I'm not a huge pizza fan & when we get one, we usually go for the "all meat" version for my husband. Island Pizza's is called the Hogs-N-Horns. We got the 18" for $27. Not bad at all since we brought home half the pizza as leftovers. OMG, I think it is one of THE BEST pizzas I've ever eaten! I love the thin crust, lots of cheese & meat. Normally I have to ask for ranch dressing to "cover" the pizza flavors I don't care for but not this pizza! I ate it as prepared & it was SOOOO DELICIOUS! The restaurant was immaculately clean. Plenty of seating. Nice music ambience. There's also a bar with TVs. And my husband said the men's bathroom was spotless. The waitress (owner?) was extremely friendly & very accommodating. We will definitely return. read more

I appreciate that there's a fun pizza joint on this island. It's a really laid-back kind of place, and stapled to the walls are dollar bills that customers have signed with black Sharpies. Very interesting. I wish I had gotten our server's name, but she was absolutely wonderful. She was so kind and understanding, and communicative when our food wasn't coming out as quickly as it probably should have. Our waitress felt like a Southern grandma who cared about us. She really made the whole evening worthwhile. As a vegan, I had wished they offered more options, but I settled on ordering a pizza with veggies and no cheese. I liked the crust which was thin and crispy. There were a good amount of vegetables too. I ended up adding a little salt and red pepper flakes to make it more flavorful. Oh, and I ordered a soda which came in a very large cup! No need for a refill. read more

Island Pizza - 10 inch pizza with spinach, tomatoes, black olives, and artichokes. No cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

We enjoyed our quick lunch at Island Pizza. The waitress was freshly and did accept my Entertainment coupon for buy 1 get 1 entree free. The pizza came out fast and was fresh. The Mediterranean pizza was delicious. The waitress did box up our leftovers. Plenty of seating and parking. The ambience is relaxed and they have dollar bills signed by people who've been there all over the restaurant. The price for one of the 10in pizzas was $21. Unsure of other pizza pricing on the island. read more

See all

We came here because it's advertised as the best pizza on the island but we were pleasantly surprised to find that their chicken wings were absolutely amazing! They were crispy and delicious and came out piping hot. They were also well coated in the delicious barbecue sauce that we ordered. The place has a good atmosphere with dollar bills hung up all around the area. The pizza came out right afterwards and the service Sophia provided was excellent, but we were a little underwhelmed with the pizza dough.... we just expected it to be crunchier and better. It was a little bit chewy and my daughter said it tasted like it came.oit of the freezer Overall a cool little spot to grab some wings, a cold drink and decent pizza..... still searching for the best pie on the island though! read more

Island Pizza - Dollar bill bar - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

I like to try new places for pizza so I figured I'd give Island Pizza a go. I wasn't sure what I was expecting, but this wasn't it. I got my pizza to go, so I only got a quick look inside. Seemed more bar than restaurant, basically there were more barstools than tables and chairs. Employees were OK. The pizza though, was like a cross between a school pizza with the overly sweet sauce and not really melting cheese, and a frozen thin crust you bake at home. I can't really recommend them at this time. read more

We got a large pizza half cheese and half pepperoni & sausage and a large salad and extra dressing the food was delicious but the price was ridiculous $45.00 plus $4.20 gratuity totaling $49.20 and that was to go. So if anyone go there to eat open up you wallet. read more

2.9 stars for this place is ridiculous. It's pizza and you're on an island. Set your expectations accordingly. It's decent. Not the best pizza you'll ever eat, but good enough if you're in the mood for pizza and a beer. We got the 2-beers-for-one deal with a 14" and walked out very satisfied for $35. Also, service was good and ambiance a pleasant island casual. read more

Pepperoni Pizza was fantastic- thin crust with fresh, flavorful ingredients. Carryout service was quick and efficient. Employees extremely honest- I dropped my wallet at the bar and the Manager held until I returned looking for it! read more

We came here and dined in recently while visiting family on Sanibel. The pizza itself was quite tasty, if greasy, and the chicken wings were excellent! We also had a caesar salad to share. The pizzas were large - it would have been nice if it was easier to see the rounds they have way up on the wall to show the size of the pizzas (we were juggling young kids and orderd in a hurry). Overall, it was decent pizza but not amazing. Taking off one more star as it smelled pretty badly of urine/bathrooms where we were sitting near the bar at a larger table. Maybe this would have been better at the tables by the windows, but where we were it was unfortunately quite noticeable! The service was good and the location is very central. read more

I really like the setup that they have here. They have a nice outdoor patio to sit and eat your pizza. The staff inside was very nice and welcoming. Now for the pizza. This was an average pizza. It's the thickness of a ny pizza the dough is a little soft and flops when you hold it. The cheese was pretty average age didn't have a ton of flavor. The meatballs were chopped into fine purses and were probably my favorite part. read more

Island Pizza - Meatball pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

Ordered our first night on Sanibel after a long travel day. Very mediocre and expensive. Would not order again.

I'm confused about the negative reviews. This place was great! Our waitress made sure our drinks were full and was very attentive. Zero complaints. We ordered a large Hogs-N-Horns and a large White Pizza. Both were great and the crust was perfect. We're excited to come back next time we're in town. read more

Island Pizza - White Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

See all

Great pizza! Crispy crust with some chew, lots of options for toppings. But! Want to know what is better than amazing pizza? The phenomenal people who run it. Tammy is very sweet person and so personable- she's always up for a chat and always in a good mood. I'll be back! read more

We got "Island Pizza" a lot when we visited Sanibel a little while ago. It was delicious! The 2.9 star rating definitely shocks me a bit, because it was some of the best pizza we'd ever had! read more

We were going to go to traders next door but when we walked in no one acknowledged us so we decided to go next door to island pizza and it was a good choice. The people were really nice. The pizza was amazing and it was fast. The place itself is really nice. read more

Island Pizza - the dining area of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

We love Island Pizza. Fantastic pizza. They also have cauliflower crust and a gluten free crust. Both great. My husband gets the regular crust and thats great too. The salads are large and always nice and fresh. They have other food too, but we love the pizza! The prices are reasonable and the service is friendly and efficient. There are other choices for Italian food on Sanibel but Island Pizza does the best pizza by far. It is a cozy little local place with great food and excellent service. read more

Not sure why this place has been blasted on reviews. We got take out from island pizza our first night on the island and the pizza was great! Also got wings with the island sauce and everyone loved the island sauce!! We talked about ordering from there again before we left read more

I feel bad giving a sub par review because there was no bad experience. We got an extra large pizza with sausage for takeout. Honestly it tasted like a frozen pizza. The sausage was chopped into tiny pieces and had that frozen taste, the crust was chewy with lots of flour, and the cheese was eh.. It was a bit below average but not awful. Great service, great price, but below average pizza. read more

Island Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

Sanibel's local pizza shack. The decor is kind of a chaotic, hot mess: signed dollar bills stapled to the walls, college pennants circling the room, a huge Clydesdale painted on the wall, and a strangely hypnotic, poured epoxy floor somewhat reminiscent of a Jackson Pollock. But hey, who cares? You didn't come here for some bougie chic vibe. You came here sandy and salty and sunburned from the beach for a classic pie and a cold beer, and that's what you're gonna get, my friend. I gravitate toward the hogs and horns. Pizza has good crust and cheese but sauce is very minimal. Try the local mango flavored beer. Dine in, pick up or delivery. Be prepared to wait a long time for your order. 5* = incredible (rare) 4* = very good/ strong desire to return 3* = generally good experience 2* = poor/ no desire to return 1* = a particularly awful experience read more

Island Pizza - The hogs and horns - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

Great pizza and customer service! Toppings are all wonderful and their crust is the way crust should be and delicious ! Definitely the place in Sanibel to grab a pizza for take-out or dine-in! read more

My grandchildren loved the pizza. I had eaten down the way and met them there. It had a nice vibe and great service. read more

Island Pizza - Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

Great pizza and garlic knots with mozzarella. XL cheese pizza and pepperoni pizza. Nice flavor and service was quick. The chocolate cake was delicious! A must have! read more

This was perfect after a day at the beach. Casual dining, good beer on tap, decent pizza. Pizza is thin crust with just the right amount of toppings to make it not soggy. The large feeds 3 easily and the individual size is a good size at 12". We had the fried pickles too. Dill pickle spears, deep fried with ranch. The ranch is eh, ok but the pickles were hot and tasty. read more

Look if you're trying to find a genuine NY pizzeria, it isn't here. But this is your choice for sanibel and their pizza was good! I had Bianca and my mom had pepperoni although the olives and onions were left off. Overall, it's good for a quick bite and to grab a few pies for the family. May be a bit overpriced but when it comes to pizza, there's just not a lot of options here minus the regular ol pizza chains and how boring is that. read more

Family run, friendly fast service. Sit down available but after a long beach day we ordered large pizza and Greek salad to-go. There's a good selection of local beer on draft and wine also. The sauce on the pizza was tasty, and it was loaded with black olives, mushrooms and pepperoni. There's a climbing tower out front and plenty of space for cars and bicycles. read more

Island Pizza - Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

See all

Amazing. Best pizza I ever had! Wonderful and friendly service. Would definitely come here again!

I used to go here with my friends. It's a great place to take the family when you don't want to spend hundreds on island dining. Their pizza is good and it's a quaint interior. Nothing extravagant. But it's got that family feel. read more

We got carry out pizza from here our first night in Captiva. Great pizza with super quick service! We ordered cheese, veggie, and pepperoni. All three were great but the veggie was my personal favorite. The thinly sliced vegetables and chopped tomatoes on it make it so good! They are also super friendly when picking up and the vibe of the shop was cool with the college pennant banners and such! Overall, I was impressed and would recommend! read more

Just ate at this location this past Friday evening. We arrived around 6pm the restaurant was not busy upon our arrival but it did pretty much fill up prior to us leaving. The atmosphere reminded us of a small cozy pizza place in the woods as it is tucked away on the Island and was decorated for Christmas. Very nice touch. The service was excellent. Everyone was very friendly and accommodating. The pizza was better than good with respect to Florida pizza standards. Sorry pizza is not the best here in FL.. Not greasy crispy crust and well cooked. We had a meatball and mushroom build your own pizza very good. I would suggest ordering an xtra-Lg pizza as the large is not what a typical Lg pizza would be as it is on the smaller side. We now know for future visits. They have an in house smoked brisket and pulled pork sandwich. To the location owner/manager, I would recommend offering those meat selections on your pizza with a BBQ sauceoption as a sauce base for the pizza.. Yummy. All in all a very good experience and we are so happy to see this business and others on the Island reestablishing themselves after the storm, so cut them a break and leave positive reviews to help them continue to re-build the business. We will definitely be back!! read more

Thank you! Great pizza. Great staff. Arrived just before closing and it was not an issue "take your time." Truly appreciated! read more

Service was meh but the food was pretty good after a long day in the sun. Gluten free crust was not edible in my opinion, the knots and regular pizza were great! read more

I am not a big pizza fan so I didn't really want to go here but it was quick and easy. The people were nice and I ordered the Hawaiian pizza it was good they give you good amounts of it and the place was nicely decorated. I heard they were hit by the hurricane but when they rebuild I look forward to coming back! read more

The crust makes the pizza and they do it well. We called in our order, it was ready on the dot and we took it to the beach nearby. Yum!

We were looking for a place that was affordable and delicious without being seafood. Hard to find on an island. Wow is this place underrated!! There was one other car in the parking lot which made us second guess our choice as almost all the other restaurants are constantly full. However we were met with friendly staff and an amazing waitress. Service was super quick and we got our food in a short amount of time. Our party ordered the Hawaiian 10", the Greek white 10", and the islander 14". All of us enjoyed our pizza and we had enough for lunch the next day. The pizza tasted delicious and fresh! The crust was super delicious. And the pizza was still tasty even after microwaving it for lunch the next day. And a plus- they use paper straws! Good for the environment! I 100% recommend this place for tasty food and excellent service! We'll be coming here again! read more

Island Pizza - With our paper straws! - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

Our pizzas were nothing like the ones pictured. Crackers with minimum toppings and flavor. So far the absolute biggest disappointment in years on the island. GAS STATION PIZZA. And the wings tasted like boiled chicken with watered down buffalo sauce. $80 for stuff that tastes like it comes from a vending machine. Buyer BEWARE read more

Island Pizza - Tasted like a saltine cracker. Thank god for the jalapeños. - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

We stopped here on our last day of our vacation. As it is Lent we needed to order meatless. We started with the toasted ravioli which was delicious. My husband ordered their Margherita pizza on the gluten free crust (celiac). The the crust was thin, thoroughly cooked, and (most importantly) did not taste like cardboard. My youngest son ordered the 10" cheese pizza. I had a 10" pineapple pizza. My older son ordered a 14" Margherita pizza. They were all very tasty! Our server Whitney greeted us warmly and came to check on us often to make sure everything was ok. We were overall very pleased with our visit. If we come to Sanibel again we will definitely stop back. Thank you for a great dining experience. read more

See all

The pizza was just ok. And the buffalo shrimp was a joke. Real tiny shrimp that were obviously from the frozen food section at a store was $10 not well spent. But the price of the pizza wasn't bad. read more

Island Pizza - Too tired to cook! - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

We stopped in while visiting for the day. The staff was so nice and my meatball grinder was delicious. My daughter had the chicken parm grinder and she said it was delicious as well. read more

First time eating here and had a great experience. There wasn't a hostess so we sat ourselves and the menus were already on the table. It took awhile for the waitress to come over but she was working the small inside restaurant all by herself. She was very apologetic and told it us it was only her second day. Phyllis was a dream waitress. She was doing the best she could and was excellent at it. We ordered the toasted ravioli and chicken wings for starters. Ravioli was delicious and the mild wings were pretty good. We also ordered the extra large Hogs and Hooves pizza (there were four of us) and it was one of the best pizzas we've ever tasted. The crust was nice and thin, sauce was not over powering and the toppings were plentiful. We were stuffed by the end of the night. Definitely would recommend to others. read more

Island Pizza - Half of a XL Hogs and Hooves pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sanibel, Florida

Gave this place a shot, but previous post was right on ... crackers with crappy sauce. $22 for a 14" ... get a few frozen pizzas instead, you'll be much happier ... read more