If I could give the flavor of the pizzas more then 5 star I would. A day later I'm still thinking about my first bite . Simple menu of deliciousness. Highly recommend the Alfredo sauce with pesto . Never had anything like it and could eat it every day . With a glass of their melot Great service as well . read more

Island Pie is hands-down my favorite pizza place--honestly, it might just be my favorite place to eat on Orcas Island, period. Their pizzas are far from ordinary. Every pie is packed with bold flavors, fresh ingredients, and that creative touch that takes them well above your standard slice. You can really tell they put care into every combination. And let's talk about their egg rolls. Yes--egg rolls at a pizza place. And not just good... the best. Crispy, flavorful, and totally addictive. If you go and don't order them, you're missing out on one of the island's hidden gems. Between the welcoming vibe, the unique menu, and the consistently delicious food, Island Pie is a place I always look forward to returning to. Whether you're a local or visiting Deer Harbor, do yourself a favor and stop by--you won't be disappointed. read more

The food (lasagna and salad) was good. I wanted to try one of their desserts, but was full thereafter maybe next time. The service was great. It got more busier after we were seated. They have outdoor seating. It was a beautiful day for outdoor, but I opt for an indoor. read more

See all

We came here for dinner in a rainy early evening and it hit the spot! The seasonal squash pizza was quite good with the "sauce" being the butternut squash and topped with cheese. We had half of that and the other half was the veggie pizza which had cauliflower, broccoli, carrots, olives with a tomato sauce. Both were delicious and cooked perfectly. For dessert, we opted for the apple pie crumble and added a scoop of vanilla ice cream, simply divine! Everything was so fresh! Overall, I'd come back for more! Happy eating! read more

Island Pie - 1/2 Seasonal Squash and 1/2 veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

See all

The pizza is the best on Orcas. Some Creative choices and everything is well done. I love their food and go back whenever I can. The ambiance is comfy and the outside seating is great. read more

We split a sausage and shallots pizza. Absolutely delicious! The 12-inch was plenty for our dinner. The next night we came back only for drinks: a Negroni and a Rob Roy. Both were expertly mixed and presented. This is a husband and wife team, where the wife prepares the delicious pizza pies, and the husband is the mixologist. Their adorable son, on a big wheels bike, gave us our menus and showed us to our table. The view of Deer Harbor is outstanding. The restaurant decor could use an uplift, but it has charm. Highly recommend the Island Pie. read more

Will need to give a more updated review when I try their pizza but wanted to recognize this place solely based on the owner. My wife and I are staying 150' from this place at the WorldMark resort. We went on a stroll and decided to swing by for a drink on the way back to our cottage. Not crazy busy but lots of locals caning in or out. Service was maybe a little slow but it didn't matter listening to the locals talk about the place and the view looking out onto the water made the time pass slowly. Oh and the owners little one running and riding their bike around the restaurant was a pure pleasure. Just a great local spot to frequent. We had a glass of wine, a beer and an egg roll appetizer. The egg roll was good but watching pizzas go by we definitely have to try one. Tonight we had other dinner plans but we will be back. Beautiful view inside and some great seating outside (but it was a little chilly tonight). read more

Super friendly owners and super delicious pizza! These people are doing the most. It was probably one of the best gluten free and dairy free I have ever had. The gluten free crust is so delicious, my husband actually liked it better than the regular crust. The regular was good too though, from what I was told, but not anything to write home about. Also a lovely outdoor deck to sit on and it appeared they had a bar as well. Overall a great spot! read more

It was a beautiful day, and we decided to stop by for a bite to eat. The owners, who work alongside their wife, were also looking after their kid. I can imagine how challenging it must be to find help. Fortunately, the food was great, and we encountered no issues at all. It's definitely a nice place to relax. Definitely a 5/5 when comparing it to other restaurants on the island. read more

Island Pie - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

Fabulous pizza and amazing location. We had the classic cheese and the squash pizza. Both were excellent. The restaurant's commitment to quality and fresh ingredients is evident. Sizes were generous and the price was modest. The staff was super friendly and attentive. It feels like a friendly family owned establishment. The kind of place where you become a regular very quickly. The location is beautiful. Across the road from Deer Harbor with amazing views and a lovely deck. We will be back for sure! read more

Island Pie makes amazing food! Enjoyed a very tasty scallion and sausage pizza tonight. They are lovely people and always so welcoming. Also, try the Vietnamese egg rolls! They are delicious! read more

Delicious pizza and garlic sticks, plus very friendly and personable staff! We will absolutely be back next time we visit. After a day on the water, traveling, etc. sometimes you just want to pick something yummy up to enjoy back at the hotel - Island Pie is the perfect place! Open later than almost every other restaurant on the island, and ready within 20-30 mins. We ordered the Cheezie Goodness Pizza and Garlic Sticks with house made ranch on the side - all was delicious! Right across from the Deer Valley Marina with a great deck for dining in outdoors with the fam as well! read more

Island Pie - Cheezie Goodness and Garlic Sticks plus side of ranch! - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

See all

Pizza was delicious and cooked to perfection. Just needed a little bit more seasoning. Great views of the harbor and quality service. Would highly recommend. read more

We have been enjoying the pizza here for five years, and it always hits the spot. Service was fast and friendly, the margaritas were cold and delicious, the meatballs super tasty and the pizza delicious! Obviously the views are too notch :) read more

My wife and I stopped in here last night to get a pizza after a long day of driving and a ferry ride. I'll keep it short...great pizza! We had the squash pizza and it was delicious. Yeah, they have a kid in a stroller who has toys laying around outside...who cares?!?! Not me...these people work their a** off (he told us they worked 100+ days this summer without a day off) and they're doing a great job. THANK YOU!! read more

Cute little pizza shop with amazing views! Service was quick and friendly, and made us feel welcomed, adding to the local serenity. The breadsticks were perfect; stuffed with garlic and crispy. The pizza absolutely hit the spot. Definitely recommend. read more

Island Pie - Cheezie Goodness - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

See all

The owners son wouldn't stop putting his head between my legs. pizza was pretty solid.

The online ordering was very easy with good descriptions so you know exactly what you're getting. They had a notice on the site when I ordered that the pizza would be slower than usual due to limited staffing - even with that notice, though, the pizza was ready at exactly the time they promised it would be - 32 minutes after I ordered. Pizza itself it was very good. We ordered a half and half of America's Favorite and squash pizza. America's Favorite had a nice amount of pepperoni and bacon on top of a slightly sweet tomato sauce with a thin but not really too thin crust dusted with cornmeal. The squash had a really good squash sauce as the base and was creative and flavorful. We also ordered the beet salad - which was very generous on the beets but could have used a few more candied pecans and maybe something else - goat cheese? Anyway ordering it helped us feel like we were being kinda healthy. The person who helped us when we picked up was very friendly and cheerful. read more

Island Pie - Half Seasonal Squash, half Americas Favorite. - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

Great friendly restaurant ! Highly recommended! Food was delicious and the service wonderful.

This location has so much potential. Unfortunately, it is being operated and mismanaged in every way. We went to Island Pie last weekend when we were at Deer Harbor Marina visiting with our boat. Walking up the sidewalk entrance, it is immediately noticeable to everyone that the owners have no pride in ownership. Dirty sidewalks, weeds, baby toys, dead plants. Same when we walked into the main dining room. We noticed how dumpy it was. Junk lined and lined all the shelves. T-shirts in a jumbled pile, pens, cans knickknacks...No care was put into creating an inviting confortable experience, and the room wasn't inviting at all. We asked to sit on the patio, which at least provided a view of the bay. Again, there is no care for the decor, cleanliness or in creating an invotimg experience for the customer. Mildewy awnings, cheap, old plastic flags, dead old flowers, orange and lemon slices on the floors, chairs askew, and no music. Dirty garbage cans front and center in front of their bar. Buckets filled with trash on the bar. The plastic menus were dirty. Our waitress wasn't sure about what beer they had. When we got the beer, it was semi flat. We ordered pizza, and while we waited, no one asked if we wanted another drink. (A business makes a lot of profit on alcohol). Our pizza arrived on a sheet of wax paper on top of a wooden paddle. We were asked to help slide the pizza onto the table. Part of the pizza was directly on the table. I asked for plates, and they brought wax paper. The owner (who was wearing her cooking apron that should be kept clean) was out on the deck and played with her toddler son. Then we waited and waited for our bill only to be told finally from another patron that we had to go to the front to check out. We spoke with other boaters about their experience, and all echoed our experience. Pizza was "okay," but maybe for takeout, and everyone said, "What a dump!" I hope the owners read this: You have an epic location and opportunity to create a destination that is fun. The bar should be where everyone in the area, and especially the marina wants to be. Us boaters want places to go! Clean the place up! Go through my critique and act on all my points. You might have to get help. It is very apparent that you don't know how to create a menu (decide if you're serving ialian or asian. Your menu is weird), create an ambiance, and an atmosphere. Train your staff better on service. They should know your offerings. You have the location that could really really be something very special. read more

See all

This was a delicious break from the water. Great place for lunch. Pizza is wonderful and just what you'd expect. Family own and operated so very friendly. Perfect views. Reasonable pricing. Highly recommend read more

Island Pie - View from the seating deck - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

See all

The best food ever! You deserve a tasty homemade pizza pie after your long boat trip to Deer Harbor, and the service is so friendly you will eat here every night like we do! The sunset views from the deck and outside bar are fantastic! Great wine and beer too. So fun, great food, and very friendly! read more

We have done takeout from there twice and I just don't find the pizzas the pizza to be that flavorful. Perhaps the puffiness of the pie took away from the flavor. We came away wishing that we had tried another spot. It might be to your liking but it might not be. Both times were takeout, not sitting at the restaurant. read more

Great people good food. Marina atmosphere. Online ordering and full bar.... We were on our boat ordered online then took our dingy in and picked up our Pizza read more

The restaurant is filthy, the food is mediocre, and the owner will spend the entire meal telling you all of his problems instead of getting your food ready. We'll probably skip Deer Harbor next year on our boat trip- YUCK read more

Expensive "meh" pizza with incredibly slow service. The server said our order would be ready in 30 minutes to pick up. When we returned, our order wasn't ready. We finally got it 25 minutes later. No apologies. No explanation. The food was just okay. Not worth the wait. And not worth the price. After reading other reviews on Google, it sounds like we were "lucky" to have waited "only" 55 minutes. Other patrons said they waited longer. The location is amazing. Sadly, the food and service weren't. Also important to note: the dining room didn't seem to have A/C. All the diners sat on the patio. We took ours to go. read more

We've been eating Island Pie pies for as long as they have been in business. After some trial and error (we are not big fans of the butternut squash pie) we learned what we like -- the white pie with pesto, sausage and mushrooms -- and order it over and over. The salads are inventive as well with things like dried cranberries included with the usual greens. They have had trouble getting sufficient staff over the years but if you are amenable to Island Time, everything comes to those that wait..... read more

Came here before our ferry and this might have been the best way to end our trip. It's in prime location with water views and it was a beautiful sunny day in April. We got here right as they opened and we were greeted by great service! I'm not the best when I go into work and there's a line already waiting for me, but this gal did great! The pizzas were delicious and we had 3 completely different pizzas, so it was nice to try all of them! We also tried their jack and coke which tasted amazing after camping and being on the island all weekend. They have ice infused with lemon or lime, Not sure which one but made the drink that much better and different! (when the ice completely melted it was a little too much but I was so busy with the pizza I forgot about my drink for once!) read more

Island Pie - Hawaiian, squash, and White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

See all

I. Overall: Decent food and Good people with a REALLY nice view... II. Disclaimer: I have not been paid or compensated to write or share this review by anyone in any way shape or form whatsoever III. The Food: The restaurant is on a different side of the island than the 'main market' and right next to Deer Harbor. We ordered... - Garlic Knots which were tasty and came with a small marinara dipping sauce - 1/2 Sausage and 1/2 Veggie Pizza - Vegetarian Pasta with Cauliflower that they specifically made for us as my partner does not eat meat (Margaret came and asked us what kind of pasta we liked and her Husband (Bruce? I think) made it for us. It was DELICIOUS !! - Apple Crumble for dessert The view is what makes this place. We enjoyed our cocktails as well while looking over the harbor. It was a very pleasant experience. IV. Ambience, Service and Charges: The place is a must if You just want to enjoy some cocktails and have a bite or two of Pizza in a relaxed setting, You'll definitely get the island vibe here The service was really nice and polite. They are super honest i.e. they came running to the car and credited me money for a cocktail that hadn't been served on their own, which was SO kind of them For all the items mentioned we spent around $88 which was very reasonable read more

See all

Amazing pizza. Service was great and it was a cute little place! Scenery from the restaurant to the harbor was amazing!

I will say that the ambience was very friendly. However, they need to do some thing about flies. Also, they have a vegan pizza but has no cheese on it. They need to get some vegan cheese. Otherwise, I would definitely go back. read more

Absolutely the best pizza! I love it is right where my timeshare is. The nicest owners. A must when you go to Orcas.

We had a great time at Island Pie. We were the first ones in on a late Saturday afternoon last weekend, and we sat down on the patio with our two rugrats in tow, and had a lovely dinner in the sunshine with an unbeatable view. We ordered cheese pizza for the kiddos and the sausage/shallot pie for us, along with a few local beers, and I have to say that their pizza crust was some of the best I've ever had. I loved the high quality ingredients on the pizzas, and the local draft beers were just the icing on the cake. Everything we had was fantastic. Service was friendly and quick. We would love to return. Thank you! read more

I hate to leave negative feedback but I feel like I can offer some helpful information. Maybe it was just the day we visited (a Wednesday) but this place was unbelievably slow and disorganized. After placing our order online, it took over 2 hours for our order to be ready. We ordered 1 pizza and 1 salad. We sat and watched as customer after customer walked up and had some sort of issue. It was really sad because the food was really good and the location is beautiful. I think they are understaffed for one thing...not sure what else is going on there. I wouldn't want to discourage anyone from eating here, but just know you should plan to place your order way in advance! read more

Island Pie - Macaroni and Cheese Pizza was delicious! (But took over 2 hours after placing our order on a Wednesday. ‍) - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

See all

This is not your typical pizza joint. We sat out on a deck looking over Deer Harbor. The pizzas are 14", enough for two. The variety is very imaginative. There are also a couple of good looking salads, lasagna, and a few other things as well as several desserts. We had a pizza, garlic knots, meatballs and we shared an apple crumble. $56 plus tip. Service was a little slow but they were busy. Owner Margaret was working right along with the servers. We plan to make this a regular stop. read more

It's pizza on an island in the PNW. What do you expect? The food was fine. The service was fine. The view is spectacular. Definitely the best pizza place in Deer Harbor. I'd go back. read more

Very nice place, right on the harbor in Deer Harbor - some pretty boats to look at. Good pizza and beer, and very nice service. Definitely worth hitting after hiking in Turtleback. read more

Island Pie - a glass of water and a bottle of liquor - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

See all

I cant eat cheese or gluten, so I ordered the sausage and shallot pizza with vegan cheese on a gluten free crust. it was the best pizza I have ever eat in my life. Seriously. I shared with my family and they agreed that it was sooooo delicious. I wanted to order three more. I hope to go back tomorrow. This is a pizza I am going to be craving for years to come. read more

Pasta pictured was dry and had no recognizable sauce. Charged $6 when asked for more explaining & why. 2 of the 3 staff rolled their eyes at each other when my daughter asked for more Alfredo. We ordered two cheese pizzas and one was pepperoni. We had waited a good deal already, so did not ask for it to remade. The raspberry martinis were too strong and tasted fake rather than tasting "flavored with real fruit", as advertised. The waitress took them back and the raspberry mojitos she made were awesome. We were sat in the sun and given a stack of paper cups, no ice, and one wine bottle full of coolish water, which was never refilled. The 20% mandatory tip for a party of 6 is a bit crazy and steep. We definitely would not have tipped that for all that we experienced. We were excited to try this place and were very disappointed. read more

Island Pie - Alfredo pasta with chicken on either order. No Alfredo was on pasta. - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

Salad was small but very good. The pizza slightly better that freezer pizza. Sauce was canned. Crust was uninspired and toppings were very good. Pizza comes in one size. To go pizza was most popular. They had Scotch Ale from Bellingham which was excellent. ADA access was limited from the gravel parking lot. In the restaurant we could get around well. We watched the Seahawks game on the TV. If you want pizza on the island, it's here or in the store therefore it works for us. Enjoy. read more