Place was great. We were on the island and decided to stop in. Place was kinda dead but we figured we'd try it. Or server / bartender Billy was absolutely awesome! We got the boneless and bone in wings - 1 hot one buffalo and one hot buffalo jerk. They were both awesome! We got half a pepperoni and half a hot honey. We got the pizza well done, had a little black on the underside of the pizza but it wasn't Burnt! Pizza dough was great flavor and fresh! We will make the drive down from westly chapel to have this pizza again! read more

Came into Islands Pizza for pizza and drinks and ended up staying way longer than planned because the bartender Sophia was THAT good. My bartender was super friendly, fast, attentive, and somehow managed to keep up with a packed bar while still making everyone feel taken care of. The drinks were perfect every time, the vibe was fun without being overwhelming, and she had the kind of personality that makes you want to come back regularly. You can tell she genuinely enjoys what she does and it completely changes the atmosphere of the place. Pizza was amazing too, but the service honestly made the whole experience. Definitely one of the best neighborhood spots to grab drinks and hang out. Will absolutely be back! read more

Islander Pizza put on the F1 watch party for us and they were incredible hosts! They had drinks specials such as mimosas and really delicious breakfast! I enjoyed traditional eggs potatoes and toast with a couple tasty mimosas. The great thing was they opened early for the F1 fans because there was a time difference in Barcelona, that was very important and much appreciated! The atmosphere was clean and friendly. They had plenty of TV screens to view the F1 from different areas which was very good for the fans. I definitely want to go back to try the pizza at Islander and I know they post specials almost nightly on their instagram page! This is also a fantastic place to meet people because I met several other F1 fans there from around Tampa Bay and even out of town. read more

Brooklyn Pizza was so delicious. Great atmosphere, locals fill up the place!! Beer was cold and the pizza was hot! Great servers, bartenders. read more

The pizza was surprising good, the selection of bourbons and whiskey impressive but the price structure makes no sense. I got the Woodford reserve double oak and it was $30 for one pour when the regular bottle is o my $89. I totally understand the markup but to charge $6 on certain days and $16 daily for Woodford reserves seems a bit off. In fact the E. H. Taylor normally $100 was poured for only $16. The staff is friendly and honestly all of the bar patrons were nice. I did go back two days in a row and wish they would have at least changed the soap in the men's restroom. read more

Went by with group of 9 people 3/8/26 AFTER 10pm. Kylie inside & Chrystine outside accommodated us outside with great food and drinks! We had burgers, grouper, buffalo cauliflower, calzones... Everything was fantastic. read more

Out of town for a nice weekend. Heard a lot about davis island. After walking around fot a bit I found this spot and not a single regret. Sophia my bartender was very friendly. I asked her about some good things to get. Bacon burger and she said she makes a very good margarita. I was amazed by the service, scenery and quality of food. Thank you sophia and thank you to the chef for the great service and food. read more

Great food and good drinks. Tory was especially great as our bartender. Definitely coming back.

Tori best bartender ever! Food was good, drinks were great, service was out of this world. would highly recommend.

I have to say Mya is a fantastic bartender! She was very attentive and had a new drink in front me before my last swallow every time! The food is great! Excellent daily specials. What a great vibe! read more

I took my boys here after a baseball game. We wanted to eat inside. We sat and waited. The bartender/waitress looked over at us multiple times and didn't ask if we needed help or even acknowledge us. We would up leaving and eating pizza elsewhere. Terrible customer service. read more

I had a terrible experience at Islands Pizza on Davis Islands. The older woman working there, who wear a name necklace that is silver and starts with an H I believe, who has clearly had one too many injections in her face, was extremely rude and completely incompetent. I have food allergies and needed some assistance, so I asked to speak to the manager. Unfortunately, the older male manager was absolutely no help either. Both of them were inconsiderate, incompetent, and unprofessional. Anyone managing a restaurant should have a basic understanding of food allergies and show some empathy. Instead, the manager told me he didn't want me to die in HIS restaurant from an allergic reaction. This kind of gross behavior is unacceptable. I would not recommend this place to anyone. read more

Islands Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

If there was a negative star I would choose it, this place smells like an unflushed toilet. I got a look at the kitchen and it looks like a landfill in there, DISGUSTING read more

I brought my family in. We had 2 medium pizzas mainly because everyone wants something different. Everyone was happy and the pizza was good. We left with about one medium in leftovers. We would go again but it was not the best pizza or best place we have been to. Overall it is ok for a local pizza place and bar. read more

I picked up pizza from Islands Pizza super bowl Saturday. They sent us a bunch of pizza coupons in the mail, I'm they they were anticipating a rush for the Super Bowl. We had one for buy one large pizza get I one free! We placed a to go order for a large pepperoni and mushroom and a BBQ chicken specialty pizza. They were really good! Really satisfying after craving pizza all day! The pickup order was ready in about 25-30 minutes. They gave us a bunch of packs of parmigiana and red pepper flakes to take home. Quick and friendly service! Would definitely order from Islands Pizza again! Live off the island but really close. Completely hit the spot when I was craving some delicious pizza cheesy gooey goodness! read more

Islands Pizza - Yes!!! - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Davis Island has a good little pizza restaurant that is not too busy inside at lunch time. They were doing a good takeout business but inside dining was pretty quiet. We originally were going to just order a few slices and then decided to purchase a whole pie. So glad we did. It was fresh and hot from the oven and the service was good. My only concern was the cleanliness inside and outside usually dictates what the kitchen cleanliness is. I will go with, "What you can't see, won't hurt you". read more

See all

They don't have a delivery service so I ordered some pizzas through EZ Cater for a training being held at my place of work. They have their medium pizzas listed online as "feeds 8" but when the pizzas were delivered I was in shock. Each pizza was small with only 8 small slices. Are you kidding me? What grown adult is only eating one slice of pizza? I'm now having to run over to pick up an extra 2 pizzas myself to properly feed my team. Absolutely ridiculous and won't be ordering from here again. read more

my husband and i really enjoyed this place! really great vibes and the food was actually delicious. the manager was super kind and accommodating we we will definitely be back. also the wings were 10/10. read more

Classic pizzas, ambiance was very baseline. Could be a little more warm in terms of appearances. Service is always great, everyone is very direct but friendly. read more

I get wings from Island Pizza all the time because I love their honey bourbon. Today I ordered 24 wings for pick up and I get there and I pay and then I get home and open the box and there's only 19 wings. I paid $38 for 24 wings and I only got 19. What a rip off, I went to their website and I click contact us and wrote to the owners so hopefully they answer. But if you don't see that, I would like a refund of some sort or like a percentage off my next order to like balance it out because I don't want to not come back because I do like the wings. I have included a picture and no I didn't eat any. I was splitting 24 with someone and that's when I realize we both don't have 12 and 12. read more

Islands Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

should a small pepperoni pizza take an hour? 5th best pizza on Davis Island. .................

Okay lets be straight up about what this place is. It is a great pizza and pub style food place. Everything I have tried was hot, fresh, large and delicious! Great job. Now let me also say that this place has one of the best and deepest selections of "great bourbon" that I have seen anywhere in Hillsborough county and quite possibly all of Florida. I have eaten at many, many of the high end bars and restaurants in Tampa, Miami and Orlando and none of them come close to this place! read more

We got the white pizza with Italian sausage and a pepperoni pizza to go. So yummy!!! When I didn't arrive to pick up within the window, the cashier called me to make sure I hadn't forgotten! It's the little things that make an establishment great. read more

My mom and I ordered a pizza tonight, a small pizza with extra cheese and mushroom. A male employee answering the phone and was rude and didn't ask for my mother's name until she asked do you need my name? Then we heard the employee we had on the phone say to someone in the background "I don't get f***ing get paid enough for this". Then he told us they were busy and would be a 45 min wait. We showed up in person about 40 mins later and the male employee could not find our order. He claimed he was on the phone with a "girl" and the call disconnected and he tried to call her back. When we asked how long it would be , he said another 45 mins. He was not apologetic whateversoever. Additionally they were not busy at all from appearances. My mom has been here before and had good service here. However as well I noticed their pizza slices this time as looked like they had been sitting out for hours and were bone dry. read more

This place is a decent option for late night food and drinks. Glad they are open late since there are very limited options in the area after 10pm on a Sunday. Food overall is average. Got the supreme pizza, chicken parmesan quesadilla and garlic knots. The Supreme Pizza had plentiful meats, average tasting when fresh and hot, and not good at all the next day when I headed it up. I recommend the Chicken parmesan quesadilla, this was better than the pizza and comes with lots of cheese, chicken and marinara sauce, a nice value at only $7 Skip the garlic knots, it's doughy bread and no taste of garlic that I could notice, I threw away the whole thing after eating just half of one knot, why would anyone skimp on the garlic, it's called garlic knots for a reason. If you walk into the restaurant thinking you just mistakenly walked into a bar, don't worry, you're in the right place. There's a long bar area on the left, a pool table on the right. Inside looks absolutely nothing like a pizza restaurant, I actually had to walk back out and double check the sign before coming back in again. read more

I first tried Islands Pizza at work and it was so good, I had to figure out where they ordered from. My husband and I decided to get a pepperoni pizza and garlic knots for dinner last night. Both were delicious! The pizza was hot, crispy and had great flavor. Knots were perfectly doughy and came with an amazing marinara. We will definitely be back! read more

Islands Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Long story short, they basically stole my money. I've been ordering from Islands for a while now. Last week I placed an order through their website for a delivery. After 2 hours with no update, I called the story repeatedly with no answer. I checked that the order had went through and I had a confirmation email, as well as a credit card transaction for the order. I called again the next day and they informed me they had closed earlier the night before... so I'm not sure why they'd accept my order. I asked about the credit card charge and after consulting with the manager I was told to "just dispute the charge". I immediately reached out to my credit card company who couldn't dispute the charge because it "was not a fraudulent charge" and I had no documentation to support me not receiving the item/service. So I called the restaurant back.... multiple times. I asked for a refund, I've asked to speak to a manager, I've left numerous voicemails over the last week. Not only have I not received a refund, I haven't even gotten a call back to try and resolve the situation and haven't been able to speak to a manager in the 10+ times my call has been answered. So, I spent $40 to have a pizza delivered... and a week later I don't have the pizza or the $40. read more

Islands Pizza - a white plate on a granite countertop - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

I loved islands pizza up until the owner started to get drunk and treat me as a customer with very utmost disrespect and then would disrespect his employees and even worse would do it in front of customers. Since this new owner it's gone down hill as he doesn't care about his customers or employees. I'm not one to usually leave a review like this but worst Owner of any bar I've ever been to. he accused me of trying to drug kids when my fiancé and I were handing out candy to kids on Halloween as well. I'm bot sorry either, whenever this owner is, is very disrespectful, rude, and should not be the owner. And you can delete my review but this is nothing but facts, the Ownerr OF ISLANDS PIZZA IS DISRESPECTFUL ASF TO CUSTOMERS AND EMPLOYEES and gets way to intoxicated at the bar instead of getting to know his locals. He also tends to fire his best employees for made up reasons as I watched it first hand. read more

Great pizza! We would stop here to take a break from being at Tampa General Hospital. We loved the thin crust pizza.

Don't order anything but pizza......They'll most definitely screw it up. 3 weeks in a row we've ordered pizza and a burger or salad. 3 weeks in a row they screwed up the burger or salad. Pizza is always good. read more

"Islands Pizza Tavern" on Davis Island, FL, is a "no joke" hidden gem for pizza and bourbon lovers. Their incredible handcrafted pizzas, boast the perfect crust and delicious toppings. Plus, you can get it by the slice!!! They also have one of greatest Bourbon selections in Tampa. (Their selection would be even impressive in Kentucky). So, if you are looking for a barrel pick and a slice, look no further than Islands Pizza Tavern! read more

Robbed by island pizza --delivery driver tossed the pizza on the front porch didn't even knock-- wrong pizza no sodas -- money down the drain. no receipt and won't pick up the phone. Would not recommend read more

First: their hours are wrong on Yelp Second: 8:24pm ordered an 20"pep sausage, s12" sausage, 20" gluten free white, cheese bread and two Greek salads. Delivery time scheduled between 9:24 and 9:44pm 8:44pm received call from grub hub saying they couldn't make a 20" gluten free. Okay, no prob. Make it two 12" GF and I will pay the diff. Check. 9:55pm receive one 12" sausage, one 20" pepp sausage and two Greek salads. No cheese bread and no GF whites. Driver apologizes and says she forgot half the order and goes back to pick up. While she is en route I call the restaurant to say please make sure she comes back with two gf whites and one cheese bread. He says, "sorry, we're already closed." Hm okay, but you still have to fix this... he says okay your order is right here waiting for her to pick up when she gets back. Okay... is I cheese bread and two gf white veggies? "It should be...." She comes back at 10:15p . With cheese bread. AND ANOTHER 20" PEP SAUSAGE. Where's the GF whites!? I call the guy. Again he says sorry we're already closed, no more pizzas. By now I'm hangry and ready to tell him off but the sweet saving grace delivery driver asked if she could speak with him. She explained to him the situation. I showed her my digital receipt and how it differed from her receipt and we figured THEY needed to take it up with grub hub but that we either needed a refund or our pizzas. This dude really really did not want to accommodate. I was positive that our pizzas would have various fluids on them by this point. But now (10:30pm) it was the principle. So he reluctantly agrees and she sweetly returns to get the za's. At 10:55 she returns (hallelujah!!) with two GF pizzas....... Sausage pepp pizzas. Not white veggie pizzas. FFS. This poor lady. I felt so bad. She deserves so much better than the tragically lazy and useless team she has on the other end of the phone line. This was comically bad service on every level. I'm positive these bad reviews are all about the same guy. Hopefully management takes notice. read more

My husband and I found this place via Groupon ($10 for $20) and it was our first outing to Davis Islands. This pizza joint is in a very quaint part of town. Its next to a couple of other restaurants and bars. It also has its own outdoors dining area and had plenty of TVs to watch football or whatever sport you desire. The wait staff was really nice and had some helpful suggestions in terms of appetizers ... we were torn between the sweet potato tater-tots and the pretzels with beer/cheese dipping sauce. We ended up going for the tater-tots which were delicious and plentiful. We also ordered Sam Adams Boston Lager which was a special on Saturdays for $3 (not a bad deal). Anyway, we ended up going for the Supreme Pizza, which had pepperoni, sausage, bacon, bell peppers, red onion, and mushrooms (we also had them add fresh basil). The pizza too about 20 min for it to come out, which I thought was reasonable, since they made it fresh. The pizza itself was very cheesy and flavorful, the basil gave it a little depth so I highly recommend adding it. The crust was delicious and crispy throughout... no soggyness found in the center. The pizza slices were pretty large and we were only able to eat half of the pizza pie, so we had plenty of left overs. Overall, this place provided a great dining experience. The pizza choices were straight forward and you could tell the ingredients were quality. The staff was friendly and were told that they provided delivery within the island. I just wish they delivered outside the island as I would definitely want to order from them. read more

Islands Pizza - Supreme pizza with extra basil. - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

One of the last times we were there (for some reason, we go here every 4-6 weeks, even though we always have a terrible experience) a patron yelled at my sister for using the restroom. He told her that it was not a gas station - implying, I suppose, that we were not paying customers, but toilet-happy vagabonds. A time before that, a man "working" while clearly combating a vicious hangover took our order then left us completely alone at the "restaurant." As he lowered his body into his vehicle, he told us that someone would come by and take care of us later. This place smells like a urinal cake. The staff is rude. The guests are more rude. The food is awful. The chicken tenders are inedible. I really hope we stop coming to this dump. read more

Islands Pizza was a family friendly pizza joint with an indoor and outdoor seating options. Order at the counter, and take a seat. There are three "areas" - two are family friendly and one is the next door Islands "Club" which is a bar where you can enjoy your pizza. The service was great - the gentleman at the counter answered all our questions and was accommodating. My husband ordered a half buffalo chicken/ half meat lovers pizza and I had a gluten free with no cheese (allergies) . For gluten free, my pizza was terrific !! Both pizzas were what we would consider "thin crust". My husband gave his pizza 4 stars, and judging by the smell and look of it it was excellent! Prices are reasonable. Keep in mind parking is limited - we found street parking easily on a Friday night, though. read more

See all

Service and food is awesome.. No complaints. Our server Trevor was friendly and fun and never missed a beat... And yes I used a groupon like everyone and enjoyed my time here. Will definitely come back again...Jay P The new chef even came to our table to check on how everything was! read more

Islands Pizza - Awesome tiramisu! - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Gone downhill. Quite possibly the worst pizza I've ever had. No taste. A lot of grease. Seems to evaporate the longer it sits. No garlic flavor. Cheese bad. Cmon people. Step up the game. We need even a mediocre pizza over here. Would be better than this. read more

Pretty good pizza! The pizza was well done (which i like) but it was pretty greasy. It was delivered hot and the delivery driver was very nice. The only thing I wasn't very impressed with was the employee on the phone when I placed the order. He was very nice until I told him I had a coupon, then he sounded extremely annoyed. read more

Very disappointed and disgusted, I ordered 2 large Caesar salad's and one of them had a dead fly in it. I threw both away and will never be coming back, I guess they don't wash their salad. Very disappointed read more

Islands Pizza - Dead fly in my Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all