ago

Recently moved here from Staten Island and it's impossible to find decent bagels or pizza. Growing up in Brooklyn and Staten Island spoils your taste buds for sure. Tiny bagel store which was super packed. The service is good and fast which is the only thing going for it. I got 6 different ones to try out. The bagels are terrible. Thick doughy and no taste. The next day they were already rock solid. Had to throw them out. And with this place having 5 star reviews looks like I'll be buying bagels from nyc and putting them in the fridge or freezer. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 1

Chuck L.

0

5

0

2 years ago

Perfect bagels, great selection of sandwiches and super nice people! Have the best prices and everything is amazing.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jen A.

Elite 21

56

105

157

6 years ago

I met a friend for coffee at Rook (which is right next door) and said to her, "I don't know about you, but I'm starving". We walked into Holmdel Bagel Market and trusted it would be good based on the steady flow of customers. We both got Taylor ham, egg, and cheese sandwiches. It was 100% one of the most perfect bagel sandwiches I've ever had. The bagel was soft and fresh but not overly doughy and there was an ideal ratio of egg to cheese to meat to bagel. One of the worst moments of enjoying a bagel sandwich is biting into it and the contents smoosh and fall out. That wasn't a problem here. I also love that they have whole wheat everything bagels because they're my fave! The staff was very friendly and personable which I'm sure isn't easy when you have to be up and functioning that early. I definitely recommend this place if you're local to the area or if you're down that way. Enjoy! read more

Holmdel Bagel Market - Taylor ham, egg, and cheese on a whole wheat everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Holmdel, New Jersey

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christopher Y.

Elite 20

342

112

75

7 years ago

Whoa. Long overdue update since my first experience. Firstly, the bagel quality which was already the best, somehow got better. Not possible, but they managed it. Not easy to do. Secondly and most importantly, the people running the shop are angels. Twice now I've been short a dollar or five (read first review about the store being cash only), and both times, the owner or staff member girl person has told me to go enjoy my bagels and come back another time. Suffice to say I came running back and dumped extra bucks into the tip jar. P.S: They should open for Black Friday. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Qathy B.

0

15

7

4 years ago

Great bagels, I pick them up on the way to work, everyone enjoys them. The staff are friendly, great service.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Nick A.

26

215

100

4 years ago

Always very good and fresh. Pro tip get your bagels here and get coffee next door at rook! Bagels are always one of the best in the are.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cassie C.

Elite 22

5

61

22

5 years ago

This bagel place is amazing! They make their own bagels, so they're fresh. They do great sandwiches, too. So happy we have our local breakfast spot! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Breanna B.

283

11

0

3 years ago

The staff (and bagels) are the reason why there's always a line out the door!! Delicious and service that makes you want to return!!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kyle F.

0

2

0

3 years ago

Great Bagels! Great Service! also very quick too. I'm always stunned with how quick they make the orders

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John A.

26

30

7

7 years ago

I have been going to this bagel shop religiously for about 3 years now. What can I say? The bagels are top notch, the folks that run the place are friendly, the food quality is consistent. It's just a rock solid bagel shop. Also the prices are VERY reasonable for things like sandwiches (lunch or egg sandwiches which are what I typically get). I think the only negative thing I can say about the place is they should really update/replace some of the counters and stuff inside the shop. It's just old and run down looking. I recommend trying this place to anyone in the area looking for a good bagel or egg sandwich. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brendan B.

30

206

307

7 years ago

Great food and great service! Bagel sandwich's are always good as well as lunch. Good prices for what you get and the employees are always on top of things and nice too! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lory M.

2

84

73

8 years ago

Just moved to area from Staten Island where bagels are the best so this was my first spot to try. It was great! Bagels match Staten Island Bagels! The service is great fast friendly! I found my new spot! Nothing better than my egg and cheese on poppy bagel is my order with great coffee on the weekend! Very satisfied! Yes it is cash only but no biggie there's an ATM and just have $20 for family bagels on hand. You won't regret it! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Steven K.

1

28

8

6 years ago

Great bagels and other hot and cold samiwiches amazing friendly service and everyone wears a mask

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeffrey B.

0

9

2

4 years ago

Great bagels and great people. Better than the bagels down the road. I've been going here for years and they rarely disappoint.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ann P.

0

8

2

6 years ago

Every time I get breakfast sandwiches from here, I am very happy. Have always gotten exactly what I ordered and the food is always tasty! Side note - they're always so kind to my little one when we walk through the door. Thanks, y'all!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tim Y.

Elite 19

633

124

386

9 years ago

Best bagel place in town! Have come here for awhile! Both Danny and mike along with girls up front are all super friendly and recognize faces! I LOVE getting pork roll, two egg, cheese, with HASHBROWN salt pepper ketchup on a jalapeño bagel! Cannot rave about this place enough! I Always stop by here! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alyssa J.

622

38

52

7 years ago

BEST BAGEL PLACE ON THE JERSEY SHORE. My family has consistently come here for the last 15 years - the bagels are the perfect combination of fluffy and chewy and the bacon egg & cheese is to die for. I love the sesame and cinnamon raisin! Holmdel Bagel Market is family-run and the family is very friendly, down to earth and generous! We have received an extra bagel more than once when ordering a dozen. Never forget those little kindnesses - Holmdel Bagel Market is our #1 favorite bagel place forever. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Donna P.

842

766

4645

11 years ago

HOLMDEL bagel is owned by an amazing family who has been part of the HOLMDEL community for well over 30 years. They work hard to maintain these delicious and authentic bagels. They are true NJ/NY bagels. Walking into the store the Smell of these freshly made warm bagels is heavenly. Soon as I get home the bag is attacked. Their mini bagels are fantastic to bring to meetings, school functions and church organizations. Call the day before to reserve large orders and they will have them ready and cut in half if requested. Fantastic breakfast and lunch sandwiches. Great coffee and cold beverages. Catering platters are perfectly done. It's a tiny place with a lot to offer. Always fresh and delicious and worth the stop by. My family members who have moved out of state always request, don't bring wine when you come to visit we want HOLMDEL Bagels. Now right there is a true testament to their bagels, because as we all know those from NJ/NY know the real deal! read more

See all

Helpful 12

Thanks 1

Love this 8

Oh no 0

Jane T.

0

22

0

7 years ago

I don't know what it is exactly, but their everything bagel is just amazing. The texture, the flavor, and the spice ratio are all perfection. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michaela D.

0

1

0

5 years ago

Always made quick within 5 minutes. Manager is friendly and always greets you at the door. If you go try the coffee crumb cake!!!! I can easily say I will be switching to this as my new spot! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Edward S.

0

1

0

5 years ago

I just discovered this hidden gem after getting my coffee from rook one day. the bagels are always toasted just the way I like it, and they are super nice. I cant help but stop and get a cheese bagel everytime I'm nearby now. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 2

See more reviews

More info about Holmdel Bagel Market

2101 State Route 35
Holmdel, NJ 07733
Directions
(732) 671-5333
Call Now

Full menu

Hours

What time does Holmdel Bagel Market open?

Holmdel Bagel Market opens at 6:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Holmdel Bagel Market close?

Holmdel Bagel Market closes at 2:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 6:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Holmdel Bagel Market take credit cards?

No, Holmdel Bagel Market does not take credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Holmdel Bagel Market have catering options?

Yes, Holmdel Bagel Market does have catering options.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Holmdel Bagel Market have bike parking?

Yes, Holmdel Bagel Market has bike parking.

Does Holmdel Bagel Market have parking?

Yes, Holmdel Bagel Market has parking options. Validated Parking

Review Highlights - Holmdel Bagel Market

“Solid bagel sandwiches and they get our order right every single time which is hard with other spots, we don't eat cheese and they never mess that up.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bagels 2,469 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Old Time Bagels

Fresh, delicious and absolutely worth the wait! They have a sign that says "we don't toast the…read morebagel unless you ask" which is always a sign of a quality bagel. Got an egg, cheese and avocado (yes they have avocado) on an everything bagel untoasted and then a side of macaroni salad. Mac salad was good but very mayo forward (to be expected but more than I would have liked). The bagel was perfection!

So happy to found this little bagel shop and my bagel breakfast made my day great…read more Also people there were so nice which makes all customers smile. I'll try for my lunch next time and I'm expecting good one again.

See all

Gem's House Of Bagels

We dont live in the area but made a stop before getting on the road to go back home…read more We took bagels home and had one there. I had ordered a bagel with 2 hash browns on the side. They put them in the bagel by mistake but ended up giving us another order. So kind! The workers are great, patient and easy to work with.

I'm not sure how to rate this or how to explain our situation. A phone order was placed the other…read moreday and we went to pick it up, while there my husband and I added two sandwiches. Ok, fine no problem. The people ahead of us got their orders, ok fine but every single person and group of people WHO PLACED THEIR ORDER AFTER MY HUSBAND AND I GOT THEIR ORDERS BEFORE US ?!?! The two men who were AFTER us got their orders and the woman behind the counter said, "ok Joe, you're ready". My husband and I were the LAST AND ONLY CUSTOMERS LEFT IN THE STORE. Meanwhile, our daughter's telephone order sandwich was sitting there ready to go when we got there. I will not play the race card because I don't believe in that. My husband's is a retired Police Officer and as a nurse I specialized in Cardiac Surgery, as a Senior Hospital Administrator I oversaw many NYC hospitals so I am nor my husband are in no way ignorant, rude, nor disrespectful.

Raisins in a pastrami sandwich...

See all

Bagel Boyz

3.6

(54 reviews)

2.6 mi

This is a great spot for bagels. They have two locations now so double the opportunity to get Bagel…read moreBoyz bagels. I liked their plain, blueberry, and French toast bagel.

My daughter and me went to bagel boyz and got two bagels to go. This is a regular weekend…read moreoccurrence for us, but this time after leaving we found so many pieces of hair all over her bagel that it was inedible. This wasn't a strand or two but more like someone had done their hair over or dropped their hairnet into the lox cream cheese and just mixed it up.

Spreads

See all

Cinnamon raisin bagel

Krib's Bagel Bazaar

2.7

(16 reviews)

2.5 mi

I enjoy a good bagel, and was in the mood to try out a new spot. On my way to work, I stopped by…read morehere early in the morning and ordered an everything bagel with cream cheese. I had the bagel toasted as well. I would say it was a solid bagel. Service was good, too. Nothing super outstanding here, but everything tasted good. They give you a fair amount of cream cheese on the bagel. And the price wasnt too bad. The bagel had a nice crisp from being toasted, which i enjoyed. For the most part, they prepared the bagel pretty fast. Overall, very good bagel, and this could be your every day go to bagel spot.

I stopped in here after the gym to try it out. I had no idea it was so nice inside. A great place…read moreto sit with friends. I ordered a whole wheat everything bagel with cream cheese. Delicious. Staff was also very friendly. This spot is a hidden gem.

Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese (Inside)

French Toast Bagels

See all

Bagel selections Aug 2020

Sheepshead Baygels

Sheepshead is a childhood spot for me and the nostalgia of the place is on point. They do…read moreeverything right as far as look, they've kept it the same for years and it's in great condition. Classic classic bagel spot in Jersey. I love their bagels, they are perfect and kill it on all sandwiches. I have always thought their pork roll on the thinner side but that's solely oppinion based.

The food was pretty good but the prices on the website are old and everything was $3.00+ more …read more The bagel definitely could have a little more cream cheese but the bagels are really delicious and unique for this

Egg bagel with lox and lox spread, excellent!

See all

Gem's House of Bagels

First and foremost, I will say that the food here is amazing. Plenty of different combinations…read moretailored to every liking. I've been going here my whole life and always got my fix. But just fyi to the people who leave these bad reviews: 1. The price is high because that's what you pay for. Unless you want to raise the pig for your ham and cheese yourself, please respect the fact that prices are rising everywhere. 2. The portion size has been criticized many times. Some say too much, some say too little. But many don't realize that it is quite simple to ask for light/heavy contents of the sandwich. The staff have a button for that, and depending on one of those, the price may change. 3. The staff being rude isn't right, and I don't say this to say it is. But many times they are very overwhelmed. Yes, the phone not being answered is on purpose. If they have a line out the door, they cannot prioritize orders of people who aren't there. Not to mention there are less than pleasant costumers that show up, and if you are rude to them, they have the right to retort. An overworked young woman, scraping by on minimum wage, isn't going to worship the ground you walk on when you're actively yelling at her for something she can't control. The employees don't control the prices, they just work there. Remember to just be kind to the people who handle your food.

Awesome bagels! Just enough crunch to soft ratio. They also had interesting sandwiches that I would…read morenever think to combine.

Inside Seating area - Sept 2021

Drink options - Sept 2021

See all

Specialty sweet bagels - Sept 2021

Planet Bagel

Bagels are so good.. service is meh and they don't take orders correct but keep it simple, check…read moreyour order and you'll be fine there's plenty of parking and the breakfast sándwiches we're spot on... they also offer everything on pump which I've never seen.

The bagels and breakfast sandwiches are REALLY good. I hate that I can't put 5 stars. The service…read moreis always so bad a majority of the time I go in. It's gotten a lot better overtime but they have days where it's impossible to get them to answer the phone. I'll show up in person and it's empty customer wise. Never understood why they have this problem.

Porkroll and cheese on why everything

Everything CC

See all

Menu front

The Bagel Nook

3.8

(31 reviews)

0.7 mi

I placed a to-go order, and they were incredibly fast getting everything ready. Even though I…read morearrived later than the suggested pickup time, my food was still warm when I got home -- which was a pleasant surprise! I ordered the blue raspberry lemonade, and it was the perfect combo -- not too sweet and not too tart. Such a delightful mix. Whenever I'm in town, I have to grab some kind of pork roll sandwich. This time I went with the Double Nooker on an everything bagel, toasted and scooped with SPK (salt, pepper, and ketchup). Yum, yum, yum. There's a lot of food packed in there, but having the bagel scooped made it the perfect amount -- super satisfying without feeling overly stuffed or risking a tummy ache. The spot itself is open concept and has tons of space if you want to sit and eat there, which makes it great whether you're grabbing something to go or staying to enjoy your meal.

We had the usual egg, cheese & pork roll on a plain bagel and also got an everything bagel with…read morescallion cream cheese. All very good and staff was super nice & friendly. Nice large area to eat inside and a few outdoor seating spots. Excellent fast convient service. They also have some fun looking iced coffees. Need to try next time.

Blue raspberry lemonade and to go order of Double Nooker

Such a great selection

See all

Blue raspberry lemonade and to go order of Double Nooker

Bagel Hut

Great little bagel place. They are quick, friendly and reasonably priced. Plenty of parking as well…read moreas decent options. Bagels are good and fresh. Would definitely go back.

Fantastic bagel spot in matawan. Got a turkey sandwich and it came with a pickle and side macaroni…read moresalad

Bagel Hut! My favorite bagel spot !

Turkey, Muenster, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo on a sesame bagel

See all

My favorite bagel place!

Oak Hill Farm

4.3

(27 reviews)

4.1 mi

I was on the hunt for something festive and when I saw Oak Hill Farms on Instagram, I couldn't wait…read moreto visit. It was such a fun find! It's a market, shop, cafe all in one. There isn't any place to sit and sip your drinks, but instead of sitting, you can take your latte for a stroll around the shop. This seems like a great place for stocking stuffers and gifts. They have lotions, soaps, candles, holiday decor pieces, ornaments. All things that everyone loves to receive and rarely buys for themselves. If you are in more of a window shopping mood, they have samples of everything. At the cafe counter (also where you can pay) you'll find a small but mighty coffee menu. I got the gingerbread latte and loved every sip. My coworker got the latte with hot honey in it and said it had just the right kick. For a place that doesn't seem to specialize in coffees, they did make two wonderful drinks for us. There was plenty of parking and it looks like they do quite a bit outside (maybe on the weekends?) with the tree lot and farm in the back.

Oak Hill Farms is a little farm with cute fall aesthetics. I can definitely see this as a place…read morepeople come to take pictures. Parking was no issue at all. There were plenty of spots on a Tuesday afternoon around 3pm. When you enter you go through these giant barn doors. The inside is a lot of fall decor with candles, bakeware, kitchen towels, all the cute home stuff that makes your house extra cozy for fall. They also have a little coffee area too but I had already gotten coffee earlier so I didn't order any. Although everything was super cute, it was also a bit pricey so I unfortunately only bought some lotion which was really moisturizing and smelled AMAZING. Something I really liked is that you could sample most of the lotions and sprays so although I didn't buy them, I could at least try them out. If you go through the back exit, you enter the farm portion with a little pumpkin patch, donkeys, and sheep! There were a few places for "photo ops" too. If you walk further there's actually a little garden/flower field which was really nice to walk around and take pictures. You couldn't pick any flowers at this time but maybe we could've earlier in the season in the summer. This was a cute little farm that I would come back to for another season to see how they change it up. Although some of the items were pricier I would come back to get something as a gift. I think there's a lot of nice stuff to give for a housewarming and it's good quality too.

Outside

Candle

See all

Paris Baguette

3.8

(12 reviews)

0.3 mi

Needed a coffee and a sweet treat to help me power through the day. When I stopped in, I was…read morepleasantly surprised to find a nice selection of pastries, and even better, my app informed me that I was eligible for a free beverage of my choice. As I browsed the display case, one item immediately caught my eye: the Strawberry Croissant. My love of croissants and strawberries made the decision an easy one. For my complimentary drink, I selected the Vanilla Sweet Cream Cold Brew. Both choices hit the spot for my craving. The croissant was a good treat, and the cold brew provided a nice boost of caffeine to keep me going through the rest of the day. Moments like this remind me why I am glad I downloaded the app. Between the rewards and occasional free treats, it is a nice perk for anyone who visits regularly. I enjoy the consistency of the brightness of every location, and they have a fairly clean station where you can retrieve utensils, sweeteners, and, if you want to add milk to your beverage. The garbage hole is found in the same area.

My love for Korean bakeries runs deep. When I heard a new Paris Baguette was opening up in this…read moreHolmdel complex, I paid a visit on their grand opening day. Things were wild yet well managed on the grand opening day, and nearly entirely half of the space is dedicated to seating - either at tables or high window tops with stools - so that your chances of finding a place to park and chill with a few pastries remains relatively high. For the lovers of sweets out there, there's a lot to explore. Mochi donuts, inventive cereal-based treats, and all kinds of croissants with all kinds of flavors. But for me, the real hidden gems are seemingly plain and savory offerings. Any of the milk bread loaves are unimaginably soft and elevate any sandwich or French toast I might make that week. I'm also an enormous fan of their sandwiches and pizza-like breads (which - hot tip - can be warmed for you upon purchase). On another note, I've noticed - and chuckled at - the complaints about the self-service aspect about this establishment from other reviewers. I imagine that's what happens when a Korean bakery is planted in an area that doesn't have many others. In some parts, where there are spots with Asian bakeries on every other block, it's seems a common thing to have customers picking up their own pastries with tongs. But I'll offer this as a broad panacea to any paranoia about cleanliness - during my visit, I loved seeing how frequently the workers came by with fresh pastries, which for me was assurance that - (1) everything is freshly baked, and (2) there are eyes on the pastries (and presumably any one potentially mishandling the goodies). The complex is enormous, so parking wasn't an issue even with the throngs of crowds coming by to check out the shiny new store installment.

See all

Holmdel Bagel Market - bagels - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Holmdel Bagel Market also viewed

Brooklyn Bagels and Deli

4.2

(61 reviews)

I absolutely loved these bagels. The owner was so friendly and the types of bagels were so unique…read more We tried literally about 6. My favorite was the original-- it's a mix of a bread roll and a plain bagel. I've literally never had anything like that before. I can't wait to come back to try more of the fresh options.

Amazing service and great people. Creative bagels, always tasty. Very fair priced. Would recommend,…read moredefinitely give them a chance

Old Time Bagels

4.4

(39 reviews)

Fresh, delicious and absolutely worth the wait! They have a sign that says "we don't toast the…read morebagel unless you ask" which is always a sign of a quality bagel. Got an egg, cheese and avocado (yes they have avocado) on an everything bagel untoasted and then a side of macaroni salad. Mac salad was good but very mayo forward (to be expected but more than I would have liked). The bagel was perfection!

So happy to found this little bagel shop and my bagel breakfast made my day great…read more Also people there were so nice which makes all customers smile. I'll try for my lunch next time and I'm expecting good one again.

Bagel World

3.2

(26 reviews)

from my days in high school this place has always been a staple over the years with relationships…read morehardships and moments of great emotion when all was settled down a bagel world trip was required the seating is inviting even if you were in pajamas or a suit and maybe should at school by that time in the morning (haha). Things do change so much not even from year to year but moment to moment in this I will say the only thing that changes at bagel world are the faces which is No worry because good people higher good people so they all have that same warm feeling and great personalized customer attention and service. And the cherry on the cake is the delicious menu and mouth watering bagel im from Brooklyn so I know 2 things Pizza and bagel and this is the closest taste to home!

He has the best bagelsss in new jersery hands downnn!!! 10/10 and the challahsss r soo good and…read morealways freshhh !

Bagel Masters

4.1

(180 reviews)

These were the best cinnamon raisin bagels I've had in years. The everything were also great. Nice…read morecrunch on the outside, light and fluffy on the inside. Just perfect. I ordered a lb. of cream cheese and they rang me in wrong for a half pound. I checked the bag before I left and they didn't even put the half pound in, so just be careful leaving and checking your order. Other than that, it's still 5 stars for me because these bagels kick ass.

I was curious to try a NJ bagel after having grown up with NY-style, but I was very underwhelmed…read morewith my bagel from here. I got a bagel with lox and it was very bread-y and had no crunch at all. The bagel also didn't come with any lettuce or tomato (which sometimes happens if you don't specify so I don't knock them too much for this). My bagel also came with a side of either coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad, + a pickle. I got the macaroni salad but I really disliked it I arrived here around 9 AM with my fiance and there was already a line out the door! Inside is a little chaotic and there are only a few small tables for seating.

King of Bagels and Subs

4.0

(48 reviews)

I LOVE their Black Russian bagel. It's so delicious! The Owner and employees are very nice here…read more They seem to have great lunch specials. Would love to try one of these days.

In Howell Plaza, you will find a little spot where you can find bagels, subs, sandwiches, and…read moremuffins. Brand: 4/5 Outside, the sign outside the business did not reflect the logo used for the brand, which has an updated look. Despite the outdated sign, I will say that I like the new logo, since it has that western aesthetic that maintains a sense of classiness. Inside, the classic brown tiles of the floor have an inviting vibe, along with the glass counters showing the food. Website: 3/5 It welcomes you with the standard Slice theme that comes with restaurant website, but only at the bare minimum. Because it typically applies to pizzerias, this red-and-green theme works against the website, since it could mislead the consumers. Also, none of the menu items have any images accompanying them. Ambiance: 4/5 The television did blare a little bit, and the table we sat at was near the cleaning area, so that sink smell kept coming. Nonetheless, I did think that the chairs felt comfortable enough and the tables had a large enough space between them. The waiting counter has a wide enough space to bring anyone's order into view without it becoming a nuisance. Service: 5/5 The staff went through great lengths to ensure we had an accommodated experience. Wait Time: 5/5 We experienced no interruptions during our wait time, and the orders came quickly. Food: 4/5 I ordered the Italian, which is essentially an Italian sub with salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, onion, tomato, mayonnaise, vinegar, and oil, with orange juice. The ingredients and the buns had a fresh, natural preparedness. The buns held their form even as the ingredients started to pour out. I will say that the flavor resembles the Italian subs from other restaurants, though in this case, the mayonnaise had the most profound flavor which complemented the sub well. I did think that it had too much grease on it. A rule of thumb of mine is if I need to use multiple napkins to wipe my hands, then the food is too greasy. Worth The Money?: 3/5 Concerning food, I think that it reflects the internal conflict of the establishment's identity. Is it Italian-based? Is it diner-based? A strong recommendation I can make is to provide some menu items so unique they set King of Bagels and Subs apart from the other eateries into its own niche buffer zone. Hybrid eateries do exist and I can see a bagel-and-Italian diner working, but I just do not see it with the website. The food works with the ambiance, since it will offer you many options with a clear space. Likewise, the meals had the appropriate amounts of wait time and service. I did not have to worry about waiting, since the staff care about their customers. I do think that while the logo does have a good design, it only works so much, since I do not know how much the business itself reflects off the theme, especially if the menu appears pretty standard. I would recommend including that logo into more spaces, including even the sign if becomes possible. I will say that the menu items can have a high price. Is the price ultimately worth it? Not unless you wish to support local businesses. Other than that, any issues beyond principles will not entice you to go to King of Bagels and Subs. Rating: 4/5 Stars I can see how this establishment could become the King of Bagels and Subs, with the Howell Plaza as its demesne and the consumers' happiness as its regal mandate. For now, I do not see it. Recommend To... Anyone who works around Howell Plaza and need a quick bite at any time of the day. I can easily see how the King of Bagels and Subs could serve someone three courses in a single day, whether breakfast, lunch, and/or dinner.

Grandpa's Bagels

4.0

(60 reviews)

The toasted Asiago bagel with vegetable cream cheese was seriously delicious. Perfectly crispy on…read morethe outside, warm and chewy inside, with that rich Asiago flavor coming through in every bite. The veggie cream cheese was fresh, smooth, and balanced everything out so well. Simple order, big flavor, and exactly what you hope for from a great bagel shop. Definitely coming back for this again

Omg my favorite place! They use quality ingredients, make their own mayonnaise. Bagels are fresh…read moreand have the best texture.

The Hot Bagel Bakery

4.4

(102 reviews)

Delicious and fresh bagels…read more Salmon lox on bagel is delicious and not skimpy (depending on the server) Take cash (no cards accepted) Expect to wait in line Go early to get best bagels No ambiance Just grab and go

I'll drive down from Mendham for their bagels. They're that good. Hot from the oven. Bring cash,…read morethey don't take credit or debit cards. The salt bagels are sublime. An everything bagel charms. Again, well worth the drive.

Terrace Bagels & Cafe

3.4

(235 reviews)

Terrace Bagels is one of the best bagel spots in the area. Their bagels are large, puffy, and…read moreincredibly fresh, exactly what you want when you're craving that perfect chew. ($19 for 12 bagels) Whether you're grabbing a classic sesame or going bold with a rainbow bagel for the kids, there's something for everyone. They even offer flat bagels for the diet-conscious. They are always fresh and generously sized The hot food menu is just as impressive. Breakfast sandwiches, melts, and other deli-style options are flavorful and satisfying. It's clear they put care into more than just their bagels. Some of the cakes displayed on the counter look better than they taste, visually tempting but a bit underwhelming flavor-wise. And while the coffee is decent, nearly $4 for a regular cup feels steep, especially when paired with a casual breakfast.

If you like bagels (about everyone I guess!) this is your place!…read moreTheir bagels are fresh everyday with fair numbers of cream cheese choice. I had everything bagel with garlic herbs cream cheese today. It was delicious - garlic and herbs flavors were balanced, herbs were fresh, and gave a hint of spicy taste. The cashier was very friendly and helpful, and my order was made in timely fashion.

The Bagel Bar

4.3

(22 reviews)

Great selection of bagels and breakfast or lunch options!…read more Good service! It does get busy but it won't disappoint

should taste like -- perfectly crisp on the outside, soft and chewy inside.Everything tasted super…read morefresh and made with care. The staff was incredibly welcoming, the place was clean, cozy, and had such a good vibe from the moment we walked in. You can tell they truly care about quality and customer experience. Definitely one of the best new bagel spots around and 100% worth trying. Can't wait to come back and work my way through the whole menu!

Gem’s House Of Bagels

4.0

(29 reviews)