Used their online menu to order an xl New Yorker. This thing was HUGE! It had virtually everything on it and was very good. Only bad thing I could say is that the slices were too big to hold. read more

Typically this place is a hit but not so much last night. The waitress (girl with the long pink finger nails) got our order wrong; we got a chicken piccata to split and a lasagne, they brought out two lasagnas. Two of us had to sit there and wait until they brought out the second dish. Trying to get the waitresses attention for a second plate to split the pasta and the garlic knots that were forgotten and she's just flirting it up at the counter with all the boys working there!! Finally got her attention and the stuff that was missing and she never checked on us again. Also charged us for the split dish but never said there was going to be a charge when we ordered. read more

Hmmm. Hadn't been here in awhile so we got a pizza to go. Floppy and soggy. Couldn't fold it, because it would droop. I gave a 3 because the toppings were fresh and tasty, but the pizza crust was a 1. Cheers! RS read more

Brooklyn Joes - IPA - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

We often drive over an hour to have dinner here. I usually get the 1/2 Caesar salad with grilled chicken and my husband gets the eggplant Parmesan sandwich. Both are excellent. Occasionally, I will order the spaghetti bolognese, which is also exceptional . The portions are so large that I have enough for two more subsequent meals . Great value for the money. We usually have a preferred server, Lisa who is outstanding . On the days that Lisa is not there, we try to sit in Allie's section. Both ladies are attentive and provide attention to detail. It's a sports bar,often loud, so the ambiance is not conducive to a quiet romantic evening. If you are looking for a decent meal, with generous portions, look no further. Highly recommended. read more

I love the tortellini cardinal. The Greek salad is also good with lots of toppings. The service is always good and it is a nice cozy experience. read more

Brooklyn Joes - Greek Salad - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

See all

Reviewed before but unable upload photos So here are a few - ok similar to chain Johnny pizza. Nice server. By the way very nice & clean women bathroom read more

Brooklyn Joes - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

See all

Had a birthday party and ordered (4) XL Pizzas! I called earlier in the day and was able to place the order with a specific delivery time! The pizza was brought on time and was hot and fresh! read more

See all

Brooklyn Joes has a great lunch menu with specials. I love the Ebbitts Field or Autumn Harvest salad. The service is always great as well.

Omg the best baked Ziti ever, true NY style pizza and terrific service. Have great lunch specials until 4PM. If you are traveling through, stop at this spacious, delicious and non-chain establishment, you won't regret it. read more

See all

This is a favorite place of ours. We order out frequently from here as well as have eaten in. Service is as great as the food. We've had several pasta dishes, subs, pizza, calamari, and Stromboli. Everything has been wonderful. If I had to pick a weak point, it'd be the subs, but they're still better than most places in that regard. Highly recommend!! read more

See all

Amazing experience!!! Their menu had so many choices and decided to ask my waitress what was popular. She had suggested the tortellini, and it was awesome. Staff was very polite and professional!!! Highly recommended!!! read more

Brooklyn Joes - Tortellini - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

See all

Have enjoyed the service and pizza here. Consistently good food and service, I liked the lunch specials

Fast, attentive service but we really love the sliced sausage topping on the pizzas and lasagna.

The food tastes so fresh. The garlic rolls are delectable. The service has always been friendly, fast, and attentive. The atmosphere is relaxed and easy going. Always enjoy coming here. read more

So we asked for crispy, and got major flop. Under cooked cheese, and much too small for the price. Why isn't there any good pizza in this area ? Highly disappointed. read more

Absolutely, the finest pizza I have eaten since I was in Brooklyn, New York decades ago. For the big family, we ordered an all cheese pizza and an all meat pizza, as well as a calzone and a large salad. The order was to go, which was driven back to a beautiful location in Dahlonega where it was eaten and devoured quickly by the very hungry family that were eating a very late supper about 8 PM. Every bite was dynamic incredible and fantastic. it is amazing to find Pizza of this caliber along Georgia 400 in Dawson County, GA. They really get it done, and if you want pizza, you owe it to yourself to go here. read more

Top notch!!! This place is gold, baby!!! How you doing? I'm 100% newyorican from that Bronx baby!! And this place is amazing... NYC pizza at its finest. Ordered the Bronx bomber, and it was so delicious the meats were delish and the veggies were fresh a must try!!!! The tile service was also on point! read more

See all

We were visiting my sister and family in Cumming for the weekend. We had been out "Jeeping" through the mountains and wanted to pickup pizza on the way home. She had tried this place once before and liked it. We did multiple dishes and were pleased with all of them. We had a chicken tenders basket with fries, a Stromboli, a pizza, a chicken fettuccine entree, a Greek salad and a side salad. There was a lot of food and even five people couldn't finish all they ordered. The only thing that wasn't great were the fries that were really undercooked. Everything else was good. The gentleman that answered the phone was so nice and helpful in answering my questions. I would recommend this spot. They also have wings, paninis, soup, desserts, etc. read more

See all

This is a great place for lunch. The specials are well worth the money and taste great I have also dined here in the evening and had a few brews again well worth the money. The service has always been friendly and prompt. read more

I've heard good things about this place. Drive by there all the time. Finally checked it out last weekend. Garlic knots were scrumptious. They had one of my favorite dishes, chicken piccata , I opted for a side of pasta Alfredo instead of marinara. . It was yummy! Rest of the family wasn't feeling pasta . They got burgers and also a Philly, We will back. I'm trying the pizza next time. read more

It's been a few years since we've eaten here. Really enjoyed this place when it first opened. Love the variety of the menu options. The service was great on our last visit however we weren't impressed with the food. The garlic buns must have been microwaved because they were so tough my knife wouldn't even cut through it, they couldn't have been fresh. The rest of the meal was alright but nothing to rave about. We probably won't be back. Disappointing. read more

Had an awesome takeout of veal Marsala, comes with a great side of spaghetti and garlic knots. Added a small salad. Just perfect!

Reminds me of NYC pizza. Reminds me of home. We had the order delivered and it was fast and without a hitch. read more

Lunch ziti good and Stromboli. Tasty. Clean place, easy in s f outback of plaza. Good parking. Good server. I got lunch do very good deal $11, but hubby charged $7 for a Extra salad ? Kinda high ...., pizzas supper to be good too read more

I had Mama's Lasagna with a small Greek Salad and it was great! The portion sizes are huge and everyone at the table had no complaints whatsoever. Our server had many tables but she was extremely attentive to everything we needed and went above and beyond! The ambiance of the location was very gentle and quiet/family style and was really cozy. I will be back for sure read more

If you want good New York style pizza go to Brooklyn Joes for dinner. Great selection of Italian food with great wine and beer choices as well. The service is always good and the restaurant reminds you of an old Italian eatery in NY. read more

I really hope this wasn't a fluke because i'm already planning my next visit! We had a taste for Italian. He wanted spaghetti. I wanted a stromboli. Brooklyn had them both on the menu, so I called it in. 20 minutes later, I pulled up to the curbside spot and a friendly young lady brought out my order. Once we got home, I was immediately impressed by the portion sizes. I ordered a small stromboli and easily shared it with my 2 children. Hubby ate spaghetti until his tummy was content and still had leftovers. Aside from the portions, the food was just really good. Seasoning in and on the stromboli was perfect and it was cooked just right. I'll have to come back to try other menu items because these choices were very impressive. read more

Good pizza is hard to find and they deliver. Did takeout so don't have much more to say about ambience or service

Always good! Love the bolognese and meatballs! Great pizza, our go to in Dawsonville.

I have been here many times over the past few years. Their Pizza is excellent, I am a Jersey girl and their pizza is my favorite in all of North Georgia. I have had their salads too and they are fresh and amazing too. It's a great casual spot that will please anyone in your party with their large selections and reasonable prices. I'm a fan. read more

Great family friendly atmosphere. Our server was Lisa. Family friend and great worker. She was friendly and so helpful. There every time we needed something. The food was delicious. We had to come from Detroit to get Detroit style pizza that tasted great. I would have taken pictures of the food but we were a large group and hungry too. So of course it disappeared. So I guess no picture of food is a good thing since we devoured it. The garlic knots were good but I like mine with a little more butter than garlic. They were delicious. I would say Fazzolis garlic bread is my favorite. read more

Dine-in restaurants may not be an option right now with Shelter in Place, but I still definitely crave some Italian food that I didn't have to cook myself. Brooklyn Joe's definitely hits the spot. Their staff is super friendly and helpful and my order was ready in just 10 minutes. I will definitely be back. read more

Brooklyn Joes - Whole wheat penne with broccoli, oil, and garlic - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

Perfect for groups, kids, and lunch!!! This is in a strip mall next to Hacienda Mexican restaurant and there is plenty of parking. Came here for a Sunday family lunch with 6 adults and 2 kids. Service is great and food was delicious. We ordered the Tortellini Cardinal and the Buffalo Chicken wrap. And it was hot and full of flavor. Pizzas and Stromboli looked awesome too! Dessert is basic. We will be back to try more so bring your appetite! read more

Brooklyn Joes - Pizza Near Me - Dawsonville, Georgia

See all

I'm starting this review as I wait for my appetizer , it's been 20 minutes since I've put it in and 2 tables that sat down before us have received their entrees . If the food is solid it may be worth it . I'll continue after I get it . Update, another table got their appetizer and their entree, still haven't gotten mine 10 minutes later . Ok, I did get my appetizer , the Joes sampler. It was good, however I got my entree probably within 5 minutes , not nearly enough time between appetizer and entree Overall my chicken parm was good, my brothers Stromboli was way too greasy, as was my girlfriends pizza. Food alone it was a 3.5 maybe 4, but the wait time was horrible. I think it's just the sampler though so I will try again and change the appetizer I get. The waitress was nice and it's not her fault the food took a long time. It seems this place is just inconsistent and in the past it's been great, tonight it was not . read more

We (party of 6) ordered garlic knots, fried pickles, fried mushrooms, gluten free personal pizza, a kid's spaghetti and meatball, and an extra large pizza with half bbq chicken, and half New York. It was all incredible! Before tip, the bill was $85. We all had plenty to eat, everything tasted fresh, and the service was so great and fast! The bathrooms and place was very clean as well. Loved everything about this place! read more

Great food and great service! The location is convenient and easy to access. I really like their pizza!

Went in for lunch ordered 2 slices and a coke pizza was decent needed more sauce crust was good.The girl that served me was very nice.My only beef is 2 slices and a coke should not be $13 bucks with tip it was $15 that is crazy in my opinion.And trust me I know good pizza growing up in the Bronx. read more

Food is okay ish, service is good, but every time we come here lose my appetite from having to look at Sean Hannitys stupid idiot face while I eat. Can there just a a space without any politics? Change the channel for gods sake. Cartoons. Sports. HGTV maybe. read more

It was a pleasure doing business with Brooklyn Joe's enjoy the pizzas. Their customer service is very good. The only problem my head is I've had a few pieces from there recently that have been a little bit too. Burned on the bottom, but they are more than happy to rectify any problems that you may have. Personally, I think Brooklyn Joe's is one of the local businesses that truly has their act together, food quality is excellent and one of the better pizzas I've had in Georgia. read more

Tonight after a long day of work my husband and I wanted pizza. We called Papa John's in Dahlonega. It was a 45 minute wait. The special was Large w 3 tipping for $15.99 we decided not to wait. We really wanted pizza so we called Brooklyn Joe's in Dawsonville we order the large with pepperoni, olives and mushrooms. The girl said $32.00 when I hung up the phone we looked at each other and said I think they made a mistake on the price but no when we picked it up Jamir was 32.00 I told the girl who was checking me out they I think they made a mistake on the price. She said no it was right. The boy at the cash register said we had to go up on our price. Omg it was a large pizza with 3 topping. We could have gone to Longhorns had great food for less than $32.00. By the way the pizza was ok not great way too expensive for pizza! read more