An Absolutely Exceptional Stay -- Silver Sands Is Something Special…read more My wife and I spent three days at Silver Sands celebrating our 31st wedding anniversary, and although this was our first visit, it certainly will not be our last. From the moment we arrived until the moment we left, the experience was exceptional. The entire staff went above and beyond to make our stay memorable. What impressed us most was how incredibly organized, attentive, and welcoming everyone was without ever being intrusive. It was almost as if the staff had mastered the art of being there exactly when you needed something, while somehow remaining nearly invisible the rest of the time. That level of service is very difficult to achieve, and Silver Sands does it beautifully. The property itself is immaculate. The grounds are meticulously maintained while still allowing the natural beauty of the surroundings to remain part of the experience. The private beach was spotless, peaceful, and beautifully organized. Throughout the day, we would notice staff quietly moving through, straightening and maintaining everything, yet they were so unobtrusive you could barely tell it was happening. The attention to detail throughout Silver Sands is remarkable. From the design and atmosphere of the property to the pour-over coffee in the room, the thoughtfully selected shampoos and conditioners, linens, amenities, and overall cleanliness -- everything feels intentional. Our room was absolutely impeccable. Silver Sands somehow manages to capture the nostalgia and charm of the classic American motel while feeling modern, sophisticated, and luxurious at the same time. Calling it a "motel" almost doesn't do it justice. It is a truly unique property that can easily rival some of the best hotels and resorts we've stayed at. And then there are Eddie's and Nookie's! Both onsite restaurants were fantastic. The staff and service were wonderful, and everything we ate was top-notch. We left already talking about coming back so we can try more of the menu. Over our 31 years together, my wife and I have been fortunate enough to travel to many beautiful and far-off destinations. Yet there were moments during our stay at Silver Sands when we genuinely felt transported somewhere else entirely -- certainly not like we were still on Long Island, and at times not even like we were anywhere in the United States. It has a special atmosphere that is difficult to describe until you experience it yourself. Thank you to the entire Silver Sands team, as well as everyone at Eddie's and Nookie's, for making our 31st anniversary one of our most memorable, relaxing, and enjoyable staycations. You helped make an already special occasion even more special. We arrived as first-time guests and left knowing we'll be back and bringing others to experience what we had. Thank you again, Silver Sands. See you all soon!

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows is the only place I'll ever stay again in Greenport. This…read moremotel feels like something out of a dream. The service is unbeatable, the grounds are beautiful, and every single detail feels thoughtfully and meticulously curated. I could not have been happier staying here. It's a true oasis of relaxation and the kind of place you never want to leave. Do yourself a favor and book a stay here.

I recently stayed at The Menhaden on July 15, 2026, and it was an exceptional experience from start…read moreto finish. This boutique hotel perfectly balances a luxurious feel with a warm, intimate atmosphere. The highlights of my stay included the careful attention to detail throughout the property, from the beautifully designed rooms to the thoughtfully curated lounge experience (loved the retro board games and Vinyl Record collection) The staff was incredibly attentive and provided top-notch service, ensuring that every need was met promptly and with a smile. Honestly, I could not find any areas for improvement during my visit; everything was seamless and well-executed. Overall, I would rate The Menhaden a solid 5 out of 5 stars. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a boutique hotel that delivers both comfort and luxury with outstanding hospitality.

This hotel is outstanding from start to finish. Everyone is super friendly. They have literally…read morethought of everything you need - they have a beautiful roof deck and they have firepits, blankets and you can roast smores. They have a lovely lounge that comes with games, and an amazing atmosphere. They leave out snacks all day that change with the time of day - cereal around breakfast, warm cookies at night. The rooms are cozy. Love it!

In the midst of farmland, vineyards, and tiny port towns, there are no Hiltons or Holiday inns to…read morebe seen. Everything around here is small, personable and locally run -- adding to the charm of being out on the east end. Your options are a smattering of bank breaking bed and breakfasts, hard to acquire airbnb rentals, cottages by the golf course and a motel with one of the best views you've ever seen. The blue inn falls somewhere in the middle of those choices. Our room reminded me of a cozy ski lodge rental. Small kitchenette, exposed wood beams and a pleasing country decor. Rates were extremely reasonable (about $150 midweek off season). Everything was very clean and they even left us a surprisingly nice toiletry package with toothpastes, floss, makeup wipes, Q-tips etc. It's the little things like this, which I wasn't really expecting that really added a nice touch. Our stay was pleasant, however the noise level deserves a mention. There were folks staying on both sides of the room and at night I could hear bits of conversations about who knows what and both of their TVs blaring incoherently. Thankfully our neighbors weren't night owls or I would have not gotten any sleep. As for sleeping - the king size bed was cozy and mushy. I liked it but its probably to soft for most. Unfortunately, the restaurant and pool were not open but I wouldn't have minded checking both out had I been here during the summer!

It's an okay place, nothing special, nothing really bad. The staff is pleasant and helpful and the…read morerooms are kept spotlessly clean. Has a roomy mini-fridge with a freezer compartment. The grounds and buildings are well-maintained. We had a second-floor room with steep stairs; no elevator. Breakfast is all carbs, only on weekends when we were there in mid- May; the restaurant was otherwise closed. The room has a small table with two kitchen chairs. There is no desk or comfy chair. The bathroom sink has no space to put anything by it. In our room, the toilet valve had to be manually reseated after every flush, and they couldn't fix it for the four days we were there. We might have changed rooms, but that seemed like a bigger pain.

Upon calling now, I got a rude and obnoxious reservation representative. Had an attitude and acted…read morethough I was bothering her to look up rooms. Not all people calling are from NYC but locals. How do you answer a phone and have an attitude when someone is asking questions about the facility. WOW. Shocked! She needs to find another job and be more hospitable and personable. If they deal with perspective bookers this way I can't imagine how they handle real problems and issues. I got nicer treatment from their sister facility in Montauk.

Booked through third party site and "sea view" was advertised however after paying they assigned us…read morea lawn view and then the hotel told me to take it up with the third party we booked through. After the third party site contacted the property I was assigned a partial sea view when I arrived. That partial view was very lack luster. Walls are very thin.. it sounded like someone was in our unit but it was the noise from the surrounding units. The beach is very shabby looking .. The young male pool attendant with the dark curly hair was a sweetheart (very polite and sociable young man) Most of the other young staff were rude and dismissive. Called about a later check out since 5pm is the check in and 10 am is the check out .. I literally asked DEVIN (front desk) for an additional 20 mins and said we would check out at 10:20 but I was told "No unfortunately you and your party need to be out by 10" SHEESH Smdh .. I will say my family did enjoy the mobile pizza truck that they had there giving out complimentary fresh pizza on a Monday and also they had an outdoor family movie that I thought looked nice. The pool hours are also too early .. it's august and they close the pool at 7. Overall I would NOT stay here again or recommend it. It does not seem as if customer service is a priority for them!

My wife and I spent a weekend out in Greenport this August. The accomodations were immaculate and…read morewe were very impressed with our one bedroom cottage. Each cottage has a picnic bench, BBQ grill, and fire pit with chairs. A huge bonus is that it's dog-friendly so we were able to enjoy the weekend with our two senior pups. There are plenty of amenities available at the resort such as a restaurant, pool, pickleball courts, huge outdoor seating area, which we didn't even take full advantage of. We will definitely plan on coming back during our next trip in the North Fork.

I had a great birthday weekend here! The cottage was adorable and beautifully designed inside and…read moreout, and most importantly clean! The resort is beautiful. Loved the fire pit area, which was so relaxing! The pool was clean, and the restaurant had delish food. There was a complimentary tea and coffee station at reception. The staff is sweet and even gave me a sweatshirt for my birthday as a souvenir! A great place for a girls trip or a family trip! We will be back!

Stayed here with my family last week. It was very clean and they were extremely accommodating. We…read moreextended our stay and they even moved our items to another room for us while we were out on the town. It includes breakfast, but we didnt eat there, just got the children some fruit. In photos it looks like there is a bar but is not. The pool was very clean and a nice area. I would stay again.

We had a three night stay at this cute little hotel. We arrived in a Tuesday and parking was a…read morelittle difficult. It's a small lot and street parking is crazy. But we eventually grabbed a spot. Walking in the front door and to the right is a beautiful bar. That is where the continental breakfast is served. The breakfast included bagels, fruit, coffee tea etc. The bar does not serve any alcohol; however there are many bars you can walk to if you want. The ladies at the front desk are very very accommodating. We were assisted by Jessica and Monica and both were very helpful. We loved our rooms overlooking the harbor. The balcony had two chairs and a small end table. Very nice. The rooms were inviting, spacious and clean. There were different pictures on the wall, dried flower arrangements and a gorgeous marble table with two chairs around it. The rooms also had a nice leather chair in each one. I felt the beds were comfortable and it had four comfy pillows per bed, along with some decorative pillows. The bathroom was large with a big sink and counter space. The showers were huge. They had several different sprays on the shower walls, which could be turned on. The bathrooms were nice and clean and the towels were huge. The kids loved the pool. It's not too big but it was ok. There are tables and chairs around the pool as well as umbrellas and lounge chairs. All in all, we loved the hotel and are considering another stay next summer. To myself and my family, this is a five star hotel. We loved it!

For what it is, it's great! My family and I come here about once a year. The price is good and the…read morepool is clean. It's about 15 minute walk into town. The staff is very friendly. They upgraded us today bc they had the up grade available... the rooms are clean with a historic look , a small marina where you can pull Up your boat... we love it here!

A quaint hotel, restaurant and marina in Greenport, NY. A must stay for tourists visiting the…read morearea. It's close enough to the village you can walk or hang out by the pool during the summer. They are renovating rooms. Those they have done are beautiful. The area is quiet. Certainly a peaceful location to rest and relax. If you want to find something more lively you can walk or Uber to the village. Check out the local wineries while visiting the area. They all have such wonderful character. The owner of Townsend Manor Inn is a local, born and raised in Greenport. Scott has a wealth of knowledge of the area so feel free to ask him if you happen to bump into him. Otherwise the bartenders are great too! A must see/stay location in Greenport.

Came with a party of 11 plenty of capacity and restaurant handled it well. Drinks came out pretty…read morequickly. Food took awhile but that was to be expected. Burger and truffle fries were mind blowing. The pasta clearly had been sitting in the pass for awhile and was okay but not great. Overall would come back for a fun ambience and would try something else on the menu.

Cute restaurant with relatively large venue. Classic American staples - good quality and quick…read moreservice. Atmosphere was cute as we enjoyed burgers, pasta, buratta, and salads. For dessert enjoyed cookies and dunk-a- Roos. Really enjoyed the apps and recommend

Amazing hotel with even better service. The location is…read moreperfect--just steps from everything in Greenport. The design has a fun retro vibe that's both stylish and thoughtfully done. You really don't need anything more. I was obsessed with the flavored water in the lobby--such a great touch. Don't miss relaxing by the firepit in the evening. A wonderful stay all around!

Most awful place I have ever stayed in my entire life. This hotel is very run down and extremely…read moreoverpriced.