Hometown Classic is, hands down, the best pizza in Hancock County. They have a great selection and we've never had a bad experience. We especially love the Hometown Classic pizza with the bbq swirl. Perfect! read more

Solid pizza but getting it delivered has not been a good experience. Ordered and they said it would be an hour... we are at hour two and still no pizza. I hope when it comes it is better than the last delivery where they forgot some of our order. I would suggest either picking it up or picking another place. read more

The reviews were good which is why this place caught my eye when I was close to starving ... and when my friend from the area said it was awesome too(!!) I had to place an order. The gal on the phone was helpful and nice. It's a relief when you ask questions and get knowledgeable answers. The cheese pizza was party cut as described ... cheese only ... because I didn't know what our various vegetarian & non-vegetarian friends would like. It was really good basic pizza! They even had it ready early as soon as I arrived at the store for pickup. Yep, I'll be going back to this corner shop and I'll try m more things on their menu. read more

Hometown Classic Pizza has the best wings in Greenfield! They are meaty and a very nice portion. Their staff are so helpful when you call to order and the delivery service is one of the best! Usually the order arrives a little earlier than they promise and it is hot still when we sit down to enjoy! Great for Sunday night football!! You should try them before the Super Bowl in case you want some for the Big Game! read more

The pizza is good as is the location. It is easy to get in and out of. We have only picked up pizza we have never eaten inside and are orders always correct, hot , and ready to go when we arrive. I am gluten intolerant and it is one of the only pizza places in town to serve gluten free. With that being said it would be nice to get a larger size as 10" is the only size they sell if you can't eat gluten. read more

Pizza is delicious! Love the crunchy crust. It's very cheesy! The interior is very cool. Video games in the back like an old school pizza joint. read more

We went on a Monday night. It was slow per usual for a Monday night. The service was prompt. The decor is so much fun! There are movie posters everywhere along with cassette tapes and 8-track tapes and random CDs and dvds. The pizza though! Oh my goodness, it was so good. I just got my usual sausage pepperoni. They have the crumbly sausage which is my very favorite. The sauce was really good and there was plenty of it. It was not sweet which is something that gets on my nerves. It was hot and fresh and tasted absolutely amazing. My friend ordered some breadsticks and the deluxe pizza those breadsticks were really good. They have that good jalapeno flavored cheese sauce. She loved her deluxe pizza but she knew she would. She's the one that suggested this place to me and I am so glad that we went. read more

Hard to pick whether the nostalgia from the posters on the walls or the pizza ingredients is the bigger draw, but I can't stop thinking about the next time I will be back in Greenfield to visit again. We just got a vegetarian pizza, but the cheese/mushrooms/tomatoes/crust were way better than other pizza ingredients I've had. Personable owner and staff exemplify Hoosier Hospitality. read more

Great place to have a Girl's Night Out. Really good food and service! We even had time to play a game... Yay! Definitely recommend. Thank you Hometown Pizza!! read more

This place is great! They have a large variety in pizzas and they all taste fantastic. I love that they put the cheese on top of the "toppings". Makes everything ooey gooey. Only three stars as sometimes the pizza is just "Ok". We order takeout pretty often, and the majority of the time we have no issues. However, one time we did wait over an hour and a half past our expected "ready by" time. That was pretty ridiculous. We have been back since then and have not had the same issue. read more

pizza is always great, but the WINGS... ALWAYS AMAZING ... HUGE, tons of meat, great flavor and consistent! best wings in town, by far. bbq and hot! read more

Tonight was my first time at this restaurant. I have seen their ads in the monthly mailers that come around so I decided to give them a try. I am very disappointed. 1. Value - You will not find it here. The prices are 25% higher than similar items at Domino's or Papa John's (example - HCP 16" 5 meats for $27.00, Domino's 16" Meatzza for $19.99, Papa John's XLNY 4 meats for $18.49). Even the prices at New Bethel Ordinary are lower (16" Large all meat for $25.79). 2. Food quality - marginal at best. The crust on my pizza was a prefab type that tasted pasty and bland. This clearly was not made using fresh dough. When I bit into it, the crust was so brittle that it literally broke apart in my hand. 3. Appearance - the tops of both pizzas I ordered tonight were burnt and that flavor permeated everything. The charcoal taste was very unpleasant. The only real plus was that my order was completed right on time according to my web notifications. As for the dining atmosphere, I carried out so I cannot comment on the ambiance. Based on how things went this time I sincerely doubt that I will return to this pizza place anytime soon. read more

We drove into town tonight with the only intention being to try this place. Reviews are awesome. Loved it before when it was downtown Greenfield, but tried it at the new location. It's not open for dine in, but we went there, placed the order then drove around while we waited. Greenfield is our hometown, so we drove around, being nostalgic, looking at our first place,.etc. fun. We went back and picked it up. We live about 28 miles away. We ordered breadsticks and a deluxe pizza. We ate the breadsticks on the way home. They were HOT and soft and wonderful!!!!! They were very airy, not super dense and just great!!! When we got home, we opened the pizza box and oh goodness. It was covered in cheese and looked wonderful. The crust was thin, but light and crispy. The flavor was wonderful and so much different than every other pizza place. Unique spices, but authentic Italian tastes. Loaded with toppings and smothered in cheese. We will certainly make the 28 miles (one way) to get this pizza again. So glad they got this reopened!!!! Not another "chain" pizza store in this small town. read more

Hometown Classic Pizza - Deluxe pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenfield, Indiana

Amazing pizza and Customer!!!Chicken BBQ PizzaHawaiian Classic PizzaHawaiian Classic Pizza read more

See all

We are pizza lovers and this was our first time at Home Town! We loved the decor and open kitchen concept. I love a great Pac-Man game and there is one right in the restaurant! Service was fast and friendly. We tried the hometown classic pizza and it was delicious! It was a combination I had never tried before but I'm so glad I tried it!! Definitely will be back! read more

Hometown Classic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenfield, Indiana

See all

Pizza joint that can't do delivery. Don't bother. I was hoping this would be a cool treat for my kiddos while Mom was away. Phone was constantly busy. Maybe a good sign. When I got through, I was quoted a two hour delivery time. The website did say something about longer deliveries and it would put it a little past normal dinner time but figured it must be good! Three hours later, I called 12 times (constantly busy phone) to get back through to check on the status of my order. THEY HADN'T STARTED IT YET!!! I told them to cancel it and they said, "Ok!" The delivery driver called 20 min later saying he was ringing our doorbell but no one was answering. It's because my kiddos were piled into the car while we drove to Little Caesar's. Would love to comment on value or anything but can't. If you want to support local that delivers, just go to Mozzis. It's clear Hometown only delivers because they feel like they have to. That's why they aren't any good at it. Just have a dine-in/carry out pizza joint. read more

Always delicious pizza!! They have great appetizers too! Definitely a favorite in greenfield! And whenever I call in an order they are very friendly! read more

We'll priced and local. The staff are really nice and the pizza and breadsticks taste great!

I always pick up my pizza, great pizza. I don't like the atmosphere here and the super loud music. I want to be able to sit down and talk to my family with our meals. No one ever has smiled or said hi when I or others have walked into the place even before the fire/move. read more

Overpriced and limited hours. Food flavor is mediocre at best. Tried this place to support local economy vs national chains. Equivalent to little Caesar's but 4 times as wxpw read more

Hawaiian classic pizza with sub barbecue sauce (Hometown has such good BBQ) is a favorite. Ingredients are so fresh and quality! You can tell. Great pizza. Cheesy garlic bread is delicious, too! read more

The cheesesteak sandwich is delicious!! Pizza is just ok, but shockingly expensive!!! I'll stick with the excellent cheesesteak!

Best pizza in town hands down. Always fresh! Wings are above average for a pizza place. Normally not a plain cheese pizza fan, but theirs is so good. read more

This place is amazing. The crispy crust, the pizza sauce, and the thick cheese makes the pizza amazing. All the decorations on the walls are nice. The place isn't that big, but you get a big surprise when you walk in. All the arcade games in there just adds more toppings onto it. The last time I went there, 1 week ago, they sat with me and my family quickly. The waitress was always checking up on us to see if we needed anything, and after we ordered we got our food in like 10 minutes. After I ate, we got up and played arcade games with my cousins. If you are looking for a place that has good pizza, fast service, and fun, go here. -BS I like this place because it has great pizza that's always hot when you get it. This place has so many different things on the menus too, like pizza, breadsticks, salads, sandwiches, desserts, beverages, and pasta. The ingredients they use are always fresh and they even use their own pizza sauce. Their also doing a thing called "Every Slice Matters" and it's dedicated to the completion of local, meaningful projects, and the continuous drive to give more. Every Slice Matters is their way of giving back to the friends and neighbors who come through their doors everyday. -LG read more

Every small town has "The Must Visit" restaurant, right? In my travels, I have found most are not worth the hype. Hometown Classic Pizza is an example of a restaurant that deserves every bit of praise. Pizza is delicious. I just brought home a medium Deluxe, no mushrooms, extra cheese. $18, and worth every cent. Sliced in squares, the way I like my pizza cut, and ate one slice, It seriously almost filled me up. And, I'm a big guy. Only 15 more slices to go. Great crust. Sauce is just right. Ingredients are fresh and plentiful. Service was notably impressive. The young man who prepared my pizza watched intently while I opened the box to check it out. I commented "Looks Perfect ..." To which he replied "That's what I like to hear!" Now, doesn't that sound like the kind of person you want making YOUR pizza? read more

Hometown Classic Pizza - This is a Medium??? It is at Hometown Classic Pizza in Greenfield, IN! - Pizza Near Me - Greenfield, Indiana

We have been reading a lot about this place since they recently reopened in their new space. Tonight we thought we'd give them a try and let me tell you it was amazing!! My wife called ahead to see how long the wait would be for carry out and we were surprised that we were told 30 minutes. I swung by on my way home and our order was ready when I pulled up right about 30 minutes after ordering! The pizza was one of the best we have ever eaten, the wings were amazing and the breadsticks were awesome!! Hometown is now likely our go to pizza spot! They may have had a bit of a rocky start when they opened their new location, but the definitely seem to have recovered strong!!! read more

Definitely worthy of all 5 stars. Staff was great as was all the food! We tried the breadsticks, wings and chicken bacon ranch pizza and it was all yummy, even the cheese for the breadsticks. This would be an ideal spot for school field trips, birthday parties, family get togethers etc... It's a huge place with pool tables, video games and the kitchen is open concept, so you can watch your pizza being made. I can tell you by far the pizza here is better than the other pizza places here in town!!! read more

See all

Always great food and always great service. Great hometown place. All items are always made fresh and taste great. Nice to go to a place where people remember your name. read more

See all

If your looking for a fun atmosphere, cheap(ish) prices, and good pizza this place is for you. You get the big time flavors with the small town feels. Good place! read more

Pizza was amazing. Crisp crust, but not burnt and lots of toppings. Also ordered the garlic parm wings "crisp" one of the best wings I have had. Cheese sauce was cold, but didn't even need the sauce because the toppings were edge to edge. read more

Delicious! We come here every few months and enjoy the service here. Their pizza is absolutely amazing. Our usual go to is a pepperoni pizza with half pineapple and half green olive! Yum! read more

We haven't actually ordered pizza from here yet. I will update as to how the pizza is when we do later this evening. I'm leaving this 5 star review to try to counter balance the 1 star review based on the fact that they were really busy. This restaurant has been a popular topic in a local FB group lately. It's a small town. You'd think people would be more supportive of local businesses. If your order is taking a long time for delivery, it's because they have been so busy. Be patient. read more

Our first visit. It's in an old historic building on town square, which is really cool IMO! The food was good too. We had cheese pizza, a deluxe pizza, BBQ sandwich, and boneless wings. Besides the food, the place is really kid friendly. Board games and old school arcade games are there to entertain. Overall this would be an awesome place to come for a large group (7-10). Staff was friendly and the place is clean. If you are thinking about giving it a shot I would say go for it!! read more

Best I've had in a long time. Old school pizza not mega chain franchise. Had a deluxe pizza. Excellent! Kids had a great time in the game room. Well worth a little wait. The Uknown Diner digs it! read more

Great pizza - great service - great place to relax! Fun, family friendly, and delicious food! We love the suits of armor in the entry! Perfect summer place for family fun and meals! Gluten free options are available here! read more

This is the WORST pizza I have ever eaten. No flavor what so ever. My wife and I were to split the deluxe and my daughter had a pepperoni. How can you screw up a pepperoni and cheese pizza? Terrible. Would not feed this crap to my dog or enemy. Yuck. read more

Hometown Classic Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenfield, Indiana

Ordered pizza to be delivered at wooden bear brewery. Website on yelp is NOT the right restaurant. Called to place order. Lady was rude. I can't be the first person to ever use yelp menu to attempt order. I finally told her that I only have yelp menu which is clearly wrong. Her response l, " yep." So, after making order out of thin air, pizza was delivered. It was tasty, I'd go again. Recommend stopping in person to place order before heading over to Wooden Bear. UPDATE: correct website has been linked to yelp. read more

Had a deluxe pizza tonight and let's just say it was paper thin with what is suppose to be 5 toppings. There was barely any topping made on it and especially no meat. We've had it better than this. read more

OMG... YUMMY! FAST DELIVERY, GOOD PRICES-BEST PIZZA DELIVERY IN GREENFIELD!I live @ the campground n the delivery driver found my campsite n got my pizza here hot n ready in less than an hour! I recommend you giv'em a try next time you're in the mood for delicious hot pizza pie delivered to you in an hour you won't be disappointed! read more

I found 2 long hairs in the first 4 pieces of my pizza. Called and asked for a manger and she said it can happen. Really? Disgusting. Did not offer a remedy and hung up on me. NEVER order from Hometown!! You will be disgusted. read more