We ordered to-go around 4:45pm on a weekday and it was ready by 5:15pm. The pick up was quick and easy and they accept credit card. We ordered four large pizzas and three servings of the large strawberry field salad. The margarita pizza was popular along with the Hawaiian. The crust is chewy and reminiscent of a good New York style pizza. The meat added to the pizza and toppings were generous and filling. It was about $25-30 a pizza and $15 for salads. The strawberry salad was a hit and included strawberries, apples, and pecans. Good pricing for the area, especially the quality. It fed 12 people easily. Absolutely would come back! read more

See all

Another great meal! First night had the Salame Piccante pizza. Had the salads tonight. Full house salad with chicken $17. Strawberry green salad with chicken $18, leaving 2 people too full for one of their yummy desserts. Enjoy! read more

Pizzeria Mangiamo - Pizza Near Me - Hill City, South Dakota

See all

The pizza was excellent, and the restaurant was clean with a very welcoming atmosphere. The highlight of our visit, however, was our server, Yanna. She was absolutely wonderful and couldn't do enough for us. We arrived just before closing, yet she treated us as if we were the first customers of the day. Her friendly attitude, professionalism, and outstanding service made our experience truly memorable. Yanna deserves a ten-star rating. She is a real asset to this restaurant!" read more

Great pizza located in the middle of Hill City. We ordered takeout, it took 20 minutes on a Friday night, and it was hot and delicious!

Stopped in for a late lunch. Seated quickly as it wasn't very crowded. Probably the time of day. Resturant was clean and inviting. We ordered a side salad and a large pepperoni and sausage pizza. Under carriage was cooked to perfection. Perfect amount of meat, however a bit too much cheese for my liking. Service was on point and friendly. Would definitely recommend if looking for a perfect pizza. read more

See all

Quite good pizzeria within Hays, SD. Upon arrival was immediately escorted to any table of choice by our waiter. Drinks (beer & wine only) were provided pronto and in chilled ice glasses as a nice touch. Ordered the neopolian style with sausage and pepperoni with outstanding meat spice and flavor however the mozzarella cheeze was a little overbearing and missing sufficient tomato sauce to my liking. The side salad was a perfect accompiant. When outside temperature permits, try the outside patio seating which overlooks main street and a huge Smokey the Bear wooden carving as an interesting alternative. read more

See all

Mario was the quintessential host answering every question my wife had due to her allergies. She had a gluten-free margarita pizza and I had the gluten filled meat pizza. Both were as delicious a pizza could legally be - and we just moved from the pizza saturated area of Las Vegas. We highly recommend this estab read more

Very tasty. I wish I could have tried more! Very authentic with the italian style pizza. However not used to the minimal cheese thats how authentic. Add cheese would be my recomendation if you want the best of both worlds. read more

Great place to gather! Service was good and our pizza was delicious. Great beer choices too.

Excellent lunch here. We had the strawberry and pecan salad (nice pieces of pecan, fresh greens), a small Salsiccia e Pepperoni and a small cauliflower crust (gluten free) Salami Piccante pizza. Both pizzas were equally good, with a crisp cornmeal crusted base. Not soggy, so yay. Friendly service and nice casual atmosphere. read more

See all

Great wood fire pizza, fresh ingredients. Nice patio facing the hills. Service was great, highly recommend if you're wanting pizza in the hills read more

Pizzeria Mangiamo - Pizza Near Me - Hill City, South Dakota

Best choice for great pizza in the area. Well worth the drive. Great ingredients, as always hot and fresh. Very good salads and desserts as well. read more

This place is awesome! The best pizza in the hills. I get the fire in the hole - it's pepperoni, jalapeño, banana peppers and hot honey. So good! Service is great every-time and the atmosphere is very relaxed and nice. They have a POW/MIA table set up to honor our missing military members - I will always support a company that supports our troops so 10/10 recommend this place! read more

See all

Visited SD from MN ordered a Brooklyn Pizza over the phone staff was very nice and helped immediately and pizza was some of the best I ever had! read more

Horrible service! We arrived shortly before 1:00. Hostess never said a word to us. Just grabbed 2 menus and started walking. I literally asked my husband "Are we supposed to follow her?" She seated us at a 2 top by the bar. We waited for over 5 minutes and were NEVER EVEN ACKNOWLEDGED by ANY of the staff who walked by! We finally got up and walked out. read more

Pizza was really lacking sauce and flavor. I had the Bianca which is light but this pizza was practically dry. We are only here for a few days and got takeout so in all fairness I didn't complain or ask for a redo. Hubby's spice pizza was also lacking any sauce. read more

Delicious and fresh salad! Thankful for a healthy and tasty option! Would eat here again.

Came here with the grandkids on a July vacation in the area. Kids meals were great, adult pizzas were tasty, vegetarian pizza was full of veggies, service was excellent, we moved from outside to inside without any problem, even though they were quite busy. Generous pours of wine, great to a fun day I Hill City. Great place for families! read more

No issues here. Good pizza, great service. No thick crust here. Prices are a little high like everywhere else. Great location and a nice woodsy feel. See our YouTube channel Coolest Life. read more

See all

I don't know about the pizza because I didn't order one, but the pasta dishes taste like something out of a box. Service was great! read more

This restaurant provided a good ambiance with both indoor and outdoor seating. Located right on the main highway in Hill city. The establishment had a good selection of food, although it is called a Pizzeria. The service was fast and very attentive to our needs. We had the chicken Alfredo dish. read more

Pizzeria Mangiamo - Tossed salad - Pizza Near Me - Hill City, South Dakota

See all

We had an amazing hike in Custer and knew pizza would hit the spot. Pizzeria Mangiamo did not disappoint. We started with a side salad. The greens were crisp and fresh and the dressing tasted homemade which is always delicious. The wood fired pizza was so good, perfect crust! We had a small Big Kulha and it was just right for the two of us. Our waiter was attentive and pleasant. My only complaint would be that we had to wait so long to be seated when the restaurant was completely open. Idk maybe it was a shift change or something. We made the best of it and ordered a couple of beers. We opted to sit outside overlooking the city. It got a bit chilly when the sun went down but we enjoyed the evening. We always appreciate a military discount but the table dedicated to the fallen soldier was above and beyond, very respectful. read more

See all

Service was very good for takeout and they were super busy. The NewYorker pepperoni was okay probably good for the area. Could have used a little bit more sauce or a more flavorful sauce. The salad was fresh and better than the normal bagged salad you get at other restaurants. The strawberry vinaigrette was not very flavorful, but they gave us plenty. read more

Pleasantly surprising! One of few places open on an October Sunday evening. Coming from NY/NJ I didn't expect to enjoy pizza in South Dakota. The margherita, salame picante and Bianca pizzas were great. It was wood fired and fresh. The harney appetizer was enjoyable too. We got takeout to eat around the hotel fire pit. The staff ensured we had paper goods to do so. read more

The pizza was delicious. The dough fresh and homemade. It was very busy but service was good. My husband left his phone in error and they put it in the safe for him. We were able to pick it up early the next morning. We really appreciated that. read more

Pizzeria Mangiamo - Pizza Near Me - Hill City, South Dakota

See all

We had a margarita pizza here and it was good. The service was good as well. It is a good pizza option in Hill City.

I would like to give this place a higher rating for the service as the bartender was super friendly and helpful but the rating is based on our full experience. On a Saturday night the dinner wait was 25 minutes so we decided to place a to go order. The front desk removed our reservation because we didn't want to wait but told us we needed to go to the bar to place our order. Odd practice but ok. The craft beer was good as we waited for our food but the bar didn't have any chairs. There was a bench seat in the bar area we could have sat down if we wanted to though, odd. We ordered a specialty pizza and it was just ok, nothing special. It was a brick oven roasted pizza so the crust was good but I prefer a good spicy sauce and that was not there. Plenty of cheese and the amount of toppings was adequate. Worth a visit but if it was close to home I would probably not visit often. read more

Pizzeria Mangiamo - Plenty of seating - Pizza Near Me - Hill City, South Dakota

See all

Quick service, great patio seating to enjoy the fall weather and sunset. We had the pizza which had a fantastic crust and lots of cheese!

This is one of the better places to eat in Hill City, especially if you're tired of burgers and regular bar food. We were here for a week night dinner and ordered a large Meat Mafia pizza to split. The pizza was great, better than we expected. We took the extra back to our hotel and ate that the next day. If you don't have a refrigerator, a medium would work better for two. The past looked good. We might have tried that if we had gone back. Service was good. The place itself wasn't too crowded but looks like it can get busy. read more

Best pizza in the Black Hills. Classically trained chef and authentic ingredients- delicious.

Best gluten free pizza crust and great mixed greens salad, too! My kids devoured the cheesy breadsticks and the pasta with sausage and vodka sauce. Great place! read more

Their hours are slightly different than posted during the winter, closing at 8pm instead of 9pm. My party of 2 arrived at 7:55 expecting to be turned away but they were more than happy to make us a to-go pizza even though every other customer seemed to be long gone. We got drinks while we waited for the pizza and all the staff were super friendly and welcoming. I don't think the pizza was traditionally Italian or New York style as it says on the menu but for a place in the Black Hills that's kind of expected. The food was great when we got it back home and I will definitely continue to eat at this restaurant. read more

Everyone in our large group of 9 found something delicious! Pizzas were great-even the GF margarita! The staff was nice & helpful. We'd definitely return! read more

Pizzeria Mangiamo - Salsiccia e pepperoni with mushrooms was a hit - Pizza Near Me - Hill City, South Dakota

This place had one vegetarian option: "veggie pizza." It was good. Unfortunately, they don't have any vegan options. So basically, they took the cheese out of vegetarian pizza to make it vegan, which leaves vegan with 0 protein. Among the whole city, this was the only place that was offering something more than just plain salad for vegans. Nice staff. read more

It looked like it was closing as we walked in at 4pm ish. They were still serving and did seat us We didn't ordered too much. Food was average, service was okay. The continued cleaning floors while serving us. Odd. read more

See all

Walked in at dinner time on a Friday - was told there would be a short wait. Went to the bar, ordered a glass of wine, and the bartender, Tracy, seated me at an open table. I ordered the linguini with meatballs and house salad. The best bleu cheese I've ever had. Thick, not runny, and a great looking salad - loaded with fresh spinach, lettuce, tomato, carrots, cucumber, and croutons. Entree was appealing, too. Other diners seemed to be pleased as well, and all of the waitstaff appeared to be attentive and pleasant. My entree came out too soon - had only just started my salad - but I'll go back again for sure, and I give them 5 stars! read more

Pizzeria Mangiamo - Salad, bread - Pizza Near Me - Hill City, South Dakota

See all

Best Pizzeria EVER. My wife and I had the Big Kahuna Pizza and Brother.in.law & Sister-in-Law had the Salsiccia E Pepperoni pizza. Fabulous wait staff., Great pizza, Great atmosphere. read more

Great food for a lunch stop. Service was quick and was able to split two different pizzas into one. Good stop read more

Pizzeria Mangiamo - Half meat mafia and half big k. - Pizza Near Me - Hill City, South Dakota

Wonderful and delicious find while on vacation here in Hill City! The hand tossed wood fired pizza was spot on, just enough of the char on the dough to bring out the flavor. The dough was very light and not heavy at all. Our server was amazing, the whole staff seemed to be working at top speed. No dirty plates or napkins left on the table, someone always making the rounds to make sure the place was spotless. Ask for Bodhi - great server! read more

We stopped here after going to Custer and all the other food places were closed. We got the Veggie pizza with pepperoni and the Big Kahuna. The Veggie had phenomenal flavor, but the Kahuna was was a bit dry, we asked for sauce on the side. Bbq would've been great on it too. The vibe inside felt like a small town family owned restaurant with country music playing in the background. Service was good, nothing spectacular, but our waiter was kind. Stop here for some really good wood fired pizza! read more

See all