The interior was much nicer than we thought. The waitress was very attentive. My husband had the Garlic Ravioli with sun dried tomatoes and spinach. He loved the fact that it had lots of spinach. My calzone was very good. read more

Isabella's Pizza - Interior - Italian Near Me - Newcastle, Wyoming

Excellent. Food was out of this world. Service was even better. Our waiter was attentive, kind, and so pleasant. The food truly surprised us. We highly recommend the pizza bombs, brisket, mac & cheese, and anything that they smoke. Anything related to the Alfredo is truly worth your time. They make their own Alfredo, and it is so good. read more

Food is tasty and comes out hot! Servers are friendly and will help you any way they can. Ambiance is lovely with the wood stools and chairs. read more

Fantastic food and the waitress was very awesome! The restaurant was very attractive and created a lot of ambiance in my mind! I've been feeling really productive lately, which is nice read more

Fabulous! The food was extraordinary! I had the classic, pineapple green pepper pizza. It was cooked to perfection and tasted amazing. The service was excellent! The ambiance was out of this world! The only negative thing was that the toilet was clogged (my bad). I will definitely be coming back! Also, I think I saw Elvis in the corner eating breadsticks. read more

Stopped in for lunch on our way through town. Service was excellent and the pizza was out of this world! Perfect ratio of cheese to pepperoni with requisite amount of delicious pizza grease. Probably among the top five best I've ever had. Get the hand tossed crust. Highly recommend! read more

Isabella's Pizza - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Newcastle, Wyoming

Food was the best. Love the country vibe. I got the white sauce pizza. Loved every bit of it. Service was the absolute best. Love small town businesses. read more

The Steak and Shrimp pasta is fire! Good atmosphere...Summer Shandy in to bottle...what's not to like...I'm ever in town again I'll be there. read more

This is a decent place. I'm pretty sure it's family-owned, but when your waitress has to go back multiple times to answer simple questions, it makes your experience less of great. I ordered their version of Fish and Chips. It was okay. I'm glad I ate the last strip, as it seemed slimy or under cooked. Came with parmesan fries, which I asked for regular fries. My husband had their Cheeseburger and it was 'decent.' read more

Nice simple atmosphere, several food choices, something for everyone. Full bar with good local micro brews.

We stopped here for lunch as a halfway point between Custer, SD and the Devil's Tower, WY. The taco burger was great and my husband liked the blue cheese burger too. Quick service and nice staff also. Parking in lot or on side street. read more

Cold food, bad service waitress not present at all, I ordered brisket mac n cheese and didn't even get brisket I had to ask for it, no refill in 30 mins, food was okay but cold. Wouldn't recommend!!!! read more

Just get a regular Cheeseburger, it looks like one you grilled at home! The patio out front may need some paint but don't be fooled

What a great place to dine. We are passing through on our way to Custer State Park and read the great reviews. The outside dining is a must for us, it is a pleasant setting on a hot summer evening. The food and brews were great. My burger cooked perfectly, my husband's salad hit the spot. The Porter was rich and full of volume, as I brought the Peach Wheat to my mouth I could smell the fragrance of the peaches so smooth. read more

See all

While staying in Custer, SD, we decided to have lunch here at Isabella's in Newcastle, Wyoming. It was pretty good. The waitresses were nice. Everything seemed clean and well taken care of. There is nice outdoor seating too. read more

See all

Their "Juicy chicken":Dry and tough. Seasoned rice: plain with parsley on top Cheeseburger: no seasoning BBQ fries: bbq is bland, fries soggy Kids Alfredo: she could eat the chicken it was too tough but she ate some of the noodles and (jar/canned/frozen...not fresh) sauce Breaded raviolis: inner cheese cold, out crust soft We won't be back. read more

The shrimp alfredo was good but instead of plain unbuttered it should be toasted!! Service was good, don't like the 4% add on for using a card read more

Isabella's was just the place I was looking for. It was recommended to me by the staff at the Sage Motel where I was staying for evening. I had come to Newcastle, Wyoming after spending the day visiting wonderful Devils Tower National Monument about 75 miles away. Eventually I was heading towards Custer, South Dakota exploring the sights and attractions of the Black Hills. I figured though Newcastle would be a good stopping point to rest for the evening. After checking into the Sage Motel, I had no idea where a good place for dinner would be. They mentioned Isabella's, located in the center of town. Actually, the town of Newcastle is pretty small...just sort of a drive through town....so finding Isabella's was no problem. I'm surprised..when I pulled up to the restaurant in the middle of the travel season of July around 7pm, it was rather quiet and empty. They have outdoor seating with even a canopy. Though no one was eating outside. Still, what drew me to this place was that local "mom and pop" type look and feel to it....and my anticipation of having some authentic homemade Italian food of course, lol. The restaurant resembled a reddish barn from a farm and when you enter inside, there are a couple of booths, tables and chairs in a main dining room area including a separate bar around the bend as well as access to the outside seating. My overall impression of Isabella's consistently reminded me of SMALL TOWN. I couldn't get that feeling out of my head, yet it's these types of places that I appreciate...coming to a simple restaurant in a quiet locale on the border of Wyoming and South Dakota. The menu had just about anything you could find and expect from an Italian restaurant. Starters, salads, homemade bread and soup, subs, pasta, calzones, pizzas, even burgers, paninis, wraps, steaks! The menu was pretty diversified and prices are plenty reasonable. The subs, pastas, sandwiches, wraps. etc...all ranged from $10 or so dollars, large pizzas $15 - $20. I chose a chicken parmesan sub, which came with a side....like mac and cheese, green beans, mashed potatoes, coleslaw, fries, rice, broccoli, or even soup or salad. I went with a salad which they brought out to me as my starter. The salad was fresh and delicious. My chicken parm sub was hot with nicely baked bread, sauce, melted cheeses and crispy pieces of fried chicken. Combined...my salad and hero went perfectly together....just what I was craving after being out on the road hiking around Devils Tower all day and then making my way here to Newcastle. Finally, the staff were friendly and attentive. The good service and food combined with the ambiance of this small town restaurant was ideal for me. I couldn't have asked for much more. I know there's not much happening in Newcastle, Wyoming, but if you're in town and stopping for the evening or while driving cross country....I'd certainly recommend eating at Isabella's. read more

See all

Last option left on a Sunday at 8pm. Was driving through town on a cross country trip with my girlfriend. Was disappointed in the initial wait time and response to be seated by a certain waitress. However Jamie stepped in and provided amazing service. She was working the bar but served us outside on the patio for the hour or so we were there. The food was fantastic including the portobello & sausage tortellinis (all homemade) and the taco burger. Would recommend this place for food and environment any day if in town for more than an hour! read more

The owner of the hotel where we stayed recommended Isabella's and I'm glad we went. The food was wonderful! Don't be mislead. Yes, they have pizza, but that's only a fraction of the menu. For appetizers we got Greenie Meanies and Spinach Artichoke dip. The Meanie Greenies are jalepeno's with cheese, roasted brisket and a raspberry sauce. I'm not sure the raspberry sauce added to the dish, but it was tasty. The dip was more sour cream that spinach or artichoke, but the toasted bread was wonderful. For dinner we got Mexican Tater Tot skillet, Italian Salmon Skillet and a personal Italian Pizza. The pizza was tasty, the sauce was superb. Mexican Tater skillet may sounds a little iffy, but it was wonderful. Black beans, corn, taco-seasoned meat, tater tots and lots of cheese. I loved my Salmon, served with an Alfredo sauce over pasta. But the pasta was not cooked in salt water, so it was a little bland. The sauce was a little watery. The prices were OK-ish. I think $10 for a personal pan pizza is a little stiff. The service was excellent, the food came quickly. So...not a perfect meal, but certainly tasty enough that we'll be going back again. read more

The patio is open and spacious, the menu has lots of options, and the food was great! read more

Isabella's Pizza - Green Pizza - Italian Near Me - Newcastle, Wyoming

See all

Sometimes a good waitress makes a wonderful impression and lasting memory. Terra made our dinner delightful with her friendly demeanor, charming personality and expert knowledge of what was good to eat. Isabella's was recommended by the motel where we are staying. The menu is lengthy - pasta, burgers, Italian fare, pizzas - there is something for everyone here. Portion sizes were large and the prices most reasonable. It is a hopping place, even on the weeknights. Beer and wine available. Street parking nearby. read more

See all

I've been looking for a good calzone for a long time. This was not a good calzone. This was a great calzone. Try it, you'll like it. read more

I hate giving small places bad reviews, but this was pretty ridiculous. I ordered a pizza to go on the road. The price of the pizza was 17.95. I asked my waitress how much the extra toppings are, she said they are 40-65 cents. I ordered 4 veggie toppings. When I get the bill the pizza is $28.95. She said oh they change depending on the size you get, when it says very clearly "price is for large 16" pizza" I had to argue with the person in charge to change it. I wouldn't have ordered the pizza to begin with if I knew the real price for the toppings. The waitress also forgot one of my orders which was Mac n Cheese, my Alfredo pasta sauce was not warm, and my cousins salad tasted old. The staff was nice and friendly. I hope they improve their service. read more

Coming into Newcastle, I was struck by the superb Jeffersonian style Weston Courthouse and going around the corner to park for a photo, there was Isabella's Pizza. I ordered a calzone with various meats and veggies. I was very good with the marina sauce inside rather than poured over the top. Some nice greens came with the calzone. read more

Isabella's Pizza - Early Lunch Time in Newcastle. - Italian Near Me - Newcastle, Wyoming

See all

Takeout was great- got the kids Mac and cheese, adult Mac and cheese with brisket, and the stuffed jalapeños appetizer- all the food was delicious and came out pretty quick too. Inside of restaurant was cool and our server was nice as well. read more

WONDERFUL place! We're staying in Newcastle on our way to Yellowstone and Isabella's looked like our kinda spot. We had the "green meanies" and split a ribeye. Everything was delicious and cooked to perfection! We did not catch the chef's name but she was a delight, and she sure knows what medium rare is! Customer service was amazing and everything came out so fast. Flavor was on point! I will definitely tell anyone passing this way to stop and eat there! read more

Nice little bar in grill! An unexpected surprise with a full American menu beyond pizza. I had the brisket on macaroni and cheese. It was delicious comfort food. The restaurant staff was friendly and attentive. This place is worth the stop if you are on Highway 16 traveling through Wyoming. read more

Isabella's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Newcastle, Wyoming

Good clean family environment. Good food good service, love going here with the family

What a pleasant surprise! Cranberry Walnut and Mae's Spinach salads were excellent, and by splitting the small Vegetarian Lasagna, we had more than enough for lunch. Specialty desserts included Chocolate Raspberry Cake, Peanut Butter Delight, and a wide selection of ice cream, shakes, malts, floats and sundae's. I had the Turtle Sandae! Do not miss this fun restaurant located in old town Newcastle. read more

Isabella's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Newcastle, Wyoming

While there's not much to choose from for miles around, you won't be disappointed. The atmosphere is a small town with kind staff. I had the build you own steak fajitas that were delicious and came with almost too much meat; priced at $12.95. My wife had the Reuben and tots. Nothing wow with the sandwich (it was certainly good), but the tots were the best. The show stopper is the homemade berry tart and vanilla ice cream. Yum all around. read more

Isabella's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Newcastle, Wyoming

See all

This place was too cute and the food was awesome. We were passing through on a cross country road trip and stopped in for dinner. I have the tortellini and my boyfriend had the taco burger. Both were excellent dishes. Have a nice outdoor seating area where we enjoyed our dinner. Great local place. read more

Our party of 4 stopped here on our way through town and it was fantastic! Great food and you'll leave full! Everything we had was great, the coffee, artichoke dip, brisket and Mac n cheese, mushroom ravioli, brisket wrap, and apple chicken salad wrap. The decor is rustic and welcoming. Definitely recommend Isabella's! read more

One of the better dining choices in Newcastle. They've got great food, and a fun atmosphere. Their pizzas are really exceptional. I've also had their spagetti and meatballs, which was superb. Its a nice place to dine without a doubt! read more

I had the salad with Buffalo chicken--very good and fresh! Great find on our long drive. My daughter had the chicken BLT panini and tomato bisque, also very fresh and good! read more

Isabella's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Newcastle, Wyoming

Traveling from Yellowstone to the Black Hills and needed a good dinner. Isabella's fit the bill, with good draft beer and fine food. Enjoyed it and definitely recommend it. read more

Super busy, waitress (named Stacey) was clearly bouncing back and forth trying to help everybody, but still made sure she got to everyone and checked on us frequently. Amazing food, the jambalaya was great as well as the mac and cheese and lasagna. Great food and great customer service, thank you Stacey ! read more

Isabella's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Newcastle, Wyoming

Nice comfortable lunch spot with good variety. Our lunches were tasty and prompt. The bar next door looked like it would be fun at night.

The best place I've found to have an evening meal along with a cocktail. If tou are adventurous, try the hog fries. Bring a friend to help. The staff are friendly and quick. read more

Newcastle has pretty minimal food options, most of which are greasy or downright nasty but, Isabella's is a slight improvement. Salads are pretty good (they're the only thing that MAY not have fallen off the Sysco truck) pizza and pasta are anywhere from generic at best to bland. Service is ok but, everyone in Newcastle acts like they're swamped when there really isn't much of anything going on. read more