Good pizza friendly staff great location!! Open early if you want a pizza after whale watching trip

Hands down the best pizza on the island!!! They give you an option to customize your pizza and you can choose different flavours in the same pizza. Basically 2 in 1 We got takeout and enjoyed the delicious pizza on our water view hotel room. Perfect date night! We ordered one half as the white pizza and the other half was americas favourite. Both were delicious nevertheless but the white pizza half was thin crust and a lil bit tastier or maybe I just liked it better because that's what my husband ordered and like always his order is always tastier than mine read more

Island Pie - a view of the ocean from a window - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

An absolute gem on the west side of the island. This definitely is not your normal pizza parlor. From Margaret sourcing the organic ingredients to their distinctive and tasty crust this is a place for good food. I'm a real fan of the fall mushroom appetizer as well as the veggie pizza. So don't expect New York style or Chicago style. This is definitely Deer Harbor style and for that I'm very thankful. read more

Island Pie is the BEST pizza in the islands! Hands down! We keep our boat in Deer Harbor and I have to fight the urge to have pizza every weekend. Our favorite pie is the sausage, with the crispy onions on top. Their crust is fabulous and the offer a GF crust which is almost as good! I'm also a big fan of their desserts. For those reviews who are unhappy with the operating model, I'm pretty sure those are the same folks who don't want to wear a mask. The owners of Island Pie have put in place protocols to protect their employees. If those are an inconvenience to you, the DH marina sells frozen pizzas - go enjoy one. read more

Had a great experience stopping by Island Pie! The staff were funny and lighthearted!!

Across from the Deer Harbor Marina, Island Pie is a great place to grab gourmet pizza, pasta or dessert and watch the sunset. The owners are friendly and helpful. We came in after the power went out at our rental, but Island Pie was up and running (with a limited menu) and still serving hot pies. We order the seasonal squash pizza and it was delicious! It hit the spot! Pies are served at the table on paper. Nothing fancy, but very homey and comfortable. read more

In 30 years of visiting the island, I've come across a few restaurants that were disappointing, but Island Pie is the only one to earn the distinction of being a disgrace. My wife and I and four friends arrived on time for our 6pm appointment. Our first pizza arrived two hours later. It wasn't the worst tasting pizza we'd ever had, but the delay was ridiculous. During that period, we witnessed other patrons expressing frustration with their delayed orders. No one was happy. The most disturbing thing was seeing a toddler under the age of two, we suspect the child of the owner, standing by himself on an unstable structure that had him several feet off the ground. We brought this to our server's attention, who said, "I've only been here one day." The view of the marina is lovely, but the terrible service and mediocre pizza will make sure you don't enjoy it. Avoid this restaurant at all costs. It's a nightmare. read more

Excelent pizza! So flavorful. Staff is friendly and meal arrived quickly. Sat outside and enjoyed sunny deck with fabulous views of the marina. Highly recommend!! read more

Last night, the owners of this adorable pizza shop saved the evening! We were able to get a pie after having a disappointing experience in town. We ordered half pepperoni and half cheese and it was delicious! Thank you again for making this right before closing. Your restaurant is very warm and inviting. We will defiantly be back! read more

The service is a tad slow and the pizza is like an elevated frozen pizza. My whole group's stomach hurts now, after it took us 2 hours to get served and eat 2 pizzas. Pizza is still just a good food, and this was the only restaurant open in Deer Harbor/Orcas Village/West Sound, so 3 stars. They played only Jimmy Buffet the whole time. read more

If you're looking for a " typical" pizza joint, this may not be your place, but, if you're looking for an experience that will have your taste buds dancing, PLEASE, give this little gem of a place a try! Each time we've eaten there it's been a great experience. The pizza's are a true combination of love and creativity. It's a quaint little place with a beautiful view of the harbor. Stop in, say hello to Margaret, Robert and Broccoli (if she's there)... I guarantee it will be the first place I go when I'm back on the island! read more

Totally loved our dining experience at Island Pie. Wine, beer, salad and pizza pies were all delicious. We saw the owner Margaret on the marina docks and she explained the online ordering process implemented to address Covid-19 concerns. As easy as Pie! We made our reservation for a specific time, paid and tipped upfront, we were seated as scheduled and our food & drinks delivered to us quickly. Great deck and shade umbrellas. Pretty nifty set up. And the follow up was stellar...! You know how you request your left overs be boxed to take with you after a meal? Well, like many others do, we left our box on the table. Margaret called and left me a voice mail. I didn't see the message until we left the docks the following day. Margaret ended up saving the box and delivered the left over pizza to our dining companions who were still at the dock. Those lucky stiffs! Service above and beyond. Great pizzas! We hope to be back next month. Thank you. read more

The good. Nice view of the harbor from this place. Not good. Very slow even while not busy. The pizza seems like a frozen pizza. You can see the perforated holes in the machine made crust. No plates, just a piece of paper they give you to eat on. Nothing else around here. Can't imagine how they can stay in business. read more

Ok....get food here. The pizza is amazing and service is awesome! Don't think twice, just do it! And thank you Margaret for the lovely birthday cupcakes you sent me. Such a lovely surprise. We will be back to enjoy your place again! read more

Really great flavors, friendly service, and a nice view. You order at the counter and then choose your seat, either inside or outside on the deck, which has a beautiful view of the harbor. The menu is kind of small, but I didn't mind... makes decisions a lot easier! I ordered the Seasonal Squash pizza (vegetarian) with a glass of red that was recommended with that pizza on the menu. Nice! The wine was tasty and the flavors of the pizza were really delicious! It included a base ("sauce) of roasted butternut squash, yam puree, fresh chopped herbs, and roasted onions. The pizza was topped with shredded cheese as well as crumbled feta and a yummy balsamic reduction drizzle. The perfect combo of sweet and salty with a hit of acid. The pizza itself was about 12" across, maybe slightly smaller, The crust was on the thin side and decent, although not as tender as I was hoping. One pizza will feed one very hungry big-eater, although I would recommend splitting a pizza and maybe sharing a salad too. I was pretty hungry after hiking and demolished an entire pizza (oops) because I didn't want to deal with leftovers. The interior of the restaurant is nothing special, but it's clean and sufficient. Prices are pretty normal for the island, about $20 for one pizza. I arrived around 7:15 pm on a Thursday and the place was about half full (including the deck) and more people trickled in throughout the evening. I would come again when visiting Orcas in the future. read more

Island Pie - Seasonal squash pizza. Lovely flavors! - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

First: the pizza was incredible. The toppings were well paired and delicious--simple enough to be approachable yet unique enough to be interesting. The crust was light, crispy bottomed, with a great chew. The menu is limited and specials run out early. It can get fairly busy so you may want to make a reservation. It's is just steps from the marina, offering indoor and outdoor seating, and charmingly simple decor. The family that runs the restaurant and their staff were kind and accommodating. read more

Great food and great views of the harbor. We ordered the Hawaiian pizza, signature salad and macaroni and cheese. All of which were outstanding. The apple crumble was ok, not the best as the apples were mushy and not worth $12 and you had to pay an extra $2 for a scoop of ice cream. Should have skipped the dessert as it was not worth the cost. read more

Working on Orcas for a month, staying outside Deer Harbor. It's the off season, so not a lot of places open consistently. Was in the mood for pizza and didn't want to drive 25 minutes to Eastsound; really glad I stopped by to get an Island Pie to go. They were happy to accommodate my own fave combo--pepperoni, pineapple, jalapeño--and I wandered around the beach/marina area for 20 minutes while they made it fresh...it was delicious. Good crust, great sauce, perfect amount and ratio of toppings. Definitely recommend! read more

The pizza looked and tasted like it was out of a box. HORRIBLE. The egg rolls were delicious but over priced.

Delicious, home made. I had the Bone Broth and friends had pineapple pepperoni and jalapeño's. So good! read more

Island Pie - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

The only good thing I can say about this place is the view is beautiful. Horrible food, service is worse. Way too expensive for the quality. I suggest skipping altogether and finding another restaurant to eat at. read more

We really enjoyed our pizza and garlic knots tonight from Island Pie! We were able to easily order takeout via their website, and we picked it up right on time. We had the half & half pizza, choosing 1/2 white pizza & 1/2 sausage & fennel. It was delish and hit the spot! I didn't think to take a picture. We will be sure to come next time we visit. :) Thanks, Island Pie! read more

Do not go here if your family has food allergies! Man I was so excited to try this place. Unfortunately, the service was so poor I will not be coming back. Not only was there an allergy mix up where nuts were used on my husbands salad (he's extremely allergic) but the staff was rude and unorganized. Ingredients were also left off of my pizza and with a high price point, it was such a letdown.I have contacted the owners via private email (two months ago) and got no response. read more

One of my favorite pizza places on the island. Very nice people it's good service - can be a little slow but they're very pleasant and worth the wait. Also check out Hogstone another winner ... Orcas is amazing. read more

This was our first trip to Orcas Island, and were excited to try Island Pie. We placed our order online for a pepperoni pizza, Island salad, and two sodas to pick up. We received a phone call a few minutes later saying that they had a large party that night, and our order would likely be ready around 7:20 (we ordered a bit before 5:00). Since we weren't that hungry, we said that was fine. We arrived at 7:20, only to be told that the order hadn't been started yet, and could we come back in about 20 minutes. We did so, and were told it was in the oven. All told, it took us around 3 hours to get a pizza, a tiny $14 salad, and two sodas. The pizza and salad were fine, nothing really to write home about. I might suggest to the owners that if you know you have a large party that will pretty much paralyze your kitchen for hours, put up a sign on the door and online that you're not taking outside orders that night. Focus on what you can provide and when you can provide it. read more

Had the seasonal squash pizza and it was great! Really unique flavors and something that I don't think I could find easily elsewhere. Also, the owners/employees were so friendly and gave us great suggestions on what we could do on the island. read more

Island Pie - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

See all

Not sure how this establishment received 4.5 starts. Views are nice, I'll give them that, other than that it was just bad. Pizzas ($22 a piece) were really bad. The squash pizza is way too sweet. The dough tasted like it was pre baked then frozen and baked again. They were out of half of the menu items. The only salad that was available came in a paper "boat" and had nothing in it that worth the price. We ended up paying $95 for 3 pies and 1 salad, no drinks. read more

Very good pizza, old beer and tasty wines! Had the pepperoni and a squash pizza with feta and a balsamic glaze. Sounds odd, but very good. Margaret the owner is very nice and make sure you feel welcome. Super busy at 5 to 6 so we took a drive and came back at 7:30 when less crowded and sat outside. Nice view of the marina and water. Lots of bunnies hanging out munching on grass. Desserts looks good, but to full from pizza darn it. Oh did I mention the crust? Just enough bite to it, not overdone and burned like alot of pizza places these days. Definitely worth stopping if your hungry! read more

See all

Great tasting options, prepared to order, with suggested wine pairings, inside or outside seating, a local community gathering place for good reason. My favorites are beet salad and squash pizza. Oh yes, chocolate pie for dessert. If you are looking for fast food bulk pizza, this is not it. read more

WOW! What a pizza. I had The Sausage and it was fabulous. Being from Chicago and living where there is no good pizza I was in 2 nd heaven. Margarit was great. Definitely a place to check out. Caution. Watch for their closed open days. Closed 3 days a week. Darn virus! read more

We adore this place, and it's vegan friendly!  Love their bruschetta (just order it w/o cheese) - if you eat it all to yourself, it's very filling.  Mushroom appetizer is good, and can be made vegan. I haven't yet tried the beet salad, but it looks delish. And they have a pizza with roasted squash and yams that can be made vegan (request w/o the cheese) - this is a bit bland, but next time I might ask for some of that tasty shallot oil to drizzle on top and turn the flavor up to 11. :-) My non-vegan friends like the sausage pizza. Great view of Deer Harbor. A truly special spot. read more

I've never written a review before but I was so disappointed tonight that it motivates me to write my first. I swear the mac and cheese was a frozen microwaveable mac and cheese that they put on a plate and charge $19 for. The pizza wasn't great either, the crust tasted like frozen pizza crust and it just had no flavor. We spent over $70 for a meal that I could've spent $20 on with a frozen pizza and frozen mac and cheese. The staff were great but that food... read more

You cannot miss a meal (or three) at Island Pie. The pizzas were great (especially the crust) and the staff were wonderful. They are dealing with impatient tourists and yet they maintain their cool. I'm impressed and grateful for their patience. Love this place! read more

Fabulous little gem of a pizza place! Super friendly service and possibly the best pizza I've ever eaten. The seasonal squash was so unique and delicious and my husband devoured his Hawaiian. Will definitely be coming back on our next trip to Orcas! read more

Island Pie - Half Hawaiian, half seasonal squash. We ate every bite. - Pizza Near Me - Deer Harbor, Washington

Hard to understand some of the 4-5 star reviews when the pizza here is so horrible. Do they have two pizza cooks, and one is great and the other terrible? We stopped in after a hike to get some pie (apple pie) and, I must say that was delicious pie (despite the fact it took 20 minutes to get us a slice of apple pie when no one else was there). Thought we would take a pizza to go for dinner later that night. Tried to ask the waitress all the right questions (thick or thin crust, etc.) but got vague answers (at least be educated about what you serve). "12 oz dough ball" we were told. Can't see a pizza first, so had to order blind. Ordered the pepperoni. As the menu says "a pie like no other!" (That's for sure, as no one can screw up a pepperoni pizza as bad as this place). "Piled high with pepperoni..." (if one layer of scattered, thin pepperonis is "piled high" then I don't understand), and "full on cheese" (which was a dusting of some sort of cheese that was overcooked). Basically wound up with a $20 super thin, odd-ball shaped pizza with barely any meat, and a spattering of overbaked cheese on top. Not sure who the owner is, but for godsake...do some quality control and give your help staff the info to answer basic questions. I can't SEE a pizza before I order it, so I'm hoping and praying it looks and tastes great. But not this one. And, FWIW, even the kids hated it. I've always said "there's no such thing as a bad pizza"...I was wrong. I did email the owner, but after 2 days have not heard back. read more

My wife and I pulled into our hotel and were looking for a place to eat as it was getting late. Luckily Island Pie was still open. Both the food and conversation were amazing. The butternut squash pizza was great as it wasn't too heavy. The couple who run the restaurant gave us some ideas on what do while we were in town and we came back a few days later as they made us some sandwiches that they are trying out for our hike. This place is a must if you are staying in Orcas! read more

Pizza was decent and the staff was nice. Felt overpriced and there was no indoor sitting or heated patio so dining in was uncomfortable

Pizza Pie was pretty good, only issue was that the pie was a bit sparse on cheese and meat ingredients. The owners truly care about their reviews I learned, so upgraded my review a bit. Hours are confusing, but my bad on how i read that. I Felt like giving this a 4 star, but will still wait to edit my review after the 2nd visit/taste like i usually do. The Family and Friends really appreciated the GF option on crust, but an omission or GF beer would go a long way with a GF pizza. I don't typically judge on that however. --RibChamp read more

Good pizza. The crust is a little thick and messy at times but it's still enjoyable. Recommend going here if you're ever in town.

Easy walk down the hill from where we are staying. Ordered 1/2 sausage + 1/2 ham and pineapple, extra sauce and add chicken to go. 45" wait for order. The sauce was good, sure glad we ordered extra. Crust was a wee bit tough and there was no pineapple. I was bummed and too lazy to walk back down and back up the hill again. They were super busy with dine in customers so that's a good thing. Pasta wasn't on the menu but when I went to pick up my pizza I saw it on the board. Will try that next visit. Edited with 2nd visit: Had the lasagna and got my grandson the Mac and cheese pizza. All were good, nothing fabulous. I did get a couple of cup cakes and they were fabulous! In fact so good I went back and got more to take home to Montana with me. The Devil's food with peanut butter frosting is to die for. read more