Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Island Pie

    4.1 (135 reviews)
    ModeratePizza, Bars
    Closed 12:00 pm - 9:00 PM
    Updated a few days ago

    Island Pie Photos

    ISLAND PIE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Casual
    Outdoor seating
    Good for kids

    Recommended Reviews - Island Pie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    1/2 Seasonal Squash and 1/2 veggie pizza
    Kamal S.

    We came here for dinner in a rainy early evening and it hit the spot! The seasonal squash pizza was quite good with the "sauce" being the butternut squash and topped with cheese. We had half of that and the other half was the veggie pizza which had cauliflower, broccoli, carrots, olives with a tomato sauce. Both were delicious and cooked perfectly. For dessert, we opted for the apple pie crumble and added a scoop of vanilla ice cream, simply divine! Everything was so fresh! Overall, I'd come back for more! Happy eating!

    Cole O.

    It was a beautiful day, and we decided to stop by for a bite to eat. The owners, who work alongside their wife, were also looking after their kid. I can imagine how challenging it must be to find help. Fortunately, the food was great, and we encountered no issues at all. It's definitely a nice place to relax. Definitely a 5/5 when comparing it to other restaurants on the island.

    Cheezie Goodness and Garlic Sticks plus side of ranch!
    Alyson C.

    Delicious pizza and garlic sticks, plus very friendly and personable staff! We will absolutely be back next time we visit. After a day on the water, traveling, etc. sometimes you just want to pick something yummy up to enjoy back at the hotel - Island Pie is the perfect place! Open later than almost every other restaurant on the island, and ready within 20-30 mins. We ordered the Cheezie Goodness Pizza and Garlic Sticks with house made ranch on the side - all was delicious! Right across from the Deer Valley Marina with a great deck for dining in outdoors with the fam as well!

    Cheezie Goodness
    Kylie H.

    Cute little pizza shop with amazing views! Service was quick and friendly, and made us feel welcomed, adding to the local serenity. The breadsticks were perfect; stuffed with garlic and crispy. The pizza absolutely hit the spot. Definitely recommend.

    Half Seasonal Squash, half Americas Favorite.
    Jesse G.

    The online ordering was very easy with good descriptions so you know exactly what you're getting. They had a notice on the site when I ordered that the pizza would be slower than usual due to limited staffing - even with that notice, though, the pizza was ready at exactly the time they promised it would be - 32 minutes after I ordered. Pizza itself it was very good. We ordered a half and half of America's Favorite and squash pizza. America's Favorite had a nice amount of pepperoni and bacon on top of a slightly sweet tomato sauce with a thin but not really too thin crust dusted with cornmeal. The squash had a really good squash sauce as the base and was creative and flavorful. We also ordered the beet salad - which was very generous on the beets but could have used a few more candied pecans and maybe something else - goat cheese? Anyway ordering it helped us feel like we were being kinda healthy. The person who helped us when we picked up was very friendly and cheerful.

    Walkway. Notice the baby gates. Is this a restaurant or a day care?
    Sarah S.

    This location has so much potential. Unfortunately, it is being operated and mismanaged in every way. We went to Island Pie last weekend when we were at Deer Harbor Marina visiting with our boat. Walking up the sidewalk entrance, it is immediately noticeable to everyone that the owners have no pride in ownership. Dirty sidewalks, weeds, baby toys, dead plants. Same when we walked into the main dining room. We noticed how dumpy it was. Junk lined and lined all the shelves. T-shirts in a jumbled pile, pens, cans knickknacks...No care was put into creating an inviting confortable experience, and the room wasn't inviting at all. We asked to sit on the patio, which at least provided a view of the bay. Again, there is no care for the decor, cleanliness or in creating an invotimg experience for the customer. Mildewy awnings, cheap, old plastic flags, dead old flowers, orange and lemon slices on the floors, chairs askew, and no music. Dirty garbage cans front and center in front of their bar. Buckets filled with trash on the bar. The plastic menus were dirty. Our waitress wasn't sure about what beer they had. When we got the beer, it was semi flat. We ordered pizza, and while we waited, no one asked if we wanted another drink. (A business makes a lot of profit on alcohol). Our pizza arrived on a sheet of wax paper on top of a wooden paddle. We were asked to help slide the pizza onto the table. Part of the pizza was directly on the table. I asked for plates, and they brought wax paper. The owner (who was wearing her cooking apron that should be kept clean) was out on the deck and played with her toddler son. Then we waited and waited for our bill only to be told finally from another patron that we had to go to the front to check out. We spoke with other boaters about their experience, and all echoed our experience. Pizza was "okay," but maybe for takeout, and everyone said, "What a dump!" I hope the owners read this: You have an epic location and opportunity to create a destination that is fun. The bar should be where everyone in the area, and especially the marina wants to be. Us boaters want places to go! Clean the place up! Go through my critique and act on all my points. You might have to get help. It is very apparent that you don't know how to create a menu (decide if you're serving ialian or asian. Your menu is weird), create an ambiance, and an atmosphere. Train your staff better on service. They should know your offerings. You have the location that could really really be something very special.

    View from the seating deck

    See all

    8 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Margaret W.

    Margaret W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Margaret W.

    Margaret W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Margaret W.

    Margaret W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Margaret W.

    Margaret W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Adia D.
    192
    4
    1

    8 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Margaret W.

    Margaret W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Margaret W.

    Margaret W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Margaret W.

    Margaret W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Margaret W.

    Margaret W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Margaret W.

    Margaret W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ron N.
    0
    13
    4

    9 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Margaret W.

    Margaret W.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of K M.
    0
    1
    0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Island Pie

    Orcas Village Store - Cute bag

    Orcas Village Store

    4.6(64 reviews)
    3.0 mi
    $

    The best part of this little store is that you could find everything you need for your stay on…read moreOrcas Island and they have an amazingly friendly and helpful staff. Granted prices are a little more but you are on an island. They have a great selection of cheeses and you can get a latte for your ferry ride.

    After looking Yelp, shocker I know!, I discovered that this little store had pastries. And it was…read moreopen early! I got up and decided to walk over for a morning treat with my coffee. Very impressive little store full of tons of stuff! Groceries, pantry staples, a small produce section, some premade deli food and cookies. I was looking for the bakery items. A previous review mentioned delicious homemade pastries. Finally as I choose a cookie and a salad for later I see them. A small pedestal plate with pastries. And on the countertop behind the register tons of croissants! I said, there they are! The two ladies working were not impressed. I asked for the flavors and the lady said, there is a menu right there. Ugh, not fully awake I realized a line had formed behind me. This is the spot to go before getting in a ferry. The sign was not clearly visible and I felt overwhelmed with the decision so I quickly decided on a raspberry almond. This is clearly a place for locals. Everyone knows what they want and where it is. Not super friendly vibes, but oh well. Took photos of my purchases back in my gorgeous villa LOL, watch for my next review. Super happy to discover this market! And I love a good market! Happy travels. SYOY!

    Photos
    Orcas Village Store - Store

    Store

    Orcas Village Store - Peanut butter cookie.

    Peanut butter cookie.

    Orcas Village Store

    See all

    Monti - Chicken liver mousse

    Monti

    4.7(35 reviews)
    6.9 mi

    Had high expectations that didn't deliver…read more My girlfriend and I came to stay the night on Orcas Island, and this was the first restaurant we tried. Having made reservations beforehand, we were really excited to try this place out. The servers who greeted us were really nice. The restaurant had a beautiful dark interior that gave off a cozy steakhouse vibe. They even offered to take my coat, how nice of them! Despite the hospitality, the food did not really live up to expectations. I got the birria, and while it was okay, it definitely wasn't worth the price I paid. My girlfriend's scallop crudel was almost as pricey and it did not even fill her up. I believe the bill for our whole meal (including a mocktail) was over $80. This was definitely not worth the price point paid for, considering that we were not fully satisfied with that meal. Regardless, many thanks to the Monti staff for having us.

    First visit and I'm smitten. Great decor and service, but the meal really distinguished itself…read more First course was a fennel shaved salad with exceptional flavor - don't be dissuaded by the reference to anchovy dressing - it works magnificently and nothing overpowers. The chicken liver with summer tomatoes was magnificent, even if they needed an extra slice of sourdough to finish the plate. The star was the roasted pork belly. I've had many in my day but this was the crown jewel of belly's - succulent, tender inside and crispy edges, and the flavor was off the chart delicious. Rigatoni with lamb did not disappoint and pasta was cooked to perfection. Saved room for chocolate mousse and it was excellent and not too sweet. Wine pairings supported the wonderful meal. I look forward to returning and trying all the dishes we didn't select. This place has it over Rosario and Madrona. Your wallet will be lighter but not unreasonably so.

    Photos
    Monti
    Monti - Tiramisu

    Tiramisu

    Monti - Salmon tartare

    See all

    Salmon tartare

    Cousin Vinnie's NY Pizza Cafe - Cannoli to die for.

    Cousin Vinnie's NY Pizza Cafe

    3.4(78 reviews)
    6.0 mi
    $$

    While rolling around San Juan Island for my daughter's bday we came across Cousin Vinnie's NY Pizza…read moreCafe on Yelp. What really drew my attention was some of the piss poor reviews from some fake Yelpstars...you know the ones folks; those fake folks that got three total reviews all one star. I thought it was comical about how scared and bent customers were regarding Vinnie's attitude. Honestly, if you can't hack a strong attitude maybe you should just stay inside and be scared! More great pizza for the rest of us. Cousin Vinnie's is not a hole in the wall pizzeria it's a walk up to a door you can't enter and order directly with Vinnie working in the kitchen! Bad A**! We ordered up one large thin crust with olives, mushrooms, pepperoni, and sausage. One personal size all meat pizza and cannolis. Vinnie told me to come back in about 35-40 minutes. He's a one man show people. Rolled back to the front of the pizzeria and Vinnie was showing off other pies he created for orders infront of us. Once ours was done he freshly filled the cannolis and showed off our pizzas. Wow not only did they look great they tasted great. Loved the flavor of the crust and ingredients! 5 stars Vinnie! Great pizza from a great guy! I'll be back!

    Rude owner Pizza was not great, don't waste your money…read more Pretty sure the crust was frozen

    Photos
    Cousin Vinnie's NY Pizza Cafe - The front of the pizzeria do not enter!!!

    The front of the pizzeria do not enter!!!

    Cousin Vinnie's NY Pizza Cafe - Custom job... mushrooms, olive, pepperoni, and sausage.

    Custom job... mushrooms, olive, pepperoni, and sausage.

    Cousin Vinnie's NY Pizza Cafe - Menu 07/01/2026

    See all

    Menu 07/01/2026

    Bakery San Juan - Key lime pie

    Bakery San Juan

    4.6(212 reviews)
    6.4 mi
    $

    Wonderful bakery in Friday Harbor with great pastries. We had the apple danish, pain au chocolat,…read moreberry cheese danish, and the carrot cake muffin. Each pastry was great but the highlight was the berry cheese danish. We also really liked how the apple danish wasn't extremely sweet and the texture of the carrot cake muffin. The bakery also has coffee and pizza available, but we didn't try any of that. Seating wise, there's both indoor and outdoor seating available for guests and water on tap. The ordering process was smooth but we sat, bussed, and served ourself which was fine.

    This is truly one of our go to spots over the many years we've been coming to SJI. Had an…read moreunfortunate experience this weekend. My husband, of course on his first trip to the island, ordered a cinnamon roll. As he was eating he pulled out a massive dark hair fully baked into the cinnamon roll, and as one does, was completely repulsed and threw it away. Sadly it tarnished is experience of the bakery which I had highly praised and was the first stop on our anniversary trip. Aside from this, the bakery has a variety of pastries that usually go quick in the mornings, my favorite is the chocolate croissant. They also have a full sandwich and pizza shop as well as indoor and outdoor seating areas. Service is always fast and they get your food out to you quickly. Again usually this is our go to so hoping it was just a one off experience.

    Photos
    Bakery San Juan - Order area

    Order area

    Bakery San Juan - Blueberry Cream Cheese Danish

    Blueberry Cream Cheese Danish

    Bakery San Juan - Bakery San Juan

    See all

    Bakery San Juan

    Island Pie - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...