Island Burger and Shake

Really a great find. The ice cream selection is one of the best I've seen. The boozy ones are…read moreamazing and the super friendly staff gave us so many tasting samples. Love the beachy small town feel. Will be back for sure!

Cream Republic Cream Republic is a hand-crafted small batch…read moreIce Creamery located on Hutchinson Island in Fort Pierce, Florida. After exploring fort pierce we went in for a real treat . Love it

Ice Cream Flight

Menu and ordering station

See all

White Ukrainian "boozy" flavor Yum!

Hershey Ice Cream & Acai Bowl Cafe

4.2(29 reviews)

1.1 mi

Came in after a hot beach day. Ice cream was very good, lots of flavors to try and choose from…read more They also make crepes. Big portions as well. Price wasn't too bad either. Definitely will come back. Great customer service

I dislike having to leave negative reviews. We stopped in after the beach for a small treat. The…read moreemployee was nice but very slow. We waited in line behind 2 people in front of us for over 20 minutes. We choose our flavors and took them outside to sit at the tables. After my husband's first bite of his cherry Italian ice there was a black curly hair in his...gross. My ice cream had a freezerburn taste and I was so disgusted with both we threw them in the trash. A waste of $16 plus the tip I left.

Acai bowl

Over 80 flavors...

See all

Inside

Joy's Ice Cream Plus

4.7(130 reviews)

6.9 mi

Love the ice cream, chocolate lasagna is AMAZING the kids…read moreare welcoming and quick to greet you!

It was really good but their portions are pretty big I got the banana pudding ice cream it was…read moredelicious but I couldn't finish it because it was really big and I wasn't that hungry.

Coffin cake . Wow!

See all

Main Street Ice Cream

3.5(2 reviews)

2.5 mi

Came with my family to eat ice cream and was sadly disappointed. I don't know what was going on but…read morethey were out of cups, out of certain ice cream flavors, out of whipped cream and they don't have hot fudge. On the plus size, they have a large scoop size.

If you anything in Fort Pierce come to Main Street Ice Cream!! So fresh and delicious :) the…read moreservice was fast and they're so sweet!! We will be back next time we are in town! + they have vegan options :)

See all

1 scoop in a waffle cone!

Sweet Willy’s Ice Cream

4.0(1 review)

2.3 mi

Nice little ice cream shop at the entrance of Crabby's Dockside restaurant. Nice young staff…read moreserving ice cream that hit the spot.

See all

Just outside Crabby's Dockside restaurant and Sweet Willy's Ice Cream Shoppe

Vampire Penguin

4.9(22 reviews)

3.9 mi

So we specifically drove down for the Halo Halo as I have become Ube addict after having Ube ice…read morecream in Las Vegas this year! It did not disappoint, and those young people might get tired of seeing me as it was actually one of the most delicious desserts I've ever had in my life! Momma wanted vanilla ice cream but I told her she was getting the Dulce de Leche.... There wasn't a drop of anything left in that bowl. She said it was also one of the most amazing desserts in her whole 86 years! I should've taken a moment for pictures, but I can tell you this if you haven't tried vampire Penguin you are missing out! Fantastic service! Amazing flavors while still a very light dessert of epic proportions!!!!! While I think one is enough for two people to share some may argue.... Don't miss the opportunity to support this local business. Sorry I didn't get pictures as I had it demolished in less than 10 minutes....

Love Vampire Penguin. Friendliest staff, yummy product, always satisfied! Our favorite place to go…read morefor dessert or a delicious snack.

Dawson waiting on his vanilla snow yum!

See all

Pops Ice Cream

4.5(78 reviews)

28.4 mi

Stopped into Pop's in Sebastian and yeah... it still hits…read more I went with a cone stacked with Raspberry Haze and Gator Tracks, and that combo absolutely worked. The Raspberry Haze had that tart, fruity punch that wakes your taste buds up, while the Gator Tracks brought the creamy, chocolate-peanut-butter goodness to balance it out. Sweet, rich, a little chaotic in the best way. The shop itself is bright, playful, and packed with personality. You can tell this place is loved by locals, kids, parents, dogs, everyone. Staff was friendly and patient even with a steady line, which I always appreciate. Simple math here. Solid flavors, generous scoops, good vibes. If you're anywhere near Sebastian and craving ice cream, Pop's is an easy yes.

A perfect end to the evening! My wife and I shared the key lime and the kids went with cookie dough…read moreand cotton candy. The portions are genuinely generous, which you don't always see at a scoop shop, and the staff were super kind and welcoming. Simple, delicious, and exactly what a great ice cream spot should be. We loved it and would absolutely be back!

Charming Chai, Pumpkin Swirl

Mocha Almond Fudge, Rocky Road

See all

Large hot fudge sundae w pb chocolate ice cream

Paradise Ice Cream

3.8(47 reviews)

25.7 mi

Quaint family owned ice cream shop, clean, well decorated, a GREAT selection of ice cream, sundaes,…read moreshakes & malts. To include regular cones, sugar cones & waffle cones. Staff is GREAT, definitely do yourself & kids a favor stop in & say hi u won't b sorry.

July was a scorcher, and days like that call for ice cream. I searched my trusty Yelp app and…read morefound that Paradise Ice Cream was located in the area I was working in that day. The shop is located in a shopping center and offers indoor and outdoor seating. The customer service was excellent as the lady who helped me provided a little bit of history on the different flavors that are natural and freshly made. The samples help me decide, but best of all, you can mix and match your selection.

Dairy Free Vanilla Soft Serve & Orange Dole Whip Twist

House made cones

See all

Chop likes the ice cream shop a lot

Five Brors Ice Cream Shop

4.0(1 review)

3.9 mi

Very good!! We will come back when we are in the area! Very friendly. Had about 12 different…read moreflavors. We had chocolate/cookies and cream/ butter pecan and rum raisin. Girl inside was very friendly

Island Beach Bar and Restaurant

4.2(144 reviews)

0.0 mi

Hidden gem for beach chair rentals! Spent the whole day at…read morethe most peaceful and serene beach thanks to Island beach bar. Brooke was really sweet and attentive, she set up our chairs and umbrellas and checked in with us and other guests throughout the day.

Ambiance: Beachfront restaurant (well, sort of beachfront as…read morea Beach in this area is closed off for a major rebuilding process) it's your typical surfer, beachcomber, swimmer type restaurant that you'll find in most oceanfront areas. Weatherford wood walls, outside tables under an awning. Inside tables are also available, although, why anyone would choose an inside table when you have a front row seat to the ocean is beyond me. Interestingly,, they have a few swing tables that you can rock back-and-forth while you eat. Not sure how many people will choose those "moving'" tables but, they're an interesting idea nonetheless. Service: I was provided with my choice of table. (I chose the swinging tables (I just had to try The experience of swinging while eating - which was actually pretty pleasant).I was seated immediately upon my arrival. My server whose name was Cynthia whose name tag said Helga (don't ask) served me quickly and with a smile. She came by several times to check on my needs but was never an overpowering presence. Couldn't ask for anything more with a server. Be warned, (which my server by the way did warn me about.), They charge an automatic 18% gratuity on the bill. Not a problem in my case as a service was excellent. The food: I ordered the mushroom and brie omelette. It came with a side of potatoes and I requested a biscuit. The was your typical omelette the plus being the tomatoes were super fresh but could've had more brie. If potatoes were combined with peppers and onions and we're nice and crispy of friends just the way they should be). Unfortunately they were out of biscuits (even though they have a biscuits and gravy dish). How you run out of SKU Ott's on a Saturday morning is beyond me. My tea was your standard black tea (they did not have steamed milk) served with honey. Interestingly, they didn't have a decent size cup so I was provided with 2 cups and two teabags. The bottom line: As with all my reviews, my (Customer so what) would I return? This restaurant is not in my top 10 but, if the beach was reopened and I wanted an oceanfront dining experience this could be a pretty good place to visit. The service was excellent. The food pretty good and the atmosphere great.

Things to do in Fort Pierce

Mani tacos

See all

The view from rm 17

Island Burger and Shake - burgers - Updated September 2026

Best of Fort Pierce

People found Island Burger and Shake by searching for…

People who viewed Island Burger and Shake also viewed

Culver's

3.3

(72 reviews)

Firstly, let me add that we were hungry!!! I'm not very familiar with Culver but my teen niece told…read moreme that it was good but expensive. Now I'm not sure if this place would be considered FAST FOOD or something a little better. They don't have a "drive-thru" per se but they have a drive up order window but then you can either park in one of the designated spots and wait for them to bring you your food or you can pull up against the curve and wait as well. They will give you a numbered sticky note to place on your car. When we got to the order board, and the voice came over the speaker, she asked "what can we prepare fresh for you?" As a part of her welcome spiel. Lots of places boast freshness but we will see about that. I ordered the cod dinner (1 piece) which comes with fries, a dinner roll, and coleslaw. My husband ordered the Shrimp dinner and the kid ordered chicken tenders and fries. I was expecting a frozen piece of low quality fish with little flavor but this was actually pretty tasty! Again...I was very hungry but it actually did taste fresh! No hint of fishy-ness and it was piping hot and crispy and I thought it was really yummy. I ordered the 1 piece thinking I was just ordering something to hold me over until dinner but that one piece of fish was pretty big. I'm Glad I opted for one. My hubby and I could split a 3 piece because I felt the piece was large and thick and filling. The breading wasn't soggy either. It was nice and crunchy (I ate right away) and the fries were decent. The fries remind me of the fries they serve at Portillo's. A crisp crinkle cut with the perfect amount of salt. I truly enjoyed my food. I will add that a one piece is $10.99. My husband loved his shrimp dinner and my kid, who only eats tenders if we go to Chick-fil-a, even said hers was good. I expected her to complain but she liked them. So I guess it was a win across the board with my family. We relocated to PSL where they have Culver's so I guess I'll be eating here more often. No pics...sorry. Maybe next time when I can sit and eat instead of driving.

Definitely this is more of a burger joint with luxury prices. I got the chicken sandwich--while the…read morechicken itself was good, the portion was not very big and, to be honest, the flavor just wasn't there. My husband got the hamburger and thought it was okay, but it didn't have those wow flavors either. We went because we had a gift card and wanted to see if it could become our new go-to burger place when we're craving one. We had to wait for our order to be delivered to the car, and there was quite a long line of cars waiting for their food. Overall, it wasn't the best experience, but we might give it another try later to see if maybe the first visit was just an off day.

NYC SUBS Deli Restaurant

4.0

(23 reviews)

The shop offers high quality (Boars Head) meats. Ordered a Reuben sandwich and a Greek Salad…read more The prices are reasonable and you get a lot for the price! My mother thoroughly enjoyed the food. Will definitely go there again and make it a point to enjoy my meal outside on their patio

It took at least 30 minutes to make three subs. The owner…read morewas there from Long Island and refused to say high to a fellow Long Islander. And refused patrons bathroom usage, Next door dunking donuts allowed people to use their bathroom. As far as I am concerned I will never come back to this establishment.

Palm Beach hot chicken

4.2

(6 reviews)

Always heard a lot of good things about this place. Good thing I was craving chicken tenders and…read moredecided to stop. Prices are definitely great and affordable food was fresh. Service was really fast. We ate in, not many people in the dining area. I would rate my meal a 6 out of 10. I also ordered a side of hush puppies, which I didn't take a picture of, but those I would write it to they were way overcooked seem like they were cooked in old oil. Even though I didn't have the greatest experience because the food was fresh besides the hush puppies, I would possibly come back just through the drive-through.

The pescatarian in me was very satisfied! Pulled up in the drive thru on a Sunday evening, there…read morewas no line when I arrived so I was a little skeptical. Prices were really good. Menu has chicken of course and a decent seafood menu. I ordered catfish & shrimp combo, catfish was a nice portion, seasoned and fried well. Shrimp was good too. Ordered a side of hush puppies and it didn't disappoint. Reminds me of Hooks and Snappers down south. Servers were quick, good customer service. Definitely will be back.

Grandpa's Diner

4.0

(172 reviews)

The food is very good. The servers come right away to help you. The prices are very reasonable,…read moreless than most places. It is a cute diner, not real fancy, a lot of people come from the surrounding areas.

My 1st time there for lunch. Waited a minute for a table…read more Service was quick. Food was so delicious and portions were more than enough. Busy as it was lunchtime. Very nice atmosphere-quiet enough to talk with my guest. Highly recommend You visit Grandpa's Diner for Breakfast Lunch and Dinner

Sharky's

4.0

(126 reviews)

I have been coming to sharkys every time I come to town for over 10 years…read more I love the Philly cheesesteak, Mahi sticks and sanwhich, yellowfin tuna, cheese burger sliders. Really everything on menu is great. I even bought a Sharkys TShirt to rock when we are in town. A must try in town. I usually order for pick ups.

The place advertises itself to be a basic roadside shack that serves fresh seafood. Fresh my a$$…read more If you ask for mahi mahi, it's previously grilled (maybe several days ago and then put in the microwave and serve back to you). You're better off eating paper. The girls at the counter are definitely nice. They tried to accommodate you every way they can. But for a $25 entre, it is not up to par.

Presutti's Italian Subs

4.4

(38 reviews)

Great sport for lunch. Some of the best sweet tea around. Service is excellent and great to sit…read moredown and eat. Some of the best subs and all around lunch menu.

Found this little sub shop in the middle of nowhere and wow--it did not disappoint! The owner…read moresuggested the Gondola Sub and it was spot on. So fresh and flavorful! Next time I might add onions or try the Hot Italian with banana peppers. My son got the Pastrami and my husband had the Cold Italian--both were delicious. Everything tasted homemade and made with care. Definitely worth the stop!

Huey Magoo's Chicken Tenders

3.8

(33 reviews)

Great food lousy service. I stood there for five minutes waiting to have my order taken when I was…read morethe only person in line. Then I asked if I could have my tenders tossed in a blend of sauces. The guy quickly said "no". Most chicken places will do that for you and at a place where you wait 15 minutes for them to prepare it fresh just for you, I thought it was, just for me, and I can order a little special. I was then charged for an extra dipping sauce without being asked and asked for their ghost pepper ranch sauce, which they were showing on a large screen TV behind the counter only to be told "we don't have that anymore". Not a great overall experience.

Music is loud. Wait for tenders seems longer than it…read moreshould be. Grilled tenders were skimpy in my wife's opinion. Food was good. Considering the dozen plus food spots in the quarter mile radius they need to do better

My Brothers Bbq

4.4

(183 reviews)

We had such a great experience at My Brothers BBQ! Our server, Twiggy, truly made the visit even…read morebetter. His hospitality, positive attitude, and great recommendations made the whole experience so pleasant. Everything he suggested was on point! Of course we had to try their famous BBQ ribs, and they did not disappoint! The mac & cheese was DIVINE -- honestly, probably some of the best mac & cheese I've ever had. The cornbread that came with it was so good too! We also tried the corn nuggets and shredded brisket, and everything was delicious. I'll definitely be back! If you visit My Brothers BBQ, ask for Twiggy as your server -- you won't regret it!

This place is great! We went for lunch with a party of 4. The waitress was very hospitable and our…read moreservice was great. The food was excellent. We had a variety of food - brisket, ribs, collard greens, Mac and cheese, candied yams - all was wonderful! I would definitely recommend this place and we will be back!!

Rick's Diner

4.2

(257 reviews)