Delicious food!!! I've ate here many times & it's always…read morebeen fantastic. Great cheddar broccoli soup Stellar sandwiches And their brewed ice tea = out of this world Service is hit or miss. Ordering is done at the counter & they bring your meal out to you. Most of the time. My 4 star review is because a few times they have yelled out my name for the entire county to hear. Prices are a little high & worth it. But, not if it's occasionally cafeteria gig

Giving three stars because I frequently come to this McAlisters and I always get a good meal…read more Unfortunately today was the exception to that. I ordered the grilled chicken club. I will attach photos of what it is supposed to look like, and what I received. I did come in 30 minutes before close, and I felt like the employee must have been done trying for the day and decided to just make the "sandwich" however they felt like it. It was clear they were blatantly disregarding this order which is u fortunate because I also paid extra for this order to have the gluten free bread and didn't even end up eating it. I was having a rough night and this was supposed to be my 'pick me up'. Very disappointed because I usually have no issues with my order or the service, which is why I would come frequently.

Really fresh tasting ingredients! The bread was soft and tasted fresh as well. I asked for extra…read moremeat and it didn't really look like extra, but the meat did taste good too. I wish there was a secret sauce or something like that to add to the sub. Overall an above average sub, but not an amazing sub. The cookies were top notch and were my favorite part of the meal!

Good Sammys, lots of meat and a nice chunk of bread. Plus, the people that work here are cool and…read moreseem to enjoy it. Its a pretty simple sandwich, but somehow it turns out special. Plus, they get you in and out of there, unlike other sandwich joints, which seem to be a big production. The dining space is pretty small, I always grab mine to go.

We just tried this place out for the first time and we really liked it! The bread is amazingly soft…read moreand fresh with a nice crunch on the outside (but not too hard). The turkey bacon sandwich was top notch to go with the soup. The Good, Really Good Chicken noodle soup was better than most, but it was missing something. Like maybe more veggies or chicken? My girlfriend ordered the chicken bowlrita. And she really liked hers as well. We'd give it a 4.5 if we could, but going with 4.

This guy was new but this boy did put a cheese divider in my sandwich. And forgot part of my order.read more

Friendly helpful staff, a large selection subs and soups, and a clean seating area. Prices run…read more12-16 dollars for subs and my half-sub is about 8" long, get the full for a meal now and one later.

I absolutely love this place. Clean space, big sandwiches, good staff, and the subs are so good…read moreevery single time. No complaints at all. If you want an amazing sandwich GET IT HERE!!

Employees were amazing !!! We were going to dine it however the temp inside the store felt like it…read morewas approx 80 degrees . I would refuse to work in that heat, I feel horrible for those workers.. Boardwalk ....Turn your air on for your employees and customers . Extremely uncomfortable

We came in this evening after a long day of traveling and didn't know what to get. The lovely girl…read morebehind the counter was super helpful and even let us try a slice of meat we had never heard of. She convinced us to get number 11 and make it a rouge. Super grateful for her suggestions and kind guest service. I wish I was in town longer so I could go back.

Good food, healthy portions and great drinks, we've had great service 9 out of 10 times and one…read moregood service (possibly a new waitress who had to be reminded to bring things a few times). Very good overall and pricing is fair. Nice servers and a good vibrant atmosphere.

I ordered the olive burger, and was literally all I got on the burger. Burger itself was dry. Added…read moresome catsup to help out the dryness. Never received my water. Fries were good, but nothing special. Wouldn't not go back, or recommend. Was very loud, not easy to talk with your friends.

Emma is amazing. Friendly staff. Just don't get the steak sandwich! I don't think this was an…read moreindividual location problem -more of a corporate problem. It was very gristley (I could barely chew) and crazy over-peppered. But again, not a reflection on the individual restaurant. Our other food was aesthetically pleasing and delish!

Dan is awesome. He helped me resolve an issue with an order and I can't thank him enough. I am more…read morethan happy to support a business that has good employees and good people who are helpful. Although this isn't the closest potbelly to us, I will support this location time and time again solely because of Dan and the exceptional customer service he provided.

I set up a group of senior ladies that graduated from Wyoming Park High School in 1964 and each…read moreyear they have been so accommodating and are willing to take our picture of our amazing group who have been friends for over 60 years!

Great food, good atmosphere, and an attentive wait staff…read more Had the lasagna and ceaser salad - would definitely recommend.

Very good sandwiches and quick service plus a large variety to choose from. Calling ahead offers a…read moreshort pickup time which was nice cause these sandwiches take a little time to make and lines at lunch can be longer.

Food and services were good The facility is filthy. I don't…read morethink the floor has been swept in two days. They have an ant problem as well. However, I know ants this time of year can be a seasonal thing. The bathroom is absolutely filthy. I don't think it's had a sufficient cleaning in well over a week. Smells of urine.

Cute place that's been here about a year. I found the staff to be friendly and tried the 1/4 sub…read morecombo with the #17 roast beef, Turkey, and prostini (house made ham) with a cup of potato soup and soda. I was quoted $13.99, but unfortunately charged over $16! It wasn't until I looked at my texted receipt that I noticed I was overcharged for half a sub instead of a quarter. Bummer. I went "rogue" with my sub where they turn the sub inside out, rub oil on it and grill it like a panini. It was good and worth the $.75 upgrade. Overall, the quality is good. I like the many mayonnaise and mustard options. Veggies tasted fresh. It's just a let down to pay so much for so little. For the same price I could sit down and have entire meal at The Winn that would be much larger (granted, I didn't get half the sub I paid for). The potato soup was okay. Not as good as Red Lobster's potato bacon. Just kinda a one note salty flavor. I probably wouldn't get that again. If I do decide to return, I might just get a huge sub for $15-16 and split it amongst my family. That was the highlight of the meal. Good meats, fresh veggies, inventive presentation with the rogue option and I enjoyed the mayonnaise Provence for some extra herbs. Next time, I'll inquire when I feel the price is too much. Oh well.

Subs are always great, enough for dinner and lunch the next day. My son loves the rogue style! The…read morestaff are very friendly- Asa, Spencer, and Christian- nice job guys! Clean place, will be back.